Ancestry of beagles in lifespan studies of radionuclide toxicity at the University of Utah.

Analysis of the ancestry of the 1,262 lifespan beagles (LSB) entered into lifespan studies at the Radiobiology Division, University of Utah, beginning in 1952 and ending in 1980, indicated that about 97% of ancestor citations in the various pedigrees were of only 10 breeding animals (breeders) among breeders within the beagle colony. In turn, just 18 AKC-registered "champion" beagles from outside of this colony (founders) accounted for about 98% of all ancestor citations among founders for the LSB. We conclude from this study that the animals used in the lifespan radionuclide experiments can be considered to be somewhat genetically interrelated.

Americium in the beagle dog: biokinetic and dosimetric model.

A biokinetic model of the systemic distribution of americium in the beagle dog is presented. The model is based on a previous biokinetic model of plutonium. The data sets used for the development of the model were the measurements of excreted activity (urine and feces) and organ burdens (skeleton, liver, and other soft tissues) for different levels of initial injected activity. In developing the model, the compartmental structure of the skeleton of the plutonium model was adopted, and only the numerical values of parameters were adapted. The model well describes the fractions of americium in the skeleton, liver, and soft tissues and the total fraction excreted in urine and feces. The tuning of the liver clearance parameter provides a realistic description of the change in the partitioning between liver and skeleton for different injection levels. The most significant features of the biokinetics and dosimetry of americium and plutonium in beagles are compared. The total fractions of the clearance to the skeleton and the liver are roughly equal to the value for plutonium, but the partitioning of americium between these organs is reversed with respect to the partitioning of plutonium. 241Am doses to liver and skeleton are similar to 239Pu doses, owing to some counteracting factors. For the highest injection level, the liver mass is dependent on the time post injection. For the skeletal tissues, the dose to the cortical endosteum by far exceeds the dose to the trabecular endosteum and the red marrow. The model provides the basis for statistical survival analyses and risk estimates.

Search for a genetic link for mammary cancer in a beagle colony.

BACKGROUND: A possible genetic link for malignant mammary tumor (MMT) was investigated. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Records of an internally-irradiated beagle colony followed from the early 1950's until about 1995 were searched and analyzed by standard statistical procedures. RESULTS: Only a single ancestor yielded a "p" value (Fisher's Exact Test) for an overrepresentation among descendants with MMT at < 0.025 (one-sided test), and the number of comparisons for the 169 ancestors where the relative fraction of animals with MMT was greater than that for non MMT dogs (61) suggests that this could have occurred by chance alone. Results of other statistical tests were not remarkable. CONCLUSION: No genetic link for MMT in this colony could be established with the available data. These findings may or may not be relevant to humans.

Survival and bone tumor hazard from internal deposition of 226Ra in beagles.

The survival of 132 young adult control beagles and 117 beagles receiving graded injections of 226Ra ranging from 0.27 kBq kg-1 to 384.2 kBq kg-1 body mass was analyzed. The hazards of natural deaths, all deaths in injection groups, and deaths by bone tumors were assumed to follow a Weibull distribution with a common shape factor of 6.3. Only the scale factors of the Weibull distributions depend on the injection level. There were no significant sex differences. The relative risk with respect to controls for all causes of death increases up to 6,925 for 384.2 kBq kg-1. The dependence of the scale factors for all deaths and death by bone tumors on injected activity was fitted to an empirical regression model, which also contains a term representing radiation-caused deaths other than bone tumors. The risk of bone tumors increases nearly as the square of the injected activity, whereas the risk of the other radiation caused deaths increases approximately in proportion to the injected activity. By means of the regression model, it is possible to predict median survival times for all deaths, bone tumor and non-bone tumor deaths for an arbitrary intake level. Also, simple expressions for the fraction of animals with bone tumors and other radiation-caused deaths can be derived. The empirical model of bone tumor induction, which was based on results from a single injection design, can be generalized to an arbitrary systemic intake schema. This is achieved by using the average dose and dose rate to the skeleton as indices of detriment. Applying the generalized model, it was confirmed that no significant differences in survival can be expected for two groups of beagles receiving multiple injections, if compared to the corresponding single injection groups of about the same total activity. The general model also predicts that even extensive protraction of the intake would increase the survival times only to a very limited extent.

Biokinetic model of radium in humans and beagles.

