Structure of a BRCA1-BARD1 heterodimeric RING-RING complex.

The RING domain of the breast and ovarian cancer tumor suppressor BRCA1 interacts with multiple cognate proteins, including the RING protein BARD1. Proper function of the BRCA1 RING domain is critical, as evidenced by the many cancer-predisposing mutations found within this domain. We present the solution structure of the heterodimer formed between the RING domains of BRCA1 and BARD1. Comparison with the RING homodimer of the V(D)J recombination-activating protein RAG1 reveals the structural diversity of complexes formed by interactions between different RING domains. The BRCA1-BARD1 structure provides a model for its ubiquitin ligase activity, illustrates how the BRCA1 RING domain can be involved in associations with multiple protein partners and provides a framework for understanding cancer-causing mutations at the molecular level.

BRCA1 RING domain cancer-predisposing mutations. Structural consequences and effects on protein-protein interactions.

Cancer-predisposing missense mutations in the RING domain of BRCA1 primarily target Zn(2+)-liganding residues. Here we report on the structural consequences of such mutations introduced into the second Zn(2+) site (Site II) of the BRCA1 RING domain and their effect on the interaction with the BARD1 RING domain. Each of the BRCA1 Site II mutants still interact and form a stable heterodimer with BARD1. Limited proteolysis of BRCA1/BARD1 complexes, monitored by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight spectrometry, show that the mutations cause a local structural perturbation that is primarily confined to the second Zn(2+) binding loop of the BRCA1 subunit. These findings are consistent with the structure of the BRCA1/BARD1 heterodimer, which shows this region is well removed from the helices required for dimerization with BARD1. Instead, the mutations alter a region of BRCA1 that appears to be required for interaction with ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes.

The whole is not the simple sum of its parts in calmodulin from S. cerevisiae.

Calmodulin is an essential Ca(2+)-binding protein involved in a multitude of cellular processes. The calmodulin sequence is highly conserved among all eukaryotic species; calmodulin from the yeast S. cerevisiae (yCaM) is the most divergent form, while still sharing 60% sequence identity with vertebrate calmodulin (vCaM). Although yCaM can be functionally substituted by vCaM in vivo, the two calmodulin proteins possess significantly different Ca(2+)-binding properties as well as abilities to activate vertebrate target enzymes in vitro. In addition, it has been observed that certain properties of the N-terminal and C-terminal domains of Ca(2+)-yCaM differ depending on whether they are in the context of the whole protein or isolated as half-molecule fragments. To investigate the structural basis for these differing properties, we have undertaken nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies on yCaM and the two half-molecule fragments representing its two individual domains, yTr1(residues 1-76) and yTr2 (residues 75-146). We present direct evidence that the two domains of Ca(2+)-yCaM interact via their exposed hydrophobic surfaces. Thus, the Ca(2+)-bound form of yCaM exists in a novel compact structure in direct contrast to the well-established structure of Ca(2+)-vCaM comprised of two independent globular domains.

A folding transition and novel zinc finger accessory domain in the transcription factor ADR1.

The region responsible for sequence-specific DNA binding by the transcription factor ADR1 contains two Cys2-His2 zinc fingers and an additional N-terminal proximal accessory region (PAR). The N-terminal (non-finger) PAR is unstructured in the absence of DNA and undergoes a folding transition on binding the DNA transcription target site. We have used a set of HN-HN NOEs derived from a perdeuterated protein-DNA complex to describe the fold of ADR1 bound to the UAS1 binding site. The PAR forms a compact domain consisting of three antiparallel strands that contact A-T base pairs in the major groove. The three-strand domain is a novel fold among all known DNA-binding proteins. The PAR shares sequence homology with the N-terminal regions of other zinc finger proteins, suggesting that it represents a new DNA-binding module that extends the binding repertoire of zinc finger proteins.

Increased helix and protein stability through the introduction of a new tertiary hydrogen bond.

In an effort to quantify the importance of hydrogen bonding and alpha-helix formation to protein stability, a capping box motif was introduced into the small phosphocarrier protein HPr. Previous studies had confirmed that Ser46, at the N-cap position of the short helix-B in HPr, serves as an N-cap in solution. Thus, only a single-site mutation was required to produce a canonical S-X-X-E capping box: Lys49 at the N3 position was substituted with a glutamic acid residue. Thermal and chemical denaturation studies on the resulting K49E HPr show that the designed variant is approximately 2 kcal mol-1 more stable than the wild-type protein. However, NMR studies indicate that the side-chain of Glu49 does not participate in the expected capping H-bond interaction, but instead forms a new tertiary H-bond that links helix-B to the four-stranded beta-sheet of HPr. Here, we demonstrate that a strategy in which new non-native H-bonds are introduced can generate proteins with increased stability. We discuss why the original capping box design failed, and compare the energetic consequences of the new tertiary side-chain to main-chain H-bond with a local (helix-capping) side-chain to main-chain H-bond on the protein's global stability.

