Inconsistent Counselor Fidelity in Delivering an Evidence-Based Adherence Intervention During a PrEP Trial.

Evidence-based adherence counseling interventions must be delivered with fidelity to ensure that their effectiveness is retained, but little is known regarding how counselors in biomedical HIV trials deliver these interventions. Forty-two counselors from the MTN-025/HOPE Study, which was conducted in 14 sites in sub-Saharan Africa, participated. They completed a quantitative assessment and consented for their HOPE counseling session ratings to be analyzed. Twenty-two (52%) self-identified as research nurses and 20 (48%) as counselors. Of 928 session ratings, 609 (66%) were classified as Good, 188 (20%) as Fair, and 131 (14%) as Poor, based on pre-established criteria. Overall mean ratings for session tasks and global components (each rated from 1 to 5) were 4.12 (SD = 0.45; range 2.46-4.73) and 4.02 (SD = 0.64; range 1.75-4.79), respectively. Twenty-six (62%) counselors attained Good or Fair ratings on at least 85% of their sessions, but 33% of counselors had more than 25% of their sessions rated as Poor; three counselors (7%) never met criteria for a Good session. Even after extensive training, counselors' fidelity to the intervention varied. Our findings highlight the value of fidelity monitoring using session audio-recordings, the importance of ongoing coaching and support, and the need to plan for counselors with consistently poor fidelity.

RESUMEN: Las intervenciones de consejería de adherencia basadas en la evidencia deben ser realizadas con fidelidad para asegurar que retengan su efectividad, pero se sabe poco sobre cómo los consejeros en ensayos biomédicos de VIH realizan estas intervenciones. Cuarenta y dos consejeros participaron del Estudio MTN-025/HOPE, el cual se llevó a cabo en 14 sitios en África subsahariana. Completaron un cuestionario cuantitativo y dieron su consentimiento para el análisis de las calificaciones de sus sesiones de consejería para HOPE. Veintidós (52%) se identificaron como enfermeras investigadoras y 20 (48%) como consejeros. De 928 sesiones calificadas, 609 (66%) fueron clasificadas como Buenas, 188 (20%) como Suficientes, y 131 (14%) como Mediocres, basado en criterios preestablecidos. Las calificaciones promedias de las tareas de las sesiones y de los componentes globales (calificados de 1 a 5) fueron de 4.12 (SD = 0.45; rango 2.46­4.73) y de 4.02 (SD = 0.64; rango 1.75­4.79), respectivamente. Veintiséis (62%) consejeros lograron calificaciones Buenas o Suficientes en al menos el 85% de sus sesiones, pero para el 33% de los consejeros, más del 25% de sus sesiones fueron calificadas como Mediocres; tres consejeros (7%) nunca cumplieron con los criterios de una Buena sesión. Aún después de una capacitación intensiva, la fidelidad a la intervención variaba. Nuestros hallazgos destacan el valor de monitorear para la fidelidad usando audio-grabaciones de las sesiones, la importancia de la instrucción y el apoyo continuo, y la necesidad de planear qué medidas tomar cuando hay consejeros que no son fieles a la intervención.

Sharing Objective Measures of Adherence to a Vaginal Microbicide Promotes Candor About Actual Use and Bolsters Motivation to Prevent HIV.

Discrepancies between self-reported and actual adherence to biomedical HIV interventions is common and in clinical trials can compromise the integrity of findings. One solution is to monitor adherence biomarkers, but it is not well understood how to navigate biomarker feedback with participants. We surveyed 42 counselors and interviewed a subset of 22 to characterize their perspectives about communicating with participants about residual drug levels, an objective marker of adherence, within MTN-025/HOPE, a Phase 3b clinical trial of a vaginal ring to prevent HIV. When biomarkers indicated low drug levels that mismatched high adherence by self-report, counselors encountered barriers to acceptance and comprehension among participants. However, discrepancies between low self-report and higher drug levels generally stimulated candor. Women recollected times they had not used the product and disclosed problems that counselors thought might otherwise have remained forgotten or concealed. Navigating conversations toward HIV prevention was easier at mid-range drug levels and when women indicated motivation to prevent HIV. Ratings of residual drug level offered a somewhat objective measure of adherence and protection that counselors perceived as meaningful to participants and as a valuable catalyst for broaching conversation about HIV prevention. However, communication about drug levels required that counselors navigate emotional barriers, respond skillfully to questions about accuracy, and pivot conversations non-judgmentally away from numerical results and toward the priority of HIV prevention. Findings suggest a role for biomarker feedback in future clinical trials as well as other clinical contexts where biomarkers may be monitored, to motivate disclosure of actual adherence and movement toward HIV prevention.Clinical Trial Number NCT02858037.

RESUMEN: Discrepancias entre la adherencia auto-reportada y la verdadera a intervenciones biomédicas de VIH pueden comprometer los ensayos clínicos. Una solución es monitorear la adherencia por medio de ensayos biológicos, pero no se entiende bien cómo comunicar estas medidas a los participantes. En MTN-025/HOPE, un ensayo fase 3b de un anillo vaginal para prevenir VIH, encuestamos a 42 consejeros de adherencia y entrevistamos a un subconjunto de 22 para caracterizar sus perspectivas sobre comunicar una medida objetiva de adherencia al anillo, el nivel residual de droga (RDL por sus siglas en inglés). Los consejeros reportaron que los participantes apreciaron la retroalimentación del RDL como una indicación de su protección de VIH. Niveles más altos de droga estimularon euforia y alivio mientras niveles mas bajos resultaron en desilusión. Una postura no crítica y el apoyo a la autonomía de elegir otras alternativas al anillo promovieron divulgación de las razones por la falta de adherencia. Hablar del monitoreo de RDL como "protección" en vez de "adherencia" ayudó a cambiar el enfoque desde resultados numéricos hasta la meta mayor del ensayo de prevenir el VIH. Personalizar la retroalimentación de medidas objetivas de adherencia requiere una conversación cuidadosa para minimizar las actitudes defensivas. La retroalimentación personalizada también se puede implementar de forma que motive la divulgación de la falta de adherencia y evoque un compromiso a prácticas de prevención. Enfatizar las motivaciones de las mujeres a prevenir el VIH, en vez de los resultados numéricos, puede incentivar a los usuarios consistentes a continuar y a los usuarios inconsistentes a usar métodos alternativos de prevención.

