Determinants of gait as applied to children with cerebral palsy.

In the present study, we quantified the isolated contributions of eight determinants of gait on the vertical center of mass (CoM) displacement of both typically developing children and children with cerebral palsy (CP). The role of these determinants, on vertical excursion, has never been examined for children or children with CP. We hypothesized that the relative contributions of the determinants to vertical CoM excursion of children with CP would be the same as the age-matched controls. We found that based on the similarities in the determinants effect on gait between the controls and adults reflect that children of this age walk with a mature gait. When applied to subjects with CP the determinant analysis found similar, but slightly exaggerated effects of those of the controls. All determinants that negatively affect CoM excursion were significantly worse in the children with CP, while those determinants that decreased excursion were varied. Heel rise, single support knee flexion, and pelvic obliquity had similar effects for on both groups. Pelvic rotation resulted in more excursion reduction in the controls, while leg inclination was more beneficial in reducing the CP groups excursion. The main cause for increased vertical excursion of the CoM in the children with CP was the increased knee flexion of both legs during double support. This excessive lowering of the CoM means that extra work is done to raise the CoM over the single support leg. The situation is aggravated by the fact that the CoM was lifted higher than typical because of the heel lifting during single support. Although these determinants allow quantification of the effects of gait kinematics and provide some useful information for gait they are limited in their ability to quantify the dynamics and kinetics of gait that are important for individuals with walking disabilities.

Effect of age on lower extremity joint moment contributions to gait speed.

We investigated the relationship of hip, knee and ankle function to gait speed in healthy elderly subjects. We hypothesized that the hip extension moment would make a significantly smaller contribution to propulsion power in the elderly than in healthy young subjects even when the elders were ambulating at speeds comparable to those of the young subjects. We analyzed the free speed gait of 16 young and 14 elderly subjects, and the fast gait of the elder subjects. In elderly subjects free speed gait linear power transfer from the leg to the upper body due to the hip and knee moments was decreased compared with young subjects walking at their normal gait speed. However, when asked to walk fast, elders significantly increase knee and hip moment contributions to hip linear power to levels comparable to those of young subjects at a similar speed. These results refute our hypothesis and support our earlier findings indicating that kinematic alterations at the hip are a cause of reduced gait speed in the elderly.

Energy consumption during level walking with arm and knee immobilized.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether there is an increase in energy use for able-bodied subjects with their arm and/or knee immobilized, while walking on a level surface at comfortable walking speed (CWS). DESIGN: Prospective, quantitative, with randomly sequenced experimental trials. SETTING: Rehabilitation center. PARTICIPANTS: Ten healthy subjects, none of whom had gait abnormality. INTERVENTION: Subjects walked on a treadmill at CWS under 4 conditions: (1) without an arm or knee immobilized (N); (2) with an arm immobilized (AI); (3) with a knee immobilized (KI); and (4) with both arm and ipsilateral knee immobilized (KAI). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Breath-by-breath oxygen cost; differences in energy consumption in trials during which constraints were used were compared with energy consumed under the N condition and the percentage of change was calculated. RESULTS: Mean oxygen cost increased by 22.7% with a knee immobilized compared with N values (mean difference,.044 mL x kg(-1) x m(-1), p <.0001), and increased by 24.7% with a knee and arm immobilized (mean difference,.048 mL x kg(-1) x m(-1), p <.0001). However, no significant differences existed in oxygen cost with AI compared with N, or with KAI compared with KI. The differences in CWS between the stages followed a similar pattern. CONCLUSIONS: Arm immobilization does not increase energy expenditure during level walking at CWS, and does not further increase energy expenditure when the ipsilateral knee also is immobilized.

A refined view of the determinants of gait.

We evaluated the effect of reducing the vertical displacement of the centre of mass (COM) on the six determinants of gait proposed by Saunders, Inman and Eberhart in 30 healthy adults. We compared the estimated reduction in COM vertical displacement due to the determinants in their compass model with the actual reduction of vertical displacement. The maximum height of the COM for the compass gait model occurred earlier than the actual COM maximum height. Different gait functions were determinant in reducing COM vertical displacement. In both cases heel rise was the main determinant (up to 2/3 of total reduction). Pelvic obliquity and single stance knee flexion contributions were more important when compass gait COM maximum was used while they were barely detectable at the actual COM maximum. Ipsi- and contra-lateral knee flexion were detrimental to the reduction of COM vertical displacements, while pelvic rotation contribution was beneficial and accounted for up to 10% of the overall COM vertical displacement reduction. Although a reduction of COM vertical displacement may have important energy implications, determining the specific gait parameters associated with this function is fundamental in understanding gait disability.

