Cell-bound complement activation products as lupus biomarkers: diagnosis, monitoring and stratification.

INTRODUCTION: Cell-bound complement activation products (CB-CAPs) were first reported in 2004, since which time multiple laboratories have demonstrated their value as biomarkers for diagnosis, monitoring, and stratification of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. Areas covered: This review summarizes the highlights of these 14 years of CB-CAPs discovery and validation, concluding with a view toward their future potential for precision medicine. Expert commentary: The practice of medicine is both art and science and each physician can be considered both artist and scientist with a variable blend of the two skill sets. There is arguably no disease that presents a greater challenge, nor a greater opportunity, for implementation of precision medicine, as does lupus. The physician who is presented with diagnosis and/or management of a patient suspected of having lupus will need to augment artistic skills with scientific guidance, and that science will be delivered in the form of biomarkers. Ultimately, we will likely have a 'lupus liquid biopsy' that will be 100% sensitive and 100% specific for a diagnosis of lupus. This will undoubtedly be a panel of biomarkers rather than an individual laboratory test. Such a liquid biopsy could transform lupus diagnosis to an entirely scientific process.

Potential Roles of Antiphospholipid Antibodies in Generating Platelet-C4d in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus.

Premature, accelerated onset of atherothrombotic disease is prevalent in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Most, if not all, atherothrombotic diseases are likely to involve platelets and complement. Previously, we discovered that platelets bearing complement activation product C4d (P-C4d) are present in SLE patients, and are significantly associated with antiphospholipid (aPL) antibody positivity and stroke in SLE patients. The goal of the present study was to further elucidate the role of aPL and other platelet-reactive autoantibodies in the generation of P-C4d. To determine the association between P-C4d and aPL antibodies, the serum levels of aPL antibodies and P-C4d of 180 SLE patients were measured by enzyme-linked immunoassays and flow cytometry, respectively. To investigate the role of aPL antibodies, and possibly other autoantibodies as well, in mediating the generation of P-C4d, in vitro 2-step P-C4d induction experiments were performed. The results showed that the presence and levels of aPL antibodies in the serum were specifically elevated in SLE patients with positive P-C4d. The plasma and immunoglobulins purified from SLE patients who were positive for P-C4d and aPL were capable of inducing C4d deposition on normal platelets in vitro. The capacity of SLE plasma in inducing P-C4d appeared to correlate proportionately to the serum aPL levels. Collectively, the results demonstrate that both aPL and other platelet-reactive autoantibodies may participate in mediating the generation of P-C4d in SLE patients.

Cardiovascular disease biomarkers across autoimmune diseases.

Cardiovascular disease is increasingly recognized as a major cause of premature mortality among those with autoimmune disorders. There is an urgent need to identify those patients with autoimmune disease who are at risk for CVD so as to optimize therapeutic intervention and ultimately prevention. Accurate identification, monitoring and stratification of such patients will depend upon a panel of biomarkers of cardiovascular disease. This review will discuss some of the most recent biomarkers of cardiovascular diseases in autoimmune disease, including lipid oxidation, imaging biomarkers to characterize coronary calcium, plaque, and intima media thickness, biomarkers of inflammation and activated complement, genetic markers, endothelial biomarkers, and antiphospholipid antibodies. Clinical implementation of these biomarkers will not only enhance patient care but also likely accelerate the pharmaceutical pipeline for targeted intervention to reduce or eliminate cardiovascular disease in the setting of autoimmunity.

Antilymphocyte autoantibodies generate T cell-C4d signatures in systemic lupus erythematosus.

