ESHRE PGD consortium best practice guidelines for organization of a PGD centre for PGD/preimplantation genetic screening.

In 2005, the European Society for Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) PGD Consortium published a set of Guidelines for Best Practice PGD to give information, support and guidance to potential, existing and fledgling PGD programmes. Subsequent years have seen the introduction of new technologies as well as the evolution of current techniques. Additionally, in light of recent advice from ESHRE on how practice guidelines should be written/formulated, the Consortium believed it was timely to update the PGD guidelines. Rather than one document that covers all of PGD, the new guidelines are separated into four documents, including one relating to organization of the PGD centre and three relating to the methods used: DNA amplification, fluorescence in situ hybridization and biopsy/embryology. Here, we have updated the sections on organization of the PGD centre. One area that has continued to expand is Transport PGD, in which patients are treated at one IVF centre, whereas their gametes/embryos are tested elsewhere, at an independent PGD centre. Transport PGD/preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) has a unique set of challenges with respect to the nature of the sample and the rapid turn-around time required. PGS is currently controversial. Opinions of laboratory specialists and clinicians interested in PGD and PGS have been taken into account here. Current evidence suggests that PGS at cleavage stages is ineffective, but whether PGS at the blastocyst stage or on polar bodies might show improved delivery rates is still unclear. Thus, in this revision, PGS has been included. This document should assist everyone interested in PGD/PGS in developing the best laboratory and clinical practice possible.

Reduced penetrance alleles for Huntington's disease: a multi-centre direct observational study.

OBJECTIVE: To obtain penetrance data for Huntington's disease when DNA results are in the range of 36-39 CAG repeats and assess the consistency of reporting the upper allele from two reference centres. METHOD: Data were collected anonymously on age of onset or age last known to be unaffected from a cohort of individuals with results in this range. DNA samples were re-analysed in two reference centres. Kaplan-Meier analysis was used to construct an age of onset curve and penetrance figures. RESULTS: Clinical data and concordant DNA results from both reference centres were available for 176 samples; penetrance figures (and 95% confidence intervals) for this cohort, at age 65 and 75 years, were 63.9% (55.5% to 73.2%) and 74.2% (64.2% to 84.2%), respectively. Inclusion of 28 additional subjects for whom repeat DNA results were unavailable, obtained from only one reference centre, or discrepant by one repeat within this range, gave penetrance data (including 95% confidence intervals) at ages 65 and 75 years of 62.4% (54.4% to 70.4%) and 72.7.% (63.3% to 82.1%), respectively. 238 duplicate results were available from the reference centres; 10 (4.2%) differed by one CAG repeat in the reporting of the upper allele and in two (0.84%) of these cases the discrepancy was between 39 and 40 repeats. CONCLUSION: When DNA results are in this range, a conservative approach is to say that there is at least a 40% chance the person will be asymptomatic at age 65 years and at least a 30% chance the person will be asymptomatic at age 75 years.

Three hundred and thirty cycles of preimplantation genetic diagnosis for serious genetic disease: clinical considerations affecting outcome.

OBJECTIVE: To report on our experience with preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) cycles performed for serious genetic disease in relation to the clinical factors affecting outcome. DESIGN: Retrospective review of data from a single centre. SETTING: Tertiary referral PGD centre in a London teaching hospital. METHODS: The PGD cycles included 172 cycles for chromosome rearrangements, 96 cycles for single-gene disorders and 62 cycles for X-linked disorders. In vitro fertilisation was the preferred method in chromosome rearrangement and X-linked cases, while intra cytoplasmic sperm injection was used in all single-gene disorders. Appropriate in situ hybridisation fluorescence probes were used in chromosome rearrangement and X-linked cases and polymerase chain reaction was used in single-gene disorders. All pregnancies were followed till delivery. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Live birth rate per PGD cycle started. RESULTS: Eighty-six percent of cycles started (283) reached oocyte retrieval and 3743 eggs were collected, of which 2086 fertilised normally (55.7%). Two hundred and fifty cycles (76%) had embryos sutiable for biopsy on day 3 of in vitro culture, 1714 embryos were biopsied, and in 205 cycles (62%), there was at least one unaffected embryo available for transfer, resulting in 90 pregnancies, 68 clinical pregnancies and 58 live birth. The live birth rate was 18% per cycle started, 21% per egg retrieval and 28% per embryo transfer which significantly affected the live birth outcome. Woman age, number of eggs collected and achieving cryopreservation of surplus embryos had no statistically significant effect on treatment outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The live birth outcome of PGD cycles for serious genetic disorder is modest and is affected by the number of embryos genetically suitable for transfer.

