Pharmacological mechanisms underlying the efficacy of antibodies generated by a vaccine to treat oxycodone use disorder.

Therapeutic vaccines offer a viable strategy to treat opioid use disorders (OUD) complementary to current pharmacotherapies. The candidate Oxy(Gly)4-sKLH vaccine targeting oxycodone displayed pre-clinical proof of efficacy, selectivity and safety, and it is now undergoing clinical evaluation. To further support its implementation in the clinic, this study tested critical in vivo neuropsychopharmacological properties of the Oxy(Gly)4-sKLH vaccine in rats. While repeated immunizations with Oxy(Gly)4-sKLH were necessary to maintain the antibody response overtime, exposure to free oxycodone did not boost oxycodone-specific antibody levels in vaccinated rats, limiting concerns of immune-related side effects. Immunization with Oxy(Gly)4-sKLH achieved sustained antibody titers over a period of five months following initial vaccination, supporting its potential for providing long-lasting protection. In vivo studies of selectivity showed that vaccination prevented oxycodone-induced but not methadone-induced antinociception, while still preserving the opioid antagonist naloxone's pharmacological effects. Vaccination did not interfere with fentanyl-induced antinociception or fentanyl distribution to the brain. These in vivo data confirm the previously reported in vitro selectivity profile of Oxy(Gly)4-sKLH. Vaccination extended oxycodone's half-life up to 25 h compared to control. While vaccination reduced the reinforcing efficacy of oxycodone in an intravenous self-administration model, signs of toxicity were not observed. These rodent studies confirm that active immunization with Oxy(Gly)4-sKLH induces highly specific and long-lasting antibodies which are effective in decreasing the reinforcing effects of oxycodone while preserving the efficacy of medications used to treat OUD and overdose.

Flavor-specific enhancement of electronic cigarette liquid consumption and preference in mice.

BACKGROUND: The use of electronic cigarettes has increased over the past decade. To determine how the abuse liability of electronic cigarette liquids (e-liquids) differs from nicotine alone, and to determine the impact of flavor, we compared nicotine-containing fruit- and tobacco-flavored e-liquids, and their nicotine-free versions, to nicotine alone in mouse models of oral consumption, reward and aversion. METHODS: Adult male C57BL/6 J mice voluntarily consumed oral nicotine, equivalent nicotine concentrations of fruit- and tobacco-flavored e-liquid, and equivalent dilutions of the nicotine-free versions in 2-bottle choice tests. Conditioned place preference and place aversion were assessed with peripherally administered e-liquids or nicotine. Serum nicotine and cotinine levels were measured after subcutaneous injections of e-liquid or nicotine. RESULTS: Mice showed higher consumption and preference for the fruit-flavored e-liquid compared with nicotine alone. This increase was not due to the flavor itself as consumption of the nicotine-free fruit-flavored e-liquid was not elevated until the highest concentration tested. The increased consumption and preference were not observed with the tobacco-flavored e-liquid. The conditioned place preference, place aversion and nicotine pharmacokinetics of the fruit-flavored e-liquid were not significantly different from nicotine alone. CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that fruit, but not tobacco flavor, increased the oral consumption of e-liquid compared with nicotine alone. Moreover, this enhancement was not due to increased consumption of the flavor itself, altered rewarding or aversive properties after peripheral administration, or altered pharmacokinetics. This flavor-specific enhancement suggests that some flavors may lead to higher nicotine intake and increased use of e-liquids compared with nicotine alone.

Similar precipitated withdrawal effects on intracranial self-stimulation during chronic infusion of an e-cigarette liquid or nicotine alone.

