Gamete sex and elevation affect genetically based variation for unreduced gamete production in a mixed-ploidy plant.

PREMISE: Unreduced gametes are the primary mechanism of neopolyploid formation. Their production in diploid populations is arguably maladaptive, but the magnitude and patterns of genetically based variation maintained in natural populations are poorly understood. METHODS: We examined variation in male and female unreduced gamete production among plants from different elevations in fireweed, Chamerion angustifolium, grown in a common environment. Using seeds from three high-elevation and three low-elevation diploid populations in one study, and a single diploid population in another, we estimated realized rates of unreduced male (sperm) and female (egg) gamete production by reciprocally pollinating diploid and tetraploid plants and estimating the incidence of tetraploid seeds using flow cytometry. RESULTS: Unreduced gamete frequencies per plant were similar in the two studies (0.12% vs. 0.08%). High-elevation populations had a greater percentage of fruit with seeds from unreduced gametes, but a lower percentage of seeds per fruit than low-elevation populations. Female unreduced gamete frequencies differed among elevations, but male frequencies did not, and the gamete sexes were not correlated at the plant level. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that genetically based variation for unreduced gametes is maintained within and among natural populations, despite their fitness disadvantages, suggesting that local selection may be ineffective at purging them under some conditions.

Best practices for instrument settings and raw data analysis in plant flow cytometry.

Flow cytometry (FCM) is now the most widely used method to determine ploidy levels and genome size of plants. To get reliable estimates and allow reproducibility of measurements, the methodology should be standardized and follow the best practices in the field. In this article, we discuss instrument calibration and quality control and various instrument and acquisition settings (parameters, flow rate, number of events, scales, use of discriminators, peak positions). These settings must be decided before measurements because they determine the amount and quality of the data and thus influence all downstream analyses. We describe the two main approaches to raw data analysis (gating and histogram modeling), and we discuss their advantages and disadvantages. Finally, we provide a summary of best practice recommendations for data acquisition and raw data analysis in plant FCM.

Demographic and reproductive impacts of hybridization unrelated to hybrid viability in a native plant.

PREMISE: Introduced species can influence native congeners through production of hybrids and introgression, but impacts not involving viable hybrids, such as reduced conspecific offspring and increased asexual seed production, are rarely examined. Here we tested for these demographic and reproductive consequences of hybridization between introduced, domesticated apple (Malus domestica) and native crabapple (M. coronaria) in southern Canada. METHODS: We applied four pollination treatments (open, M. coronaria, M. domestica, open + M. coronaria) to focal M. coronaria trees across multiple years and assessed the number and reproductive origins of resulting seeds (hybrid or conspecific endosperm and, for each, sexual or asexual embryo) using flow cytometry. RESULTS: In open-pollinated fruit, 27% of seeds had hybrid endosperm; 52% of embryos were asexual. The number of conspecific embryos (sexual or asexual) per fruit did not decline significantly with increasing hybridization, indicating no seed discounting, but hand pollinations using only domestic apple or crabapple pollen reduced the number of conspecific embryos significantly. Hybridization was not associated with a change in percentage asexual embryos, overall, but there was an increase in asexual embryos in tetraploid seeds, the maternal and most common offspring ploidy. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that hybridization can influence native Malus in ways beyond the production of viable hybrids, with significant implications for population dynamics and genetic structure.

Isolation of plant nuclei for estimation of nuclear DNA content: Overview and best practices.

A critical aspect for obtaining accurate, reliable, and high-resolution estimates of nuclear DNA content is the release of nuclei from the cytoplasm in sufficient amounts, while maintaining their integrity throughout the analysis, protecting their DNA from degradation by endonucleases, and enabling stoichiometric DNA staining. In embryophytes, the most common method consists of chopping the plant material with a sharp razor blade to release nuclei into an isolation buffer, filtering the homogenate, and staining the nuclei in buffered suspension with a fluorochrome of choice. Despite the recent description of alternative approaches to isolate nuclei, the chopping procedure remains the most widely adopted method, due to its simplicity, rapidity, and effectiveness. In this review article, we discuss the specifics of nuclei isolation buffers and the distorting effects that secondary metabolites may have in nuclear suspensions and how to test them. We also present alternatives to the chopping procedure, options for filtering and fluorochromes, and discuss the applications of these varied approaches. A summary of the best practices regarding the isolation of plant nuclei for the estimation of nuclear DNA content is also provided.