The effect of voluntary toe-walking on body propulsion.

OBJECTIVE: We studied the kinetics of toe-walking by comparing the linear power flow from the leg to the upper-body. Our hypothesis was that toe-walking has no inherent biomechanical disadvantage with regard to upper-body propulsion and support. DESIGN: We studied healthy subjects capable of both heel-toe gait and voluntary toe-walking so that the two forms of gait could be directly compared. BACKGROUND: Ankle joint power at terminal stance is significantly reduced in toe-walking, which has been presumed to imply impaired propulsion and support. However, linear power analysis may be more appropriate for assessing this aspect of gait. METHODS: We compared the normal heel-toe gait of 10 healthy young adult subjects to their voluntary toe-walking gait using gait laboratory kinematic and kinetic data. Inverse dynamic analysis was performed to determine the net joint moments and joint linear powers. The contribution of each joint moment to the total hip linear power was also determined. RESULTS: Hip linear power for toe-walking was similar to that of heel-toe gait with no significant differences in the linear power peaks. The stance phase contributions of the knee and ankle moments were significantly altered in toe-walking only in early stance. CONCLUSIONS: Toe-walking does not inherently impair propulsion and support. RELEVANCE: Linear power analysis is a useful adjunct to clinical gait analysis, complementing joint power analysis. Understanding the inherent kinetics of toe-walking will enhance our analysis of pathological toe-walking and improve treatment design.

Women's shoes and knee osteoarthritis.

We assessed whether wearing wide-heeled shoes has a similar effect on knee torque to narrow-heeled shoes by measuring the joint torques of 20 healthy women during walking. Wearing wide-heeled shoes had a 30% greater effect on peak external knee flexor torque than walking barefoot. Walking with wide-heeled and narrow-heeled shoes increased peak knee varus torque by 26% and 22%, respectively. Our findings imply that wide-heeled shoes cause abnormal forces across the patellofemoral and medial compartments of the knee, which are the typical anatomical sites for degenerative joint changes.

Spastic paretic stiff-legged gait: joint kinetics.

OBJECTIVE: The authors previously suggested that spastic paretic stiff-legged gait, defined as reduced knee flexion in swing associated with upper-motor neuron injury, can be attributed to multiple impairments besides spastic quadriceps activity. This study hypothesizes that subjects with spastic paretic stiff-legged gait have altered kinetics not only about the knee but also about the hip and ankle. DESIGN: Joint kinetic data of 20 subjects with spastic paretic stiff-legged gait caused by stroke were compared with data obtained from 20 able-bodied subjects. RESULTS: Significant reductions in the subject group were found in both peak knee-joint power absorption (0.42+/-0.34 vs. 0.99+/-0.27 W/(kg x m x m/sec)) and peak ankle-joint power generation (0.74+/-0.42 vs. 1.51+/-0.17 W/(kg x m x m/sec); both P < 0.0001). The authors observed increases in peak external-hip flexion torque in stance, hip-power generation in loading response, knee-extension torque in midstance, ankle-dorsiflexion torque, and ankle-power absorption in stance. There was substantial variability in most torque and power values among subjects, which was significantly greater than that observed in the control subjects. CONCLUSIONS: These findings, in conjunction with previous studies, support the likelihood of multiple mechanisms for reduced knee flexion in swing. Alternatively, some of the joint kinetic differences could be compensations for or associated with reduced knee flexion in swing. The substantial variability among subjects implies that despite a similar visual appearance of reduced knee flexion among subjects with a spastic paretic stiff-legged gait pattern, each individual has unique mechanisms associated with this observed gait pattern.

Reduced hip extension during walking: healthy elderly and fallers versus young adults.

OBJECTIVES: To test the hypothesis that reduced hip extension range during walking, representing a limiting impairment of hip tightness, is a consistent dynamic finding that (1) occurs with increased age and (2) is exaggerated in elderly people who fall. DESIGN: Using a 3-dimensional optoelectronic motion analysis system, we compared full sagittal plane kinematic (lower extremity joint motion, pelvic motion) data during walking between elderly and young adults and between elderly fallers and nonfallers. Comparisons were also performed between comfortable and fast walking speeds within each elderly group. SETTING: A gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-three healthy elderly subjects, 16 elderly fallers (otherwise healthy elderly subjects with a history of recurrent falls), and 30 healthy young adult subjects. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: All major peak joint angle and pelvic position values. RESULTS: Peak hip extension was the only leg joint parameter measured during walking that was both significantly lower in elderly nonfallers and fallers than in young adult subjects and was even lower in elderly fallers compared with nonfallers (all p <.05). Peak hip extension +/- standard deviation during comfortable walking speed averaged 20.4 degrees +/- 4.0 degrees for young adults, 14.3 degrees +/- 4.4 degrees for elderly nonfallers, and 11.1 degrees +/- 4.8 degrees for elderly fallers. Peak hip extension did not significantly improve when elderly subjects walked fast. CONCLUSION: An isolated and consistent reduction in hip extension during walking in the elderly, which is exaggerated in fallers, implies the presence of functionally significant hip tightness, which may limit walking performance. Overcoming hip tightness with specific stretching exercises is worthy of investigation as a simple intervention to improve walking performance and to prevent falls in the elderly.