A compartmental model of the distribution of radium in humans and young adult beagle dogs (approximately 500-550 d) is presented. The model consists of one soft tissue compartment and seven skeletal compartments for humans, and five skeletal compartments for beagles. The number of transfer parameters to be estimated was reduced by using remodeling rates of bone and imposing several constraints deduced from known features of bone physiology, radium metabolism, and autoradiographic analyses. The model predictions are in good agreement with measured retentions in plasma, whole body, skeleton, and soft tissues of both species. Moreover, for beagles even the retention in individual bones can be predicted quite well if the relevant morphometric parameters are known. While some of the estimated transfer parameters are similar in both species, others differ by an order of magnitude or more. Wherever possible, a comparison of model parameters with those of previous models is given. The new model not only is instrumental for calculating local doses in the skeleton but also can be used for characterizing the microdistribution of radium in this organ.

Review of 239Pu and 226Ra effects in beagles.

A long term biological study has been completed that was designed to assess the predicted effects in humans of internally deposited 239Pu by comparison with 226Ra in beagles. Herein we summarize for the first time results of several previous reports about the effects of these two radionuclides in our beagles in an attempt to elucidate what has been learned since the beginning of the study in the early 1950's. Perhaps the most important finding was that bone surface-seeking plutonium is more toxic at equal mean skeletal radiation doses (<3 Gy for 239Pu, <20 Gy for 226Ra) than bone volume-seeking radium for the induction of skeletal malignancy by about a factor of 16 for a single intravenous injection of monomeric 239Pu. In addition, ancillary studies have shown that when plutonium transfers continuously onto bone surfaces from a depot of particulate 239Pu in phagocytic cells, its relative toxicity per Gy average skeletal dose is enhanced by about a factor of 2. Juvenile animals or dogs injected as mature adults were only about half as sensitive for equal mean skeletal doses as dogs injected as young adults. Male and female dogs were about equally sensitive to radiation of the skeleton by either radionuclide. Findings about radiation-induced fractures are summarized as well as data on the induction of soft-tissue malignancies by 239Pu or 226Ra. Natural survival was not affected at the lower dosage levels of either 226Ra or 239Pu as compared with control dogs given no radioactivity, but the survival of animals at higher levels was reduced. No additional life-shortening effects beyond those attributable to occurrence of radiation-induced malignancies or other radiation-induced effects were suggested by analysis of data for low dosage levels.

Does longevity in beagles injected with bone-seeking radionuclides depend upon radiation dose in the absence of known radiation effects?

Regression analyses of longevity as a function of skeletal radiation dose among groups of beagles injected with 226Ra, 228Ra, 228Th, 241Am, 90Sr or monomeric 239Pu suggested that at low doses and dose-rates (those at which induced effects are low), age at death seems to be independent of dose when animals dying with specific radiation effects were excluded, although longevity does appear to be a function of dose when animals dying with established radiation effects and at all doses were included. We conclude tentatively that, for mammals receiving skeletal dose from bone-seeking radionuclides at low doses and low dose-rates, longevity may not be dependent upon skeletal radiation dose in the absence of radiation-induced malignancies or other radiation effects.

Effective thresholds for induction of skeletal malignancies by radionuclides.

Our analysis of data from the beagle project completed at the University of Utah has provided some comparisons that appear to be useful in testing the model proposed by Raabe of effective thresholds for induction of skeletal malignancy by bone-seeking radionuclides in beagles. Raabe's model predicted that cumulative skeletal doses of less than about 0.9 to 1.4 Gy from alpha emitters or 28 to 70 Gy from beta emitters deposited in the skeleton require a long enough time for bone cancer expression that the dog's natural lifespan would be exceeded before the tumor appeared. Results from the Utah beagle project seem to confirm these projections for 226Ra, 228Ra and, perhaps, for 90Sr. The lowest doses at which malignant bone tumors were observed in animals injected with these radium isotopes were about 0.9 Gy (226Ra) and 3 Gy (228Ra). For the beta emitter, 90Sr, the lowest doses at which bone tumors were seen were about 18, 50, and 70 Gy with an expectation for naturally occurring tumor of about one. Twenty-six of the two hundred and thirty-three Utah beagles given monomeric 239Pu that developed skeletal malignancies had doses between 0.02 and 0.51 Gy (80 of these dogs had skeletal doses of less than 0.9 Gy). Three dogs of 54 given 241Am with doses lower than 0.9 Gy had bone tumors at 0.23, 0.56, and 0.88 Gy with the expectation of about one naturally occurring case. For 25 animals injected with 228Th at skeletal doses below 0.9 Gy, one bone tumor dog had a dose of about 0.4 Gy, and the expectation of a dog with natural tumor among the group was only about 0.38. Five beagles of 74 given 224Ra with resulting doses of less than 0.9 Gy died with skeletal malignancy at 0.32 Gy or less with an expectation for non 224Ra induced tumor of about one. It appears that Raabe's proposal might be confirmed for some but not all of the radionuclides used in the Utah studies. Models presented in earlier papers by Raabe provide results that are somewhat different from his recent abstract and compare more favorably with those cited herein for Utah dogs. Re-examination of our data for these analyses has suggested a novel concept for calculation of carcinogenic dose to endosteal bone surfaces.

