Critical attributes of human early mesenchymal stromal cell-laden microcarrier constructs for improved chondrogenic differentiation.

BACKGROUND: Microcarrier cultures which are useful for producing large cell numbers can act as scaffolds to create stem cell-laden microcarrier constructs for cartilage tissue engineering. However, the critical attributes required to achieve efficient chondrogenic differentiation for such constructs are unknown. Therefore, this study aims to elucidate these parameters and determine whether cell attachment to microcarriers throughout differentiation improves chondrogenic outcomes across multiple microcarrier types. METHODS: A screen was performed to evaluate whether 1) cell confluency, 2) cell numbers, 3) cell density, 4) centrifugation, or 5) agitation are crucial in driving effective chondrogenic differentiation of human early mesenchymal stromal cell (heMSC)-laden Cytodex 1 microcarrier (heMSC-Cytodex 1) constructs. RESULTS: Firstly, we found that seeding 10 × 103 cells at 70% cell confluency with 300 microcarriers per construct resulted in substantial increase in cell growth (76.8-fold increase in DNA) and chondrogenic protein generation (78.3- and 686-fold increase in GAG and Collagen II, respectively). Reducing cell density by adding empty microcarriers at seeding and indirectly compacting constructs by applying centrifugation at seeding or agitation throughout differentiation caused reduced cell growth and chondrogenic differentiation. Secondly, we showed that cell attachment to microcarriers throughout differentiation improves cell growth and chondrogenic outcomes since critically defined heMSC-Cytodex 1 constructs developed larger diameters (2.6-fold), and produced more DNA (13.8-fold), GAG (11.0-fold), and Collagen II (6.6-fold) than their equivalent cell-only counterparts. Thirdly, heMSC-Cytodex 1/3 constructs generated with cell-laden microcarriers from 1-day attachment in shake flask cultures were more efficient than those from 5-day expansion in spinner cultures in promoting cell growth and chondrogenic output per construct and per cell. Lastly, we demonstrate that these critically defined parameters can be applied across multiple microcarrier types, such as Cytodex 3, SphereCol and Cultispher-S, achieving similar trends in enhancing cell growth and chondrogenic differentiation. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study that has identified a set of critical attributes that enables efficient chondrogenic differentiation of heMSC-microcarrier constructs across multiple microcarrier types. It is also the first to demonstrate that cell attachment to microcarriers throughout differentiation improves cell growth and chondrogenic outcomes across different microcarrier types, including biodegradable gelatin-based microcarriers, making heMSC-microcarrier constructs applicable for use in allogeneic cartilage cell therapy.

Expansion in microcarrier-spinner cultures improves the chondrogenic potential of human early mesenchymal stromal cells.

BACKGROUND AIMS: Cartilage tissue engineering with human mesenchymal stromal cells (hMSC) is promising for allogeneic cell therapy. To achieve large-scale hMSC propagation, scalable microcarrier-based cultures are preferred over conventional static cultures on tissue culture plastic. Yet it remains unclear how microcarrier cultures affect hMSC chondrogenic potential, and how this potential is distinguished from that of tissue culture plastic. Hence, our study aims to compare the chondrogenic potential of human early MSC (heMSC) between microcarrier-spinner and tissue culture plastic cultures. METHODS: heMSC expanded on either collagen-coated Cytodex 3 microcarriers in spinner cultures or tissue culture plastic were harvested for chondrogenic pellet differentiation with empirically determined chondrogenic inducer bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP2). Pellet diameter, DNA content, glycosaminoglycan (GAG) and collagen II production, histological staining and gene expression of chondrogenic markers including SOX9, S100ß, MMP13 and ALPL, were investigated and compared in both conditions. RESULTS: BMP2 was the most effective chondrogenic inducer for heMSC. Chondrogenic pellets generated from microcarrier cultures developed larger pellet diameters, and produced more DNA, GAG and collagen II per pellet with greater GAG/DNA and collagen II/DNA ratios compared with that of tissue culture plastic. Moreover, they induced higher expression of chondrogenic genes (e.g., S100ß) but not of hypertrophic genes (e.g., MMP13 and ALPL). A similar trend showing enhanced chondrogenic potential was achieved with another microcarrier type, suggesting that the mechanism is due to the agitated nature of microcarrier cultures. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study demonstrating that scalable microcarrier-spinner cultures enhance the chondrogenic potential of heMSC, supporting their use for large-scale cell expansion in cartilage cell therapy.