The other ear: findings and results in 1,800 bilateral stapedectomies.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the incidence of middle ear abnormalities in patients with bilateral otosclerosis, which could potentially affect successful stapedectomy, and the rates of success in these patients, including the chance of overclosure in the second ear. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective case review of operative and audiologic records. SETTING: Private otology practice. PATIENTS: One thousand eight hundred patients underwent 3,600 primary stapedectomies for bilateral otosclerosis. INTERVENTION: Analysis of perioperative and follow-up audiograms with associated operative findings, including obliterative otosclerosis and solid footplates, dehiscent or overhanging facial nerve, narrow oval window niche, promontory overhang, and ossicular fixation or malformation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Audiologic stapedectomy success was determined as overclosure or closure of preoperative air-bone gap to less than 10 dB at 1 year or more of follow-up. RESULTS: The rate of finding any abnormality was 25%. Abnormalities present bilaterally were found in 135 patients (7%), with otosclerosis requiring an oval window drillout as the most common finding (41%), followed by dehiscent or overhanging facial nerves (25%). Success in patients with abnormalities was 78% overall, with bilateral overclosure in 40%. CONCLUSIONS: Abnormal middle ear findings during stapedectomy occur in a significant percentage of patients. Reasonable rates of success and overclosure can still be expected, but this is somewhat finding-specific. The predictive value of these findings, the associated rates of success with potential impact on surgical counseling, and planning for the "other ear" are discussed.

Stapedectomy following tympanoplasty.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the success of stapedectomy in patients who have previously had a tympanoplasty because of chronic otitis media (COM). Fourteen patients from a private otology practice had undergone tympanoplasty for COM and subsequently underwent stapedectomy. Measurements were taken of the air-bone gap (ABG) closure and pure tone average (PTA) which showed hearing improvement. Patients had a mean 36.9 dB PTA hearing gain with 79 per cent closing the ABG to within 20 dB. The need for stapedectomy alone is a rare occurrence for patients with a history of COM requiring a tympanoplasty. Hearing improvement following stapedectomy in these cases was significant, although somewhat less than following traditional stapedectomy in otosclerosis alone.

Ossiculoplasty in canal wall down mastoidectomy.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the initial and longer term success of closing the air-bone gap (ABG) to 20 dB in ossiculoplasty with canal wall down mastoidectomy. METHODS: This study was conducted at a private otologic practice. Patients included those who underwent ossiculoplasty from 1989 to 1996 with canal wall down mastoidectomy, whether primary or revision (33 from a total of 387 tympanomastoidectomies). Outcome measures included ABG closure, long-term hearing stability, mastoid appearance, extrusion, and sensorineural hearing loss. RESULTS: Almost 64% of ABGs were closed to within 20 dB. The mean pure-tone average improvement was 12.3 dB. The mean PTA hearing decline in the years after surgery was slightly less than 1 dB/year. CONCLUSION: Hearing improvement with a stable long-term hearing result is possible with canal wall down mastoidectomy. The potential for hearing gain is greatest for patients having larger preoperative ABGs.

Cavum major tympano-ossiculoplasty.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the success of tympano-ossiculoplasty in patients with previous canal wall down mastoidectomy. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review of 79 patients who underwent cavum major tympano-ossiculoplasty from a total of 1,910 tympanomastoidectomies from 1976 to 1998. OUTCOME MEASURES: The results of air-bone gap closure, surgical findings, and revision surgery are presented. RESULTS: In 63% of patients, the air-bone gap closed to within 20 dB with a mean gain of 14.7 dB. CONCLUSION: A significant percentage of patients will gain substantial improvement in their hearing after cavum major tympano-ossiculoplasty with minimal risk.

Otosclerosis in the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s.

EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVE: The focus of this paper is on the changing patterns of presentation of otosclerosis over the past 37 years. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review. SETTING: Private otology practice. PATIENTS: Randomized selection of 400 patients (100 per decade) from 15,372 who underwent stapedectomy over the past four decades. OUTCOME MEASURES: Extent of cochlear involvement, bilaterality of disease, length of history, degree of hearing loss, and pathological findings are noted. RESULTS: The decreasing incidence of footplates necessitating drillouts is discussed. Changing audiometric patterns at presentation such as decreased pure-tone average hearing thresholds and smaller air-bone gaps are also reviewed. CONCLUSION: This review demonstrates the changing patterns of presentation of otosclerosis over the past 37 years and will help guide the stapes surgeon into the year 2000.