The FDA recently extended their regulatory authority to electronic cigarettes (ECs). Because the abuse liability of ECs is a leading concern of the FDA, animal models are urgently needed to identify factors that influence the relative abuse liability of these products. The ability of tobacco products to induce nicotine dependence, defined by the emergence of anhedonia and other symptoms of nicotine withdrawal following cessation of their use, contributes to tobacco abuse liability. The present study compared the severity of precipitated withdrawal during chronic infusion of nicotine alone or nicotine-dose equivalent concentrations of three different EC refill liquids in rats, as indicated by elevations in intracranial self-stimulation (ICSS) thresholds (anhedonia-like behavior). Because these EC liquids contain constituents that may enhance their abuse liability (e.g., minor alkaloids), we hypothesized that they would be associated with greater withdrawal effects than nicotine alone. Results indicated that the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor antagonist mecamylamine precipitated elevations in ICSS thresholds in rats receiving a chronic infusion of nicotine alone or EC liquids (3.2mg/kg/day, via osmotic pump). Magnitude of this effect did not differ between formulations. Our findings indicate that nicotine alone is the primary CNS determinant of the ability of ECs to engender dependence. Combined with our previous findings that nicotine alone and these EC liquids do not differ in other preclinical addiction models, these data suggest that product standards set by the FDA to reduce EC abuse liability should primarily target nicotine, other constituents with peripheral sensory effects (e.g. flavorants), and factors that influence product appeal (e.g., marketing).

Abuse liability assessment of an e-cigarette refill liquid using intracranial self-stimulation and self-administration models in rats.

BACKGROUND: The popularity of electronic cigarettes (ECs) has increased dramatically despite their unknown health consequences. Because the abuse liability of ECs is one of the leading concerns of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), models to assess it are urgently needed to inform FDA regulatory decisions regarding these products. The purpose of this study was to assess the relative abuse liability of an EC liquid compared to nicotine alone in rats. Because this EC liquid contains non-nicotine constituents that may enhance its abuse liability, we hypothesized that it would have greater abuse liability than nicotine alone. METHODS: Nicotine alone and nicotine dose-equivalent concentrations of EC liquid were compared in terms of their acute effects on intracranial self-stimulation (ICSS) thresholds, acquisition of self-administration, reinforcing efficacy (i.e., elasticity of demand), blockade of these behavioral effects by mecamylamine, nicotine pharmacokinetics and nicotinic acetylcholine receptor binding and activation. RESULTS: There were no significant differences between formulations on any measure, except that EC liquid produced less of an elevation in ICSS thresholds at high nicotine doses. CONCLUSIONS: Collectively, these findings suggest that the relative abuse liability of this EC liquid is similar to that of nicotine alone in terms of its reinforcing and reinforcement-enhancing effects, but that it may have less aversive/anhedonic effects at high doses. The present methods may be useful for assessing the abuse liability of other ECs to inform potential FDA regulation of those products.

Vaccination against nicotine alters the distribution of nicotine delivered via cigarette smoke inhalation to rats.

Preclinical models of nicotine vaccine pharmacology have relied on i.v. or s.c. administration of nicotine. Models using cigarette smoke inhalation might more accurately simulate nicotine exposure in smokers. Nicotine vaccine effects were examined in rats using two cigarette smoke exposure models: a 10 min nose-only exposure (NSE) producing serum nicotine levels equivalent to the nicotine boost from 1 cigarette in a smoker, and a 2h whole-body exposure (WBE) producing serum nicotine levels similar to those associated with regular mid-day smoking. Vaccination prior to 10min smoke NSE reduced nicotine distribution to brain by 90%, comparable to its effect on nicotine administered i.v. Vaccination prior to 2 h smoke WBE reduced nicotine distribution to brain by 35%. The nicotine concentration in broncheoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid obtained after 2 h WBE was increased by 230% in vaccinated rats but was also increased in rats passively immunized with a nicotine-specific monoclonal antibody, and so was likely due to transfer of antibody from serum rather than local production at the pulmonary mucosa. Nicotine-specific IgA was not detectable in BAL fluid, but titers in serum were appreciable at 21-25% of the IgG titer and could contribute to vaccine efficacy. Both vaccination and passive immunization are effective in reducing nicotine distribution to brain in rats when nicotine is delivered via inhaled cigarette smoke. These data validate results previously obtained in rodents for nicotine vaccines using i.v. or s.c. nicotine dosing and provide a quantitative method for studying aspects of nicotine exposure which are unique to cigarette smoke inhalation.

Vaccination against nicotine does not prevent nicotine-induced changes in fetal nicotinic receptor binding and c-fos mRNA expression in rats.