T cells bearing C4d, a complement activation product (CAP), have been shown to be highly sensitive and specific as diagnostic biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). T cells bearing C4d are also functionally abnormal, suggesting a role for cell-bound CAPs in lupus pathogenesis. However, the mechanism responsible for generation of T-C4d has not been determined. The purpose of this cross-sectional and prospective study was to investigate the potential role of anti-T-cell autoantibodies in the generation of the T cell-bound C4d (T-C4d) signatures in SLE. Briefly, T cells from patients with SLE (n = 326), patients with other inflammatory diseases (n = 185), and healthy controls (n = 48) were characterized for surface deposition of either or both of C4d and immunoglobulin (Ig) by flow cytometry. In vitro phenotype transfer experiments were performed to characterize Ig from patients with SLE for the capacity to generate T-C4d signatures in vitro. The results demonstrate that individual patients with SLE harbor specific signatures reflecting the presence of either or both of C4d and Ig on their T cells and T-cell subsets. In addition, SLE patient-specific signatures can be transferred in vitro to normal T cells by exposure to Ig purified from the signature donor. Complement activation does not proceed through the generation of C5b-9 (membrane attack complex) or cellular lysis, and T-C4d does not correlate with lymphopenia. In conclusion, these results suggest that patient-specific T-C4d signatures are generated by anti-T-cell autoantibodies that trigger sublytic complement activation, a previously unrecognized pathway in lupus pathogenesis.

The lupus biomarker odyssey: one experience.

The last decade has witnessed an explosion in efforts to discover and validate lupus biomarkers. The currently steep trajectory of this progress is unprecedented. However, advances in the lupus biomarker field remain fewer and slower than physicians, patients, and pharmaceutical companies have hoped for. This chapter will review the challenges confronted by physicians and scientists in pursuit of lupus biomarkers and will present our experience on this path and specific efforts to surmount some of the obstacles in this endeavor. A comprehensive review of the current landscape in lupus biomarker research has recently been published elsewhere (Ahearn et al. Transl Res 159:326-342, 2012; Liu et al. Ther Adv Musculoskelet Dis 5:210-233, 2013; Liu and Ahearn Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol 23:507-523, 2009; Liu et al. Curr Opin Rheumatol 17:543-549, 2005).

Biomarkers in systemic lupus erythematosus: challenges and prospects for the future.

The search for lupus biomarkers to diagnose, monitor, stratify, and predict individual response to therapy is currently more intense than ever before. This effort is essential for several reasons. First, epidemic overdiagnosis and underdiagnosis of lupus, even by certified rheumatologists, leads to errors in therapy with concomitant side effects which may be more serious than the disease itself. Second, identification of lupus flares remains as much an art as it is a science. Third, the capacity to stratify patients so as to predict those who will develop specific patterns of organ involvement is not currently possible but would potentially lead to preventive therapeutic strategies. Fourth, only one new drug for the treatment of lupus has been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration in over 50 years. A major obstacle in this pipeline is the dearth of biomarkers available to prove a patient has responded to an experimental therapeutic intervention. This review will summarize the challenges faced in the discovery and validation of lupus biomarkers, the most promising lupus biomarkers identified to date, and the promise of future directions.

Biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus.

The urgent need for lupus biomarkers was demonstrated in September 2011 during a Workshop sponsored by the Food and Drug Administration: Potential Biomarkers Predictive of Disease Flare. After 2 days of discussion and more than 2 dozen presentations from thought leaders in both industry and academia, it became apparent that highly sought biomarkers to predict lupus flare have not yet been identified. Even short of the elusive biomarker of flare, few biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) diagnosis, monitoring, and stratification have been validated and employed for making clinical decisions. This lack of reliable, specific biomarkers for SLE hampers proper clinical management of patients with SLE and impedes development of new lupus therapeutics. As such, the intensity of investigation to identify lupus biomarkers is climbing a steep trajectory, lending cautious optimism that a validated panel of biomarkers for lupus diagnosis, monitoring, stratification, and prediction of flare may soon be in hand.

Cell-bound complement biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus: from benchtop to bedside.

Systemic lupus erythematosus is arguably the most clinically and serologically diverse autoimmune disease. This article highlights the biomarkers helpful in diagnosing this disease. The authors' own research is presented.

Erythrocyte C3d and C4d for monitoring disease activity in systemic lupus erythematosus.

