Characterization of a T-DNA insertion mutant for the protein import receptor atToc33 from chloroplasts.

In Arabidopsis thaliana, the Toc34 receptor component of the chloroplast import machinery is encoded by two independent but highly homologous genes, atToc33 and atToc34. We have isolated a T-DNA insertion mutant of atToc33 which is characterized by a pale phenotype, due to reductions in the levels of photosynthetic pigments, and alterations in protein composition. The latter involve not only chloroplast proteins but also some cytosolic polypeptides, including 14-3-3 proteins which, among other functions, have been proposed to be cytosolic targeting factors for nucleus-encoded chloroplast proteins. Within the chloroplast, many, though not all, proteins of the photosynthetic apparatus, as well as proteins not directly involved in photosynthesis, are found in significantly reduced amounts in the mutant. However, the accumulation of other chloroplast proteins is unaffected. This suggests that the atToc33 receptor is responsible for the import of a specific subset of nucleus-encoded chloroplast proteins. Supporting evidence for this conclusion was obtained by antisense repression of the atToc34 gene in the atToc33 mutant, which results in an exacerbation of the phenotype.

Targeting of EGFP chimeras within chloroplasts.

We have tested the potential of EGFP, a derivative of the green fluorescent protein (GFP), as a passenger protein for the analysis of protein transport processes across the thylakoid membranes in chloroplasts. In contrast to the majority of fusion proteins commonly used in such studies, EGFP is not of plant origin and can therefore be assumed to behave like a "neutral" passenger protein that is unaffected by any internal plant regulatory circuits. Our in vitro transport experiments clearly demonstrate that EGFP is a suitable passenger protein that can be correctly targeted either to the stroma or to the thylakoid lumen if fused to the appropriate transit peptide. The transport of EGFP across the thylakoid membrane shows, however, a clear pathway preference. While the protein is efficiently targeted by the deltapH/TAT pathway, transport by the Sec pathway is barely detectable, either with isolated thylakoids or with intact chloroplasts. This pathway specificity suggests that EGFP is folded immediately after import into the chloroplast stroma, thus preventing further translocation across the thylakoid membrane by the Sec translocase. The data obtained provide a good basis for the development of molecular tools for transport studies using EGFP as a passenger protein. Furthermore, plant lines expressing corresponding EGFP chimeras are expected to allow in vivo studies on the transport and sorting mechanisms involved in the biogenesis of the chloroplast.

Without a little help from 'my' friends: direct insertion of proteins into chloroplast membranes?

The chloroplast membranes are highly regulated and biological active regions of the living plant cell, which carry numerous essential proteinaceous components. For example, in the thylakoid membrane the photosynthesis apparatus, one of the most life-relevant biological machineries, is located. How these membrane proteins are targeted to and inserted into their target membranes was one of the questions we aimed to understand in the last few years. Fifteen years ago little to nothing was known about the targeting and translocation of outer envelope proteins (G.W. Schmidt and L.M. Mishkind, Annu. Rev. Biochem. 55 (1986)). Although several protein assisted pathways for translocation of proteins across the membranes have been characterised, only recent results gave insight into how membrane proteins are inserted into the chloroplast membranes. Here we will focus on the mode of insertion of a class of proteins into the outer envelope and the thylakoid membranes, which share a unique feature: they insert apparently directly into the lipid bilayer, i.e. without the help of a proteinaceous translocation pore.

The Rieske Fe/S protein of the cytochrome b6/f complex in chloroplasts: missing link in the evolution of protein transport pathways in chloroplasts?

