Manipulating the direction of electron transfer in the bacterial reaction center by swapping Phe for Tyr near BChl(M) (L181) and Tyr for Phe near BChl(L) (M208).

We have investigated the primary charge separation processes in Rb. capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) bearing the mutations Phe(L181) --> Tyr, Tyr(M208) --> Phe, and Leu(M212) --> His. In the YFH mutant, decay of the excited primary electron donor P occurs with an 11 +/- 2 ps time constant and is trifurcated to give (1) internal conversion to the ground state ( approximately 10% yield), (2) charge separation to the L side of the RC ( approximately 60% yield), and (3) electron transfer to the M-side bacteriopheophytin BPh(M) ( approximately 30% yield). These results relate previous work in which the ionizable residues Lys (at L178) and Asp (at M201) have been used to facilitate charge separation to the M side of the RC, and the widely studied L181 and M208 mutants. One conclusion that comes from this work is that the Tyr (M208) --> Phe and Gly(M201) --> Asp mutations near the L-side bacteriochlorophyll (BChl(L)) raise the free energy of P(+)BChl(L)(-) by comparable amounts. The results also suggest that the free energy of P(+)BChl(M)(-) is lowered more substantially by a Tyr at L181 than a Lys at L178. The results on the YFH mutant further demonstrate that the free energy differences between the L- and M-side charge-separated states play a significant role in the directionality of charge separation in the wild-type RC, and place limits on the contributing role of differential electronic matrix elements on the two sides of the RC.

Relationship between altered structure and photochemistry in mutant reaction centers in which bacteriochlorophyll replaces the photoactive bacteriopheophytin.

Qy-excitation resonance Raman (RR) spectra are reported for two mutant reaction centers (RCs) from Rhodobacter capsulatus in which the photoactive bacteriopheophytin (BPhL) is replaced by a bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) molecule, designated beta. The pigment change in both mutants is induced via introduction of a histidine residue near the photoactive cofactor. In one mutant, L(M212)H, the histidine is positioned over the core of the cofactor and serves as an axial ligand to the Mg+2 ion. In the other mutant, F(L121)H/F(L97)V, the histidine is positioned over ring V of the cofactor, which is nominally too distant to permit bonding to the Mg+2 ion. The salient observations are as follows: (1) The beta cofactor in F(L121)H/F(L97)V RCs is a five-coordinate BChl molecule. However, there is no evidence for the formation of a Mg-His bond. This bond is either much weaker than in the L(M212)H RCs or completely absent, the latter implying coordination by an alternative ligand. The different axial ligation for beta in the F(L121)H/F(L97)V versus L(M212)H RCs in turn leads to different conformations of the BChl macrocycles. (2) The C9-keto group of beta in F(L121)H/F(L97)V RCs is free of hydrogen bonding interactions, unlike the L(M212)H RCs in which the C9-keto of beta is hydrogen bonded to Glu L104. The interactions between other peripheral substituents of beta and the protein are also different in the F(L121)H/F(L97)V RCs versus L(M212)H RCs. Accordingly, the position and orientation of beta in the protein is different in the two beta-containing RCs. Nonetheless, previous studies have shown that the primary electron transfer reactions are very similar in the two mutants but differ in significant respects compared to wild-type RCs. Collectively, these observations indicate that changes in the conformation of a photoactive tetrapyrrole macrocycle or its interactions with the protein do not necessarily lead to significantly perturbed photochemistry and do not underlie the altered primary events in beta-type RCs.

M-side electron transfer in reaction center mutants with a lysine near the nonphotoactive bacteriochlorophyll.