OBJECTIVE: Disease activity in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is typically monitored by measuring serum C3 and C4. However, these proteins have limited utility as lupus biomarkers, because they are substrates rather than products of complement activation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the utility of measuring the erythrocyte-bound complement activation products, erythrocyte-bound C3d (E-C3d) and E-C4d, compared with that of serum C3 and C4 for monitoring disease activity in patients with SLE. METHODS: The levels of E-C3d and E-C4d were measured by flow cytometry in 157 patients with SLE, 290 patients with other diseases, and 256 healthy individuals. The patients with SLE were followed up longitudinally. Disease activity was measured at each visit, using the validated Systemic Lupus Activity Measure (SLAM) and the Safety of Estrogens in Lupus Erythematosus: National Assessment (SELENA) version of the Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Disease Activity Index (SLEDAI). RESULTS: At baseline, patients with SLE had higher median levels of E-C3d and E-C4d (P < 0.0001) in addition to higher within-patient and between-patient variability in both E-C3d and E-C4d when compared with the 2 non-SLE groups. In a longitudinal analysis of patients with SLE, E-C3d, E-C4d, serum C3, and anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibodies were each significantly associated with the SLAM and SELENA-SLEDAI. In a multivariable analysis, E-C4d remained significantly associated with these SLE activity measures after adjusting for serum C3, C4, and anti-dsDNA antibodies; however, E-C3d was associated with the SLAM but not with the SELENA-SLEDAI. CONCLUSION: Determining the levels of the erythrocyte-bound complement activation products, especially E-C4d, is an informative measure of SLE disease activity as compared with assessing serum C4 levels and should be considered for monitoring disease activity in patients with SLE.

The search for lupus biomarkers.

Few biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) have been validated and employed for making clinical decisions. The lack of reliable, specific biomarkers for SLE hampers the proper clinical management of patients with SLE and impedes the development of new lupus therapeutics. This void has led to renewed enthusiasm for identifying biomarkers that precisely and specifically reflect the pathophysiological and clinical changes of SLE. Several laboratory markers have shown early promise as biomarkers for lupus susceptibility, diagnosis and monitoring. These include polymorphisms and copy-number variations of complement C4 and Fcgamma receptor genes (disease susceptibility), cell-bound complement C4d (diagnosis and/or disease activity), CD27(high) plasma cells (disease activity), 'interferon signature' (disease activity) and anti-C1q and anti-NMDA (disease activity and organ involvement). Although these and other promising candidate biomarkers have been identified, they still need to be validated through rigorous, large-scale multicentre studies. This article briefly reviews the historical aspects of lupus biomarkers and summarises current efforts to advance the field.

Lymphocyte-bound complement activation products as biomarkers for diagnosis of systemic lupus erythematosus.

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is frequently misdiagnosed due to the lack of definitive diagnostic tests. The purpose of this study was to determine specifically whether complement activation products (CAP) are deposited on lymphocytes of SLE patients and whether lymphocyte-bound CAP (LB-CAP) may serve as novel biomarkers for the diagnosis of SLE. We conducted a cross-sectional study of 224 patients with SLE, 179 patients with other diseases, and 114 healthy controls. LB-CAP on peripheral blood lymphocytes was measured by flow cytometry. Diagnostic utility of LB-CAP was determined by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. Significantly elevated levels of C4d and C3d were detected specifically on T and B lymphocytes (designated T-C4d, T-C3d, B-C4d, and B-C3d) of SLE patients. As diagnostic tools, T-C4d and B-C4d, respectively, were 56% sensitive/80% specific and 60% sensitive/82% specific in differentiating SLE from other diseases. Moreover, compared with measurement of anti-dsDNA, serum C3, or serum C4, measurement of T-C4d/B-C4d was significantly more sensitive in identifying SLE patients during a single clinic visit. This is the first investigation of lymphocytes bearing complement activation products in human disease. T-C4d and B-C4d have high diagnostic sensitivity and specificity for SLE and may have added value to current laboratory tests for SLE diagnosis.