Revision stapedectomy for incus erosion: long-term hearing.

One of the most common ossicular problems in revision stapedectomy is the eroded incus. Revision surgery has been reported as successful in 70% to 80% of cases at 1 year. Little is written about long-term results or the association of erosion with various prostheses. We evaluated 83 cases from 1 to 20 years, including multiple revisions. In 23 cases the erosion was seen at initial stapedectomy. Surgery was performed with the patient under local anesthesia, with the use of the Lippy modified prosthesis. Initial success was seen in 72% (41/57), satisfactory results in 90%, no change in 5%, and none worse. At 10 years, success had declined to 50% (7 of 14), with 80% satisfactory. The numbers for multiple revisions were lower. Success in nonrevision cases was 90% (21 of 23), dropping to 86% at 10 years, with satisfactory results in 100%. The type of prosthesis associated with erosion was a crimped wire in 34% (24 of 70), a plastic strut in 23%, and a Robinsion prosthesis in 17%. We conclude that the risk of incus erosion appears less with the Robinson prosthesis. The Lippy modified prosthesis yields good long-term results, particularly when erosion is seen at initial stapedectomy. Results worsen with subsequent revision.

Short- and long-term results of stapedectomy in children.

Studies have indicated that stapedectomy can be an effective procedure in children for correcting conductive hearing losses due to juvenile otosclerosis. However, because childhood otosclerosis is rare and children commonly choose to use hearing aids in lieu of undergoing surgery, little outcome data are available. The purpose of this retrospective study was to provide additional outcome data in both the short and the long term. Stapedectomies were performed on 47 children. Preoperative hearing results were compared with 6-month postoperative hearing results. Hearing results for the children who had long-term follow-up (5 years or more) were compared with the 6-month postoperative results. Stapedectomy was successful (postoperative air conduction pure-tone average [PTA] within 10 dB of the preoperative bone conduction PTA) in 91.7% of the cases. The mean overclosure of the preoperative bone conduction PTA by the postoperative air conduction PTA was 0.2 dB. The mean PTA hearing improvement was 32.8 dB. Results from the 21 children (28 ears) who had long-term follow-up indicated an average 0.7 dB/year PTA worsening from the 6-month postoperative PTA. Results from this study provide additional evidence that stapedectomy can be an effective procedure for correcting conductive hearing losses due to juvenile otosclerosis.

Prosthesis size in stapedectomy.

Primary stapedectomies were performed on 60 patients with bilateral otosclerosis. Every patient had a 4 mm long Robinson prosthesis with a 0.4 mm wide shaft placed in one ear and a 4 mm long Robinson prosthesis with 0.6 mm wide shaft placed in the opposite ear. With the 0.4 mm wide prosthesis, 54 patients overclosed the air bone gap and 6 were within 10 dB of closing. With the 0.6 mm wide prosthesis, which was placed in the opposite ear, 51 patients overclosed their air-bone gap and 8 were within 10 dB of closing. We conclude that there is no statistical difference in hearing results between the 0.4 mm and the 0.6 mm wide Robinson prosthesis when they are used in a partial stapedectomy with a vein graft covering the oval window.

Clinical utility of the 512-Hz Rinne tuning fork test.

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to examine the reliability of the 512-Hz Rinne tuning fork test to detect conductive hearing losses. The effects of tester experience, the use of masking, and the interpretation of equivocal (+/-) Rinne results on test reliability also were examined. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective. SETTING: Private otology practice. PATIENTS: 1,000 adult patients (2,000 ears) seen for their initial otologic evaluation. INTERVENTIONS: Diagnostic. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Sensitivity of the 512-Hz Rinne tuning fork test was assessed by comparing tuning fork results with the pure-tone average air-bone gap. RESULTS: Results showed the 512-Hz Rinne tuning fork test could be very effective at detecting conductive hearing losses when performed by an experienced tester and when masking was used. Sensitivity was lower when masking was not used and lowest when the Rinne was performed by a less-experienced tester. Sensitivity for all groups was improved by interpreting equivocal results as indicating a conductive loss. CONCLUSIONS: Despite reports of poor reliability, the 512-Hz Rinne tuning fork test can be an important tool in an otology practice for the detection of conductive hearing losses and for confirming audiometric findings. In primary care settings, the Rinne would be most effective as part of a screening program for conductive hearing losses, but not as the sole indicator for referral.