Gestational exposure of rats to nicotine produces long-lasting alterations in brain development. Vaccination of adult female rats against nicotine reduces the distribution of maternally administered nicotine to fetal brain, suggesting that vaccination might protect against these effects. In the current study, the effects of vaccination on nicotine-induced changes in fetal (3)H-epibatidine binding and c-fos mRNA expression were evaluated using tissue from a previous pharmacokinetic study of vaccination. An intermittent nicotine dosing regimen designed to resemble nicotine intake in a smoker was administered from GD1-20. Peak nicotine levels in fetal brain were reduced by vaccination, whereas the chronic accumulation of nicotine in fetal brain was not. Gestational nicotine exposure produced significant increases in (125)I-epibatidine binding to brain and spinal cord on GD20, and decreased c-fos mRNA expression in fetal striatum, adrenal and lung. Vaccination did not significantly alter these effects. These data suggest that nicotine dosing, using a clinically relevant intermittent bolus dose regimen, produces substantial changes in fetal nicotinic receptor and c-fos mRNA expression. The decrease in c-fos mRNA expression contrasts with previously reported increases, and suggests that the nicotine dosing regimen used may influence its effects. The lack of effect of vaccination suggests that the cumulative exposure of fetal tissues to nicotine may influence the measured parameters to a greater extent than peak exposure levels.

Changes in maternal and fetal nicotine distribution after maternal administration of monoclonal nicotine-specific antibody to rats.

Vaccination against nicotine to elicit the production of nicotine-specific antibodies is a potential treatment for tobacco addiction which reduces nicotine distribution from serum to brain. Vaccination of pregnant rats also reduces the distribution of maternally-administered nicotine to the fetal brain. Whether this is due to maternal antibody reducing the transfer of nicotine from mother to fetus, or to fetal antibody altering the distribution of nicotine within the fetus, is not clear. In the current study, passive immunization of rats with the murine monoclonal nicotine-specific antibody Nic311 was used as a surrogate for vaccination because antibody transfer to the fetus was anticipated to be lower than with vaccination. Pregnant rats received nicotine from gestational day (GD) 18-20 as frequent i.v. boluses to simulate nicotine exposure from smoking. Nic311 was administered at doses of 30, 80 or 240 mg/kg on GD 19. Fetal serum Nic311 levels on GD 20 were <3% of concurrent maternal levels, but concentrations of up to 20 ug/ml in fetal serum were obtained owing to the very high levels in maternal serum. Accumulation of the chronically administered nicotine, measured on GD 20, was not changed by Nic311 treatment in either maternal or fetal brain. The early distribution of nicotine to maternal brain, measured 5 min after a dose, was markedly reduced by Nic311, while the early distribution of nicotine to whole fetus and fetal brain was not substantially altered. These data suggest that the limited transfer of Nic311 to the fetus in turn limits the ability of Nic311 to reduce nicotine distribution to the fetal brain.

Differential effects of passive immunization with nicotine-specific antibodies on the acute and chronic distribution of nicotine to brain in rats.

Vaccination against nicotine blocks or attenuates nicotine-related behaviors relevant to addiction in rats. Passive immunization with nicotine-specific antibodies is an alternative to vaccination with the potential advantages of allowing control of antibody dose and affinity. In the current study, the effects of two antibodies on the distribution of nicotine to brain were evaluated during chronic nicotine administration in rats; the monoclonal antibody Nic311 (K(d) = 60 nM) and nicotine-specific antiserum (K(d) = 1.6 nM). Nicotine was administered via repeated i.v. bolus doses over 2 days and antibody was administered during the first day. Neither antibody appreciably reduced the chronic accumulation of nicotine in brain, despite high protein binding of nicotine in serum (98.9%) and a 73% reduction in the unbound serum nicotine concentration with the highest Nic311 dose. However, both antibodies substantially reduced the early distribution of nicotine to brain 5 min after a dose. The higher affinity antibody was no more effective than Nic311. The highest Nic311 dose produced serum antibody levels 10 times higher than those reported with vaccination. The efficacy of Nic311 was dose-related, with the highest dose producing a 76% decrease in the early distribution of nicotine to brain. These findings, along with previous data, suggest that the primary effect of passive immunization is to slow, rather than prevent, the distribution of nicotine to brain. In the setting of chronic nicotine dosing, antibodies with a moderate affinity for nicotine produced substantial effects on the early distribution of nicotine to brain and were as effective as higher affinity antibodies.