Mannose-binding lectin is a disease-modifying factor in North American patients with systemic lupus erythematosus.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether development of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), its clinical manifestations, and autoantibody production are associated with polymorphisms of the mannose-binding lectin (MBL) gene in North American patients with SLE. METHODS: MBL gene polymorphisms in codons 52 (designated variant D, with the wild-type designated A), 54 (variant B), and 57 (variant C) were determined by polymerase chain reaction-sequence specific priming in 130 patients with SLE and 142 healthy controls. Autoantibodies against double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), Smith antigen, phospholipids, Ro/SSA, La/SSB, and RNP were tested at certified clinical pathology laboratories. RESULTS: A statistically significant increased likelihood of anti-Smith antibody production was observed in SLE patients with the heterozygous A/B genotype [odds ratio (OR) 5.1; 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.6-16.6; the A/A genotype as the reference group] or A/C genotype (OR 8.2; 95% CI 2.0-33.9). SLE patients with the homozygous or compound heterozygous variant genotype (O/O; O, a common designation for variant alleles) had an increased likelihood of mounting autoantibody responses against dsDNA, Ro/SSA, and La/SSB, and were more likely to have a history of renal disease (OR 4.8; 95% CI 0.9-25.2). However, differences in the frequencies of MBL variant alleles and genotypes observed between patients with SLE and controls did not reach statistical significance. CONCLUSION: A significantly increased prevalence of anti-Smith antibody was associated with the heterozygous genotypes A/B and A/C. Although MBL structural gene polymorphism was not a risk factor for SLE development in this study population, homozygosity of MBL variant alleles may be a weak disease-modifying factor, particularly for renal involvement, in North American patients with SLE.

Cell-bound complement activation products (CB-CAPs) as a source of lupus biomarkers.

Measurement of serum C3 and C4 has been used for several decades to monitor disease activity in patients with SLE. Despite the limited utility and recognized weaknesses of these assays, they have remained the gold standard during an era of unprecedented discovery in the complement field. The current urgent need for lupus biomarkers warrants efforts to mine the complement system for assays superior to serum C3 and C4. Recent studies of soluble and cell-bound complement activation products hold promise for achieving this goal.

Platelet C4d is highly specific for systemic lupus erythematosus.

OBJECTIVE: Complement-activation product C4d is deposited on normal erythrocytes, while abnormal levels have been observed on the surface of erythrocytes of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). This study examines whether C4d also deposits on human platelet surfaces, and whether platelet-bound C4d may provide a biomarker for SLE. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional study of 105 patients with SLE, 115 patients with other diseases, and 100 healthy controls. Levels of C4d on the surface of platelets were examined by flow cytometry and scanning confocal microscopy. Statistical analyses were performed to determine the clinical variables associated with platelet C4d. RESULTS: Abnormal levels of platelet C4d were found to be highly specific for SLE. Platelet C4d was detected in 18% of patients with SLE, being 100% specific for a diagnosis of SLE compared with healthy controls and 98% specific for SLE compared with patients with other diseases (P < 0.0001). In addition, platelet C4d was significantly associated with positivity for lupus anticoagulant (P < 0.0001) and anticardiolipin antibodies of the IgG (P = 0.035) or the IgM (P = 0.016) isotype. Platelet C4d was also significantly associated with SLE disease activity according to the SLE Disease Activity Index (P = 0.039), low serum C4 (P = 0.046), an elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate (P = 0.006), and abnormal levels of C4d on erythrocytes (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: This observation suggests that platelet-bound C4d may be a useful biomarker for SLE and may be a clue to the pathogenic mechanisms responsible for the myriad thrombotic and vascular complications of lupus associated with antiphospholipid antibodies.

Apoptosis and autoimmunity.

