Prolonged inappropriate TSH suppression during hypothyroidism after thyroid ablation in a patient with nonautoimmune familial hyperthyroidism.

Prolonged TSH suppression was reported in a patient with nonautoimmune hyperthyroidism. These observations were made during L-thyroxine treatment and it was not possible to investigate a possible increase in serum TSH concentrations to levels observed in untreated hypothyroidism. We describe nonautoimmune familial hyperthyroidism identified in an Israeli woman, which is remarkable for the prolonged inappropriate TSH suppression after thyroid ablation. After 2 radioiodine treatments for several years, her TSH was always lower than 0.03 mU/l with 1.6 µg/kg/day (100 µg) thyroxine. 14 years after the radioiodine treatments, she discontinued thyroxine for 3.5 months and developed myxoedema with fT4 <6.0 and fT3 1.3 pmol/l and TSH of only 4.4 mU/l, which rose to only 8.6 after TRH. Genomic analysis showed a germline substitution M626I in the TSHR gene. Both exons of the thyroid-releasing hormone receptor revealed no mutations in this gene. Functional in vitro characterization of M626I showed a cell surface expression of 70% compared with the wt (100%), a significant increase of basal activity (5-fold over wt basal), which was confirmed by linear regression analysis (LRA) (slope: M626I=7, wt=1). No TRH-receptor mutation was detected. Therefore, this is the first patient with nonautoimmune hyperthyroidism with unequivocal evidence for inappropriately prolonged TSH suppression documented by a clearly insufficient TSH increase during clinical hypothyroidism. The in vitro characterization of the TSH-receptor mutation did not show any explanations for the prolonged TSH suppression. Therefore, other possible candidate genes remain to be investigated for potential explanations for this prolonged TSH suppression.

Lack of consistent association of thyrotropin receptor mutations in vitro activity with the clinical course of patients with sporadic non-autoimmune hyperthyroidism.

BACKGROUND: Up to date, 14 patients with sporadic non-autoimmune hyperthyroidism (SNAH) caused by sporadic germline mutations in the TSH receptor (TSHR) gene have been reported. Despite considerable differences in the activity of hyperthyroidism, all SNAH case reports concluded that the demonstrated constitutive activity explains the phenotype. AIM: Recently, linear regression analysis (LRA) of constitutive activity as a function of TSHR expression determined by 125I-bTSH binding or fluorescence activated cell sorting analysis was described as a more reliable way of characterizing the in vitro activity (IVA) of a constitutively activating TSHR mutation. Therefore, we analyzed a possible genotype-phenotype correlation in a systematic review of the case reports and investigated the TSHR mutation's LRA in selected cases. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We determined the LRA for all sporadic germline mutations which had not previously been reported. Moreover, we systematically evaluated all case reports of SNAH for evidence of an association of the clinical course (CC) with the IVA of the mutated TSHR. RESULTS: The LRA determined were: M453T (5.2+/-0.8), L512Q (4.5+/-0.7), I568T (25.6+/-6.3), F631L (45.9+/-9.4), T632I (14.5+/-2.7), D633Y (16.4+/-6.4). None of the 10 examined clinical signs showed a significant association with the LRA. Moreover, the comparison of the CC of patients harboring the same mutation (S281N, M453T, I568T, S505N) also showed no relation of the clinical activity with a high LRA. CONCLUSION: Considering the different diagnostic circumstances, therapeutic strategies and the limitations of a systematic analysis of case reports due to the restricted number of case reports and limited follow-up we found no consistent relation of the TSHR mutation's IVA determined by LRA with the CC of patients with SNAH. This may also be due to the action of genetic, epigenetic, and environmental modifiers.