The Rieske Fe/S protein, a nuclear-encoded subunit of the cytochrome b(6)/f complex in chloroplasts, is retarded in the stromal space after import into the chloroplast and only slowly translocated further into the thylakoid membrane system. As shown by the sensitivity to nigericin and to specific competitor proteins, thylakoid transport takes place by the DeltapH-dependent TAT pathway. The Rieske protein is an untypical TAT substrate, however. It is only the second integral membrane protein shown to utilize this pathway, and it is the first authentic substrate without a cleavable signal peptide. Transport is instead mediated by the NH(2)-terminal membrane anchor, which lacks, however, the twin-arginine motif indicative of DeltapH/TAT-dependent transport signals. Furthermore, transport is affected by sodium azide as well as by competitor proteins for the Sec pathway in chloroplasts, demonstrating for the first time some cross-talk of the two pathways. This might take place in the stroma where the Rieske protein accumulates after import in several complexes of high molecular mass, among which the cpn60 complex is the most prominent. These untypical features suggest that the Rieske protein represents an intermediate or early state in the evolution of the thylakoidal protein transport pathways.

Two distinct translocation intermediates can be distinguished during protein transport by the TAT (Deltaph) pathway across the thylakoid membrane.

During thylakoid transport of the chimeric precursor protein 16/23 which takes place by the twin arginine translocation (TAT) (Deltaph)-dependent pathway, two distinct translocation intermediates can be identified which represent successive steps in the translocation process. Both intermediates are partially inserted into the thylakoid membrane and can be distinguished by specific degradation fragments occurring after thermolysin treatment of the thylakoids. While the formation of the early translocation intermediate does not depend on a functional TAT translocation machinery, the appearance of the late intermediate is strictly coupled to the Deltaph-dependent transport of the 16/23 chimera. Accordingly, this translocation intermediate is found associated with two distinct complexes in the thylakoid membrane having apparent molecular masses of approximately 560 and 620 kDa, respectively.

Bacterial proteins carrying twin-R signal peptides are specifically targeted by the delta pH-dependent transport machinery of the thylakoid membrane system.

Glucose-fructose oxidoreductase (GFOR), a periplasmic protein of Zymomonas mobilis, is synthesized as a precursor polypeptide with a twin-R signal peptide for Sec-independent protein export in bacteria. In higher plant chloroplasts, twin-R signal peptides are specific targeting signals for the Sec-independent delta pH pathway of the thylakoid membrane system. In agreement with the assumed common phylogenetic origin of the two protein transport mechanisms, GFOR can be efficiently translocated by the delta pH-dependent pathway when analyzed with isolated thylakoid membranes. Transport is sensitive to the ionophore nigericin and competes with specific substrates for the delta pH-dependent transport route. In contrast, neither sodium azide nor enzymatic destruction of the nucleoside triphosphates in the assays affects thylakoid transport of GFOR indicating that the Sec apparatus is not involved in this process. Mutagenesis of the twin-R motif in the GFOR signal peptide prevents membrane translocation of the protein emphasizing the importance of these residues for the transport process.

Phylogenetic transfer of organelle genes to the nucleus can lead to new mechanisms of protein integration into membranes.

Subunits CFo-I and CFo-II of ATP synthase in chloroplast thylakoid membranes are two structurally and functionally closely related proteins of bitopic membrane topology which evolved from a common ancestral gene. In higher plants, CFo-I still originates in plastid chromosomes (gene: atpF), while the gene for CFo-II (atpG) was phylogenetically transferred to the nucleus. This gene transfer was accompanied by the reorganization of the topogenic signals and the mechanism of membrane insertion. CFo-I is capable of integrating correctly as the mature protein into the thylakoid membrane, whereas membrane insertion of CFo-II strictly depends on a hydrophobic targeting signal in the transit peptide. This requirement is caused by three negatively charged residues at the N-terminus of mature CFo-II which are lacking from CFo-I and which have apparently been added to the protein only after gene transfer has occurred. Accordingly, the CFo-II transit peptide is structurally and functionally equivalent to typical bipartite transit peptides, capable of also translocating hydrophilic lumenal proteins across the thylakoid membrane. In this case, transport takes place by the Sec-dependent pathway, despite the fact that membrane integration of CFo-II is a Sec-independent, and presumably spontaneous, process.

Targeting signals for a bacterial Sec-independent export system direct plant thylakoid import by the delta pH pathway.