Flow cytometric analysis of pollen and spores: An overview of applications and methodology.

Pollen grains are the male gametophytes in a seed-plant life cycle. Their small, particulate nature and crucial role in plant reproduction have made them an attractive object of study using flow cytometry (FCM), with a wide range of applications existing in the literature. While methodological considerations for many of these overlap with those for other tissue types (e.g., general considerations for the measurement of nuclear DNA content), the relative complexity of pollen compared to single cells presents some unique challenges. We consider these here in the context of both the identification and isolation of pollen and its subunits, and the types of research applications. While the discussion here mostly concerns pollen, the general principles described here can be extended to apply to spores in ferns, lycophytes, and bryophytes. In addition to recommendations provided in more general studies, some recurring and notable issues related specifically to pollen and spores are highlighted.

The origins and evolutionary history of feral apples in southern Canada.

Feral populations of domesticated crops can establish through two nonmutually exclusive pathways: hybridization with native relatives and recruitment of and recombination between known cultivars. The extent and relative importance of these pathways is not known, especially for woody fruit crops. Here, we examined the evolutionary origins of feral populations of Malus domestica (domestic apple) in southern Canada using a population genetic analysis. We characterized genotypes of 578 putative feral apple trees and evaluated them in relation to genotypes of 156 commercial cultivars, 28 non-native, ornamental crabapples and 47 native Malus coronaria trees using 14 microsatellite markers. No feral trees were genetic admixtures between domestic and native Malus; however, a minority of trees were admixed with introduced ornamental Malus. Feral trees and commercial cultivars both occurred in two major genetic groups and seven subgroups distributed throughout all commercial growing regions. A total of 42 cultivars, both heritage and currently grown, occurred in probable parental pairs for feral trees, with nine heritage varieties accounting for 72% of parental assignments. We conclude that feral apples in southern Canada are not products of hybridization with native M. coronaria but we cannot exclude ornamental apple species as contributing to the naturalization process. Nonhybrid feral domestic apples have multiple origins, with a prominent signature of early heritage cultivars. These lineages have spread and coexist throughout Ontario, rather than being derived strictly from local sources.

flowPloidy: An R package for genome size and ploidy assessment of flow cytometry data.

PREMISE OF THE STUDY: Despite advantages in terms of reproducibility, histogram analysis based on nonlinear regression is rarely used in genome size assessments in plant biology. This is due in part to the lack of a freely available program to implement the procedure. We have developed such a program, the R package flowPloidy. METHODS AND RESULTS: flowPloidy builds on the existing statistical tools provided with the R environment. This base provides tools for importing flow cytometry data, fitting nonlinear regressions, and interactively visualizing data. flowPloidy adds tools for building flow cytometry models, fitting the models to histogram data, and producing visual and tabular summaries of the results. CONCLUSIONS: flowPloidy fills an important gap in the study of plant genome size. This package will enable plant scientists to apply a more powerful statistical technique for assessing genome size. flowPloidy improves on existing software options by providing a no-cost workflow streamlined for genome size and ploidy determination.

Evolutionary Dynamics of Unreduced Gametes.

Unreduced gametes, which have the somatic (2n) chromosome number, are an important precursor to polyploid formation and apomixis. The product of irregularities in meiosis, 2n gametes are expected to be rare and deleterious in most natural populations, contrary to their wide taxonomic distribution and the prevalence of polyploidy. To better understand this discrepancy, we review contemporary evidence related to four aspects of 2n gamete dynamics in natural populations: (i) estimates of their frequency; (ii) their environmental and genetic determinants; (iii) adaptive and nonadaptive processes regulating their evolution; and (iv) factors regulating their union and production of polyploids in diploid populations. Aided by high-throughput methods of detection, these foci will advance our understanding of variation in 2n gametes within and among species, and their role in polyploid evolution.