Word recognition score changes after stapedectomy for far advanced otosclerosis.

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to examine word recognition score (WRS) changes after stapedectomy for far-advanced otosclerosis (FAO). The WRS changes were examined to determine whether they were consistent with acclimatization or recovery from auditory deprivation changes that have been seen after the restoration of sound by amplification. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective. SETTING: Private otology practice. PATIENTS: A total of 24 patients were selected by including all the case in which a stapedectomy was performed within the past 10 years to improve the hearing of a severe or profoundly hearing-impaired patient with otosclerosis. INTERVENTION: Diagnostic. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Changes in WRSs. RESULTS: One month after surgery, the mean WRS had improved 16.5%. The WRSs continued to improve an additional 12% or more for 17 (71%) of 24 patients within 2 years after their initial postoperative hearing test. The mean WRS improvement within 2 years of the initial postoperative test was 16.2%. CONCLUSIONS: Initial WRS changes were attributed to hearing thresholds no longer being at or beyond audiometric limits. Additional WRS changes were consistent with reports of acclimatization or recovery from auditory deprivation that have been seen after hearing aid use. The authors believe these additional WRS changes illustrate that at least some improvement in WRSs from acclimatization or auditory recovery may be fairly common after the restoration of sound. Finally, the authors believe the overall WRS improvement (32.7%) should be taken into account when considering stapedectomy for patients with FAO.

Practical use of total and partial ossicular replacement prostheses in ossiculoplasty.

The use of porous polyethylene total and partial ossicular replacement prostheses (TOPs and POPs) for ossicular reconstruction in middle ear surgery was retrospectively reviewed at the Warren Otologic Group, a tertiary referral center for otologic problems. Extrusion rates, lower than those previously reported, and improvement in hearing results were found in 250 cases. Follow-up ranged from 6 months to 8 years. This paper details the optimal placement and relationships of the prosthesis, the interposed tragal cartilage, and the drum. Modifications to the prosthesis have increased stability and ease of reconstruction. The hearing results of both TOP and POP reconstruction, and comparison with the literature, will be presented. With TOPs, the air-bone gap was closed to within 20 dB in 67% of cases. With POPs, similar results were obtained in 81% of cases.

Stapedectomy in patients with small air-bone gaps.

Controversy exists concerning stapedectomy for patients with small air-bone gaps. The purpose of this study was to examine the results for patients who had a stapedectomy to correct a small (10 dB or less) air-bone gap. One hundred fifty-four patients with suspected otosclerosis were explored and a stapedectomy was performed in 136 (88.3%) of these cases. The mean pure-tone average (PTA) improved 16.7 dB and overdosed the preoperative bone conduction PTA by 8.1 dB. The majority of the stapedectomy patients (89.7%) had a PTA closure greater than or equal to 0 dB. These results showed that stapedectomy can be an effective procedure for eliminating and overdosing even small air-bone gaps due to otosclerosis.

Stapedectomy in the elderly.

Clinical records were reviewed to examine the effectiveness of stapedectomy in patients 70 years and older. A total of 154 patients was studied, including 11 with profound hearing loss with long-standing otosclerosis. Ages at the time of surgery ranged from 70 to 92 years (mean, 76.3 years). The mean pure-tone average (500, 1,000, 2,000, and 4,000 Hz) improved 30.6 dB after surgery for the 143 patients in the main otosclerotic group and 26.8 dB for the patients in the profound-hearing-loss group. The rate of successful stapedectomies for the 70(+)-year-old patients (90.9%) and the younger comparison group (90.0%) were similar. These findings extend the documented range of stapedectomy as a safe and effective procedure through the eighth decade of life.

Stapedectomy in combat pilots.