Preproteins targeted to the Sec-independent protein transport systems of plant thylakoids and of bacteria both have unusual transfer peptides bearing a consensus twin-arginine motif. Possible mechanistic similarity between the two Sec-independent transport pathways was investigated by assessing the ability of bacterial twin-arginine transfer peptides to direct thylakoid import. High efficiency import was observed. This process was demonstrated to occur specifically via the Sec-independent deltapH pathway and to depend on an intact twin-arginine motif on the transfer peptide. These results provide strong evidence for the operation of mechanistically related Sec-independent protein transport pathways in chloroplasts and bacteria.

Transport of CtpA protein from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis 6803 across the thylakoid membrane in chloroplasts.

The CtpA protein in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis 6803 is a C-terminal processing protease that is essential for the assembly of the manganese cluster of the photosystem II complex. When fused to different chloroplast-targeting transit peptides, CtpA can be imported into isolated spinach chloroplasts and is subsequently translocated into the thylakoid lumen. Thylakoid transport is mediated by the cyanobacterial signal peptide which demonstrates that the protein transport machinery in thylakoid membranes is functionally conserved between chloroplasts and cyanobacteria. Transport of CtpA across spinach thylakoid membranes is affected by both nigericin and sodium azide indicating that the SecA protein and a transthylakoidal proton gradient are involved in this process. Saturation of the Sec-dependent thylakoid transport route by high concentrations of the precursor of the 33-kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving system leads to a strongly reduced rate of thylakoid translocation of CtpA which demonstrates transport by the Sec pathway. However, thylakoid transport of CtpA is affected also by excess amounts of the 23-kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving system, though to a lesser extent. This suggests that the cyanobacterial protein is capable of also interacing with components of the deltapH-dependent route and that transport of a protein across the thylakoid membrane may not always be restricted to a single pathway.

Transmembrane topology of the Rieske Fe/S protein of the cytochrome b6/f complex from spinach chloroplasts.

The topology of the Rieske protein of the cytochrome b6/f complex in thylakoids from spinach chloroplasts was examined by protease protection experiments as well as polypeptide extraction assays using solutions of chaotropic salts or alkaline pH. While neither thermolysin nor trypsin cleave any of the Rieske protein when added to the stromal side of the thylakoid membrane, proteinase K is capable of removing approximately four residues from its NH2-terminus. The protein is resistant to membrane extraction by 0.1 M Na2CO3 or 2 M NaBr but is quantitatively released by 0.1 M NaOH. Treatment of thylakoids with 2 M NaSCN leads to extraction of variable amounts of the protein, depending on the presence or absence of sucrose in the medium which apparently stabilizes the cytochrome complex. From these results we conclude that the Rieske protein is an integral component of the cytochrome complex which spans the thylakoid membrane with a single hydrophobic segment and is anchored predominantly by electrostatic interactions.

Sec-dependent thylakoid protein translocation. Delta pH requirement is dictated by passenger protein and ATP concentration.

A Sec-type system is responsible for the translocation of a subset of proteins across the thylakoid membrane in higher plant chloroplasts. Previous studies have suggested that the thylakoidal delta pH plays a minor role in this translocation mechanism, but we show here that it can be essential for the translocation process, depending on the identity of the passenger protein and the concentration of ATP. Studies using chimeric proteins show that, whereas the presequence dictates the translocation pathway, the delta pH requirement is dictated exclusively by the passenger protein; some passenger proteins are virtually delta pH-independent whereas others are absolutely dependent. delta pH requirement is not related to charge characteristics of the passenger proteins, ruling out an electrophoretic effect. Analysis of the 33-kDa photosystem II protein reveals an inverse relationship between delta pH requirement and ATP concentration; import into isolated thylakoids is inhibited 14-fold by nigericin at moderate ATP concentrations, and totally inhibited when the ATP concentration is reduced to 2 microM. The results indicate that the roles of the delta pH and ATP overlap and suggest that the delta pH may be obligatory when the passenger protein is abnormally difficult to translocate, possibly due to the folding of the polypeptide chain. We compare the energetics of this system with those of prokaryotic systems from which the chloroplast system is believed to have evolved.