Quantification of pelvic rotation as a determinant of gait.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effect of pelvic rotation, originally described as the first determinant of gait, on reducing the vertical displacement of the center of mass (COM) during comfortable speed walking. DESIGN: Pelvic and lower extremity kinematic data during walking were collected. A modified compass gait model incorporating measured inputs was used to estimate the effect of pelvic rotation on reducing the vertical displacement of the COM. The actual reduction in vertical displacement was also calculated. SETTING: A gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Thirty able-bodied subjects. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The estimated reduction in COM vertical displacement caused by pelvic rotation was compared with the actual reduction in COM displacement. RESULTS: The estimated effect of pelvic rotation in reducing COM displacement was 2.5 +/- 1.1mm, accounting for only 12% of the actual reduction. CONCLUSION: During normal comfortable speed walking by able-bodied subjects, pelvic rotation contributes only a small portion of the actual reduction in the vertical displacement of the COM compared with a compass gait model. Other primary gait factors or determinants are needed to explain the actual reduction in vertical displacement of the COM.

Propulsive adaptation to changing gait speed.

Understanding propulsion and adaptation to speed requirements is important in determining appropriate therapies for gait disorders. We hypothesize that adaptations for changing speed requirements occur primarily at the hip. The slow, normal and fast gait of 24 healthy young subjects was analyzed. The linear power was analyzed at the hip joint. The anterior-posterior and vertical induced accelerations of the hip were also determined. Linear power and anterior-posterior-induced acceleration (IA) analyses of the hip reveal that the lower limb joint's moments contribute to body forward propulsion primarily during late swing and early stance. Propulsive adaptations to speed changes occur primarily at the hip and secondarily at the ankle. These analyses show that hip muscles, particularly the hip extensors, are critical to propulsion. They also show that ankle function is primarily for support, but is important to propulsion, especially at slow speeds.

Can toe-walking contribute to stiff-legged gait?

OBJECTIVE: Spastic paretic stiff-legged gait, defined as reduced knee flexion in swing, has previously been attributed solely to spastic quadriceps activity. In earlier work, the authors suggested that reduced knee flexion in swing can be attributed to other indirect factors, such as poor hip flexion and abnormal foot-ankle function during gait. The present study was undertaken to determine whether toe-walking, which often occurs in conjunction with stiff-legged gait, in and of itself, might explain some of the reduced knee flexion in swing. DESIGN: An analysis was performed of three-dimensional kinematic data collected from able-bodied subjects while walking on their toes vs. normal heel-toe walking. RESULTS: Peak knee flexion was reduced significantly compared with normal heel-toe walking (42.2+/-8.9 degrees toe-walking vs. 59.2+/-5.7 degrees heel-toe walking; P < 0.00001). CONCLUSIONS: This finding, which occurred when controlling for walking speed, may be clinically relevant for patients who have both a toe-walking and a stiff-legged gait pattern. Some of the reduced knee flexion in swing may be merely a consequence of toe-walking, rather than a result of other causes, such as intrinsic spasticity or abnormal muscle firing about the knee.

Knee joint torques: a comparison between women and men during barefoot walking.

OBJECTIVE: To determine if knee joint torques, which are likely relevant to the development and, possibly, progression of knee osteoarthritis, are equivalent between genders during natural, barefoot walking. DESIGN: Collected stereophotogrammetric and force platform data during comfortable, barefoot walking. Knee joint torques were plotted and statistically compared between genders using both an unpaired t test (p < .05) and an equivalence test (20% delta). SETTING: A gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: One hundred ten healthy, nondisabled young women and men. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Four knee joint torque parameters normalized for height and weight: (1) peak and (2) duration of sagittal flexor joint torque from early to midstance, and (3) first and (4) second peak coronal (frontal) varus torque values during the stance period. RESULTS: No statistically significant differences between genders were found, and the values were equivalent between genders for each of the 4 knee joint torque parameters. CONCLUSION: These findings support the hypothesis that under similar barefoot conditions women and men have a similar intrinsic biomechanic risk for knee osteoarthritis. Future research to assess the effects of other potential biomechanic factors, such as shoe-wear and activity type, may assist not only in preventing knee joint osteoarthritis, but also in developing new rehabilitative strategies to treat osteoarthritis of the knee.