Frequency and maintenance of unreduced gametes in natural plant populations: associations with reproductive mode, life history and genome size.

Fertilization involving unreduced (2n) gametes is considered the dominant mechanism of polyploid formation in angiosperms; however, our knowledge of the prevalence of and evolutionary mechanisms maintaining 2n gametes in natural populations is limited. We hypothesize that 2n gametes are deleterious consequences of meiotic errors maintained by mutation-selection balance and should increase in species with relaxed opportunities for selection on sexual processes (asexuality), reduced efficacy of selection (asexuality, selfing) and increased genome instability (high chromosome number). We used flow cytometry to estimate male 2n gamete production in 60 populations from 24 species of Brassicaceae. We quantified variation in 2n gamete production within and among species, and examined associations with life history, reproductive mode, genome size and chromosomal number while accounting for phylogeny. Most individuals produced < 2% 2n male gametes, whereas a small number had > 5% (up to 85%) production. Variation in 2n gamete production was significant among species and related to reproductive system; asexual species produced significantly more 2n gametes than mixed-mating and outcrossing species. Our results, unique in their multi-species perspective, are consistent with 2n gametes being deleterious but maintained when opportunities for selection are limited. Rare individuals with elevated 2n gamete production may be key contributors to polyploid formation.

Distinguishing 2N gamete nuclei from doublets in pollen using flow cytometry and pulse analysis.

The value of flow cytometry for quantifying unreduced (2N) pollen production in plants is well recognized; however, the approach has been limited by technical obstacles to obtaining high quality nuclei fluorescence histograms and the difficulty in distinguishing 2N nuclei from 1N doublets. Here, we use mathematical arguments and observations of fluorescence properties of angiosperm pollen nuclei to generate guidelines for applying pulse analysis to correct for doublets in pollen nuclei data. We show that the theoretical requirements for applying pulse analysis for doublet correction are met when nucleus fluorescence height and/or width measures in the unreduced gamete (2C DNA content) region exhibit bimodality (reflecting singlets and doublets) in combination with unimodal distributions of the same parameters in the reduced gamete (1C) region. These conditions are regularly met in the family Brassicaceae but not in the Asteraceae and Poaceae. We further show that when these requirements are met, pulse analysis estimates of doublet proportions are well correlated with estimates obtained with microscopy. We propose guidelines for doublet correction when estimating frequencies of unreduced male gametes.

Environmental correlates of cytotype distribution in Andropogon gerardii (Poaceae).

UNLABELLED: • PREMISE OF THE STUDY: Information about geographic distribution of cytotypes can provide insight into the origin and maintenance of autopolyploid complexes and builds a foundation for understanding cytotype differentiation and the dynamics of mixed-ploidy populations. Here, we investigate environmental correlates of the geographic distributions of 6x and 9x individuals in the ecologically dominant grass Andropogon gerardii to examine the role of climate in shaping patterns of cytotype distribution in this species.• METHODS: Flow cytometry was used to estimate ploidy level in 352 individuals from 32 populations across North America. Ecological differentiation of cytotypes was tested by relating BIOCLIM variables to cytotype distribution using principal components analysis and partial linear regression.• KEY RESULTS: Broad geographic sampling confirmed two primary cytotypes-6x (hexaploid) and 9x (enneaploid)-and revealed that 9x plants are more common than previously thought. Enneaploids occur frequently in the southern portions of the range, with hexaploids dominating in northern regions. Mixed-ploidy populations were common (46.9%). Principal components analysis and partial linear regression indicated that reduced summer precipitation and increased variation in diurnal and seasonal temperature range were significant predictors of the frequency of 9x plants in a population.• CONCLUSIONS: Results indicate that (1) geographic distribution of 6x and 9x individuals is nonrandom; (2) environmental variables are associated with cytotype distribution in A. gerardii; and (3) nearly half of populations surveyed include both 6x and 9x individuals. The persistence of mixed-ploidy populations may reflect a combination of recurrent polyploid formation and the prevalence of clonal reproduction.