Sorting of nuclear-encoded chloroplast membrane proteins to the envelope and the thylakoid membrane.

The spinach triose phosphate/phosphate translocator and the 37-kDa protein are both integral components of the chloroplast inner envelope membrane. They are synthesized in the cytosol with N-terminal extensions, the transit peptides, that are different in structural terms from those of imported stromal or thylakoid proteins. In order to determine if these N-terminal extensions are essential for the correct localization to the envelope membrane, they were linked to the mature parts of thylakoid membrane proteins, the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein and the CF0II-subunit of the thylakoid ATP synthase, respectively. In addition, the transit peptide of the CF0II-subunit that contains signals for the transport across both the envelope and the thylakoid membrane was fused to the mature parts of both envelope membrane proteins. The chimeric proteins were imported into isolated spinach chloroplasts, and the intraorganellar routing of the proteins was analyzed. The results obtained show that the N-terminal extensions of both envelope membrane proteins possess a stroma-targeting function only and that the information for the integration into the envelope membrane is contained in the mature parts of the proteins. At least part of the integration signal is provided by hydrophobic domains in the mature sequences since the removal of such a hydrophobic segment from the 37-kDa protein leads to missorting of the protein to the stroma and the thylakoid membrane.

Isolation and characterization of a cDNA encoding the SecA protein from spinach chloroplasts. Evidence for azide resistance of Sec-dependent protein translocation across thylakoid membranes in spinach.

Thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts in higher plants harbor different pathways for the translocation of proteins. One of these routes is related to the prokaryotic Sec pathway, which mediates the secretion of particular proteins into the periplasmic space and involves the SecA protein as an essential component. We have isolated a full size cDNA of 3739 nucleotides encoding the SecA homologue from spinach. It contains an open reading frame of 1036 codons corresponding to a polypeptide with a calculated mass of 117 kDa. The deduced amino acid sequence shows between 43 and 49% identity to SecA proteins from bacteria and lower algae and 62% identity to SecA of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC7942. Compared with the Escherichia coli protein, spinach SecA carries an amino-terminal extension of approximately 80 residues. In organello experiments performed with the protein made in vitro by transcription of the cDNA and cell-free translation of the resulting RNA showed that this extension comprises a transit peptide that mediates the import of the protein into the chloroplast. The processed product of approximately 107 kDa accumulates predominantly in the stroma and to a lower extent associates with the thylakoid membrane. Comparably to E. coli, in which SecA activity can be inhibited by sodium azide, thylakoid translocation of a subset of lumenal proteins is sensitive to sodium azide in pea but not in spinach chloroplasts, suggesting that the latter contain an azide-resistant SecA variant.

A new type of signal peptide: central role of a twin-arginine motif in transfer signals for the delta pH-dependent thylakoidal protein translocase.

The delta pH-driven and Sec-related thylakoidal protein translocases recognise distinct types of thylakoid transfer signal, yet all transfer signals resemble bacterial signal peptides in structural terms. Comparison of known transfer signals reveals a single concrete difference: signals for the delta pH-dependent system contain a common twin-arginine motif immediately before the hydrophobic region. We show that this motif is critical for the delta pH-driven translocation process; substitution of the arg-arg by gln-gln or even arg-lys totally blocks translocation across the thylakoid membrane, and replacement by lys-arg reduces the rate of translocation by > 100-fold. The targeting information in this type of signal thus differs fundamentally from that of bacterial signal peptides, where the required positive charge can be supplied by any basic amino acid. Insertion of a twin-arg motif into a Sec-dependent substrate does not alter the pathway followed but reduces translocation efficiency, suggesting that the motif may also repel the Sec-type system. Other information must help to specify the choice of translocation mechanism, but this information is unlikely to reside in the hydrophobic region because substitution by a hydrophobic section from an integral membrane protein does not affect the translocation pathway.