Mapping the functional domains of BRCA1. Interaction of the ring finger domains of BRCA1 and BARD1.

Breast cancer 1 (BRCA1) and BRCA1-associated RING domain 1 (BARD1) are multidomain proteins that interact in vivo via their N-terminal RING finger motif regions. To characterize functional aspects of the BRCA1/BARD1 interaction, we have defined the structural domains required for the interaction, as well as their oligomerization state, relative stability, and possible nucleic acid binding activity. We have found that the RING finger motifs do not themselves constitute stable structural domains but are instead part of larger domains comprising residues 1-109 of BRCA1 and residues 26-119 of BARD1. These domains exist as homodimers and preferentially form a stable heterodimer. Shorter BRCA1 RING finger constructs do not interact with BARD1 or with longer BRCA1 constructs, indicating that the heterodimeric and homodimer interactions are mediated by regions outside the canonical RING finger motif. Nucleic acid binding is a generally proposed function of RING finger domains. We show that neither the homodimers nor the heterodimer displays affinity for nucleic acids, indicating that the proposed roles of BRCA1 and BARD1 in DNA repair and/or transcriptional activation must be mediated either by other regions of the proteins or by additional cofactors.

Solution structure of the sodium channel inactivation gate.

The sodium channel initiates action potentials by opening in response to membrane depolarization. Fast channel inactivation, which is required for proper physiological function, is mediated by a cytoplasmic loop proposed to occlude the ion pore via a hinged lid mechanism with the triad IFM serving as a hydrophobic "latch". The NMR solution structure of the isolated inactivation gate reveals a stably folded core comprised of an alpha-helix capped by an N-terminal turn, supporting a model in which the tightly folded core containing the latch motif pivots on a more flexible hinge region to occlude the pore during inactivation. The structure, in combination with substituted cysteine mutagenesis experiments, indicates that the IFM triad and adjacent Thr are essential components of the latch and suggests differing roles for the residues of the IFMT motif in fast inactivation.

Ca2+-dependent conformational changes in bovine GCAP-2.

GCAP-2, a mammalian photoreceptor-specific protein, is a Ca2+-dependent regulator of the retinal membrane guanylyl cyclases (Ret-GCs). Sensing the fall in intracellular free Ca2+ after photo-excitation, GCAP-2 stimulates the activity of Ret-GC leading to cGMP production. Like other members of the recoverin superfamily, GCAP-2 is a small N-myristoylated protein containing four EF-hand consensus motifs. In this study, we demonstrate that like recoverin and neurocalcin, GCAP-2 alters its conformation in response to Ca2+-binding as measured by a Ca2+-dependent change in its far UV CD spectrum. Differences in the conformation of the Ca2+-bound and Ca2+-free forms of GCAP-2 were also observed by examining their relative susceptibility to V8 protease. In contrast to recoverin, we do not observe proteolytic cleavage of the myristoylated N-terminus of Ca2+-bound GCAP-2. NMR spectra also show that, in contrast to recoverin, the chemical environment of the N-terminus of GCAP-2 is not dramatically altered by Ca2+ binding. Despite the similarity of GCAP-2 and recoverin, the structural consequences of Ca2+-binding for these two proteins are significantly dissimilar.

Prediction and structural characterization of an independently folding substructure in the src SH3 domain.

Previous studies of the conformations of peptides spanning the length of the alpha-spectrin SH3 domain suggested that SH3 domains lack independently folding substructures. Using a local structure prediction method based on the I-sites library of sequence-structure motifs, we identified a seven residue peptide in the src SH3 domain predicted to adopt a native-like structure, a type II beta-turn bridging unpaired beta-strands, that was not contained intact in any of the SH3 domain peptides studied earlier. NMR characterization confirmed that the isolated peptide, FKKGERL, adopts a structure similar to that adopted in the native protein: the NOE and 3JNHalpha coupling constant patterns were indicative of a type II beta-turn, and NOEs between the Phe and the Leu side-chains suggest that they are juxtaposed as in the prediction and the native structure. These results support the idea that high-confidence I-sites predictions identify protein segments that are likely to form native-like structures early in folding.

