Tuberculosis among health care workers at King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, 1988-2002.

SETTING: It is still not well determined whether health care workers (HCWs) in developing countries-where background tuberculosis (TB) prevalence in the general population is high-have a higher risk of TB than other occupations. OBJECTIVE: To examine the risk of TB among HCWs in an area where TB prevalence is high. DESIGN: A cohort of 3959 HCWs at Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, Thailand, was observed from 1988 to 2002. RESULTS: The overall TB incidence rate was 188 per 100 000 person-years (py), with specific incidence rates of 77, 48 and 63/100 000 py, respectively, for confirmed, possible and self-reported TB cases. The highest risk work site was the emergency room, with rate ratios (RRs) of 10.4 (95%CI 3.0-44.7), 22.6 (95%CI 2.7-1041.2) and 9.4 (95%CI 1.5-99.1) for overall, confirmed and possible TB cases, respectively. The 11 TB cases in this area were 9 registered nurses, 1 nursing auxiliary and 1 housekeeper. The occupation of highest risk was nurse, with RRs of 2.4 (95%CI 0.9-9.1) for overall TB cases. However, only the increased RRs for the emergency room were statistically significant. CONCLUSION: The results of this study support the premise that certain groups of HCWs in developing countries are occupationally at increased risk of TB.

Cost-effectiveness and sustainability of lambdacyhalothrin-treated mosquito nets in comparison to DDT spraying for malaria control in western Thailand.

The cost-effectiveness of lambdacyhalothrin-treated nets in comparison with conventional DDT spraying for malaria control among migrant populations was evaluated in a malaria hyperendemic area along the Thai-Myanmar border. Ten hamlets of 243 houses with 948 inhabitants were given only treated nets. Twelve hamlets of 294 houses and 1,315 population were in the DDT area, and another 6 hamlets with 171 houses and 695 inhabitants were in the non-DDT-treated area. The impregnated net program was most cost-effective (US$1.54 per 1 case of prevented malaria). Spraying with DDT was more cost-effective than malaria surveillance alone ($1.87 versus $2.50 per 1 case of prevented malaria). These data suggest that personal protection measures with insecticide-impregnated mosquito net are justified in their use to control malaria in highly malaria-endemic areas in western Thailand.

Dependence and active life expectancy of the elderly population living in the central region of Thailand.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence and the independent socio-economic factors with respect to the dependence status of the Thai elderly population living in the central region and to calculate the active life expectancy (ALE) based on the results of this survey and abridged life tables for Thailand. DESIGN: A cross-sectional mulitistage random sampling survey. SETTING: Communities in the central region, Thailand. SUBJECTS: 723 elderly subjects. RESULTS: Mean age and its standard deviation (SD) of the 723 recruited subjects were 69.9 and 7.3 years, respectively. Forty three per cent of the subjects were men. Mean values (SD) of the BAI score and the CAI score were 18.78 (2.6) and 6.47 (2.4), respectively. Except for housework, elderly women had a higher prevalence rate of dependence on activities of daily living (ADL) compared with elderly men. Seven univariate factors of the BAI and the CAI were demonstrated. According to the multiple linear regression analysis by entering all univariate factors of the BAI and the CAI except "working status", independent factors of both the BAI (adjusted R2 = 0.051) and the CAI (adjusted R2 = 0.146) were age, sex and writing ability. The prevalence rate (95% confidence interval) of dependence regarding self-care activities of daily living was 5.9 per cent (4.2-7.6%). The rate of dependence increased with age. The female elderly were more dependent on self care than their male counterparts. Although the elderly women live longer than the elderly men, they spend more years in a severely dependent state. Findings on ratios between health and life expectancy demonstrate that Thai men spend more proportional time leading a healthy life than Thai women. CONCLUSION: Prevalence rates of dependence regarding activities of daily living among the Thai elderly living in the Central region were rather high showing the health of elderly women to be worse than that of elderly men. The elderly women spend more years in a severely dependent state although they live longer than the elderly men.