The thylakoid translocation of subunit 3 of photosystem I, the psaF gene product, depends on a bipartite transit peptide and proceeds along an azide-sensitive pathway.

Subunit 3 of photosystem I (PSI-3), the product of the nuclear psaF gene, is the docking protein for plastocyanin during photosynthetic electron transport in thylakoid membranes and is synthesized in the cytosol with a transit peptide that resembles structurally the bipartite targeting signals of hydrophilic, lumenal components such as plastocyanin. In organello import experiments performed with the authentic PSI-3 precursor and chimeric polypeptides consisting of residue-correct fusions of transit peptides and mature proteins derived from different plastid proteins demonstrate that the PSI-3 transit peptide is indeed capable of translocating proteins into the thylakoid lumen and that, conversely, mature PSI-3 depends on a bipartite transit peptide for its thylakoid transfer. Of the three recently described translocation/integration pathways for nucleus-encoded proteins carrying bipartite transit peptides that are distinct in their physiological requirements and strictly protein-specific, PSI-3, like plastocyanin and the 33-kDa protein of the oxygen-evolving complex, is translocated by a pathway that involves stromal factors but no proton gradient across the membrane. It is not affected by saturating amounts of the precursor for the 23-kDa protein of the oxygen-evolving complex that follows the latter route. Thylakoid translocation of PSI-3 is, however, impaired in the presence of sodium azide, which indicates that a homolog to the bacterial SecA protein might be involved in this process suggesting, thus, a prokaryote-like translocation pathway. The azide-sensitive factor appears to interact predominantly with the transit peptide of a precursor protein, since chimeras consisting of a presequence from an azide-resistant precursor and a mature part of an azide-sensitive polypeptide are still translocated in the presence of the inhibitor.

The Role of Plastids in the Expression of Nuclear Genes for Thylakoid Proteins Studied with Chimeric [beta]-Glucuronidase Gene Fusions.

We have analyzed plastid and nuclear gene expression in tobacco seedlings using the carotenoid biosynthesis inhibitor nor-flurazon. mRNA levels for three nuclear-encoded chlorophyll-binding proteins of photosystem I and photosystem II (CAB I and II and the CP 24 apoprotein) are no longer detectable in photobleached seedlings, whereas those for other components of the thylakoid membrane (the 33- and 23-kD polypeptides and Rieske Fe/S polypeptide) accumulate to some extent. Transgenic tobacco seedlings with promoter fusions from genes for thylakoid membrane proteins exhibit a similar expression behavior: a CAB-[beta]-glucuronidase (GUS) gene fusion is not expressed in herbicide-treated seedlings, whereas PC-, FNR-, PSAF-, and ATPC-promoter fusions are expressed, although at reduced levels. All identified segments in nuclear promoters analyzed that have been shown to respond to light also respond to photodamage to the plastids. Thus, the regulatory signal pathways either merge prior to gene regulation or interact with closely neighboring cis elements. These results indicate that plastids control nuclear gene expression via different and gene-specific cis-regulatory elements and that CAB gene expression is different from the expression of the other genes tested. Finally, a plastid-directing import sequence from the maize Waxy gene is capable of directing the GUS protein into the photodamaged organelle. Therefore, plastid import seems to be functional in photobleached organelles.

Mutations at the stromal processing peptidase cleavage site of a thylakoid lumen protein precursor affect the rate of processing but not the fidelity.