Between 1977 and 1995, nine stapedectomies using the Robinson-vein graft technique were performed in six high-performance airplane pilots diagnosed with otosclerosis. All of them returned to full active duty after stapedectomy without any vestibular symptoms. These cases illustrate that it can be safe for fighter or test pilots to return to full flight status after stapedectomy. These cases also suggest that full flight status can be reinstated as soon as 3 months after stapedectomy without endangering flight safety.

Prosthesis on a mobilized stapes footplate.

Managing a mobilized footplate in stapedectomy surgery can be challenging. Between 1963 and 1992, 145 footplates were inadvertently mobilized during otosclerosis surgery. After a vein graft, a 4.0-mm Robinson prosthesis was placed on all footplates, making no attempt to remove the footplate. There were 73 thin, blue footplates and 72 thick, white footplates. Hearing results in the thin, blue footplate group was 97% successful and 100% satisfactory at 3 years. No footplate refixed. In the thick, white group, hearing was 60% successful and 72% satisfactory at 6 months. Footplate refixation was found at revision in all but one unsuccessful case. After revision, the thick, white group had 79% successful and 89% satisfactory hearing results at 3 years. No patient in either group was worse. We conclude that placing a vein graft and a Robinson prosthesis is a safe and effective technique for a mobilized footplate. If the footplate is thin and blue, there is little or no risk of refixation. If the footplate is thick and white, approximately 30% will require revision.

Acoustic reflexes, auditory brainstem response, and MRI in the evaluation of acoustic neuromas.

Patient records were reviewed to determine whether persons with absent acoustic reflexes have a higher incidence of abnormal auditory brainstem response (ABR) results in the absence of a cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumor than those with normal acoustic reflexes. Results showed patients with absent reflexes to have borderline or abnormal ABR results in 45.2% of the cases. Patients with normal reflexes had borderline or abnormal ABR results in 14.2% of the cases. Results indicate that magnetic resonance imaging is a more appropriate test for patients with absent reflexes, since ABR was often nondiagnostic for a CPA tumor in this group.

Simultaneous presentation of facial nerve neuroma and otosclerosis.

Otosclerosis often occurs as a unilateral mixed or conductive hearing loss. In the absence of retrocochlear findings, otologists usually do not pursue further diagnostic testing. A patient who presented to the Warren Otologic Group with a unilateral mixed hearing loss is discussed. He was followed for 1 year with the intent of scheduling a stapedectomy. Two weeks prior to the surgical date, the patient developed a sudden hearing loss and was admitted to the hospital for treatment. Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated a tiny, enhancing mass in the lateral internal auditory canal, measuring 7 mm in diameter. At surgery, the tumor was found to originate at the union of the nervus intermedius and the facial nerve. The simultaneous occurrence of facial nerve neuroma and otosclerosis is discussed, with emphasis on a thorough evaluation of all unilateral mixed hearing losses, including those attributable to otosclerosis.

Far-advanced otosclerosis.

Far-advanced otosclerosis (FAO) is an uncommon diagnosis. Hearing levels in patients with FAO may range from profound loss, by air conduction and fragmentary bone conduction thresholds, to no measurable air or bone conduction thresholds. Thus, FAO may be difficult to distinguish from a sensorineural hearing loss. This report presents the results of surgery in 73 ears with FAO, 77 percent of which had improvement in air conduction thresholds of greater than 20 dB. Discrimination was improved by more than 15 percent in 54 percent of cases, and 75 percent realized improvement in use of a hearing aid. There was no evidence that success was related to preoperative hearing. The surgical results of a subgroup of 14 patients having bilateral FAO were also analyzed. For all 14, similar surgical outcomes were achieved in both the initial and the contralateral ear, with six successes bilaterally and eight failures bilaterally. Although far advanced otosclerosis is uncommon and difficult to diagnose, surgery is worthwhile.

Evolution of techniques of stapedectomy from the total stapedectomy to the small fenestra stapedectomy.

No consensus exists among surgeons about how much of the footplate to remove in stapes surgery. By comparing ideal cases with identical surgical techniques, it may be possible to select an optimal amount of the stapes footplate to remove. This article details the evolution of techniques of stapedectomy from the total stapedectomy to the small fenestra stapedectomy.