Cell death by apoptosis plays a significant and seemingly contradictory role in the development and pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases. Apoptosis is integral to the assembly and maintenance of a healthy, self-tolerant immune system. However, many of the molecular and cellular events specific to apoptosis generate a reservoir of self-antigens with the potential to initiate and possibly perpetuate autoimmune conditions. Recent findings that support this latter, more sinister role for apoptosis have shed light on a mystery that is common to many systemic autoimmune diseases, namely, why the majority of autoantibodies produced in patients with these diseases target proteins that are normally found inside the cell, often within the nucleus. This review will discuss how autoantigens are specifically altered during the apoptotic process, and how the complement system participates in recognizing and clearing these potentially immunogenic packages.

Reticulocytes bearing C4d as biomarkers of disease activity for systemic lupus erythematosus.

OBJECTIVE: There is an urgent need for biomarkers with which to monitor disease activity in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). We recently showed that abnormal levels of C4d, an activation-derived fragment of complement component C4, are deposited on the surface of erythrocytes from patients with SLE. This study focused on reticulocytes, the youngest and shortest-lived erythrocytes (lifespan 24-48 hours), with the objective of testing our hypothesis that when reticulocytes emerge from the bone marrow, they are immediately exposed to and acquire C4d at levels proportionate to the extent of complement activation at that time, thereby reflecting disease activity in SLE. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional study of 156 patients with SLE, 140 patients with other diseases, and 159 healthy controls. Levels of C4d on the surface of reticulocytes were examined using a 2-color flow cytometric assay. The results were analyzed for correlations with SLE disease activity. RESULTS: A wide range of increased levels of reticulocyte C4d was specifically detected in SLE patients. These levels fluctuated in SLE patients and correlated with clinical disease activity, as determined by the Safety of Estrogens in Lupus Erythematosus: National Assessment (SELENA) version of the Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Disease Activity Index (SLEDAI) and the Systemic Lupus Activity Measure (SLAM). Specifically, in cross-sectional analyses, patients with reticulocyte C4d levels in the highest quartile compared with those in the lowest quartile had significantly higher SELENA-SLEDAI (P = 0.00002) and SLAM (P = 0.02) scores. Longitudinal observation demonstrated that the reticulocyte C4d levels changed in relation to the clinical course in individual patients. CONCLUSION: These findings support our hypothesis that C4d-bearing reticulocytes may serve as biomarkers of disease activity in patients with SLE.

Biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus: a review and perspective.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Despite decades of extensive work in the understanding of the etiopathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus, few biomarkers have been validated and widely accepted for this disease. The lack of reliable, specific biomarkers not only hampers clinical management of systemic lupus erythematosus but also impedes development of new therapeutic agents. This paper reviews briefly the historical aspects of systemic lupus erythematosus biomarkers and summarizes recent studies on candidate biomarkers. RECENT FINDINGS: Recognizing the urgent need for lupus biomarkers, a Lupus Biomarker Working Group has recently been initiated to facilitate collaborative efforts aimed at identifying and validating biomarkers for systemic lupus erythematosus. Based on available data, several laboratory markers have shown promise as biomarkers for susceptibility, diagnosis, and disease activity. These include Fc receptor genes (disease susceptibility), complement C4d-bound erythrocytes (diagnosis or disease activity), CD27 plasma cells (disease activity), 'interferon signature' (disease activity), and anti-C1q antibodies (disease activity and organ involvement). SUMMARY: There is a longstanding and recently rejuvenated enthusiasm for biomarkers that precisely and specifically reflect the pathophysiologic and clinical changes in systemic lupus erythematosus. Promising candidate biomarkers have been identified but must still be validated through rigorous, large-scale multicenter studies.

Identification of a novel estrogen-sulfating cytosolic SULT from zebrafish: molecular cloning, expression, characterization, and ontogeny study.

