Reproducibility of two coronary calcium quantification algorithms in patients with different degrees of calcification.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the reproducibility of coronary calcium quantification algorithms by electron beam CT (EBT) in patients with different amounts of calcified plaque using the conventional (Agatston) score and an area score and to demonstrate a potential application of these results for evaluation of follow-up scans. METHODS: In 50 consecutive patients. the conventional calcium score (CCS = Agatston score) and the area score (AS) were summed for each artery and patient. Data were analyzed in four groups according to degrees of calcification: 0 (absent-minimal): CCS 0-9, I (mild): CCS 10-99, II (moderate): CCS 100-399, III (severe): CCS > or = 400. We determined and compared the reproducibility for each algorithm within and among groups. RESULTS: Median percent reproducibility improved with increasing amounts of calcified plaque for the CCS and the AS (p = 0.002 and p = 0.004, respectively). We demonstrate how these reproducibility values can be used to evaluate long-term follow-up studies. The reduction of median reproducibility per patient using the AS vs. the CCS was 32% (13 vs. 19%, respectively). On a vessel-by-vessel basis, the reduction of median reproducibility was 7% (24.3 vs. 22.6%, CCS vs. AS, p < 0.02), which was attributable to a 45% reduction in reproducibility in arteries with mild scores (46.1 vs. 25.5%, CCS vs. AS, p < 0.005). CONCLUSION: The AS has an improved reproducibility compared with the CCS, especially in patients with small amounts of coronary calcifications which may prove clinically useful. Different reproducibility values in different degrees of calcification can be used for an individual assessment of changes in amounts of coronary calcification.

Natural history and topographic pattern of progression of coronary calcification in symptomatic patients: An electron-beam CT study.

Electron-beam CT may assess the progression of coronary atherosclerosis by visualizing changes in calcification. The present investigation analyzes (1) the rate of progression of calcification in symptomatic patients, (2) the topographic pattern, and (3) the influence of baseline plaque burden and risk factors. Progression of calcification during a mean (median) interval of 18 (15) months was measured in 102 symptomatic outpatients (aged 59+/-9 years, 80% male) with calcification. In 4 patient groups with a baseline total score (Agatston criteria) of 1 to 30, >30 to 100, >100 to 400, and >400, the median was 3.1, 26.1, 58.9, and 109.7, respectively, for absolute annual progression of the score (P<0.05) and 57%, 49%, 32%, and 15%, respectively, for relative progression (P<0.05). On the coronary segmental level, changes were largely restricted to typical predilection sites of coronary atherosclerosis. The presence of angiographically defined coronary narrowing influenced absolute, but not relative, progression. Of the risk factors, only low density lipoprotein cholesterol levels showed a trend, although not significant, for predicting progression. These data indicate that baseline plaque burden determines the rate of progression of calcification. This appears to be a coronary systemic process, reflecting the natural history of coronary atherosclerosis.

Usefulness of topography of coronary calcium by electron-beam computed tomography in predicting the natural history of coronary atherosclerosis.

Electron-beam computed tomography (EBCT) allows for accurate noninvasive detection and quantification of coronary calcium that is representative of underlying atherosclerotic disease. The present study quantitatively analyzes the topography and establishes the natural history of coronary calcium in patients with variable degrees of coronary atherosclerosis. EBCT was performed in 330 consecutive patients aged 56 +/- 12 years (70% men) with recent (<3 months) onset of signs or symptoms of coronary artery disease (CAD) or who were evaluated because of a presumed high risk. Total calcium scores, computed by the Agatston method, were positive in 269 patients (82%) (mean age 58 +/- 11 years, 73% men). These patients were classified into 4 groups, with total calcium scores ranging between 1 and 30, >30 and 100, >100 and 400, and >400, respectively. The presence and amount of calcium was additionally assessed in 10 major segments of the coronary arterial tree, including the major coronary arteries. Of the 72 patients with calcium of only 1 of the major coronary arteries, the left anterior descending coronary artery was involved in 39 patients (54%) and the right coronary artery in 18 patients (25%). Left main stem calcium was observed in only 10 of 139 patients (7%) with 1- or 2-vessel calcium and in 17 of 77 patients (23%) with 3-vessel calcium. Calcium was consistent most frequently in the proximal left anterior descending coronary artery, followed by the proximal left circumflex and right coronary artery segments. A significant decrease of frequency and amount of calcium from the proximal to distal segments was observed in the left coronary system but not in the right coronary artery, where the distribution was more even. With increasing total calcium scores, segmental scores in the more distal segments were enhanced, but the increase was most pronounced in the proximal segments and particularly in the proximal left anterior descending coronary artery. EBCT-derived coronary calcium shows an axial distribution that appears comparable to that of atherosclerotic lesions observed in pathologic and angiographic studies, highlighting the potential role of EBCT for studying the natural history of CAD.