Solvent exchange rates of side-chain amide protons in proteins.

Solvent exchange rates and temperature coefficients for Asn/Gln side-chain amide protons have been measured in Escherichia coli HPr. The protons of the eight side-chain amide groups (two Asn and six Gln) exhibit varying exchange rates which are slower than some of the fast exchanging backbone amide protons. Differences in exchange rates of the E and Z protons of the same side-chain amide group are obtained by measuring exchange rates at pH values > 8. An NOE between a side-chain amide proton and a bound water molecule was also observed.

A disorder-to-order transition coupled to DNA binding in the essential zinc-finger DNA-binding domain of yeast ADR1.

The motional dynamics and solvent-exchange behavior of free and DNA-bound forms of the minimal zinc-finger DNA-binding domain of the yeast transcription factor ADR1 (ADR1-DBD) are investigated using NMR. The parameters measured include the 1H-15N heteronuclear NOE, 15N and 1H T1 relaxation rates, 15N T2 relaxation rates, and solvent-exchange rates. The spin relaxation parameters, spectral density maps, and solvent-exchange behavior show that, exclusive of the N and C termini, three distinct regions of free ADR1-DBD exhibit different motions on multiple timescales. The N-terminal proximal, or accessory, region appears to be unstructured and highly flexible: it exhibits large amplitude motions on a picosecond timescale, little or no protection from solvent exchange, and random-coil proton chemical shifts. The two zinc fingers tumble anisotropically as folded domains, with the tumbling of the individual fingers being only partly correlated to each other, and are modestly protected from solvent exchange except near the tips of the fingers and in the linker joining them. Free ADR1-DBD exhibits exchange broadening around P97 in the proximal region, at the tip of finger 1, and throughout finger 2. Upon binding, most of the proximal region and both zinc fingers tumble as a single domain and exhibit significantly reduced picosecond timescale motions. This region becomes more protected from solvent exchange. The bound portion of the proximal region is proposed to lie exposed on the surface of the DNA. Exchange broadening remains around P97 but also becomes evident for residues in direct contact with the DNA and in the linker. We conclude that the region of ADR1-DBD essential for high-affinity binding undergoes a disorder-to-order transition upon binding to its cognate DNA and, together with the zinc fingers, forms a cohesive molecular complex with the nucleic acid.

The cancer-predisposing mutation C61G disrupts homodimer formation in the NH2-terminal BRCA1 RING finger domain.

The breast and ovarian cancer tumor suppressor gene, BRCA1, encodes for a Zn2+-binding RING finger motif located near the protein NH2 terminus. The RING finger motif is characterized by eight conserved Cys and His residues which form two Zn2+-binding sites termed Site I and Site II. We used limited proteolysis in conjunction with matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectroscopy to investigate the metal binding properties and to probe the solution structures of wild-type and mutant BRCA1 constructs that include the RING finger. Our results show that the RING finger motif is part of a larger proteolysis-resistant structural domain which encompasses the first 110 residues of BRCA1. Analytical gel-filtration chromatography and chemical cross-linking experiments demonstrate that the BRCA1 NH2-terminal domain readily homodimerizes in solution. The cancer-predisposing C61G mutation, which alters a conserved Zn2+-binding residue, abolishes metal binding to Site II of the RING finger motif, while Site I remains intact and functional. The C61G mutation also results in increased proteolytic susceptibility of the COOH-terminal portion of the NH2-terminal domain and perturbs the oligomerization properties of BRCA1.

Paramagnetic cobalt as a probe of the orientation of an accessory DNA-binding region of the yeast ADR1 zinc-finger protein.

The minimal DNA-binding domain of the yeast ADR1 transcription factor consists of two Cys2-His2 zinc fingers and an additional 20 residues N-terminal and proximal to the fingers. The accessory sequence likely plays a role in contacting DNA. Paramagnetic cobalt was incorporated into the fingers of an ADR1 DNA-binding construct (ADR1z) to serve as a probe of the proximity of the accessory sequence to the zinc fingers. NMR signals from the accessory region are not perturbed by cobalt incorporation. Previous studies showed that this region is random coil in the ADR1z construct in the absence of DNA; it does not adopt a fixed orientation with respect to the cobalt sites. In contrast, many residues of the accessory region are perturbed by cobalt in the DNA-bound form of the protein, suggesting this region becomes constrained. This observation agrees with previous results showing a disorder-to-order transition for the accessory region upon DNA binding. Furthermore, these results indicate that the accessory region lies close to the fingers in the protein-DNA complex. This region thus does not extend along the DNA away from the zinc fingers; it more likely binds the same stretch of DNA contacted by the zinc fingers. Comparison to the behavior of other zinc-finger proteins that utilize an accessory DNA-binding sequence suggested that the region of ADR1 proximal to the zinc fingers might form an alpha-helix. Analysis of sequential NOEs in the accessory region of DNA-bound ADR1z reveals no helical structure.