Preimplantation genetic diagnosis of skin fragility-ectodermal dysplasia syndrome.

Skin fragility-ectodermal dysplasia syndrome is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by loss-of-function mutations in the desmosomal protein, plakophilin 1. Clinically, there may be considerable morbidity from extensive skin erosions and painful fissures on the palms and soles. In the absence of any specific treatment, prenatal diagnosis is an option for couples at reproductive risk of recurrence. In 2000, we developed and applied a single cell nested polymerase chain reaction protocol to test one couple for compound heterozygous plakophilin 1 gene mutations by preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). Although pregnancy was established, an unrelated trisomy 22 led to a spontaneous abortion. However, eight embryos of known genetic status were cryopreserved at that stage, and we planned to undertake subsequent frozen embryo replacement cycles that might lead to the birth of an unaffected child in this family. Embryo cryopreservation was carried out in June 2000 using standard protocols in a three-step freezing procedure. Four embryos were thawed in March 2003, one of which was viable and was used in a frozen embryo replacement cycle, but pregnancy did not occur. The remaining four embryos were thawed in February 2004, two of which were viable (both carriers of the paternal mutation) and these were used in a second frozen embryo replacement cycle, and a singleton pregnancy was established. The child's plakophilin 1 genotype was assessed by direct nucleotide sequencing across the site of both potential mutations. Following two frozen embryo replacement cycles, and almost 4 years after the initial embryo biopsy and mutation analysis, a pregnancy was achieved that progressed to term with the birth of a healthy baby girl. Nucleotide sequencing of cord blood DNA, taken immediately after delivery, showed that the child was a heterozygous carrier of the paternal mutation but not of the maternal mutation. This case demonstrates the value of embryo cryopreservation, which can increase the number of embryo replacement procedures and hence the cumulative pregnancy rate per retrieval cycle. Moreover, this is the first report of successful full-term pregnancy and birth of a healthy baby following exclusion of a severe genodermatosis by PGD. The successful outcome of PGD in this case illustrates what is technically possible for couples at risk of recurrence of a severe inherited skin disease.

Clinical and counselling implications of preimplantation genetic diagnosis for Huntington's disease in the UK.

Huntington's disease is an autosomal dominant neurodegenerative disorder that usually occurs in adult life. Individuals at risk can have a gene test before the onset of symptoms, and prenatal diagnosis is available. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) for Huntington's disease is now available for couples in whom one partner has the gene for Huntington's disease. A licence to practise PGD is required from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, and there are several complex issues relating to PGD for Huntington's disease that require consideration. The partner of the Huntington's disease gene carrier should have a presymptomatic test to ensure accuracy in a PGD cycle. There should be a delay between blood sampling and testing for Huntington's disease to allow time for reflection and withdrawal from testing. All PGD treatment has an associated risk of misdiagnosis. If confirmatory prenatal testing is not undertaken after a successful PGD cycle, no confirmation of diagnosis will be obtained at birth. Guidelines indicate that individuals who are at risk cannot be tested before 18 years. There is concern over the ability of a child or adolescent to make an informed choice about testing before this age. Confirmatory testing at birth after PGD would be in direct contravention of these guidelines. In the UK, the law requires consideration of the welfare of children born after assisted conception treatment. Presenting symptoms of Huntington's disease may affect the parenting abilities of an affected individual. There is a need for an assessment of a patient's current Huntington's disease status and their planned provision of care of children if Huntington's disease affects parenting. It has been necessary to create a detailed working protocol for the management of PGD for Huntington's disease to address these issues.