We report the primary charge separation events in a series of Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) that have been genetically modified to contain a lysine near the bacteriochlorophyll molecule, BChl(M), on the nonphotoactive M-side of the RC. Using wild type and previously constructed mutants as templates, we substituted Lys for the native Ser residue at position 178 on the L polypeptide to make the S(L178)K single mutant, the S(L178)K/G(M201)D and S(L178)K/L(M212)H double mutants, and the S(L178)K/G(M201)D/L(M212)H triple mutant. In the triple mutant, the decay of the photoexcited primary electron donor (P) occurs with a time constant of 15 ps and is accompanied by 15% return to the ground state, 62% electron transfer to the L-side bacteriopheophytin, BPh(L), and 23% electron transfer to the M-side analogue, BPh(M). The data supporting electron transfer to the M-side include bleaching of the Q(X) band of BPh(M) at 528 nm and a spectrally and kinetically resolved anion band with a maximum at 640 nm assigned to BPh(M)(-). The decay of these features and concomitant approximately 20% decay of bleaching of the 850 nm band of P give a P(+)BPh(M)(-) lifetime on the order of 1-2 ns that reflects deactivation to give the ground state. These data and additional findings are compared to those from parallel experiments on the G(M201)D/L(M212)H double mutant, in which 15% electron transfer to BPh(M) has been reported previously and is reproduced here. We also compare the above results with the primary electron-transfer processes in S(L178)K, S(L178)K/G(M201)D, and S(L178)K /L(M212)H RCs and with those for the L(M212)H and G(M201)D single mutants and wild-type RCs. The comparison of extensive results that track the primary events in these eight RCs helps to elucidate key factors underlying the directionality and high yield of charge separation in the bacterial photosynthetic RC.

Resonance raman characterization of reaction centers with an Asp residue near the photoactive bacteriopheophytin.

Qy-excitation resonance Raman (RR) studies are reported for a series of Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) containing mutations at L-polypeptide residue 121 near the photoactive bacteriopheophytin (BPhL). The studies focus on the electronic/structural perturbations of BPhL induced by replacing the native Phe with an Asp residue. Earlier work has shown that the electron-transfer properties of F(L121)D RCs are closely related to those of RCs in which BPhL is replaced by bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) (beta-type RCs) or by pheophytin. In addition to the F(L121)D single mutant, RR studies were performed on the F(L121)D/E(L104)L double mutant, which additionally removes the hydrogen bond between BPhL and the native Glu L104 residue. The vibrational signatures of BPhL in the single and double mutants containing Asp L121 are compared with one another and with those of BPhL in both wild-type and F(L121)L RCs. The replacement of the aromatic Phe residue with Leu has no discernible effect on the vibrational properties of BPhL, a finding in concert with the previously reported absence of an effect of the mutation on the electron-transfer characteristics of the RC. In contrast, replacement of Phe with Asp significantly perturbs the vibrational characteristics of BPhL, and in a manner most consistent with Asp L121 being deprotonated and negatively charged. The negative charge of the carboxyl group of Asp L121 interacts with the pi-electron system of BPhL in a relatively nonspecific fashion, diminishing the contribution of charge-separated resonance forms of the C9-keto group to the electronic structure of the cofactor. The presence of a negative charge near BPhL is consistent with the known photochemistry of F(L121)D RCs, which indicates that the free energy of P+BPhL- is substantially higher than in wild-type RCs.

Effects of Asp residues near the L-side pigments in bacterial reaction centers.

The primary photochemistry in Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) containing the Phe to Asp mutation at L polypeptide residue 121 near the photoactive bacteriopheophytin (BPhL) is characterized using ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy. At 285 K, initial charge separation from P* proceeds with essentially unity quantum yield in approximately 6 ps to form a transient denoted P+I-. This transient is proposed to involve P+BPhL- and probably P+BChlL- as well (BChlL is the L-side bacteriochlorophyll molecule). P+I- decays in approximately 150 ps both by electron transfer to give P+QA- (approximately 78% yield) and by charge recombination to the ground state (approximately 22% yield). These results indicate that the F(L121)D mutant is closely related, in terms of its electron transfer properties, to previously reported RCs in which BPhL is replaced with a bacteriochlorophyll (beta-type RCs) or a pheophytin. However, the native BPhL pigment is retained in the F(L121)D mutant. We propose that the Asp at L121 raises the free energy of P+BPhL-, thereby giving rise to the altered photochemistry. At 77 K, the P+I- lifetime is shortened slightly to approximately 120 ps and the yield of P+QA- is increased to approximately 88%. This result is somewhat different from that obtained for beta-type RCs at low temperature, where the P+I- lifetime lengthens and the yield of P+QA- diminishes or stays about the same compared to the values near room temperature. We exploit these differences in developing a model for the charge separation process in the F(L121)D mutant. The effects of introducing an Asp near BPhL are compared to those obtained previously in two mutants in which an Asp is introduced near BChlL.

