Substrate recognition and selectivity of peptide deformylase. Similarities and differences with metzincins and thermolysin.

The substrate specificity of Escherichia coli peptide deformylase was investigated by measuring the efficiency of the enzyme to cleave formyl- peptides of the general formula Fo-Xaa-Yaa-NH2, where Xaa represents a set of 27 natural and unusual amino acids and Yaa corresponds to a set of 19 natural amino acids. Substrates with bulky hydrophobic side-chains at the P1' position were the most efficiently cleaved, with catalytic efficiencies greater by two to five orders of magnitude than those associated with polar or charged amino acid side-chains. Among hydrophobic side-chains, linear alkyl groups were preferred at the P1' position, as compared to aryl-alkyl side-chains. Interestingly, in the linear alkyl substituent series, with the exception of norleucine, deformylase exhibits a preference for the substrate containing Met in the P1' position. Next, the influence in catalysis of the second side-chain was studied after synthesis of 20 compounds of the formula Fo-Nle-Yaa-NH2. Their deformylation rates varied within a range of only one order of magnitude. A 3D model of the interaction of PDF with an inhibitor was then constructed and revealed indeed the occurrence of a deep and hydrophobic S1' pocket as well as the absence of a true S2' pocket. These analyses pointed out a set of possible interactions between deformylase and its substrates, which could be the ground driving substrate specificity. The validity of this enzyme:substrate docking was further probed with the help of a set of site-directed variants of the enzyme. From this, the importance of residues at the bottom of the S1' pocket (Ile128 and Leu125) as well as the hydrogen bond network that the main chain of the substrate makes with the enzyme were revealed. Based on the numerous homologies that deformylase displays with thermolysin and metzincins, a mechanism of enzyme:substrate recognition and hydrolysis could finally be proposed. Specific features of PDF with respect to other members of the enzymes with motif HEXXH are discussed.

Solution structure of nickel-peptide deformylase.

In the accompanying paper, we report that zinc is unlikely to be the co-factor supporting peptide deformylase activity in vivo. In contrast, nickel binding promotes full enzyme activity. The three-dimensional structure of the resulting nickel-containing peptide deformylase (catalytic domain, residues 1 to 147) was solved by NMR using a 13C-15N-doubly labelled protein sample. A set of 2261 restraints could be collected, with an average of 15.4 per amino acid. The resolution, which shows a good definition for the position of most side-chains, is greatly improved compared to that previously reported for the zinc-containing, inactive form. A comparison of the two stuctures indicates however that both share the same 3D organization. This shows that the nature of the bound metal is the primary determinant of the hydrolytic activity of this enzyme. Site-directed mutagenesis enabled us to determine the conserved residues of PDF involved in the structure of the active site. In particular, a buried arginine appears to be critical for the positioning of Cys90, one of the metal ligands. Furthermore, the 3D structure of peptide deformylase was compared to thermolysin and metzincins. Although the structural folds are very different, they all display a common structural motif involving an alpha-helix and a three-stranded beta-sheet. These conserved structural elements build a common scaffold which includes the active site, suggesting a common hydrolytic mechanism for these proteases. Finally, an invariant glycine shared by both PDF and metzincins enables us to extend the conserved motif from HEXXH to HEXXHXXG.

Structure-function relationships within the peptide deformylase family. Evidence for a conserved architecture of the active site involving three conserved motifs and a metal ion.

