Influence of scaffold stiffness on subchondral bone and subsequent cartilage regeneration in an ovine model of osteochondral defect healing.

BACKGROUND: In osteochondral defects, subchondral bone, as a load-bearing structure, is believed to be important for bone and cartilage regeneration. HYPOTHESIS: A stiff scaffold creates better conditions for bone formation and cartilage regeneration than does a softer one. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Critical osteochondral defects were created in the femoral condyles of 24 sheep. Subchondral bone was reconstructed with a stiff scaffold or a modified softer one, with untreated defects serving as controls. The repair response was evaluated with mechanical, histological, and histomorphometrical techniques at 3 and 6 months postoperatively. RESULTS: The elastic modulus of regenerated fibrocartilage over the stiff scaffold tended to be higher than in the soft scaffold group (61% vs 46% of healthy cartilage) at 3 months. No difference was determined at 6 months; all were well below healthy cartilage. Treated defects showed substantial degradation of the soft scaffold with surrounding sclerotic bone at 3 and 6 months. In contrast, degradation of the stiff scaffold was slower and occurred together with continuous osseous replacement. CONCLUSION: Stiff scaffolds were found to improve bone regeneration. In contrast, soft scaffolds provided less support, and consequently subchondral bone became sclerotic. Although regenerated cartilage formed over the stiff scaffolds at 3 months, and these exhibited better mechanical properties than did the soft scaffold group, the mechanical properties in both treated groups were the same at 6 months, not dissimilar to that of tissue formed in the untreated specimens and inferior to native articular cartilage. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The results imply that subchondral defect filling in clinical settings advances bone regeneration and should have a comparable stiffness to that of healthy subchondral bone rather than being too flexible. Degradation of resorbable materials and consequently the loss of stiffness may compromise the healing of critical defects.

Crushed bone grafts and a collagen membrane are not suitable for enhancing cartilage quality in the regeneration of osteochondral defects--an in vivo study in sheep.

Hyaline joint cartilage has only a limited potential for self-repair. Some of the published techniques for osteochondral defect therapy try to improve that potential. In this study, it was hypothesised that one of those surgical techniques, the crushed transplanted bone graft together with a collagen membrane, accelerates significantly the reconstruction of the subchondral bone plate and improves the mechanical and histological quality of repaired cartilage in osteochondral defects compared to an empty control defect. In order to test this hypothesis, defects were created in the left knee of 12 sheep and filled either with autologous crushed bone graft or left empty. The animals were sacrificed after 3 (n = 6) and 6 (n = 6) months. No differences were found either macroscopically or histomorphometrically between the bone graft and empty control defects. The biomechanical as well as the histological results of the bone graft defects were inferior to the control defects with inflammatory processes caused either by bone graft or membrane remnants. Based on the results in this sheep model, the filling of subchondral bone defects with compacted cancellous bone should be carefully reconsidered.

Mechanical behavior of articular cartilage after osteochondral autograft transfer in an ovine model.

BACKGROUND: Grafting of autologous hyaline cartilage and bone for articular cartilage repair is a well-accepted technique. Although encouraging midterm clinical results have been reported, no information on the mechanical competence of the transplanted joint surface is available. HYPOTHESIS: The mechanical competence of osteochondral autografts is maintained after transplantation. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Osteochondral defects were filled with autografts (7.45 mm in diameter) in one femoral condyle in 12 mature sheep. The ipsilateral femoral condyle served as the donor site, and the resulting defect (8.3 mm in diameter) was left empty. The repair response was examined after 3 and 6 months with mechanical and histologic assessment and histomorphometric techniques. RESULTS: Good surface congruity and plug placement was achieved. The Young modulus of the grafted cartilage significantly dropped to 57.5% of healthy tissue after 3 months (P < .05) but then recovered to 82.2% after 6 months. The aggregate and dynamic moduli behaved similarly. The graft edges showed fibrillation and, in some cases (4 of 6), hypercellularity and chondrocyte clustering. Subchondral bone sclerosis was observed in 8 of 12 cases, and the amount of mineralized bone in the graft area increased from 40% to 61%. CONCLUSIONS: The mechanical quality of transplanted cartilage varies considerably over a short period of time, potentially reflecting both degenerative and regenerative processes, while histologically signs of both cartilage and bone degeneration occur. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Both the mechanically degenerative and restorative processes illustrate the complex progression of regeneration after osteochondral transplantation. The histologic evidence raises doubts as to the long-term durability of the osteochondral repair.

A new device to detect early cartilage degeneration.

BACKGROUND: Currently available arthroscopic techniques do not allow the quantification of cartilage stiffness without direct mechanical indentation or penetration of the tissue. PURPOSE: A novel device, capable of quantifying cartilage stiffness during arthroscopy, is believed to detect degenerated cartilage. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: The stiffness of biological materials was measured arthroscopically without contact between the instrument and the examined object. Object deformation was produced by a flow of sodium chloride and measured optically. Eight ovine femoral condyles and tibial plateaus were tested in a native and degenerated (0.1% trypsin solution) state. Cartilage stiffness was nondestructively determined by using the new device and by indentation methods. In addition, a standard probe was measured by 5 independent users. RESULTS: The trypsin caused cartilage degeneration and consequently stiffness reduction, measured at 30.8% by the new device and 33.0% by indentation. A good correlation (r = 0.69) between the new device and the standard indentation procedure was observed. Intraindividual and interindividual variability of the new device were low (<10%). CONCLUSIONS: The developed device has demonstrated the ability to quantify the mechanical quality of cartilage by means of mechanical stiffness measurements. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The findings suggest that this device has the capability to detect cartilage degeneration at an early stage.

THA loading arising from increased femoral anteversion and offset may lead to critical cement stresses.

Aseptic loosening of artificial hip joints is believed to be influenced by the design and orientation of the implant. It is hypothesised that variations in implant anteversion and offset lead to changes in the loading of the proximal femur, causing critical conditions to both the bone and cement. The goal of this study was therefore to analyse the role of these parameters on loading, bone strains and cement stresses in total hip arthroplasty (THA). A validated musculo-skeletal model was used for the analysis of muscle and joint contact forces during walking and stair climbing. Two different anteversion angles (4 degrees vs. 24 degrees ) and prostheses offsets (standard vs. long) were analysed. The loads for each case were applied to a cemented THA finite element model. Generally, stair climbing caused higher bone strains and cement stresses (max. +25%) than walking. Variations in anteversion and offset caused changes in the loading environment, bone strain distribution and cement stresses. Compared to the standard THA configuration, cement stresses were raised by increasing anteversion (max. +52%), offset (max. +5%) and their combination (max. +67%). Femoral anteversion, offset and their combination may therefore lead to an increased risk of implant loosening. Analyses of implant survival should consider this as a limiting factor in THA longevity. In clinical practice, implant orientation, especially in regard to pre- and post-operative anteversion, should be considered to be more critical.