Comparison of thalamotomy to deep brain stimulation of the thalamus in essential tremor.

OBJECTIVE: To compare outcome in Essential Tremor (ET) patients who have undergone either thalamotomy or Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) of the thalamus. BACKGROUND: Although both thalamotomy and thalamic DBS are effective surgical treatments of tremor, it is not known if one procedure is superior to the other. DESIGN/METHODS: Thirty-five ET patients underwent thalamotomy between 1994-1998. Data on 18 patients were excluded. The remaining 17 patients were matched for age, sex, side of surgery, and tremor severity to 17 ET patients who underwent thalamic DBS. There were nine men and eight women in each group. The mean age of the thalamotomy group was 74.4 years and that of the thalamic DBS group was 73.1 years. RESULTS: There were no significant differences between any efficacy outcome variables comparing thalamotomy to DBS of the thalamus at baseline or follow-up visits. The surgical complications were higher for the thalamotomy group as compared to the DBS group. However, a larger number of DBS patients underwent repeat surgeries due to problems with the device and the leads. CONCLUSION: Although the efficacy is similar for thalamotomy and DBS of the thalamus for ET, thalamotomy is associated with a higher complication rate. DBS of the thalamus should be the procedure of choice for the surgical treatment of ET in most cases.

Neuropsychological and quality of life outcome after thalamic stimulation for essential tremor.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate short-term effects of unilateral thalamic deep brain stimulation (DBS) on cognition, mood state, and quality of life in patients with essential tremor (ET). BACKGROUND: Unilateral thalamotomy and thalamic DBS are effective in alleviating refractory tremor contralateral to the side of surgery. Thalamotomy can lead to cognitive morbidity, and DBS might be a preferable surgical intervention given potential avoidance or reversibility of such morbidity. Although unilateral thalamic DBS is cognitively safe and leads to quality of life improvement in PD, its neurobehavioral effects in ET are unknown. METHODS: Forty patients with ET were administered a broad neuropsychological test battery, measures of mood state, and generic and disease-specific quality of life measures approximately 1 month before and 3 months after surgery (left hemisphere, 38 patients). RESULTS: Unilateral thalamic DBS was associated with significant improvements in tremor and dominant-hand fine visuomotor coordination. Statistically significant but clinically modest gains were observed on tasks of visuoperceptual and constructional ability, visual attention, delayed word list recognition, and prose recall. Only lexical verbal fluency declined significantly after surgery. Patients rated themselves as less anxious after surgery, and they perceived their quality of life as improved significantly. In particular, patients reported improved quality of life with respect to activities of daily living, stigma, emotional well-being, and communication. CONCLUSIONS: Unilateral thalamic DBS for ET is cognitively safe and associated with improvements in anxiety and quality of life in the near term and in the absence of operative complications. Patients were better able to carry out activities of daily living after surgery, and they reported improvement in several psychosocial domains of quality of life.

Lesion volume and clinical outcome in stereotactic pallidotomy and thalamotomy.

Postoperative lesion volume and clinical outcome were assessed in 19 Parkinson's disease (PD) patients who received posteroventral pallidotomy, and in 14 essential tremor (ET) patients who received ventrolateral thalamotomy. Before and after surgery, PD patients were evaluated using the Unified PD Rating Scale (UPDRS), and ET patients were evaluated using the Fahn-Tolosa-Marin (FTM) tremor rating scale. Inner and total lesion volumes were determined with postoperative MR imaging and three-dimensional data segmentation. Lesion volumes were compared to percent improvement in UPDRS and FTM scores, using Spearman's rank-order correlation test. No rank-order correlations were found between lesion volume and clinical improvement in either the PD or the ET patients. In performing stereotactic surgery for movement disorders, any lesion volume within a prescribed range may be equally effective in relieving symptoms associated with PD or ET.

Comparative magnetic resonance image-based evaluation of thalamotomy and pallidotomy lesion volumes.

Acute thalamotomy and pallidotomy lesion volumes based on magnetic resonance (MR) images were measured in 22 patients (11 thalamotomy and 11 pallidotomy patients). Thalamotomy inner lesion volumes (0.06 +/- 0.04 ml; thermocoagulative zone) were smaller than pallidotomy inner lesion volumes (0.14 +/- 0.08 ml) as determined using T(1)-weighted 3D-MPRAGE (1.5-mm slice spacing). Similar results were found using T(1)-weighted (6-mm slice spacing) image sets (0.09 +/- 0.05 ml, thalamotomy; 0.13 +/- 0.05 ml, pallidotomy). No differences were found when comparing thalamic or pallidal inner lesion volumes when the comparison was based on T(2) weighted images. Thalamotomy total lesion volumes (thermocoagulative and surrounding edematous zones) were less than pallidotomy total lesion volumes independent of the MR protocol. The difference in thalamotomy and pallidotomy lesion volumes is most likely based on the distance between each discrete lesion placed along the lesioning tracts. In 7 of 11 thalamotomies, this distance was 1 mm with the remaining having 2 mm between each discrete lesion. All pallidotomy discrete lesions were 2 mm apart. More overlap between discrete lesioning sites for thalamotomies is likely to produce reduced lesion volumes.