Phosphorylation on histidine is accompanied by localized structural changes in the phosphocarrier protein, HPr from Bacillus subtilis.

The histidine-containing protein (HPr) of bacterial phosphoenolpyruvate:sugar phosphotransferase system (PTS) serves a central role in a series of phosphotransfer reactions used for the translocation of sugars across cell membranes. These studies report the high-definition solution structures of both the unphosphorylated and histidine phosphorylated (P-His) forms of HPr from Bacillus subtilis. Consistent with previous NMR studies, local conformational adjustments occur upon phosphorylation of His 15, which positions the phosphate group to serve as a hydrogen bond acceptor for the amide protons of Ala 16 and Arg 17 and to interact favorably with the alpha-helix macrodipole. However, the positively charged side chain of the highly conserved Arg 17 does not appear to interact directly with phospho-His 15, suggesting that Arg 17 plays a role in the recognition of other PTS enzymes or in phosphotransfer reactions directly. Unlike the results reported for Escherichia coli P-His HPr (Van Nuland NA, Boelens R, Scheek RM, Robillard GT, 1995, J Mol Biol 246:180-193), our data indicate that phosphorylation of His 15 is not accompanied by adoption of unfavorable backbone conformations for active site residues in B. subtilis P-Ser HPr.

Binding of the catabolite repressor protein CcpA to its DNA target is regulated by phosphorylation of its corepressor HPr.

Catabolite repression of a number of catabolic operons in bacilli is mediated by the catabolite control protein CcpA, the phosphocarrier protein HPr from the phosphoenolpyruvate-dependent sugar transport system (PTS), and a cis-acting DNA sequence termed the catabolite-responsive element (cre). We present evidence that CcpA interacts with HPr that is phosphorylated at Ser46 (Ser(P) HPr) and that these proteins form a specific ternary complex with cre DNA. Titration experiments following the circular dichroism signal of the cre DNA indicate that this complex consists of two molecules of Ser(P) HPr, a CcpA dimer, and the cre sequence. Limited proteolysis experiments indicate that the domain structure of CcpA is similar to other members of the LacI/GalR family of helix-turn-helix proteins, comprised of a helix-turn-helix DNA domain and a C-terminal effector domain. NMR titration of Ser(P) HPr demonstrates that the isolated C-terminal domain of CcpA forms a specific complex with Ser(P) HPr but not with unphosphorylated HPr. Based upon perturbations to the NMR spectrum, we propose that the binding site of the C-terminal domain of CcpA on Ser(P) HPr forms a contiguous surface that encompasses both Ser(P)46 and His15, the site of phosphorylation by enzyme I of the PTS. This allows CcpA to recognize the phosphorylation state of HPr, effectively linking the process of sugar import via the PTS to catabolite repression in bacilli.

NMR chemical shift perturbation mapping of DNA binding by a zinc-finger domain from the yeast transcription factor ADR1.

Mutagenesis studies have revealed that the minimal DNA-binding domain of the yeast transcription factor ADR1 consists of two Cys2-His2 zinc fingers plus an additional 20 residues proximal and N-terminal to the fingers. We have assigned NMR 1H, 15N, and 13C chemical shifts for the entire minimal DNA-binding domain of ADR1 both free and bound to specific DNA. 1H chemical shift values suggest little structural difference between the zinc fingers in this construct and in single-finger constructs, and 13C alpha chemical shift index analysis indicates little change in finger structure upon DNA binding. 1H chemical shift perturbations upon DNA binding are observed, however, and these are mapped to define the protein-DNA interface. The two zinc fingers appear to bind DNA with different orientations, as the entire helix of finger 1 is perturbed, while only the extreme N-terminus of the finger 2 helix is affected. Furthermore, residues N-terminal to the first finger undergo large chemical shift changes upon DNA binding suggesting a role at the protein-DNA interface. A striking correspondence is observed between the protein-DNA interface mapped by chemical shift changes and that previously mapped by mutagenesis.