Thermus thermophilus peptide deformylase was characterized. Its enzymatic properties as well as its organization in domains proved to share close resemblances with those of the Escherichia coli enzyme despite few sequence identities. In addition to the HEXXH signature sequence of the zinc metalloprotease family, a second short stretch of strictly conserved amino acids was noticed, EGCLS, the cysteine of which corresponds to the third zinc ligand. The study of site-directed mutants of the E. coli deformylase shows that the residues of this stretch are crucial for the structure and/or catalytic efficiency of the active enzyme. Both aforementioned sequences were used as markers of the peptide deformylase family in protein sequence databases. Seven sequences coming from Haemophilus influenzae, Lactococcus lactis, Bacillus stearothermophilus, Mycoplasma genitalium, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, Bacillus subtilus and Synechocystis sp. could be identified. The characterization of the product of the open reading frame from B. stearothermophilus confirmed that it actually corresponded to a peptide deformylase with properties similar to those of the E. coli enzyme. Alignment of the nine peptide deformylase sequences showed that, in addition to the two above sequences, only a third one, GXGXAAXQ, is strictly conserved. This motif is also located in the active site according to the three-dimensional structure of the E. coli enzyme. Site-directed variants of E. coli peptide deformylase showed the involvement of the corresponding residues for maintaining an active and stable enzyme. Altogether, these data allow us to propose that the three identified conserved motifs of peptide deformylases build up the active site around a metal ion. Finally, an analysis of the location of the other conserved residues, in particular of the hydrophobic ones, was performed using the three-dimensional model of the E. coli enzyme. This enables us to suggest that all bacterial peptide deformylases adopt a constant overall tertiary structure.

The C-terminal domain of peptide deformylase is disordered and dispensable for activity.

Upon trypsinolysis, the 18 C-terminal residues of Escherichia coli peptide deformylase were removed but the resulting form exhibited full activity. Moreover, a mutant fms gene encoding the first 145 out of the 168 residues of the enzyme was able to complement a fms(Ts) strain and exhibited full activity. Upon progressive truncation up to residue 139, both activity and stability decreased up to complete inactivation. Mutagenesis of residues of the 138-145 region highlights the importance of Leu-141 and Phe-142. N-Terminal deletions were also carried out. Beyond two residues off, the enzyme showed a dramatic instability. Finally, NMR and thermostability studies of the full-length enzyme and comparison to the 1-147 form strongly suggest that the dispensable residues are disordered in solution.

Mapping of the active site zinc ligands of peptide deformylase.

A set of 50 site-directed mutants of the Escherichia coli fms gene was constructed to delineate the residues of the active site of peptide deformylase, including the ligands of the zinc ion. In particular, because zinc is usually coordinate by Asp, Cys, Glu or His residues, all the corresponding codons were individually changed. The functional consequence of the substitutions was assessed by complementation of a fms-null strain with the help of vectors expressing the mutate genes. In addition to the mutations of the Cys90 codon, only those of the three conserved residues of the 132HEXXH136 motif of peptide deformylase prevented the indicator strain growing. Most enzyme variants were purified to homogeneity in a second step. Their characterization in vitro showed that the defects in complementation as observed in vivo corresponded to huge decreases of deformylation efficiency. The change of Glu88 also led to a significant decrease in catalytic rate. Unexpectedly, upon substitutions of Glu79 or of Glu83, the enzymes exhibited a strongly increased catalytic efficiency. The measurement of the content of zinc in each purified variant indicated that Cys90, His132 and His136 bound the metal ion. Zinc-free variants mutated at these positions were obtained and shown to display an increased sensitivity to proteolytic attack. Altogether, the data showed that both the presence of zinc and the conserved residues of the HEXXH motif were crucial for the activity of deformylase. This behaviour identified the enzyme as a member of the zinc metalloproteases superfamily. However, the unexpected participation in the binding of the zinc atom of Cys90, upstream from the HEXXH motif, suggested that peptide deformylase could be representative of a new sub-family, distinct from those of thermolysin and astacin.

Role of the 1-72 base pair in tRNAs for the activity of Escherichia coli peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase.