Monoclonal nicotine-specific antibodies reduce nicotine distribution to brain in rats: dose- and affinity-response relationships.

Vaccination against nicotine is being studied as a potential treatment for nicotine dependence. Some of the limitations of vaccination, such as variability in antibody titer and affinity, might be overcome by instead using passive immunization with nicotine-specific monoclonal antibodies. The effects of antibodies on nicotine distribution to brain were studied using nicotine-specific monoclonal antibodies (NICmAbs) with K(d) values ranging from 60 to 250 nM and a high-affinity polyclonal rabbit antiserum (K(d) = 1.6 nM). Pretreatment with NICmAbs substantially increased the binding of nicotine in serum after a single nicotine dose, reduced the unbound nicotine concentration in serum, and reduced the distribution of nicotine to brain. Efficacy was directly related to antibody affinity for nicotine. Efficacy of the highest affinity NICmAb, NICmAb311, was dose-related, with the highest dose reducing nicotine distribution to brain by 78%. NICmAb311 decreased nicotine clearance by 90% and prolonged the terminal half-life of nicotine by 120%. At equivalent doses, NICmAb311 was less effective than the higher affinity rabbit antiserum but comparable efficacy could be achieved by increasing the NICmAb311 dose. These data suggest that passive immunization with nicotine-specific monoclonal antibodies substantially alters nicotine pharmacokinetics in a manner similar to that previously reported for vaccination against nicotine. Antibody efficacy is a function of both dose and affinity for nicotine.

Tissue-dependent effects of immunization with a nicotine conjugate vaccine on the distribution of nicotine in rats.

Vaccination of rats against nicotine reduces nicotine distribution to brain even at nicotine doses greatly exceeding the estimated binding capacity of the available antibody. This observation suggests a differential effect by which vaccination reduces nicotine distribution to brain to a greater extent than to other tissues. To test this hypothesis, vaccinated rats received a single intravenous nicotine dose equal to twice the estimated binding capacity of nicotine-specific antibody in vaccinated rats. The total and bound serum nicotine concentrations were higher in the vaccinated rats compared to controls, while the unbound serum nicotine concentration was lower. Distribution of nicotine to brain was reduced in vaccinated rats in a time-dependent manner, with a greater reduction at 1 min (64%) than at 25 min (45%). Vaccination reduced nicotine distribution to muscle, testis, spleen, liver, heart, and kidney, but to a lesser extent than to brain, while nicotine distribution to fat was increased. Chronically infused nicotine showed a similarly altered pattern of tissue distribution in vaccinated rats, but differences were in general smaller than after a single nicotine dose; brain nicotine concentration was 24% lower in vaccinated rats, while lung nicotine concentration was higher. The presence of nicotine-specific antibody in tissues may have contributed to the increased nicotine concentrations in fat and lung. These data suggest that vaccination reduces nicotine distribution to brain not only by sequestering nicotine in serum but also by redirecting tissue distribution disproportionately away from brain, such that nicotine concentrations are reduced to a greater extent in brain than in other tissues.

Maternal vaccination against nicotine reduces nicotine distribution to fetal brain in rats.

Cigarette smoking during pregnancy is associated with a variety of adverse fetal outcomes. Nicotine is a likely contributor to these adverse effects, with fetal brain as one target organ. Vaccination of adult male rats against nicotine has been shown to reduce nicotine distribution to the brain. The current study examined whether vaccination of female rats before pregnancy would reduce the distribution to fetal brain of a single nicotine dose administered during gestation. Female rats immunized with a nicotine conjugate vaccine received a single dose of nicotine 0.03 mg/kg i.v. on gestational day 16 to 22. Five minutes later, vaccinated rats had substantially higher bound and lower unbound serum nicotine concentration and lower brain nicotine concentration than controls. Fetal brain nicotine concentration was reduced by 43% in vaccinated rats, comparable to the reduction in the maternal brain nicotine concentration. The whole-fetus nicotine concentration was not altered by vaccination. A similar experiment was performed in which pregnant rats were passively immunized with rabbit nicotine-specific IgG 7 or 21 mg/kg just before nicotine dosing. The effects of passive immunization on nicotine distribution in the mother were IgG dose-related and the higher dose reduced nicotine distribution to fetal brain by 60%. These data suggest that vaccine effects on nicotine distribution to serum and brain are similar in pregnant female rats to those previously reported in adult males. Vaccination of female rats before pregnancy, or passive immunization during pregnancy, can reduce the exposure of fetal brain to a single dose of maternally administered nicotine.

