Experimental evidence of the genetic hypothesis on the etiology of bicuspid aortic valve aortopathy in the hamster model.

Bicuspid aortopathy occurs in approximately 50% of patients with bicuspid aortic valve (BAV), the most prevalent congenital cardiac malformation. Although different molecular players and etiological factors (genetic and hemodynamic) have been suggested to be involved in aortopathy predisposition and progression, clear etiophysiopathological mechanisms of disease are still missing. The isogenic (genetically uniform) hamster (T) strain shows 40% incidence of BAV, but aortic dilatations have not been detected in this model. We have performed comparative anatomical, histological and molecular analyses of the ascending aorta of animals with tricuspid aortic valve (TAV) and BAV from the T strain (TTAV and TBAV, respectively) and with TAV from a control strain (HTAV). Aortic diameter, smooth muscle apoptosis, elastic waviness, and Tgf-ß and Fbn-2 expression were significantly increased in T strain animals, regardless of the valve morphology. Strain and aortic valve morphology did not affect Mmp-9 expression, whereas Mmp-2 transcripts were reduced in BAV animals. eNOS protein amount decreased in both TBAV and TTAV compared to HTAV animals. Thus, histomorphological and molecular alterations of the ascending aorta appear in a genetically uniform spontaneous hamster model irrespective of the aortic valve morphology. This is a direct experimental evidence supporting the genetic association between BAV and aortic dilatation. This model may represent a population of patients with predisposition to BAV aortopathy, in which increased expression of Tgf-ß and Fbn-2 alters elastic lamellae structure and induces cell apoptosis mediated by eNOS. Patients either with TAV or BAV with the same genetic defect may show the same risk to develop bicuspid aortopathy.

Embryonic development of bicuspid aortic valves.

Bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) is the most common congenital cardiac malformation, frequently associated with aortopathies and valvulopathies. The congenital origin of BAV is suspected to impact the development of the disease in the adult life. During the last decade, a number of studies dealing with the embryonic development of congenital heart disease have significantly improved our knowledge on BAV etiology. They describe the developmental defects, at the molecular, cellular and morphological levels, leading to congenital cardiac malformations, including BAV, in animal models. These models consist of a spontaneous hamster and several mouse models with different genetic manipulations in genes belonging to a variety of pathways. In this review paper, we aim to gather information on the developmental defects leading to BAV formation in these animal models, in order to tentatively explain the morphogenetic origin of the spectrum of valve morphologies that characterizes human BAV. BAV may be the only defect resulting from gene manipulation in mice, but usually it appears as the less severe defect of a spectrum of malformations, most frequently affecting the cardiac outflow tract. The genes whose alterations cause BAV belong to different genetic pathways, but many of them are direct or indirectly associated with the NOTCH pathway. These molecular alterations affect three basic cellular mechanisms during heart development, i.e., endocardial-to-mesenchymal transformation, cardiac neural crest (CNC) cell behavior and valve cushion mesenchymal cell differentiation. The defective cellular functions affect three possible morphogenetic mechanisms, i.e., outflow tract endocardial cushion formation, outflow tract septation and valve cushion excavation. While endocardial cushion abnormalities usually lead to latero-lateral BAVs and septation defects to antero-posterior BAVs, alterations in cushion excavation may give rise to both BAV types. The severity of the original defect most probably determines the specific aortic valve phenotype, which includes commissural fusions and raphes. Based on current knowledge on the developmental mechanisms of the cardiac outflow tract, we propose a unified hypothesis of BAV formation, based on the inductive role of CNC cells in the three mechanisms of BAV development. Alterations of CNC cell behavior in three possible alternative key valvulogenic processes may lead to the whole spectrum of BAV.

Bicuspid Aortic Valve in 2 Model Species and Review of the Literature.

Bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) is the most common human congenital cardiac malformation. Although the etiology is unknown for most patients, formation of the 2 main BAV anatomic types (A and B) has been shown to rely on distinct morphogenetic mechanisms. Animal models of BAV include 2 spontaneous hamster strains and 27 genetically modified mouse strains. To assess the value of these models for extrapolation to humans, we examined the aortic valve anatomy of 4340 hamsters and 1823 mice from 8 and 7 unmodified strains, respectively. In addition, we reviewed the literature describing BAV in nonhuman mammals. The incidences of BAV types A and B were 2.3% and 0.03% in control hamsters and 0% and 0.3% in control mice, respectively. Hamsters from the spontaneous model had BAV type A only, whereas mice from 2 of 27 genetically modified strains had BAV type A, 23 of 27 had BAV type B, and 2 of 27 had both BAV types. In both species, BAV incidence was dependent on genetic background. Unlike mice, hamsters had a wide spectrum of aortic valve morphologies. We showed interspecific differences in the occurrence of BAV between humans, hamsters, and mice that should be considered when studying aortic valve disease using animal models. Our results suggest that genetic modifiers play a significant role in both the morphology and incidence of BAV. We propose that mutations causing anomalies in specific cardiac morphogenetic processes or cell lineages may lead to BAV types A, B, or both, depending on additional genetic, environmental, and epigenetic factors.