Prevalence of osteopenia and osteoporosis in Thai women.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the age-specific and age-adjusted prevalence of osteopenia and osteoporosis in pre- and postmenopausal Thai women. METHODS: This was a descriptive study of 1,935 Thai women ranging in age from 40 to 80 years, with randomly selected strata using multistage sampling and stratifying from six representative provinces of the country. After recruiting, all the women were interviewed by a well-trained interviewer using structured questionnaires. Bone mineral density (BMD) of lumbar spine 1-4 and nondominant hip was measured by a dual energy photon absorptiometer. The investigators were trained and standardized; inter- and intraobserver variations were measured periodically. Every BMD outcome was re-examined by the specialist. Age-specific prevalence of osteoporosis and osteopenia were determined using both Thai and Western standard BMD values. Age-adjusted prevalence of osteopenia and osteoporosis was calculated using the age-adjusted direct method. RESULTS: Using the Thai BMD reference, the age-specific prevalence of osteoporosis among Thai women rose progressively with increasing age to more than 50% after the age of 70. The age-adjusted prevalence of osteoporosis also rose progressively. It was 19.8%, 13.6%, and 10% for lumbar spine, femoral neck, and intertrochanteric. The age-adjusted prevalence of osteoporosis indicates the overall magnitude of that condition in the population or country. In our study, using a Western BMD reference resulted in a misleadingly high prevalence of osteoporosis in the population of Asian countries. CONCLUSION: It is important to calculate the age-adjusted prevalence of osteopenia and osteoporosis to address the overall magnitude of the problem in Thai women. This will allow us to predict the socioeconomic impact of preventable chronic conditions such as osteoporosis. The results obtained from this study are important data for public health policy: maximizing bone mass throughout life as well as detection of important risk factors is essential.

Bone mineral density of lumbar spine and proximal femur in normal Thai women.

OBJECTIVE: To find the reference data for age-specific normal bone mineral density in a Thai female population. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional, Descriptive study. MATERIAL AND METHOD: 1773 Thai women aged between 11-80 years were recruited, using multistage cluster sampling and stratifying from six represented provinces in the country, each strata was randomly selected. After recruiting, the women were interviewed by well-trained personnel using structured questionnaires. Bone mineral density of the lumbar spine 1-4 and nondominant hip were measured by Dual Energy Photon Absorptiometer. The scientists, X-rays technician were trained and standardized inter and intra observers variation. Quality control of examination was measured periodically. Every BMD outcome was re-examined by a specialist. RESULTS: The peak bone mineral density of both spines and hips was between the age of 30 to 34 years old. Mean Value for spine and femoral neck was 0.957 and 0.814 g/cm2 respectively. The BMD of spine and hip was significantly decreased after the age of 35 and the loss was accelerated at age 50. Osteoporosis for spine and femoral neck is considered when BMD are below 0.682 and 0.569 g/cm2 respectively. CONCLUSION: The results are important data for public health policy, by maximizing bone mass during skeletal growth before menopause and minimizing bone loss throughout life as well as for detection of important risk factors.

Situational analysis of the health insurance market and related educational needs in the era of health care reform in Thailand.

The purposes of this study were to explore the situation of health insurance in Thailand, to compare public and private perspectives and to identify related educational needs. Between March and April of 1998, the study employed in-depth interviews of 12 public and private major stakeholders of the health insurance systems, including policy makers, providers and insurers. Additional inputs were gathered in a brainstorming session with 41 participants from organizations with important roles in regulating, monitoring, paying, or providing health care services, as well as research and education. The findings indicated the health insurance market was expanding. But there was no national policy on health insurance. Insurance-related law was outdated. Public and private schemes overlapped, and were generally characterized by inadequate risk diversification, overutilization of services, lack of effective cost containment, inconsistent service quality, and poor understanding of health insurance principles. There were needs for more education and training in various aspects of health services management and health-insurance related functions. Consequently, continuing education and training related to health insurance services for policy makers, system administrators, managers, providers and insurers are strongly recommended during the health-care reform process.

Economic impact of tuberculosis at the household level.