Repeated exposure to inhaled toluene induces behavioral and neurochemical cross-sensitization to cocaine in rats.

RATIONALE: Toluene is a solvent found in many commercial products and is frequently abused by inhalation. Whether previous exposure to toluene alters subsequent responses to other drugs of abuse is not known. OBJECTIVES: This study determined the effects of repeated toluene exposure on the acute motor-stimulant response to cocaine and on cocaine-induced dopamine (DA) concentrations in the nucleus accumbens (NAc). METHODS: One week following bilateral cannulae implantation over the NAc, 27 adult, male Wistar rats began a daily 30-min exposure regimen to either toluene (8,000 ppm) or air for ten sessions. Approximately 24 h or 96 h after their last exposure, animals were injected with either saline or cocaine (15 mg/kg, i.p.) and locomotor activity and DA concentrations in the NAc were measured. RESULTS: Exposure to toluene rendered the rats immobile, and the time required for recovery of normal posture decreased across the ten sessions. In all animals tested, systemic cocaine administration enhanced both locomotor activity and DA concentrations in the NAc. These increases, however, were significantly greater in rats previously exposed to toluene. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, these findings show that repeated toluene exposure enhances behavioral and neurochemical responses to subsequent cocaine administration.

A comparison of cocaine, GBR 12909, and phentermine self-administration by rhesus monkeys on a progressive-ratio schedule.

The dopamine reuptake inhibitor GBR 12909 and the dopamine releaser phentermine may have potential for the treatment of cocaine abuse in humans. Pre-session treatment with either drug can decrease cocaine-maintained responding in rhesus monkeys while not affecting food-maintained responding. Both drugs are self-administered, but in some reports the patterns of responding they maintain differ from typical cocaine-reinforced responding. This study compared self-administration of cocaine (1--100 microg/kg/inj), GBR 12909 (3--100 microg/kg/inj), and phentermine (10--170 microg/kg/inj) in rhesus monkeys on a progressive-ratio schedule. Individual unit doses of each drug were available across several consecutive sessions. Cocaine self-administration was typical: the average number of ratios completed per session was a bitonic (increasing/decreasing) function of unit dose. Phentermine self-administration was variable across subjects (two of four monkeys self-administered reliably); one subject exhibited clear signs of behavioral toxicity. Self-administration of GBR 12909 was similarly variable across subjects. In the two subjects that self-administered GBR 12909 reliably, self-administration of small to mid-sized unit doses was enhanced following exposure to large unit doses. These data indicate that differences in self-administration of these drugs can be observed under progressive ratio procedures. Further, the data add to existing evidence suggesting that phentermine and GBR 12909 have at least moderate potential to be abused by humans.

Effects of cocaine and morphine under mixed-ratio schedules of food delivery: support for a behavioral momentum analysis.

Previous studies have shown that ratio size influenced the development of tolerance under simple and multiple schedules, but not under progressive-ratio (PR) schedules. PR schedules share certain features with mixed-ratio (MR) schedules, and pilot data suggested that ratio size fails to modulate tolerance to cocaine or morphine under MR schedules. The present study examined more comprehensively the pre- and postchronic effects of cocaine and (in separate birds) morphine under MR schedules with fixed-ratio (FR) 5 and FR 95, FR 25 and FR 75, and FR 50 and FR 50 components. Acute doses of cocaine and morphine initially were given in an ascending series (beginning with 0.56 mg/kg) until responding was reduced to near-zero levels. Chronic (daily) dosing with a dose that reduced, but did not eliminate, responding then occurred until response rates stabilized. Finally, postchronic dose-response determinations were conducted. Both cocaine and morphine reduced response rates at all FR values. Tolerance was consistently observed to the effects of morphine, but not to those of cocaine. With both drugs the degree of tolerance observed did not vary as a function of FR value. These findings, like those obtained under PR schedules, indicate that ratio size does not always modulate drug tolerance. A behavioral momentum analysis of drug action appears to account for whether or not ratio size modulates tolerance, and such an analysis is provided.