Control of electron transfer between the L- and M-sides of photosynthetic reaction centers.

An aspartic acid residue has been introduced near ring V of the L-side accessory bacteriochlorophyll (BCHlL) or the photosynthetic reaction center in a rhodobacter capsulatus mutant in which a His also replaces Leu 212 on the M-polypeptide. The initial stage of charge separation in the G(M201)D/L(M212)H double mutant yields approximately 70 percent electron transfer to the L-side cofactors, approximately 15 percent rapid deactivation to the ground state, and approximately 15 percent electron transfer to the so-called inactive M-side bacteriopheophytin (BPhM). It is suggested here that the Asp introduced at M201 modulates the reduction potential of BCHlL, thereby changing the energetics of charge separation. The results demonstrate that an individual amino acid residue can, through its influence on the free energies of the charge-separated states, effectively dictate the balance between the forward electron transfer reactions on the L-side of the RC, the charge-recombination processes, and electron transfer to the M-side chromophores.

Characterization of bacterial reaction centers having mutations of aromatic residues in the binding site of the bacteriopheophytin intermediary electron carrier.

We report the initial characterization of a series of reaction centers (RCs) from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus having single or double mutations of phenylalanines 97 and 121 on the L polypeptide. Substitution of these aromatic amino acids, which may interact with the photoactive bacteriopheophytin associated with the L polypeptide (BPhL), was carried out to examine their possible roles in electron transfer, charge stabilization, and/or BPhL binding. In some mutant RCs, the wild-type pigment content is obtained while in certain others a bacteriochlorophyll (BChL) replaces BPhL. The mutant RCs with wild-type pigment content are found to have overall photochemistry effectively identical to that of wild-type RCs. This indicates aromatic residues at L97 and L121 are not critical factors in the charge separation process, although an approximate 2-fold increase in the rate of electron transfer from BPhL- to QA is observed in two mutants where residue L121 is leucine. In two double mutants where L121 is histidine and L97 is either valine or cysteine, BPhL is replaced with a BChl (denoted beta). This pigment content is surprising since in the native RC structure amino acid L121 is not in optimum geometry for coordination to the Mg in the center of the pigment macrocycle. Charge separation takes place in the beta-containing mutants with an approximately 70% yield of P+QA- at 285 K compared to approximately 100% for wild-type. The photochemistry of these new beta-type RCs is very similar to that reported previously for the beta RC from Rhodobacter sphaeroides wherein the same pigment change was induced by a mutation in the M polypeptide.

Studies on selectin-carbohydrate interactions.

Recruitment of neutrophils to sites of inflammation is now believed to occur through an initial rolling interaction at the luminal surface of activated endothelium and is mediated by a class of mammalian lectins referred to as the selectins. Selectins recognize carbohydrate determinants on co-receptors. It is generally believed that many selectin molecules must bind to many carbohydrate receptor molecules i.e. multivalent binding, to enable sufficient binding strength to elicit the rolling response between the neutrophil and the endothelial cell. One of the approaches to the generation of more potent molecular antagonists of the selectin-mediated cell-cell interaction is to mimic the multivalent interaction in a single compound. Recent experiments utilising conjugated forms of sialyl Lewisx-BSA have explored this feasibility (Welply et al., 1994). In that study, monovalent sLex (sialic acid alpha 2-3Gal beta 1-4(Fuc alpha 1-3)GlcNAc), the minimum binding determinant for E-selectin, as well as monovalent sialyllactosamine (sialic acid alpha 2-3Gal beta 1-4GlcNAc), a non-binding structure, and the corresponding multivalent BSA-conjugated forms were tested for their ability to inhibit binding of HL-60 cells to immobilised E-selectin. As expected, only sLex and sLex-BSA were found to do so. sLex16-BSA (16 mol tetrasaccharide/mol BSA) showed a dose-dependent inhibition of HL-60 binding with a measured IC50 of 1 microM; demonstrating close to a three-order of magnitude enhancement of inhibitory activity compared to free sLex. This result indicated that multivalent forms of sLex are capable of binding to E-selectin with higher affinity than do monovalent glycans. In another study, fluorescent forms of monovalent sLex were synthesized and used to measure a true thermodynamic dissociation constant for the monovalent sLex:E-selectin interaction of 120 +/- 31 microM (Jacob et.al., 1995).