Demonstration of protein-protein interaction specificity by NMR chemical shift mapping.

Chemical shift mapping is becoming a popular method for studying protein-protein interactions in solution. The technique is used to identify putative sites of interaction on a protein surface by detecting chemical shift perturbations in simple (1H, 15N)-HSQC NMR spectra of a uniformly labeled protein as a function of added (unlabeled) target protein. The high concentrations required for these experiments raise questions concerning the possibility for non-specific interactions being detected, thereby compromising the information obtained. We demonstrate here that the simple chemical shift mapping approach faithfully reproduces the known functional specificities among pairs of closely related proteins from the phosphoenolpyruvate:sugar phosphotransferase systems of Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis.

Influence of N-cap mutations on the structure and stability of Escherichia coli HPr.

This paper describes the effect of N-capping substitutions on the structure and stability of histidine-containing protein (HPr). We have used NMR spectroscopy and conformational stability studies to quantify changes in local and global free energy due to mutagenesis at Ser46, the N-cap for helix B in HPr. Previous NMR studies suggested that helix B of Escherichia coli HPr is dynamic as judged by the rate of exchange of amide protons with solvent. Ser46 was chosen because it is the site of regulatory phosphorylation in HPrs from Gram-positive bacteria, and mutation of this residue to an aspartic acid (S46D) in E. coli HPr (Gram-negative) also makes it a poor substrate in the bacterial phosphoenolpyruvate: sugar phosphotransferase system. Therefore, to understand the mechanism of inactivation of E. coli S46D HPr, as well as the effect of mutagenesis on protein stability, we have characterized three mutants of E. coli HPr: Ser46 has been mutated to an Asp, Asn, and Ala in S46D, S46N, and S46A HPrs, respectively. The results indicate that these N-cap replacements have a marked influence on helix B stability. The effect of mutagenesis on local stability is correlated to global unfolding of HPr. The ability of amino acids to stabilize helix B is Asp > Asn > Ser > Ala. In addition, since there are neither large-scale conformational changes nor detectable changes in the active site of S46D HPr, it is proposed that the loss of phosphotransfer activity of S46D HPr is due to unfavorable steric and/or electrostatic interactions of the Asp with enzyme I of the PTS.

Hydrogen bonding and equilibrium isotope enrichment in histidine-containing proteins.

We have measured deuterium/hydrogen fractionation in three histidine-containing proteins, ecHPr, ecHPr mutant S31A, and bsHPr, and in random coil peptides using NMR and mass spectrometry. The amide protons of unstructured peptides exhibit equilibrium enrichment for deuterium, in agreement with previous studies. Enrichment for both protium and deuterium was observed in both HPrs, with fractionation factors ranging from 0.63 to 1.41. Enrichment for protium was seen in alpha-helical secondary structure. 'Strong' HBs previously identified by mutagenesis and thermodynamic measurements are significantly enriched for protium. Sites of protium enrichment are conserved in a structural context across species lines, though ecHPr and bsHPr share only 30% sequence identity, suggesting that strong HBs are conserved and may play an important role in stabilizing the folded state.

MyoD forms micelles which can dissociate to form heterodimers with E47: implications of micellization on function.

MyoD is a member of a family of DNA-binding transcription factors that contain a helix-loop-helix (HLH) region involved in protein-protein interactions. In addition to self-association and DNA binding, MyoD associates with a number of other HLH-containing proteins, thereby modulating the strength and specificity of its DNA binding. Here, we examine the interactions of full-length MyoD with itself and with an HLH-containing peptide portion of an E2A gene product, E47-96. Analytical ultracentrifugation reveals that MyoD forms micelles that contain more than 100 monomers and are asymmetric and stable up to 36 degrees C. The critical micelle concentration increases slightly with temperature, but micelle size is unaffected. The micelles are in reversible equilibrium with monomer. Addition of E47-96 results in the stoichiometric formation of stable MyoD-E47-96 heterodimers and the depletion of micelles. Micelle formation effectively holds the concentration of free MyoD constant and equal to the critical micelle concentration. In the presence of micelles, the extent of all interactions involving free MyoD is independent of the total MyoD concentration and independent of one another. For DNA binding, the apparent relative specificity for different sites can be affected. In general, heterodimer-associated activities will depend on the self-association behavior of the partner protein.