OBJECTIVE: Previous economic analyses of tuberculosis control interventions have focused on the provider perspective. To assess the overall economic impact of the disease and the adequacy of current control strategies from a societal viewpoint, the determination of direct and indirect patient costs is required. SETTING AND DESIGN: In a cross-sectional survey, all adult tuberculosis patients who completed treatment between August 1996 and February 1997 at 16 randomly selected government health care facilities in Thailand (n = 673) were interviewed using a structured questionnaire. Information were obtained on direct and indirect patient costs before and after diagnosis, and on financing methods and changes in household consumption patterns. All results were stratified for three levels of patient household income: above national average, below national average but above the poverty line, and below the poverty line. RESULTS: Illness-related costs particularly affected patients with incomes below the poverty line (n = 153). In this group, average out-of-pocket expenditures for the disease amounted to more than 15% of annual household income, while incomes were reduced by 5 % due to illness-related effects. Expenditures were most frequently financed from household savings or transfer payments from community members and relatives. However, 11.8% of patient households took out bank loans, and 15.9% sold part of their property. CONCLUSION: The current low case detection and treatment completion rates for tuberculosis patients in Thailand may partly be due to the inability of poor patients to cope with the economic consequences of diagnosis and treatment. Suggested improvements include the strict enforcement of an existing government policy of free care, the further decentralization of services to reduce travel costs and work absences, and social security payments for patients undergoing treatment.

Cost and performance of malaria sector: a case study at Malaria Sector 11, Tak Province, Thailand.

The objective of this study was to assess the cost and performance of each operational unit at the malaria sector level and to calculate the unit cost of each activity accordingly. Data were collected at Malaria Sector No.11 situated at the western border of Thailand with Myanmar during the fiscal year of 1995. The unit cost was calculated by dividing the total cost of each activity by its output using appropriate units of analysis. The result showed that 67% of the total cost of malaria sector was labor cost and 45% of the total cost was allocated to diagnosis and treatment activities. Unit cost in terms of cost/visit, cost/case found, cost/case of falciparum malaria treated, cost/case of vivax malaria treated, cost/house spray and cost/impregnated net were US$1.85, 8.21, 10.07, 8.46, 2.24 and 1.54 respectively. The results of this study will provide important information as to the best use of limited available resources to determine which activities should be stopped, continued, increased or decreased at the malaria sector level.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of lambdacyhalothrin-treated nets for malaria control: the patients' perspective.

The present study was undertaken to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of lambdacyhalothrin-treated nets in comparison with conventional DDT-spraying as a method of malaria control according to the patients' perspective among migrant populations in a high-risk area along the Thai-Myanmar border in Thailand. Ten hamlets comprising 243 houses with 948 inhabitants were given only treated nets. Twelve hamlets comprising 294 houses and 1,315 inhabitants represented the DDT-treated area and another six hamlets with 171 houses and 695 inhabitants served as controls. Information as to consumer costs was obtained by interviewing 3,214 patients seeking care at all levels of the health care system in the study area. Analysis showed that the impregnated-net program was more cost-effective than the DDT-spraying program or surveillance alone (US$ 0.59 vs US$ 0.74 vs US$ 0.79 per 1 case of prevented malaria). We conclude that in a high-risk area such as along the Thai-Myanmar border in western Thailand, integrating the use of impregnated nets with large-scale primary health care programs is likely to constitute the most cost-effective method for controlling malaria according to the patients' perspective.

Randomized controlled trial of directly observed treatment (DOT) for patients with pulmonary tuberculosis in Thailand.