A refined view of the determinants of gait: significance of heel rise.

OBJECTIVES: Although the major determinants of gait described by Saunders and colleagues have been accepted for more than 40 years, recent investigations raise the question of whether the reduction in center of mass (COM) displacement compared with a compass gait model indeed results from the factors originally described. We tested the hypothesis that heel rise at the end of stance is a true determinant that can explain a considerable portion of the reduction in COM vertical displacement during walking. DESIGN: Stereophotogrammetric data during walking were collected. A modified compass gait model incorporating the effect of heel rise, as compared with predictions based on a standard compass model, were used to estimate the isolated effect of heel rise on reducing the vertical displacement of COM. SETTING: A gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Thirty able-bodied subjects. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The estimated reduction in COM displacement due to heel rise was compared with the actual reduction in displacement. RESULTS: The estimated effect of heel rise on reduction in COM displacement was 23.4+/-7.6mm, whereas the actual reduction in COM displacement was 21.2+/-6.5mm (difference not significant, paired p = .185). CONCLUSION: During normal walking, heel rise from foot flat has a considerable role in raising the height of the COM when it is at its lowest, thus reducing its overall displacement. Insofar as reduction of COM vertical displacement may have important energy implications, appreciating the specific gait parameter of heel rise is key in rehabilitative approaches to improve gait disability.

Kinetic alterations independent of walking speed in elderly fallers.

OBJECTIVES: To determine if joint kinetic gait alterations in fallers persist when they attempt to walk at a faster speed that is more comparable with nonfallers' comfortable walking speed. DESIGN: Retrospective, case-control study. Stereophotogrammetric and force platform data were collected. SETTING: A gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Sixteen elderly subjects who had at least 2 falls in the last 6 months from an unclear cause and 23 elderly subjects with no history of repeated falls. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Differences in all major peak joint kinetic (moment and power) values during the gait cycle between elderly nonfallers walking at comfortable speed and elderly fallers walking at (1) comfortable and (2) fast speed. RESULTS: Statistically significant differences present at both comfortable and fast walking speeds were present in 4 sagittal plane parameters. There was an increase in peak external hip flexion moment in stance, a reduction in peak hip extension moment, a reduction in knee flexion moment in preswing, and a reduction in knee power absorption in preswing. CONCLUSION: The presence and persistence of 4 specific alterations in sagittal plane joint kinetics at both comfortable and fast walking speeds imply specific intrinsic pattern differences and allow for new insights into the mechanics of gait in elderly people who fall. The presence of these alterations also suggests they may serve as potential identifiable markers to detect those who may be at risk for falls.

Hip hiking and circumduction: quantitative definitions.

OBJECTIVE: To define and propose clinically useful quantitative measurements of hip hiking and circumduction using standard three-dimensional motion analysis techniques. DESIGN: We studied pelvic, hip, and thigh motions in 23 subjects with hemiparetic, stiff-legged gait as a result of stroke and compared these motions with those obtained from 23 able-bodied controls. RESULTS: We observed significantly increased hip abduction on the unaffected limb during stance, with simultaneous elevation of the affected side of the pelvis during swing. We define these differences as hip hiking and, thus, can quantify the degree to which hip hiking occurs by measuring the unaffected coronal hip angle and/or the coronal pelvic angle when the affected limb is in midswing. We also observed a greater than normal coronal thigh angle during midswing of the affected limb that we can use to quantitatively define circumduction. Of note, hip abduction during swing was not increased on the affected swing limb, compared with the control. CONCLUSIONS: Hip hiking can be defined precisely as unaffected coronal hip and/or pelvic angle when the affected limb is in midswing and circumduction can be defined as greater than normal coronal thigh angle during midswing of the affected limb. These precise definitions should allow us to better communicate and understand the implications of these gait patterns, and can serve as the basis for clinically meaningful quantitative assessment and outcome measurement tools.

Compensatory advantages of toe walking.