Flow cytometric analysis of pollen grains collected from individual bees provides information about pollen load composition and foraging behaviour.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Understanding the species composition of pollen on pollinators has applications in agriculture, conservation and evolutionary biology. Current identification methods, including morphological analysis, cannot always discriminate taxa at the species level. Recent advances in flow cytometry techniques for pollen grains allow rapid testing of large numbers of pollen grains for DNA content, potentially providing improved species resolution. METHODS: A test was made as to whether pollen loads from single bees (honey-bees and bumble-bees) could be classified into types based on DNA content, and whether good estimates of proportions of different types could be made. An examination was also made of how readily DNA content can be used to identify specific pollen species. KEY RESULTS: The method allowed DNA contents to be quickly found for between 250 and 9391 pollen grains (750-28 173 nuclei) from individual honey-bees and between 81 and 11 512 pollen grains (243-34 537 nuclei) for bumble-bees. It was possible to identify a minimum number of pollen species on each bee and to assign proportions of each pollen type (based on DNA content) present. CONCLUSIONS: The information provided by this technique is promising but is affected by the complexity of the pollination environment (i.e. number of flowering species present and extent of overlap in DNA content). Nevertheless, it provides a new tool for examining pollinator behaviour and between-species or cytotype pollen transfer, particularly when used in combination with other morphological, chemical or genetic techniques.

Cytotype coexistence leads to triploid hybrid production in a diploid-tetraploid contact zone of Chamerion angustifolium (Onagraceae).

PREMISE OF THE STUDY: Polyploids are often geographically segregated from their diploid progenitors, but the extent of sympatry and the consequences for reproductive isolation and coexistence are rarely quantified. • METHODS: In this study, we document the distribution and co-occurrence of diploid and tetraploid Chamerion angustifolium among 57 populations within the diploid-tetraploid contact zone in the Canadian Rocky Mountains. Rates of hybrid mating in mixed-ploidy populations were inferred from the frequency of triploid offspring in open-pollinated seed families. • KEY RESULTS: Twenty-three of 57 populations sampled contained a single cytotype; 20 (87%) were tetraploid and three (13%) were diploid. Thirty-four populations (60%) contained multiple ploidies. Diploid and tetraploid plants occurred in all mixed-ploidy populations; triploids occurred in 13 populations and averaged 1.4% of plants per population. The proportion of tetraploids in a population was negatively related to elevation (partial regression: F = 27.2, P <0.0001) and latitude (partial regression: F = 17.4, P < 0.0001). Triploids were detected in seed from all eight mixed-ploidy populations sampled ( = 3.7% of seed per population), comprising 7% of that expected with random mating (G = 2589.2, df = 1, P <0.0001, n = 2628), and were more often produced by diploid maternal parents than tetraploid parents. • CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that tetraploids regularly coexist with diploids in the contact zone and that this coexistence is likely promoted by both strong reproductive isolation and asymmetric intercytotype mating between diploid and tetraploid C. angustifolium.