Client-Centered Adherence Counseling with Adherence Measurement Feedback to Support Use of the Dapivirine Ring in MTN-025 (The HOPE Study).

Fostering adherence and open communication about adherence challenges is key to harnessing the potential of biomedical HIV prevention products. We describe the counseling intervention and objective adherence measure feedback process implemented to support adherence to the dapivirine vaginal ring among participants in four sub-Saharan countries and present findings on the counselors' likeability and acceptability of the intervention. Most counselors (N = 42; 86%) liked Options counseling "very much" and during in-depth interviews (N = 22), reported that the intervention reshaped their adherence counselling approach by emphasizing understanding participants' experiences using the ring, which facilitated open discussion of adherence challenges. Counselors found that reframing residual drug level (RDL) discussions from the "adherence" to "protection" perspective encouraged adherence among consistent users and facilitated decisions to switch to a different HIV prevention approach among infrequent users. Among counselors, 24% said participants "liked it very much" while 26% said that participants "liked it a little" possibly due to two main complaints: perceived repetitiousness of sessions and variability in the RDL assay, which at times resulted in unexpected low RDLs.

RESUMEN: Fomentar la adherencia y la comunicación abierta sobre los desafíos con la adherencia es clave para aprovechar el potencial de los productos biomédicos de prevención del VIH. Describimos la intervención de consejería y el proceso de compartir los resultados de medidas objetivas de adherencia con participantes en cuatro países subsaharianos para apoyar la adherencia al anillo vaginal de dapivirine y presentamos los resultados sobre la agradabilidad y la aceptabilidad de la intervención a los consejeros. A la mayoría de los consejeros (N=42; 86%) "les gustó mucho" la consejería quienes, durante entrevistas en profundidad (N=22) y reportaron que la intervención cambió su aproximación a la consejería sobre la adherencia. Se enfocaban más en comprender la experiencia de uso del anillo entre las participantes, lo cual facilitaba una conversación abierta sobre posibles desafíos a la adherencia. Los consejeros encontraron que cambiar el enfoque de "adherencia" a "protección" en las conversaciones sobre los niveles residuos de drogas fomentaba la adherencia entre las mujeres que usaban el anillo consistentemente y facilitaba la decisión de cambiar a otro método de prevención del VIH entre las mujeres que lo usaban con poca frecuencia. Entre los consejeros, 24% dijeron que a las participantes "les gustó mucho" la consejería y 26% que a las participantes "les gustó un poco". Es posible que esto se deba a dos quejas principales: la percepción de que las sesiones sean repetitivas y la variabilidad en el ensayo de los niveles residuos de drogas, lo cual a veces resultaba en niveles bajos inesperados.

Counselors' acceptability of adherence counseling session recording, fidelity monitoring, and feedback in a multi-site HIV prevention study in four African countries.

Biomedical HIV prevention trials increasingly include evidence-based adherence counseling to encourage product use. To retain effectiveness, interventions must contain key components. Monitoring counseling fidelity ensures inclusion of components but is challenging in multinational contexts with different languages and scarce local supervision. The MTN-025/HOPE Study, a Phase 3b open-label trial to assess continued safety of and adherence to the dapivirine vaginal ring for HIV prevention, was the largest such trial to integrate fidelity monitoring using audio recordings of counseling sessions. We describe the monitoring process, along with counselor and participants' perceptions of it, which were collected via quantitative online survey (counselors only N = 42) and in-depth interviews with a subset of counselors (N = 22) and participants (N = 10). Sessions were conducted in five languages across 14 study sites in four countries. In total, 1238 sessions (23% of submitted sessions) were randomly selected and rated. Assessment of interrater reliability was essential to address drift in ratings. Counselors were apprehensive about being monitored, but appreciated clear guidance and found ratings very helpful (mean = 6.64 out of 7). Some participants perceived sessions as time-consuming; others found monitoring improved counseling quality. Fidelity monitoring of counseling sessions in mult-isite biomedical HIV studies is feasible and supportive for counselors.

Culturally-Based Challenges to and Recommendations for Delivering Adherence Counseling in a Multicultural Biomedical HIV Prevention Trial in Four African Countries.

Research is needed to identify how to effectively tailor evidence-based interventions across cultures with limited resources, particularly for behavioral components in large HIV prevention trials. Through surveys and interviews with counselors of sub-Saharan African women during an open-label microbicide trial (MTN-025), we examined language, education, and cultural barriers in delivering a motivational interviewing-based adherence counseling intervention (i.e., Options Counseling). Counselors encountered an array of barriers, most prominently that participants struggled to comprehend culturally incongruent pictorial guides, such as traffic light images, and to uphold product use when primary partners disapproved. Overwhelmingly, counselors cited the intervention's inherent flexibility as an asset; it encouraged them to tailor language and examples to be more culturally relevant to participants. Future resource-conscious researchers may preemptively offset similar barriers by consulting with communities during intervention development. Similarly, affording counselors flexibility while delivering the chosen intervention may enable them to troubleshoot barriers that arise on the ground.