Characterization of Protection Mechanisms to Blast Overpressure for Personal Hearing Protection Devices - Biomechanical Measurement and Computational Modeling.

Hearing damage induced by blast exposure is a common injury in military personnel involved in most operation activities. Personal hearing protection devices such as earplugs come as a standard issue for Service members; however, it is not clear how to accurately evaluate the protection mechanisms of different hearing protection devices for blast overpressures (BOP). This paper reports a recent study on characterization of earplugs' protective function to BOP using human cadaver ears and 3D finite element (FE) model of the human ear. The cadaver ear mounted with pressure sensors near the eardrum (P1) and inside the middle ear (P2) and with an earplug inserted was exposed to BOP in the blast test chamber. P1, P2, and BOP at the ear canal entrance (P0) were simultaneously recorded. The measured P0 waveform was then applied at the ear canal entrance in the FE model and the P1 and P2 pressures were derived from the model. Both experiments and FE modeling resulted in the P1 reduction which represents the effective protection function of the earplug. Different earplugs showed variations in pressure waveforms transmitted to the eardrum, which determine the protection level of earplugs.

Biomechanical Measurement and Modeling of Human Eardrum Injury in Relation to Blast Wave Direction.

Rupture of the eardrum or tympanic membrane (TM) is one of the most frequent injuries of the ear after blast exposure. To understand how the TM damage is related to blast wave direction, human cadaver ears were exposed to blast waves along three directions: vertical, horizontal, and front with respect to the head. Blast overpressure waveforms were recorded at the ear canal entrance (P0), near the TM (P1), and inside the middle ear (P2). Thirteen to fourteen cadaver ears were tested in each wave direction and the TM rupture thresholds were identified. Results show that blast wave direction affected the peak P1/P0 ratio, TM rupture threshold, and energy flux distribution over frequencies. The front wave resulted in lowest TM rupture threshold and the horizontal wave resulted in highest P1/P0 ratio. To investigate the mechanisms of TM injury in relation to blast wave direction, the recorded P1 waveforms were applied onto the surface of the TM in a three-dimensional finite element model of the human ear and distributions of the stress in TM were calculated. Modeling results indicate that the sensitivity of TM stress change with respect to P1 pressure (dσ/dP1) may characterize mechanical damage of the TM in relation to blast waves.

Computational Modeling of Blast Wave Transmission Through Human Ear.

Hearing loss has become the most common disability among veterans. Understanding how blast waves propagate through the human ear is a necessary step in the development of effective hearing protection devices (HPDs). This article presents the first 3D finite element (FE) model of the human ear to simulate blast wave transmission through the ear. The 3D FE model of the human ear consisting of the ear canal, tympanic membrane, ossicular chain, and middle ear cavity was imported into ANSYS Workbench for coupled fluid-structure interaction analysis in the time domain. Blast pressure waveforms recorded external to the ear in human cadaver temporal bone tests were applied at the entrance of the ear canal in the model. The pressure waveforms near the tympanic membrane (TM) in the canal (P1) and behind the TM in the middle ear cavity (P2) were calculated. The model-predicted results were then compared with measured P1 and P2 waveforms recorded in human cadaver ears during blast tests. Results show that the model-derived P1 waveforms were in an agreement with the experimentally recorded waveforms with statistic Kurtosis analysis. The FE model will be used for the evaluation of HPDs in future studies.

Mechanical damage of tympanic membrane in relation to impulse pressure waveform - A study in chinchillas.

Mechanical damage to middle ear components in blast exposure directly causes hearing loss, and the rupture of the tympanic membrane (TM) is the most frequent injury of the ear. However, it is unclear how the severity of injury graded by different patterns of TM rupture is related to the overpressure waveforms induced by blast waves. In the present study, the relationship between the TM rupture threshold and the impulse or overpressure waveform has been investigated in chinchillas. Two groups of animals were exposed to blast overpressure simulated in our lab under two conditions: open field and shielded with a stainless steel cup covering the animal head. Auditory brainstem response (ABR) and wideband tympanometry were measured before and after exposure to check the hearing threshold and middle ear function. Results show that waveforms recorded in the shielded case were different from those in the open field and the TM rupture threshold in the shielded case was lower than that in the open field (3.4 ± 0.7 vs. 9.1 ± 1.7 psi or 181 ± 1.6 vs. 190 ± 1.9 dB SPL). The impulse pressure energy spectra analysis of waveforms demonstrates that the shielded waveforms include greater energy at high frequencies than that of the open field waves. Finally, a 3D finite element (FE) model of the chinchilla ear was used to compute the distributions of stress in the TM and the TM displacement with impulse pressure waves. The FE model-derived change of stress in response to pressure loading in the shielded case was substantially faster than that in the open case. This finding provides the biomechanical mechanisms for blast induced TM damage in relation to overpressure waveforms. The TM rupture threshold difference between the open and shielded cases suggests that an acoustic role of helmets may exist, intensifying ear injury during blast exposure.