Abuse liability of the anesthetic propofol: self-administration of propofol in rats under fixed-ratio schedules of drug delivery.

RATIONALE: Previous reports suggest that propofol (PPF) may have abuse potential in humans. Hence, we hypothesized that PPF could reinforce self-administration behavior in other species. Positive reinforcing effects of PPF could be interpreted as an index of abuse liability. OBJECTIVE: Acquisition and maintenance of i.v. PPF self-administration were examined in 12 rats. METHODS: Six rats were initially given access to methohexital (MHX, 2.0 mg/kg per infusion) under a fixed ratio (FR) 1 schedule, while the other six were initially given access to PPF (1.7 mg/kg per infusion). Once stable responding was established, various doses of PPF (0.56, 1.0, and 1.7 mg/kg per infusion) and vehicle (Intralipid 20%) were made available. RESULTS: The number of PPF infusions per session was an inverse function of dose, with 0.56 mg/kg and 1.0 mg/kg per infusion maintaining significantly more infusions per session than vehicle in most rats under the FR 1 schedule. For some rats, the number of vehicle infusions per session was equal to or greater than the number of PPF infusions. Increasing the response requirement to FR 5 decreased the number of vehicle infusions per session in these rats, while PPF maintained a higher number of infusions than vehicle under this FR value in six of seven rats. CONCLUSION: PPF served as a reinforcer in rats under FR schedules of i.v. drug delivery, adding to the extant evidence that it has abuse potential.

Preclinical research on cocaine self-administration: environmental determinants and their interaction with pharmacological treatment.

It has been asserted that any comprehensive understanding of cocaine abuse and its treatment will require attention to both behavioral and pharmacological variables. Although the preclinical literature evaluating the effects of pharmacological variables on cocaine self-administration has been extensively reviewed, no comprehensive review of the effects of environmental variables on cocaine self-administration has been published. The present review summarizes and critiques the preclinical findings on environmental determinants of cocaine self-administration. The influence of environmental variables on the effects of pharmacological interventions on cocaine self-administration are also described. Several environmental variables have been shown to affect cocaine self-administration, including unit dose, schedule of cocaine delivery, schedules of nondrug stimuli, behavioral history, conditioned stimuli, food deprivation, exposure to stress, and rearing environment. Among these variables, unit dose, schedule of cocaine delivery, availability of alternative nondrug reinforcers, food deprivation, and rearing environment have also been shown to alter pharmacological treatment effects on cocaine self-administration. Thus, drug effects on cocaine self-administration are malleable and dependent upon the environmental context within which they occur. Suggestions for future research on the effects of these and other environmental variables on cocaine self-administration and its pharmacological treatment are presented.

Effects of phentermine on responding maintained by progressive-ratio schedules of cocaine and food delivery in rhesus monkeys.

Previous reports indicate that intravenous pretreatment with phentermine can decrease cocaine-maintained responding without affecting food-reinforced responding under fixed-ratio schedules. The present experiments were designed to explore the generality of this effect using progressive-ratio schedules of reinforcement and different routes of phentermine administration. Unit doses of cocaine and food-pellet magnitudes were identified that maintained similar breaking points, and the effects of acute exposure to phentermine were assessed. In Experiment 1, a 'conventional' (one-trial) progressive-ratio schedule was used, in which response requirements increased after each reinforcer delivery; in Experiment 2, a 'modified' (five-trial) progressive-ratio schedule was used, in which response requirements increased after every five reinforcer deliveries. In one group of monkeys, responding was maintained by food; in another, cocaine infusions maintained responding. Phentermine (0.1-5.6mg/kg, intramuscularly (i.m.)) dose-dependently decreased breakpoints on both progressive-ratio schedules. There were no differences in phentermine's effects on cocaine- and food-maintained behavior. In Experiment 3, intravenous administration of phentermine had largely similar effects. Taken together with results from previous reports, these data suggest that the effects of phentermine pretreatment are influenced by the behavioral procedure used to maintain responding and/or by the efficacy of the food and cocaine reinforcers.