Nuclear-encoded stromal proteins are imported into the chloroplast by means of presequences, or transit peptides, which are removed after import by a stromal processing peptidase (SPP); the presequences of thylakoid lumen proteins are processed by SPP at intermediate sites prior to transport of these proteins across the thylakoid membrane. SPP has been previously shown to be a highly specific enzyme, but the basis for the reaction specificity is unclear, because the cleavage sites of different substrates display virtually no primary structure similarity. We have examined the influence of the cleavage site residues on the SPP reaction mechanism by introducing mutations at these positions (denoted -1 and +1, relative to the SPP cleavage site) within the presequence of the lumenal 33-kDa photosystem II protein. Substitution of the -1 Arg by Ala or Met leads to a 5-7-fold reduction in the rate of processing, whereas substitution by Glu almost completely blocks cleavage. The replacement of the +1 Ala by Lys likewise almost completely blocks cleavage. None of the introduced -1 mutations affect cleavage fidelity; we show that all three mutants are cleaved only at the correct site. All of the mutant precursors are efficiently imported into the thylakoid lumen of intact chloroplasts, indicating that this cleavage event is not an important element of the overall import pathway. The results indicate that the identity of the -1 residue, within the context of a given presequence, is important in terms of influencing processing efficiency, but that the site of cleavage is specified by other determinants. At least a proportion of the other determinants are likely to be in close proximity to the cleavage site, since the deletion of a 7-residue section spanning this site completely blocks processing.

Targeting of proteins to the thylakoids by bipartite presequences: CFoII is imported by a novel, third pathway.

The CFoII subunit of the ATP synthase is an integral component of the thylakoid membrane which is synthesized in the cytosol with a bipartite, lumen-targeting presequence similar in structural terms to those of imported lumenal proteins such as plastocyanin. This presequence is shown to possess a terminal cleavage site for the thylakoidal processing peptidase, but no intermediate site for the stromal processing peptidase. The integration of CFoII into the thylakoid membrane of Pisum sativum has been analysed using in vitro assays for the import of proteins into intact chloroplasts or isolated thylakoids. Efficient integration into thylakoids is observed in the light and dark, and the integration process does not require the presence of either stromal extracts or nucleoside triphosphates. The uncoupler nigericin inhibits integration only very slightly, indicating that the thylakoidal delta pH does not play a significant role in the integration mechanism. In each of these respects, the requirements for CFoII integration differ notably from those determined for integration of the light-harvesting chlorophyll-binding protein of photosystem II. The integration mechanism also differs significantly from the two mechanisms involved in the translocation of lumenal proteins across the thylakoid membrane, since one of these processes requires the presence of stromal protein factors and ATP, and the other mechanism is dependent on the thylakoidal delta pH. This conclusion is reinforced by the finding that saturation of the translocation system for the precursor to the lumenal 23 kDa oxygen-evolving complex protein does not affect integration of CFoII into thylakoids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Electron transfer from plastocyanin to photosystem I.

Mutant plastocyanins with Leu at position 10, 90 or 83 (Gly, Ala and Tyr respectively in wildtype) were constructed by site-specific mutagenesis of the spinach gene, and expressed in transgenic potato plants under the control of the authentic plastocyanin promoter, as well as in Escherichia coli as truncated precursor intermediates carrying the C-terminal 22 amino acid residues of the transit peptide, i.e. the thylakoid-targeting domain that acts as a bacterial export signal. The identity of the purified plastocyanins was verified by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry. The formation of a complex between authentic or mutant spinach plastocyanin and isolated photosystem I and the electron transfer has been studied from the biphasic reduction kinetics of P700+ after excitation with laser flashes. The formation of the complex was abolished by the bulky hydrophobic group of Leu at the respective position of G10 or A90 which are part of the conserved flat hydrophobic surface around the copper ligand H87. The rate of electron transfer decreased by both mutations to < 20% of that found with wildtype plastocyanin. We conclude that the conserved flat surface of plastocyanin represents one of two crucial structural elements for both the docking at photosystem I and the efficient electron transfer via H87 to P700+. The Y83L mutant exhibited faster electron transfer to P700+ than did authentic plastocyanin. This proves that Y83 is not involved in electron transfer to P700 and suggests that electron transfer from cytochrome f and to P700 follows different routes in the plastocyanin molecule. Plastocyanin (Y83L) expressed in either E. coli or potato exhibited different isoelectric points and binding constants to photosystem I indicative of differences in the folding of the protein. The structure of the binding site at photosystem I and the mechanism of electron transfer are discussed.