Six unaffected livebirths following preimplantation diagnosis for spinal muscular atrophy.

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a severe neurodegenerative autosomal recessive disorder, second only in frequency to cystic fibrosis. In its most severe form, SMA type I (Werdnig-Hoffman), death invariably ensues before age 2 years from respiratory failure or infection. Around 98% of clinical cases of SMA are caused by the homozygous absence of a region of exons 7 and 8 of the telomeric copy of the SMN gene (SMN1) on chromosome 5. We have developed a novel means of preimplantation diagnosis of SMA using a nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of exon 7 of SMN, followed by a HinfI restriction digest of the PCR product enabling the important SMN1 gene to be distinguished from the centromeric SMN2 gene which has no clinical phenotype. This method was designed to reduce the likelihood of misdiagnosis. Five couples were treated using this method. Four proceeded to embryo transfer which resulted in six liveborns (one singleton, one twin and one triplet), all free of SMA. Embryo transfer was not performed in one cycle because of PCR contamination.

United Kingdom experience with presymptomatic testing of individuals at 25% risk for Huntington's disease.

Between 1994 and 1998, the 23 UK genetics departments, which form the UK Huntington's Disease Consortium, have undertaken 161 direct mutation adult predictive tests on individuals whose at-risk parent was alive or had died without showing signs of Huntington's disease (HD) (5.7% of total UK tests). This study describes the number of requests for 25% risk predictive testing for HD in 1994 (the first year in which direct testing was available in the UK), and also a descriptive survey of the first 85 tests. In total, 85 tests were performed in the first 2 years of direct mutation testing, ten (11.8%) tests were mutation positive, 73 (85.91%) were negative and two (2.3%) were equivocal. The at-risk parent was alive in 54 (63.5%) cases. Four of the ten mutation positive candidates had parents who were alive and therefore received a prediction through their child. All centres included a discussion about the effect of testing on the 50% at-risk parent and all offered to see the parent for counselling. Of the 87 applicants for testing during 1994, 31 (35.6%) withdrew, this is higher than the 25% withdrawal rate for the 50% risk candidates. The candidates who withdrew were significantly younger and had more parents who were alive than those who continued with testing. Seven of the 31 candidates who withdrew from testing had at-risk parents who decided to be tested in the first instance. During the counselling process, issues were raised relating to pre-test agreements and family secrecy. This study indicates the importance of pre-test counselling and the involvement of the parent in the counselling process. 25% risk testing for HD is now being offered in the majority of UK centres. As more genes are identified for late-onset conditions, it is important that the complexities of 25% risk testing for late-onset conditions are not underestimated. This limited survey does not investigate how individual families cope with the psychological and social issues raised by this study and further research in this area is needed.

Evidence against an X-linked locus close to DXS7 determining visual loss susceptibility in British and Italian families with Leber hereditary optic neuropathy.

Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) is associated with mutations of mtDNA, but two features of LHON pedigrees are not explicable solely on the basis of mitochondrial inheritance. There is a large excess of affected males, and not all males at risk develop the disease. These observations could be explained by the existence of an X-linked visual loss susceptibility gene. This hypothesis was supported by linkage studies in Finland, placing the susceptibility locus at DXS7, with a maximum lod score of 2.48 at a recombination fraction of 0. Linkage studies in 1 Italian and 12 British families with LHON, analyzed either together or separately depending on the associated mtDNA mutation, have excluded the presence of such a locus from an interval of about 30 cM around DXS7 in these kindreds, with a total lod score of -26.51 at a recombination fraction of 0.