Progressive-ratio schedules of drug delivery in the analysis of drug self-administration: a review.

Drugs, like other reinforcers, can vary in their relative abilities to support operant responding. Considerable research has been designed to obtain useful measures of a given drug's or dose's "reinforcing efficacy" and to identify the ways in which a variety of behavioral and pharmacological variables impact these measures. Progressive-ratio schedules of drug delivery generate an index of a drug's or dose's reinforcing efficacy (the breaking point) and are being used increasingly as tools in the analysis of drug self-administration. Progressive-ratio schedules of drug delivery have been used to characterize the effects of pretreatment drugs, lesions, drug deprivation, physical dependence, and repeated non-contingent drug exposure on breaking points. Behavioral factors, including food restriction and electric shock, and organismic factors, including gender and strain, have also been investigated using progressive-ratio schedules of drug delivery. To the extent that breaking points provide an index of reinforcing efficacy, these studies demonstrate that a wide range of variables can influence the reinforcing efficacy of self-administered drugs. The objectives of this review are to critique existing research themes, outline potential limitations of progressive-ratio procedures, and to suggest potentially fruitful uses of these procedures in future research.

Effects of chlorpromazine on rats' acquisition of lever-press responding with immediate and delayed reinforcement.

The effects of chlorpromazine (0, 2, 6, and 10 mg/kg) on the acquisition of lever-press responding by rats were examined under conditions where reinforcement (water delivery) was immediate or delayed. Under the immediate reinforcement condition, water-deprived rats were exposed during 8-h sessions to a fixed-ratio 1 (FR 1) schedule of water delivery without prior autoshaping or hand shaping. Under the delayed reinforcement condition, similar rats were exposed to a tandem FR 1 fixed-time 8-s schedule of water delivery. A different squad of eight rats was exposed to each delay condition and drug dose. For all subjects, responses on one lever produced water and responses on a second lever had no programmed consequences. Regardless of whether reinforcement was immediate or delayed, chlorpromazine reduced in dose-dependent fashion the mean number of operative-lever responses emitted, which suggests that the drug interfered with learning. At all chlorpromazine doses except 10 mg/kg, substantially more operative-lever than inoperative-lever responding occurred, indicating that the operant response was acquired. Chlorpromazine at 2 and 6 mg/kg disrupted the acquisition of stimulus control by the operative lever when reinforcement was delayed, but not when it was immediate. At 10 mg/kg, most subjects did not acquire lever-pressing regardless of whether they were exposed to the immediate or delayed reinforcement procedure. Procedures similar to those used in the present study appear to provide a reasonable assay for examining how drugs affect the initial behavioral effects of immediate and delayed reinforcement, and may merit further investigation.

Effects of D-amphetamine on response acquisition with immediate and delayed reinforcement.

The present study examined in 8-hour sessions the effects of d-amphetamine (1.0, 5.6, and 10 mg/kg) on the acquisition of lever-press responding in rats that were exposed to procedures in which water delivery was delayed by 0, 8, or 16 seconds relative to the response that produced it. Both nonresetting- and resetting-delay conditions were studied. Although neither shaping nor autoshaping occurred, substantial levels of operative-lever responding developed under all conditions in which responses produced water. The lowest dose (1.0 mg/kg) of d-amphetamine either had no effect on or increased operative-lever pressing, whereas higher doses typically produced an initial reduction in lever pressing. Nonetheless, overall rates of operative-lever pressing at these doses were as high as, or higher than, those observed with vehicle. Thus, response acquisition was observed under all reinforcement procedures at all drug doses. In the absence of the drug, most responding occurred on the operative lever when reinforcement was immediate. Such differential responding also developed under both nonresetting- and resetting-delay procedures when the delay was 8 seconds, but not when it was 16 seconds. d-Amphetamine did not affect the development of differential responding under any procedure. Thus, consistent with d-amphetamine's effects under repeated acquisition procedures, the drug had no detrimental effect on learning until doses that produced general behavioral disruption were administered.