Comparison of actual pallidotomy lesion location with expected stereotactic location.

Accuracy of pallidotomy lesion placement was assessed by comparing actual lesion locations with expected pallidotomy lesion locations based on stereotaxy. Actual and expected lesions were compared in anteroposterior, dorsoventral and lateral axes. In 22 pallidotomies, actual lesion locations were determined using axial MR images. Expected lesion locations were calculated using a starting point derived from preoperative computerized tomography, displacements from the starting point based on microelectrode-driven electrophysiological refinement, and the trajectory angle of the lesioning tract relative to the anterior-posterior commissural plane. On average, actual lesion locations were found 2.91 +/- 2.23 mm posterior, 3.22 +/- 2.49 mm ventral, and 0.05 +/- 1.80 mm lateral compared to the expected lesion location. Discrepancies between the actual lesion and expected lesion locations may be mostly accounted for by posterior and ventral lesion spread from the exposed electrode tip, in-plane and volume averaging effects associated with MR images, and possible brain shifting during surgery. However, despite the remaining small differences between actual and expected lesion location, good clinical outcome of reduced dyskinesias and 'off' time along with UPDRS-based improvement in mentation, motor and activity of daily living measures was observed.

Analysis of pallidotomy lesion positions using three-dimensional reconstruction of pallidal lesions, the basal ganglia, and the optic tract.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the position of radiofrequency pallidotomy lesions placed using microelectrode stimulation and cellular recordings in relation to a stereotactically defined starting point. Radiofrequency lesion locations were also evaluated in relation to the putamen, posterior limb of the internal capsule, and optic tract. METHODS: Magnetic resonance images obtained from 23 patients with Parkinson's disease who underwent pallidotomy at the University of Kansas Medical Center were analyzed. Using computerized techniques, lesion positions in relation to the midcommissural point and a hypothetical starting point were determined. Data segmentation and three-dimensional reconstruction of pallidal lesions, the internal capsule, and the optic tract allowed assessment of lesion position in relation to internal anatomy. Clinical outcome of pallidotomy was assessed using both the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale and the Dementia Rating Scale. RESULTS: Pallidal lesions were usually placed anterior and dorsal to the stereotactically defined starting point. The position of pallidal lesions in the men were observed, in four trials, to be significantly more dorsal than the lesions in the women. The outer zone of the lesion was usually adjacent to the internal capsule and the putamen and relatively close to the optic tract. The inner zone of the lesion was usually several millimeters removed from anatomic boundaries of the putamen, internal capsule, and optic tract. Patients achieved favorable outcomes, with reduced dyskinesias and "off" time and improvement of their Parkinsonian symptoms, as evidenced by clinical assessment, the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale, and the Dementia Rating Scale. CONCLUSION: Microelectrode stimulation and cellular recordings usually led to a final pallidotomy lesion position that deviated from the stereotactically defined starting point. The pallidotomy lesions in the men were observed to be more dorsal than the lesions in the women. Clinical outcomes were not correlated with either lesion location relative to the starting point or distances between the pallidal lesion and the putamen, internal capsule, or optic tract. Kinesthetically responsive cells may be localized generally more anterior and dorsal to the starting point (within the globus pallidus) and may be grouped variably from patient to patient in relation to other basal ganglia structures. Although the primary lesion site is most likely within the sensorimotor region of the globus pallidus internus, the more dorsal locations of responsive cell groups may indicate that some lesion sites may be localized within the globus pallidus externus.

Magnetic resonance image evaluation of pallidotomy lesions: a volumetric and shape analysis.

Determination of acute pallidotomy-produced lesion volumes, pre- and postpallidotomy globus pallidus (GP) volumes, and assessment of lesion shape using magnetic resonance (MR) imaging-based computerized segmentation (contouring) and three-dimensional rendering was made in 19 patients. Magnetic resonance image slice thickness (1.5 mm or 6 mm) was not found to be a significant factor influencing contour-based pallidotomy lesion volume estimates. Previously reported lesion volumes produced by pallidotomy have often been estimated using the ellipsoid volume formula. Using 1.5-mm-thick MR sections, contour-based pallidotomy-produced lesion volumes were significantly different from those volumes estimated by the ellipsoid formula. Globus pallidus volumes, estimated by contouring T2-weighted MR images, were bilaterally similar (2.4 +/- 0.37 ml [right]; 2.2 +/- 0.45 ml [left]). Postoperative GP volumes were found on the contralateral, unlesioned side to be 2 +/- 0.45 ml and on the lesioned side to be 1.25 +/- 0.45 ml. Using the contralateral, unlesioned side as a reference volume, approximately 39 +/- 14% of the GP was visibly affected on the lesioned side. Seventeen of 18 patients had a favorable outcome with reduced dyskinesias and "off" time with improvement in parkinsonian symptoms. Analysis of computerized three-dimensional rendering of pallidotomy-produced lesions based on MR images showed no relationship between lesioning technique and resulting lesion shape. Important factors in the volumetric analysis of pallidotomy lesions are identified and allow reasonable assessment of the pallidotomy lesion volume and shape and the extent of the affected GP.