Previous work by Schulman and Pelka (1975) J. Biol. Chem. 250, 542-547, indicated that the absence of a pairing between the bases 1 and 72 in initiator tRNA(fMet) explained the relatively small activity of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase towards N-acetyl-methionyl-tRNA(fMet). In the present study, the structural requirements for the sensitivity of an N-acetyl-aminoacyl-tRNA to Escherichia coli peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase activity have been further investigated. Ten derivatives of tRNA(fMet) with various combinations of bases at positions 1 and 72 in the acceptor stem have been produced, aminoacylated and chemically acetylated. The release of the aminoacyl moiety from these tRNA derivatives was assayed in the presence of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase purified from an overproducing strain. tRNA(fMet) derivatives with either C1A72, C1C72, U1G72, U1C72 or A1C72 behaved as poor substrates of the enzyme, as compared to those with C1G72, U1A72, G1C72, A1U72 or G1U72. With the exception of U1G72, it could be therefore concluded that the relative resistance of tRNA(fMet) to peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase did not depend on a particular combination of nucleotides at positions 1 and 72, but rather reflected the absence of a base pairing at these positions. In a second series of experiments, the unpairing of the 1 and 72 bases, created with C-A or A-C bases, instead of G-C in methionyl-tRNA(mMet) or in valyl-tRNA(Val1), was shown to markedly decrease the rate of hydrolysis catalysed by peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase. Altogether, the data indicate that the stability of the 1-72 pair governs the degree of sensitivity of a peptidyl-tRNA to peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase.

Critical role of the acceptor stem of tRNAs(Met) in their aminoacylation by Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase.

To be aminoacylated by Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase, a tRNA requires the presence of the methionine anticodon (CAU sequence). However, the importance in this reaction of the other nucleotides of tRNAs(Met) has still to be described. In this work, through the study of more than 35 variants of tRNAs(Met), it is shown, firstly, that the parameters of the aminoacylation reaction remain independent of the mutations affecting either the sequences or the sizes of the D-loop, D-stem and variable loop. This conclusion is illustrated by the construction and study of a tRNAf(MetCAU) with the D-stem, D-loop and very long variable loop of a class II tRNA. The resulting chimaeric tRNA is methionylated as efficiently as tRNAf(MetCAU) or tRNAm(MetCAU). Secondly, mutations affecting base 73 and base pairs 2.71 and 3.70 in the acceptor stem of tRNAf(MetCAU), as well as bases 32, 33 and 37, adjacent to the anticodon, cause a strong reduction of the rate of the aminoacylation reaction. Thirdly, it is shown that, provided it is given the acceptor stem of tRNAm(MetCAU) or tRNAf(MetCAU), a tRNA having the anticodon loop of tRNA(Met) can be converted into a substrate for methionyl-tRNA synthetase as efficient as tRNAf(MetCAU) or tRNAm(MetCAU). Finally, it is proposed that, beyond the binding of the anticodon loop to the synthetase, the sequence of the acceptor stem may strongly influence the rate of the catalytic step of the aminoacylation reaction by properly orientating the 3'-end of the tRNA towards the catalytic centre.

Nucleotides of tRNA governing the specificity of Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA(fMet) formyltransferase.

In Escherichia coli, the free amino group of the aminoacyl moiety of methionyl-tRNA(fMet) is specifically modified by a transformylation reaction. To identify the nucleotides governing the recognition of the tRNA substrate by the formylase, initiator tRNA(fMet) was changed into an elongator tRNA with the help of an in vivo selection method. All the mutations isolated were in the tRNA acceptor arm, at positions 72 and 73. The major role of the acceptor arm was further established by the demonstration of the full formylability of a chimaeric tRNA(Met) containing the acceptor stem of tRNA(fMet) and the remaining of the structure of tRNA(mMet). In addition, more than 30 variants of the genes encoding tRNA(mMet) or tRNA(fMet) have been constructed, the corresponding mutant tRNA products purified and the parameters of the formylation reaction measured. tRNA(mMet) became formylatable by the only change of the G1.C72 base-pair into C1-A72. It was possible to render tRNA(mMet) as good a substrate as tRNA(fMet) for the formylase by the introduction of a limited number of additional changes in the acceptor stem. In conclusion, A73, G2.C71, C3.G70 and G4.C69 are positive determinants for the specific processing of methionyl-tRNA(fMet) by the formylase while the occurrence of a G.C or C.G base-pair between positions 1 and 72 acts as a major negative determinant. This pattern appears to account fully for the specificity of the formylase and the lack of formylation of any aminoacylated tRNA, excepting the methionyl-tRNA(fMet).