Binding of sialyl Lewis x to E-selectin as measured by fluorescence polarization.

Fluorescence polarization has been used to directly measure the binding of the tetrasaccharide sialyl Lewisx (sLe(x)[Glc], or NeuAc alpha 2-3Gal beta 1-4[Fuc alpha 1-3]Glc) to a soluble form of E-selectin, a member of the class of adhesion molecules that plays an important role in immune-cell response to inflammation. The experiments utilized a fluorescent derivative of sLe(x)[Glc] with fluorescein attached directly to the glucose residue through a beta-glycosidic linkage. The resulting fluorescent sLe(x) was shown to inhibit binding of HL60 cells to immobilized E-selectin and exhibited fluorescence polarization enhancement in the presence of a monovalent form of a recombinant soluble E-selectin-Fc chimera. Thermodynamic dissociation constants of 107 +/- 26 and 120 +/- 31 microM were obtained for the fluorescent sLe(x)[Glc] and the free sLe(x)[Glc] sugars, respectively. These results demonstrate that E-selectin interacts weakly with the minimal carbohydrate recognition determinant sLe(x). Additional binding interactions through the action of the authentic coreceptor or via clustering of the ligand and E-selectin molecules on the respective neutrophil and endothelial cell surfaces may also play a role in the overall cellular binding strength. However, the basic interaction between carbohydrate and protein appears weak, consistent with other carbohydrate-protein interactions studied to date.

Investigation into the source of electron transfer asymmetry in bacterial reaction centers.

We have investigated the primary photochemistry of two symmetry-related mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides in which the histidine residues associated with the central Mg2+ ions of the two bacteriochlorophylls of the dimeric primary electron donor (His-L173 and His-M202) have been changed to leucine, affording bacteriochlorophyll (BChl)/bacteriopheophytin (BPh) heterodimers. Reaction centers (RCs) from the two mutants, (L)H173L and (M)H202L, have remarkably similar spectral and kinetic properties, although they are quite different from those of wild-type RCs. In both mutants, as in wild-type RCs, electron transfer to BPhL and not to BPhM is observed. These results suggest that asymmetry in the charge distribution of the excited BChl dimer (P*) in wild-type RCs (due to differing contributions of the two opposing intradimer charge-transfer states) contributes only modestly to the directionality of electron transfer. The results also suggest that differential orbital overlap of the two BChls of P with the chromophores on the L and M polypeptides does not contribute substantially to preferential electron transfer to BPhL.

Charge separation in a reaction center incorporating bacteriochlorophyll for photoactive bacteriopheophytin.

Site-directed mutagenic replacement of M subunit Leu214 by His in the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides results in incorporation of a bacteriochlorophyll molecule (BChl) in place of the native bacteriopheophytin (BPh) electron acceptor. Evidence supporting this conclusion includes the ground-state absorption spectrum of the (M)L214H mutant, pigment and metal analyses, and time-resolved optical experiments. The genetically modified RC supports transmembrane charge separation from the photoexcited BChl dimer to the primary quinone through the new BChl molecule, but with a reduced quantum yield of 60 percent (compared to 100 percent in wild-type RCs). These results have important implications for the mechanism of charge separation in the RC, and rationalize the choice of (bacterio)pheophytins as electron acceptors in a variety of photosynthetic systems.

An assessment of the mechanism of initial electron transfer in bacterial reaction centers.

Subpicosecond time-resolved photodichroism measurements on Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 reaction centers are reported in the key region between 620 and 740 nm, where the anions of both bacteriopheophytin and bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) have their most diagnostic absorption bands. These measurements fail to resolve clearly the formation of a reduced BChl species. The implications of this for elucidating the role of the accessory BChl in the initial stage of charge separation are discussed.

Evidence that a distribution of bacterial reaction centers underlies the temperature and detection-wavelength dependence of the rates of the primary electron-transfer reactions.