While directly observed treatment (DOT) has been recommended as the standard approach to tuberculosis control, empirical data on its feasibility and efficiency are still scarce. We conducted a controlled trial of DOT at 15 health care facilities at various levels of the government health care system in Thailand. A total of 836 patients diagnosed between August 1996 and October 1997 were randomly assigned to be treated either under DOT or self-supervised using monthly drug supplies (SS). Options for treatment supervisors were health staff, community members or members of the patients' families. Treatment outcomes were compared on the basis of cure, treatment-completion, default and death rates. In both study arms, treatment outcomes were improved compared to pre-study conditions. Cure and treatment-completion rates were significantly higher in the DOT cohort (76% and 84%) than in the SS group (67% and 76%). The benefits of DOT were more pronounced at district and provincial hospitals (DOT cure rate 81% vs. 69% in the SS group), while differences for patients treated at referral centres were non-significant (DOT cure rate 72% vs. 66% in the SS group). No significant differences in outcomes could be observed between patient groups receiving DOT under the various options for treatment supervisors. DOT appears especially suited for treatment at decentralized facilities. While a general focus on programme performance can improve outcomes, DOT provides significant additional benefits. If basic conditions are met, a DOT strategy can be tailored to country-specific conditions by exploring multiple observation options, without decreasing its effectiveness.

Compliance with artesunate and quinine + tetracycline treatment of uncomplicated falciparum malaria in Thailand.

A randomized, controlled, malaria-clinic-based field trial was conducted to compare compliance with a 7-day quinine + tetracycline regimen and a 5-day 700-mg artesunate regimen for the treatment of uncomplicated falciparum malaria in a community in Thailand. Of 137 patients, aged 15-60 years attending a malaria clinic, 77 received artesunate and 60 received quinine + tetracycline. Compliance and cure rates were evaluated on days 5 (artesunate) and 7 (quinine + tetracycline) using patient interview/residual pill counts and peripheral blood smear, respectively. Data were analysed using the intention-to-treat approach, and the reasons for compliance and noncompliance were investigated. Compliance was significantly higher (98.4%) with artesunate than with quinine + tetracycline (71.7%) (relative risk adjusted for sex (aRR) = 1.39 (95% C.I. = 1.15-1.68); referent: quinine + tetracycline). Cure rate (100%) was higher in those receiving artesunate than quinine + tetracycline (77.4%) (aRR = 1.32 (95% C.I. = 1.12-1.55)). Reasons for compliance included the desire to be cured and to follow the advice of malaria staff/employer, and the simple dosing regimen. Noncompliance was mostly due to adverse reactions and forgetting to take the drugs. These results can serve as a baseline for designing and evaluating new interventions to improve compliance, as well as for studying cost-effectiveness to help drug policy decision-making. We recommend a strategy which integrates a short-course, once-a-day regimen (with minimal adverse reactions), a better delivery system for antimalarial drugs and health education, and an enhanced advisory role of malaria staff. Considering the higher compliance rate and curative effectiveness of artesunate, we recommend its use instead of quinine + tetracycline for the treatment of uncomplicated malaria in clinics in Thailand.

Epidemiological studies of malaria at Pong Nam Ron, eastern Thailand.

Malaria is still a serious health problem in Thailand. Present attempts at controlling the disease by drug treatment and other means remain unsatisfactory. Thus, development of vaccination against malaria is a major research goal of malaria immunology. The objective of this study was to acquire epidemiological base line data for subsequent vaccine trials. A cross-sectional descriptive survey was conducted among 451 local inhabitants during the beginning of the transmission season in June 1989 at Pong Nam Ron District, Chanthaburi Province, Eastern Thailand where malaria transmission was likely to be high. Following the cross-sectional survey weekly morbidity surveillance was started to detect new cases of malaria by using active and passive case detection at the district hospital, local health centers and at neighboring malaria clinics. Entomological observations were made monthly to determine inoculation rates. Forty-six percent of the population were male and 54% female; one third were under the age of 15 and 14% under the age of 5 years. Eighty percent of the adults were married. Sixty percent of the subjects interviewed gave a history of malarial illness in the past. Malaria, malnutrition, abnormal hemoglobin diseases and parasitic infestation were the main health problems in the study area. The annual parasite incidence of malaria was 149.6/1,000 population and two-thirds of them were asymptomatic indicating a semi-immune condition among these subjects. It was difficult to interpret the results of entomological studies due to low density of the malaria vector.

Disability among Thai elderly living in Klong Toey slum.