Radium-induced eye melanomas in dogs.

The intraocular radiotoxicity of intravenously injected 226Ra and 228Ra was studied in beagle dogs. Approximately 0.071% of injected radium was retained in each eye of beagles following intravenous administration. The retention was principally in the tapetum and the intraocular pigmented structures where significant pigmentary lesions were produced. These included melanotic plaques on the iris, melanosis of the ciliary body, varying degrees of tapetal degeneration, and intraocular melanomas. The tumors occurred principally in the ciliary body and to a much lesser extent in the iris. They appeared to arise from the pigment epithelium layer of the ciliary body. Thus, unlike melanomas arising in other sites, they are apparently not of neural crest origin. In addition to bone cancer, they represent another radium-induced neoplasm in beagles. Radium-induced intraocular melanomas have not been reported in people.

Does body size contribute to sensitivity of bone tumor induction by radionuclide exposure?

Investigation of a possible increase in sensitivity to occurrence of radionuclide-induced skeletal malignancy with increasing body size was analyzed among 358 beagles injected as young adults with either 226Ra or monomeric 239Pu and maintained for their lifespans. Corresponding analyses were performed for about 240 other beagles injected as young adults with 90Sr, 228Ra, or 228Th. Body masses at the time of injection ranged between about 5.6 and 16 kg. Logistic regression analysis using body mass and cumulative skeletal radiation dose as the independent variables indicated that there could not be established a dependency of tumor occurrence upon body mass, although skeletal dose was found to be significantly correlated with occurrence of bone cancer. Regression analysis indicated that for any dosage group there could not be established a correlation between body mass and skeletal dose. Each dosage group having similar injected kBq kg(-1) for each nuclide was divided into 2 subgroups of equal size, one containing the less massive dogs and the other containing the more massive dogs. These subgroups within a roughly uniform value of skeletal dose-rate were compared by Fisher's Exact Test, and the less massive subgroups were combined within each nuclide for an additional, separate analysis against the combined more massive subgroups using the same method. In only one instance (the dosage group given 3607 kBq 90Sr kg(-1)) was there indicated a substantially greater tumor occurrence among dogs in the more massive subgroup (p = 0.061). However, for the group given 0.382 kBq 239Pu kg(-1) there was indicated a significant difference between subgroups, but the effect was exactly opposite to that found for the highest level 90Sr dogs in that the less massive subgroup had a higher relative tumor occurrence than the most massive (p = 0.042). For all groups with a p-value < 0.10, a possible correlation was investigated between survival and body mass at injection (since bone tumor occurrence might be a function of longevity), but a significant relationship could not be determined. No significant differences could be established between the combined more massive and the combined less massive subgroups for any radionuclide. We conclude that, for the conditions in our experiment, relative size within a species does not contribute importantly to the sensitivity (lifetime occurrence) for induction of skeletal malignancy.

Fracture occurrence from radionuclides in the skeleton.