Using flow cytometry to estimate pollen DNA content: improved methodology and applications.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Flow cytometry has been used to measure nuclear DNA content in pollen, mostly to understand pollen development and detect unreduced gametes. Published data have not always met the high-quality standards required for some applications, in part due to difficulties inherent in the extraction of nuclei. Here we describe a simple and relatively novel method for extracting pollen nuclei, involving the bursting of pollen through a nylon mesh, compare it with other methods and demonstrate its broad applicability and utility. METHODS: The method was tested across 80 species, 64 genera and 33 families, and the data were evaluated using established criteria for estimating genome size and analysing cell cycle. Filter bursting was directly compared with chopping in five species, yields were compared with published values for sonicated samples, and the method was applied by comparing genome size estimates for leaf and pollen nuclei in six species. KEY RESULTS: Data quality met generally applied standards for estimating genome size in 81 % of species and the higher best practice standards for cell cycle analysis in 51 %. In 41 % of species we met the most stringent criterion of screening 10 000 pollen grains per sample. In direct comparison with two chopping techniques, our method produced better quality histograms with consistently higher nuclei yields, and yields were higher than previously published results for sonication. In three binucleate and three trinucleate species we found that pollen-based genome size estimates differed from leaf tissue estimates by 1·5 % or less when 1C pollen nuclei were used, while estimates from 2C generative nuclei differed from leaf estimates by up to 2·5 %. CONCLUSIONS: The high success rate, ease of use and wide applicability of the filter bursting method show that this method can facilitate the use of pollen for estimating genome size and dramatically improve unreduced pollen production estimation with flow cytometry.

The effects of rapid desiccation on estimates of plant genome size.

Flow cytometry has become the dominant method for estimating nuclear DNA content in plants, either for ploidy determination or quantification of absolute genome size. Current best practices for flow cytometry involve the analysis of fresh tissue, however, this imposes significant limitations on the geographic scope and taxonomic diversity of plants that can be included in large-scale genome size studies. Dried tissue has been used increasingly in recent years, but largely in the context of ploidy analysis. Here we test rapid tissue drying with silica gel as a method for use in genome size studies, potentially enabling broader geographic sampling of plants when fresh tissue collection is not feasible. Our results indicate that rapid drying introduces comparatively minor error (<10%), which is similar to the error introduced by other common methodological variations such as instrument. Additionally, the relative effect of drying on genome size and data quality varied between species and buffers. Tissue desiccation provides a promising approach for expanding our knowledge of plant genome size diversity.

Sexing pollen reveals female bias in a dioecious plant.

* Information on angiosperm sex ratios has largely been restricted to surveys of flowering individuals. These often deviate from equality, with male bias more commonly reported. Female-biased sex ratios are concentrated in a few taxa and have been linked to the possession of heteromorphic sex chromosomes and bias introduced during the gametophytic stage of the life cycle. It has been proposed that differences in gamete quantity and quality could give rise to female bias, although there is no direct evidence with which to evaluate this possibility. * Here, we use flow cytometry to investigate microgametophytic 'sex ratios' in a flowering plant. We demonstrate that differences in DNA content between the sexes in Rumex nivalis, a species with heteromorphic sex chromosomes, make it possible to distinguish female- vs male-determining pollen nuclei. * We found a small but significant female bias in microgametophytes produced by males (mean 0.515) with significant variation among family means (range 0.463-0.586), and 18 of 22 families averaging > 0.50. * The observed female bias at the gametophytic stage of the life cycle is consistent with the direction of bias previously reported for seeds and vegetative and reproductive plants in wild populations of R. nivalis, but is insufficient to fully explain the degree of bias.

The consequences of clone size for paternal and maternal success in domestic apple (Malus x domestica).

Clonal growth in plants can increase pollen and ovule production per genet. However, paternal and maternal reproductive success may not increase because within-clone pollination (geitonogamy) can reduce pollen export to adjacent clones (pollen discounting) and pollen import to the central ramets (pollen limitation). The relationship between clone size and mating success was investigated using clones of Malus × domestica at four orchards (blocks of 1-5 rows of trees). For each block, maternal function was measured as fruit and seed set in all rows and paternal function as siring rate estimated from isozyme profiles in the first row of the adjacent block. Expected relations between reproductive success and clone size were generated from simulations and data on pollen dispersal in this species. Siring rate per clone averaged 70% and did not increase significantly with block size, consistent with simulations of pollen dispersal under pollen discounting. Simulations also indicated that the ratio of compatible to incompatible pollen received by a tree should decline with increased block size and from the periphery to the center of blocks. However, female function was not significantly reduced among block sizes or within blocks. The results suggest that paternal function may be more sensitive to the effects of clonality than female function.