Forty three per cent of the elderly in Klong Toey slum had BAI score less than 20. One point six per cent were moderately severe or severely disabled and needed special care. Around one-third of them caused by stroke. Locomotion, reaching and stretching, dexterity, continence and seeing are common significant types of disability among this population study. Perceived health status, age and working status are independent factors related to disability level. The Barthel ADL index is suitable for using as a tool for a disability survey among Thai elderly. The ODS questionnaire may be applied after considerable modification of the questions concerning behavior and intelligence dimensions.

The meaning of activities of daily living in a Thai elderly population: development of a new index.

Activities of daily living (ADL) of 703 Thai elderly people (aged 60+ years) living in a Bangkok slum community were studied with the aims of describing the prevalence of disability, considering the appropriateness of Western ADL scales and developing a new ADL index for Asian populations. The levels of disability found were higher than in industrial populations and the important areas of disability were in instrumental ADLs. The mean (SD) Barthel ADL Index (BAI) for the group was 19.5 (1.2) with a range of 10-20. The mean (SD) Office of Populations Censuses and Surveys (OPCS) disability score was 4.8 (1.9) with a range of 0-10 but was unsuitable for use in Thailand because of misinterpretation of behavioural and intellectual disability leading to 99% of subjects being scored as disabled. An analysis of the underlying dimensions making up ADL was conducted using factor analysis. Four dimensions of ADL were found: basic self-care ADLs, extended ADLs, mobility ADLs and continence. An extended ADL index suitable for use in developing countries was developed (the Chula ADL Index) which had strong hierarchical properties and high correlations with both the OPCS disability score and the Barthel ADL Index. Analysis of data derived from ADL instruments should consider each ADL dimension separately. The BAI is useful as an index of self-care ADL but the behaviour and intellectual disability sub-scales of the OPCS scale require further development for cross-cultural applications.

The influence of dissemination of information on the changes of knowledge, attitude and acceptance of hepatitis B vaccination among hospital personnel in Chulalongkorn Hospital.

Lack of knowledge and negative attitudes were the main reasons for refusal, in a vaccination programme against hepatitis B using plasma-derived vaccine which was offered to the hospital personnel of Chulalongkorn University Hospital, Bangkok. Therefore, to ascertain whether an educational intervention among hospital personnel is effective in modifying acceptance of the vaccine, a quasi-experimental design (using a before and after approach) was used to compare the knowledge, attitudes and acceptance rate of hepatitis B vaccination among 1,915 hospital personnel. After dissemination of information, knowledge and attitudes improved significantly, and acceptance rates were increased from 56.9% to 77.7% (P < 0.0000). More specific educational efforts should be started before launching vaccination programmes of this kind in order to increase acceptance.

PIP: The potential for infection with hepatitis B vaccine is a serious threat to all health care workers, especially among hospital personnel frequently exposed to blood and its products. Chulalongkorn University Hospital is a 1400-bed university teaching hospital in Bangkok. Recognizing the risk of infection, it was planned to offer free vaccinations against hepatitis B using the Hevac B Pasteur plasma-derived vaccine to all hospital personnel. A pre-vaccination program survey of 1492 nursing personnel found the initial acceptance rate to be only 49.7%, with 39.2% undecided and 11.1% planning to not accept. 65.7% of the remaining 1299 personnel planned to accept the vaccine, with the lowest rate among physicians at 48.2%. Lack of knowledge and negative attitudes were the main reasons for refusal to accept the vaccine. The authors used a quasi-experimental before-after design to explore whether an educational intervention among hospital personnel would be effective in increasing the acceptance of the vaccine. Findings are based upon comparisons of the knowledge, attitudes, and acceptance rate of hepatitis B vaccination among 1915 hospital personnel. Levels of knowledge and attitudes were found to improve significantly after the information was disseminated, with acceptance rates increasing from 56.9% to 77.7%. This success highlights the potential merit of implementing targeted educational interventions before launching vaccinations programs of this kind in other settings.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of three short-course anti-tuberculosis programmes compared with a standard regimen in Thailand.