Because skeletal fractures were an important finding among persons contaminated with 226Ra, experience with fractures among dogs in our colony was summarized to determine the projected significance for persons contaminated with bone-seeking radionuclides. Comparison by Fisher's Exact Test of lifetime fracture occurrence in the skeletons of beagles injected as young adults suggested that for animals given 226Ra, 228Ra, 228Th, or 239Pu citrate, there was probably an excess over controls in fractures of the ribs, leg bones, spinous processes, and pelvis (os coxae) plus the mandible for dogs given 226Ra and the scapulae for dogs given 228Ra or 228Th. Regression analysis indicated that significantly elevated fracture occurrence was especially notable at the higher radiation doses, at about 50 Gy average skeletal dose for 239Pu, 140 Gy for 226Ra, about 40 Gy for 228Ra, and more than 15 Gy for 228Th. The average number of fractures per dog was significantly elevated over that noted in controls for the highest radiation doses of 239Pu and 226Ra and for the higher doses of 228Ra and 228Th. For those dogs given 90Sr citrate, there was virtually no important difference from control beagles not given radionuclides, even at group mean cumulative skeletal radiation doses up to 101 Gy. Because of a large proportion of dogs with fractures that died with bone malignancy (even at dosage levels lower than those exhibiting an excess average number of fractures per dog), we conclude that fracture would not be an important endpoint at lower levels of plutonium contamination in humans such as would be expected to occur from occupational or environmental exposure.

Biokinetic and dosimetric model of plutonium in the dog.

A biokinetic model of the systemic distribution and dosimetry of 239Pu in the beagle dog is presented. To achieve maximum consistency with experimental data, known histomorphometric parameters and results of autoradiographic studies were adopted directly. The remaining parameters were determined from retention and excretion measurements by optimization procedures. The beagle model attempts to parallel the human model as much as possible, but only one liver compartment and one compartment representing other soft tissues were needed to describe the data adequately. The salient features and differences of the biokinetic behavior of 239Pu beagles and humans are compared. Generally the organ retention of the beagle in relation to the lifetime is longer than in humans. This is particularly pronounced in the skeleton. Trabecular deposits of plutonium are gradually shifted to cortical sites. For the dosimetric model some additional features disregarded in the human model were employed. These relate to bone volume labels, a gradation of concentrations in marrow, the energy-dependence of absorbed fractions, and the self-absorption in marrow. The model predicts that the contribution of surface deposits to the endosteal dose still exceeds the contributions from bone volume and marrow labels. The average endosteal dose is about eight times and the marrow dose about two times larger than the average skeletal dose. The model provides the basis for the analysis of survival and relative risks.

Some problems in the skeletal dosimetry of bone-seeking radionuclides.

There are fundamental problems with the calculation of radiation doses to the skeleton from internal emitters deposited in bone. Some of these include dose inhomogeneities, identity of cells at risk and their dynamics, changing deposition patterns of bone-seeking radionuclides with time after exposure, seemingly unique responses of the skeleton to each deposited radionuclide, the role of radioactive progeny produced by deposited emitters and their individual dynamics and effects, different responses of mammals of different ages at exposure to identical dosages, different responses to different chemical forms of a given radionuclide, and different responses to an identical dose from a given radionuclide at different dose-rates. This situation makes it necessary to choose some common dose parameter that will allow the overall effects of different radionuclides to be compared directly so that projected effects of each of them in humans can be estimated. For radiation protection purposes, it appears premature to abandon the concept of average skeletal dose (which appears to be a practical compromise for use) until an undelusive, non-artificial and uncontrived method of calculating absorbed dose to the appropriate cells in bone is developed that fulfills the requirement of equal cancer response for equal skeletal dose for all circumstances.

Relative radiosensitivity of bone tumor induction among beagles as a function of age at injection of 239Pu or 226Ra.

A comparison was made of the response to induction of skeletal malignancy from exposure of beagles to monomeric 239Pu or to 226Ra as juveniles (3 mo of age), young adults (1.5 y of age), or mature adults (5 y of age). This indicated that of these age groups, animals injected as young adults are most sensitive per Gy of average skeletal dose evaluated at 1 y before death. Dogs exposed either as juveniles or as mature adults appeared to be less sensitive. Relative radiosensitivities (RRS) of juvenile and mature beagles ranged between about 0.3 and 0.7 that of dogs injected as young adults. Mean values of RRS for both radionuclides were about 0.5, but RRS values derived from dogs given monomeric 239Pu appeared to be most reliable and were 0.27+/-0.09 for dogs injected as juveniles and 0.41+/-0.13 for animals exposed as mature adults.

Is there a difference in radionuclide-induced bone tumor sensitivity between male and female beagles?