By searching the expressed sequence tag database, a zebrafish cDNA encoding a putative cytosolic sulfotransferase (SULT) was identified. Sequence analysis indicated that this zebrafish SULT belongs to the SULT1 cytosolic SULT gene family. The recombinant form of this novel zebrafish SULT, expressed using the pGEX-2TK expression system and purified from transformed BL21 (DE3) Escherichia coli cells, displayed sulfating activities specifically for estrone and 17beta-estradiol among various endogenous compounds tested as substrates. The enzyme also exhibited sulfating activities toward some xenobiotic phenolic compounds. This new zebrafish SULT showed dual pH optima, at 6.5 and 10-10.5, with estrone or n-propyl gallate as substrate. Kinetic constants of the sulfation of estrone, 17beta-estradiol, and n-propyl gallate were determined. Developmental stage-dependent expression experiments revealed a significant level of expression of this novel zebrafish estrogen-sulfating SULT at the beginning of the hatching period during embryogenesis, which continued throughout the larval stage onto maturity.

Measurement of erythrocyte C4d and complement receptor 1 in systemic lupus erythematosus.

OBJECTIVE: C4-derived activation fragments are the only complement ligands present on the surfaces of normal erythrocytes. The significance of this observation is unknown, and the role of erythrocyte-bound C4 (E-C4) in human disease has not been explored. More than any other human disease, the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has been characterized by defects in clearance of complement-bearing immune complexes via erythrocytes expressing complement receptor 1 (CR1). This study was undertaken to determine whether these functional defects might be reflected by abnormal patterns of E-C4 and E-CR1 expression on erythrocytes of patients with SLE. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional study of 100 patients with SLE, 133 patients with other diseases, and 84 healthy controls. Erythrocytes were characterized by indirect immunofluorescence and by flow cytometry for determination of levels of C4d and CR1. RESULTS: Patients with SLE had higher levels of E-C4d and lower levels of E-CR1 than did patients with other diseases (P < or = 0.001) or healthy controls (P < or = 0.001). The test was 81% sensitive and 91% specific for SLE versus healthy controls and 72% sensitive and 79% specific for SLE versus other diseases, and it had an overall negative predictive value of 92%. CONCLUSION: This is the first report of abnormal levels of E-C4d in human disease. We found that abnormally high levels of E-C4d and low levels of E-CR1 are characteristic of SLE, and combined measurement of the 2 molecules has high diagnostic sensitivity and specificity for lupus. Determination of E-C4d/E-CR1 levels may be a useful addition to current tests and criteria for SLE diagnosis.

Sustained muscle expression of dystrophin from a high-capacity adenoviral vector with systemic gene transfer of T cell costimulatory blockade.

Adenoviral vector (Ad)-mediated gene delivery of normal, full-length dystrophin to skeletal muscle provides a promising strategy for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). However, cellular and humoral immune responses induced by vector gene transfer limit the application of this approach. Blockade of the costimulatory interaction between naïve T cells and antigen-presenting cells has proven to be a successful means to diminish immunity induced by gene transfer. In this study we explore the potential of supplementing dystrophin gene delivery to dystrophin-deficient Dmd mouse skeletal muscle with systemic gene delivery of CTLA4Ig and CD40Ig molecules to effect costimulatory blockade. We found that systemic administration of a high-capacity Ad (HC-Ad) vector carrying murine CTLA4Ig (AdmCTLA4Ig) either alone or codelivered with an HC-Ad vector carrying murine CD40Ig (AdmCD40Ig) provided sustained expression of recombinant full-length murine dystrophin from an HC-Ad vector carrying the dystrophin cDNA (AdmDys). The level of AdmDys vector genomes remained stable in animals cotreated with systemic delivery of vectors carrying molecules to block costimulation. In addition, muscle CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell infiltrates and Th1 cytokine production by splenocytes were reduced. The production of neutralizing antibody against Ad vector was significantly inhibited in mice receiving systemic codelivery of both AdmCTLA4Ig and AdmCD40Ig, but not in the mice treated with AdmCTLA4Ig alone. The results suggested that coblockade of both CD28/B7 and CD40L/CD40 costimulatory pathways is required for effective inhibition of the Ad vector-induced humoral immune response in Dmd mice, whereas blockade of CD28/B7 alone by murine CTLA4Ig would be sufficient for prolonged dystrophin expression in treated muscle.