The present study was undertaken to compare the efficacy, effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of three short-course regimens with a standard programme for treatment of new tuberculosis (TB) cases. The study was conducted by reviewing the results of TB treatment in 1642 newly diagnosed, sputum positive pulmonary TB patients with four drug regimens carried out in five zonal TB centres throughout Thailand in 1987-1989. Analysis showed that the three-short-course regimens were more cost-effective than the standard regimen from the perspective of both providers and patients. Among the three short-course programmes, isoniazid, rifampicin and pyrazinamide for 2 months, followed by isoniazid and rifampicin twice a week for 4 months was the most cost-effective (US$70.24/effectiveness from providers' perspective and US$103.31/effective from patients' perspective). The result of this study throws some light on the development of new policy options, with scarce health resources, in the treatment of tuberculosis by the National Tuberculosis Programme in Thailand.

Economic analysis of malaria control for migrant workers in eastern Thailand.

A randomized, double-blind field trial was carried out to compare the economic impact of permethrin-treated nets with that of untreated nets as a method of malaria control. The study was conducted in 261 long-term migrant workers and 138 seasonal agricultural migrant workers in the eastern rural areas known to be highly endemic for multidrug-resistant Plasmodium falciparum infection. One hundred and twenty-six longterm migrants and 59 seasonal migrants used treated nets, while 135 and 79, respectively, used untreated nets. The impregnated-nets program was cost-saving as well as offering improved effectiveness. The net benefit of using a treated net was US$1.17 per worker from the Malaria Division's perspective and US$1.61 per worker from the worker viewpoint. The use of impregnated nets with large-scale primary health care programs likely will be the most cost-effective and cost-beneficial method for controlling malaria in eastern Thailand.

Malaria in a rural area of eastern Thailand: baseline epidemiological studies at Bo Thong.

Malaria is still a serious health problem in Thailand. Present attempts at controlling the disease by drug treatment and other means remain unsatisfactory. Thus, development of vaccination against malaria is a major research goal of malaria immunology. The objective of this study was to acquire epidemiological base line data for subsequent vaccine trials. A cross-sectional descriptive survey was conducted among 253 local inhabitants during the beginning of the transmission season in July 1989 at Bo Thong District, Chonburi Province, Eastern Thailand where malaria transmission was likely to be moderately high. Following the cross-sectional survey weekly morbidity surveillance was started to detect new cases of malaria by using active and passive case detection at the district hospital, local health centers and at neighboring malaria clinics. Fifty-four percent of the population were male and forty-six percent female: nearly a half (48.3%) were under the age of 15 and 17% under the age of 5 years. Eighty percent of the adults were married. Seventy percent of the subjects interviewed gave a history of malarial illness in the past. Malaria, malnutrition, anemia abnormal hemoglobin diseases and parasitic infestations were the main health problems in the study area. The annual parasite incidence of malaria was 169.4/1,000 population and 77% of parasitemic individuals were asymptomatic, indicating the existence of a semi-immune condition among these subjects. Antibody level to crude parasite antigen increased with age. It is hoped that the information obtained from these field studies may be useful in malaria vaccine trials in the near future.

Factors influencing acceptance of hepatitis B vaccination by hospital personnel in an area hyperendemic for hepatitis B.

A free-of-charge vaccination program against hepatitis B, in which plasma-derived vaccine was used, was offered to 1,299 hospital personnel of Chulalongkorn University Hospital, Bangkok. The initial acceptance rate for vaccination was 65.7%, with 10.0% nonacceptance and 24.3% undecided. The highest rates of acceptance were among medical students (75.5%), student nurses (68.8%), and newly graduated nurses (63.6%). The lowest rate of acceptance was among physicians (48.2%). Factors strongly associated with the acceptance of vaccination were nature of work, age of personnel (< or = 40 yr), number of years spent in profession (< or = 15 yr), knowledge of hepatitis B, confidence in vaccine efficacy and safety, no history of hepatitis B infection, and contact with blood or blood product. Different types of fear, as well as lack of knowledge, were the main reasons responsible for 46.2% of all refusals. More specific educational efforts about vaccine safety and efficacy may positively influence the acceptance of hepatitis vaccination program among health care personnel.