An analysis of bone tumor occurrences among male and female beagles given monomeric 239Pu or 226Ra was not able to establish a difference in sensitivity to induction of bone malignancy by radium or plutonium exposure. This is in contrast to the situation reported for mice. Female mice are substantially more sensitive to 239Pu irradiation than males, but this difference is obliterated by gonadectomy, females becoming less sensitive and males becoming more sensitive. Although there may be some nonuniformity between human males and females for radiation-induced bone sarcoma occurrence, analysis of data sets containing both men and women exposed to 224Ra, 226Ra, 228Ra, or 226+228Ra appears not to reveal substantial differences in sensitivity by gender, a situation similar to that reported herein for beagles.

241Am removal by DTPA vs. occurrence of skeletal malignancy.

Beagle dogs injected with 241Am and treated subsequently with DTPA exhibited a reduced occurrence of skeletal malignancies and increased lifespans when compared to corresponding untreated animals also given 241Am. Whereas 92% of dogs given about 11 kBq 241Am kg(-1) and not treated with DTPA developed bone cancer (skeletal dose about 5.9 Gy), skeletal malignancy was seen in only 40% and 27%, respectively, among two groups of DTPA-treated animals injected with 11 kBq kg(-1) (doses of 5.7 and 1.7 Gy). The median lifespan among the untreated dogs was 1,728 d, but the median lifespans in the DTPA-treated groups were 2,478 and 3,654 d, respectively. Untreated dogs with a skeletal dose averaging about 2 Gy had 53% bone cancer occurrence and a median lifespan of 3,227 d. These data did not enable us to address the question of whether the reduction in cancer occurrence was proportional to, greater than, or less than the reduction in skeletal dose, but the third possibility seems unlikely.

Does age of the host affect growth rates of skeletal malignancies?

Statistical analysis of bone tumor growth rates as a function of age at initiation of radiation-induced skeletal malignancies in our animal colony indicated that the p value for an association between these parameters was <0.05, suggesting a correlation in beagle dogs. The youngest animals appeared to exhibit the most slowly growing tumors, and the trend was toward more rapidly growing tumors with increasing age. Less effective immune systems in older animals were invoked as a possible explanation of this relationship.

Microdistribution of 239Pu in the beagle skeleton.

The microdistribution of 239Pu was analyzed in the humerus, lumbar vertebra, and proximal ulna of young adult beagles using neutron induced autoradiography. The animals were sacrificed serially in groups of three at 4, 8, 16, 32, and 64 wk after a single injection of 3.5 kBq kg(-1) body weight. The kinetic behavior of surface concentrations was modeled using a simple concept of deposition and clearance in skeletal regions. Bones with high turnover showed a larger initial uptake and a faster clearance than bones with low turnover rates. Using a regression procedure, the surface deposition and clearance of plutonium was calculated as a function of the turnover rate. With time after injection the initial nonuniformity of trabecular surface labels tends to become more uniform. The trabecular:cortical affinity ratio is about 10. Trabecular activity is gradually translocated to cortical sites. The affinity ratio of forming to resting surfaces is about three. In some bones a continuous increase of marrow stars was observed, whereas in other bones no clear-cut tendency could be seen. The highest level of marrow labeling occurred in the lumbar vertebra and the humerus shaft.

Relationship of natural incidence and radiosensitivity for bone cancer in dogs.

A comparison of the risk coefficients for 239Pu- or 226Ra-induced bone cancer in two canine breeds, one with a relatively low (beagle) and the other with a very high (St. Bernard) natural incidence, indicated only slightly higher risk in the giant breed. The differences in risk for skeletal malignancy in 239Pu and 226Ra dogs were nonsignificant (p > 0.05). Likewise, the values of the 239Pu:226Ra "toxicity ratios" for these respective breeds, using bone cancer as the endpoint, were not significantly different at the 0.05 level. The anatomical distribution of the radiation-induced bone tumors tended to be a function of both the bone mass and the skeletal distribution of the radionuclide, not the site of predilection for naturally occurring bone neoplasia. Although the etiology of the higher natural incidence of bone cancer in the St. Bernard was not determined, several possible factors, including a higher osteoblastic activity level in the St. Bernards, are presented. These data suggest that making extrapolations of radiation-induced bone cancer risk from animals to humans is valid.