OBJECTIVES: The study's hypothesis is that toe walking requires less peak muscle strength distally about the ankle and knee compared with normal heel-toe walking and thus may have compensatory advantages for patients with upper motor neuron injury and distal muscle weakness. DESIGN: Motion analysis and force platform data were collected in able-bodied subjects during toe walking and normal walking. Sagittal plane joint torques reflecting muscle force requirements and joint powers reflecting nonisometric muscle contraction were compared between the two conditions using paired t tests, applying a Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons. SETTING: A gait laboratory. SUBJECTS: Seventeen able-bodied adults, 9 of whom were ballet dancers. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Peak hip, knee, and ankle joint torque and power variables during walking. RESULTS: Peak ankle plantarflexor torque and ankle power generation during terminal stance and preswing were reduced (p<.001), as compared with normal heel-toe walking. The normal ankle dorsiflexor torque at initial contact-and the knee extensor torque and knee power generation during loading response were all essentially absent during toe walking. Hip extensor torque and hip power generation during the loading response phase were greater for toe walking (p<.001). CONCLUSION: Toe walking may require less ankle plantarflexor, ankle dorsiflexor, and knee extensor strength than normal heel-toe walking and thus may have compensatory advantages for patients with upper motor neuron injury and distal lower extremity weakness.

Kinetics of stiff-legged gait: induced acceleration analysis.

Treating spastic paretic stiff-legged gait, defined as reduced knee flexion in swing, holds a high priority in the rehabilitation of patients with upper motor neuron lesions. We propose a method to determine the relative contributions of hip, knee, and ankle impairments to this disability. We analyzed the gait of ten patients with stiff-legged gait (SLG) due to a single stroke and ten healthy, able-bodied controls. Using subject specific models, we analyzed the induced accelerations (IA's) at the knee. Knee IA's throughout the gait cycle were calculated and the sum of the IA's was compared to the knee joint angular acceleration estimated from kinematic data. The preswing and early swing IA's were the focus of our examination as these largely determine knee kinematics in swing. Knee angular accelerations estimated from IA's and kinematic data agreed for both controls and patients. Gait cycle IA analysis of individual patients identified highly variable causes of SLG including ankle and hip joint impairments. Induced acceleration analysis (IAA) suggested that multiple impairments, not just about the knee, but also about the hip and ankle, lead to this disability. Individual subjects are likely to have individual reasons for their stiff-legged gait. Defining the link between the patients specific impairments and their gait disability should be a goal of clinical gait analysis. IAA is a useful tool for this purpose with a strong potential for clinical application.

Rectus femoris: its role in normal gait.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the role of the rectus femoris muscle in nondisabled gait at various walking velocities using fine-wire dynamic electromyography. DESIGN: Descriptive study. Fine-wire electromyography data were collected from the rectus femoris during level walking at four walking speeds. Rectus femoris activity patterns in the loading response phase and the pre- and initial-swing phase of the gait cycle were compared using paired t tests. SETTING: A gait laboratory. SUBJECTS: Ten nondisabled adult volunteers. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Amplitude of rectus femoris activity in the loading response phase and the pre- and initial-swing phase during walking at four speeds. RESULTS: There was a bimodal pattern of rectus femoris activity in all subjects, at all speeds, in both phases, with high variability in the onsets, durations, and amplitudes of activity, and paired t tests revealed no significant differences (p > .05) between phases at any walking speed. CONCLUSION: Activity in the rectus femoris in the pre- and initial-swing phase in nondisabled individuals at all speeds suggests that similar activity detected in individuals with stiff-legged gait may not be inappropriate.

Spastic paretic stiff-legged gait: biomechanics of the unaffected limb.

A concern for individuals with hemiparesis affecting their gait, which heretofore has never been studied, is the possibility that various compensations occurring in the unaffected limb may strain or fatigue the muscles or ligaments and/or predispose to joint injury in that limb. We studied the biomechanics of the unaffected limb during walking in 20 subjects with hemiparesis who had stiff-legged gait as a result of stroke. An optoelectronic motion analysis and force platform system was used to estimate torques in all three planes about the hip, knee, and ankle. Sagittal plane joint motion and power about the unaffected hip, knee, and ankle were also studied. Data were compared with control walking data collected from 20 able-bodied controls. On average, peak torques and powers were all either reduced or the same compared with controls, even though in some instances values were >2 standard deviations (SD) above the control means. Our findings suggest that on average the probability of excessive muscular-tendon effort and the risk for biomechanical injury in the unaffected limb are minimal compared with able-bodied, walking controls. However, given individual variability, we recommend routine clinical gait analysis for all people with stiff-legged gait to eliminate excessive values in certain biomechanical parameters, which could, if not addressed, predispose to muscle-tendon strain or joint or ligamentous injury.