The rates of the primary electron-transfer processes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers have been examined in detail by using 150-fs excitation flashes at 870 nm. At room temperature the apparent time constants for both initial charge separation (P* --> P+BPhL-) and subsequent electron transfer (P+BPhL- --> P+QA-) are found to encompass a range of values (approximately 1.3-4 ps and approximately 100-320 ps, respectively), depending on the wavelength at which the kinetics are followed. We suggest this reflects a distribution of reaction centers (or a few conformers), having differences in factors such as distances or orientations between the cofactors, hydrogen bonding, or other pigment-protein interactions. We also suggest that the time constants observed at cryogenic temperatures (approximately 1.3 and approximately 100 ps, respectively, with much smaller or negligible variation with detection wavelength) do not reflect an actual increase in the rates with decreasing temperature but rather derive from a shift in the distribution of reaction centers toward those in which electron transfer inherently occurs with the faster rates.

Electron transfer in a genetically modified bacterial reaction center containing a heterodimer.

Time-resolved optical measurements encompassing the femtoseconds to seconds time scales have been used to investigate Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) in which the histidine residue at position 200 on the M polypeptide has been changed to a leucine by site-directed mutagenesis. The HisM200----Leu RC, which has a heterodimer consisting of a bacteriochlorophyll and a bacteriopheophytin, is capable of the primary photochemistry observed in wild-type Rb. capsulatus RCs, but with an overall quantum yield reduced by about half. The lower yield resides in the initial electron transfer reaction and may be associated in part with substantial charge transfer character of the excited heterodimer. These and other comparisons between Rb. capsulatus wild-type and HisM200----Leu RCs have important implications for our understanding of the mechanism of electron transfer in the RC and the efficiency of the charge separation process.

Primary photochemistry of reaction centers from the photosynthetic purple bacteria.

Photosynthetic organisms transform the energy of sunlight into chemical potential in a specialized membrane-bound pigment-protein complex called the reaction center. Following light activation, the reaction center produces a charge-separated state consisting of an oxidized electron donor molecule and a reduced electron acceptor molecule. This primary photochemical process, which occurs via a series of rapid electron transfer steps, is complete within a nanosecond of photon absorption. Recent structural data on reaction centers of photosynthetic bacteria, combined with results from a large variety of photochemical measurements have expanded our understanding of how efficient charge separation occurs in the reaction center, and have changed many of the outstanding questions.

Primary photochemistry of iron-depleted and zinc-reconstituted reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides.

The primary photochemistry of Fe-depleted and Zn-reconstituted reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26.1 was studied by transient absorption spectroscopy and compared with native, Fe(2+)-containing reaction centers. Excitation of metal-free reaction centers with 30-ps flashes produced the initial charge-separated state P(+)I(-) (P(+)BPh(-), where P is the primary donor and BPh is bacteriopheophytin) with a yield and visible/near-infrared absorption difference spectrum indistinguishable from that observed in native reaction centers. However, the lifetime of P(+)I(-) was found to increase approximately 20-fold to 4.2 +/- 0.3 ns (compared to 205 ps in native reaction centers), and the yield of formation of the subsequent state P(+)Q(A) (-) (Q(A) is the primary quinone acceptor) was reduced to 47 +/- 5% (compared to essentially 100% in native reaction centers). The remaining 53% of the metal-free reaction centers were found to undergo charge recombination during the P(+)I(-) lifetime to yield both the ground state (28 +/- 5%) and the triplet state P(R) (25 +/- 5%). Reconstitution of Fe-depleted reaction centers with Zn(2+) restored the "native" photochemistry. Possible mechanisms responsible for the reduced decay rate of P(+)I(-) in metal-free reaction centers are discussed.

Primary photochemistry in the facultative green photosynthetic bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus.

The mechanism of primary photochemistry has been investigated in purified cytoplasmic membranes and isolated reaction centers of Chloroflexus aurantiacus. Redox titrations on the cytoplasmic membranes indicate that the midpoint redox potential of P870, the primary electron donor bacteriochlorophyll, is +362 mV. An early electron acceptor, presumably menaquinone has Em 8.1 = -50 mV, and a tightly bound photooxidizable cytochrome c554 has Em 8.1 = +245 mV. The isolated reaction center has a bacteriochlorophyll to bacteriopheophytin ratio of 0.94:1. A two-quinone acceptor system is present, and is inhibited by o-phenanthroline. Picosecond transient absorption and kinetic measurements indicate the bacteriopheophytin and bacteriochlorophyll form an earlier electron acceptor complex.