Individual bias and fluctuations in collective decision making: from algorithms to Hamiltonians.

In this paper, we reconsider the spin model suggested recently to understand some features of collective decision making among higher organisms (Hartnettet al2016Phys. Rev. Lett.116038701). Within the model, the state of an agentiis described by the pair of variables corresponding to its opinionSi=±1and a biasωitoward any of the opposing values ofSi. Collective decision making is interpreted as an approach to the equilibrium state within the nonlinear voter model subject to a social pressure and a probabilistic algorithm. Here, we push such a physical analogy further and give the statistical physics interpretation of the model, describing it in terms of the Hamiltonian of interaction and looking for the equilibrium state via explicit calculation of its partition function. We show that, depending on the assumptions about the nature of social interactions, two different Hamiltonians can be formulated, which can be solved using different methods. In such an interpretation the temperature serves as a measure of fluctuations, not considered before in the original model. We find exact solutions for the thermodynamics of the model on the complete graph. The general analytical predictions are confirmed using individual-based simulations. The simulations also allow us to study the impact of system size and initial conditions on the collective decision making in finite-sized systems, in particular, with respect to convergence to metastable states.

Generalized Ising Model on a Scale-Free Network: An Interplay of Power Laws.

We consider a recently introduced generalization of the Ising model in which individual spin strength can vary. The model is intended for analysis of ordering in systems comprising agents which, although matching in their binarity (i.e., maintaining the iconic Ising features of '+' or '-', 'up' or 'down', 'yes' or 'no'), differ in their strength. To investigate the interplay between variable properties of nodes and interactions between them, we study the model on a complex network where both the spin strength and degree distributions are governed by power laws. We show that in the annealed network approximation, thermodynamic functions of the model are self-averaging and we obtain an exact solution for the partition function. This allows us derive the leading temperature and field dependencies of thermodynamic functions, their critical behavior, and logarithmic corrections at the interface of different phases. We find the delicate interplay of the two power laws leads to new universality classes.