Efficacy of dental prophylaxis (rubber cup) for the prevention of caries and gingivitis: a systematic review of literature.

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this systematic review was to assess the efficacy of routine dental prophylaxis applied before professionally applied topical fluoride (PATF) or at a regular recall visit in the prevention of caries or gingivitis. TYPES OF STUDIES REVIEWED: Ovid MEDLINE and its allied versions; CINAHL; Cochrane Library; EMBASE; Health and Psychosocial Instruments; HealthSTAR; International Pharmaceutical Abstracts; and ACP Journal Club were searched for English and Human articles from 1966 to 2007 for original in vivo English publications assessing rubber cup dental prophylaxis. In vitro studies, case series, case reports or letters to editors (not containing primary data), editorials, review articles and commentaries were excluded but were read to identify any potential studies. RESULTS: One hundred and eighty-nine articles were searched for relevancy resulting in six original studies that met our inclusion criteria. There was a unanimous agreement in four studies that a dental prophylaxis is not warranted before a PATF for caries prevention in children. A generalisation on dental prophylaxis before PATF cannot be applied to adolescents and adults. Available evidence (two other studies) fails to demonstrate any benefit in the prevention of gingivitis from further dental prophylaxis at interval used for recall examinations. CLINICAL IMPLICATION: To prevent caries in children, dental prophylaxis need not be provided either at a recall visit or before PATF. Dental prophylaxis at intervals of four months or more is not justified for the prevention of gingivitis in the general population.

Toothbrushing competency among high-risk grade one students: an evaluation of two methods of dental health education.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effectiveness of two methods of dental health education (DHE) for improving toothbrushing competency among grade one students at high risk for dental diseases. METHODS: Fifty elementary schools in the former city of North York, Ontario, Canada, were assigned to one of two groups. In one group, students received a classroom-based DHE lesson that was reinforced by two small group sessions (n = 243). In the other group, students received only a single classroom-based DHE lesson (n = 206). Trained examiners assessed 11 toothbrushing skills at pre- and postintervention. RESULTS: At the preintervention test, few significant differences were found between the groups and many students did not display competency in fundamental oral health skills, such as placing a toothbrush at the gum line. Following DHE interventions, students in both groups demonstrated improvements in most skills. A significantly higher proportion of students who received both classroom and small group sessions displayed gains in competency in three skills, compared to students receiving only a classroom lesson. These skills were brushing anterior lingual surfaces, brushing posterior lingual surfaces, and brushing all areas in a routine fashion. Students receiving only a classroom session did not display greater improvements in any skill areas compared to "classroom plus small group" students. Some students in both groups still lacked fundamental skills at the end of the DHE program. CONCLUSIONS: While one must exercise caution in interpreting the results due to several methodologic limitations, findings suggest that for high-risk grade one students, a classroom-based lesson combined with small group sessions is a more effective method of improving toothbrushing skills compared to a single classroom-based lesson.

Oral hygiene knowledge of high-risk Grade One children: an evaluation of two methods of dental health education.

The effectiveness of two methods of dental health education (DHE) for improving oral hygiene knowledge among high-risk Grade One students was evaluated. Fifty elementary schools in the former City of North York, Canada were assigned to one of two groups. In one group, students received a classroom-based DHE lesson which was reinforced by two small-group sessions (n=243). In the other group, students received only a single classroom-based DHE lesson (n=206). After DHE interventions, students in both groups displayed improved knowledge for most oral hygiene questions (e.g., when should you throw your toothbrush away?). However, for several questions, a significantly higher proportion of "classroom plus small-group sessions" students displayed improved knowledge compared to students receiving only a classroom lesson. These items included: awareness that cavity prevention and removal of germs are two purposes of oral hygiene; and knowledge that teeth help people to eat and talk. Results suggest a classroom-based lesson combined with small-group sessions is a more effective method of improving oral hygiene knowledge among high-risk Grade One students compared to a single classroom-based lesson.

A system of diagnostic codes for dental health care.

OBJECTIVES: We set out to develop and implement a system of diagnostic codes for use in the computerized management information system of the Community Dental Services of the North York Public Health Department. METHODS: We received staff input on common diagnoses, reviewed other diagnostic systems and established criteria for an ideal coding system. The codes are consistent with the format of other classification systems used in dental management information in Canada. They were implemented in 1997-98. RESULTS: We developed a system of four-digit, numeric codes for dental diagnoses. The diagnostic codes are specific at the level of the patient, consistent with current evidence on the natural history and classification of diseases, consistent with conventional measures of oral conditions, and fit the paradigm of the Canadian system of treatment codes. In the first year, 91 percent of 6,740 patients had at least one diagnosis, with a mean of 2.5 per patient. The five most common diagnoses were smooth surface caries, pit and fissure caries, calculus, teeth with deep fissures, and gingivitis. CONCLUSIONS: We have developed a coding system for dental diagnoses that has achieved high use and provided more accessible information on the conditions seen by staff dentists.

Reducing variability in treatment decision-making: effectiveness of educating clinicians about uncertainty.

The objective of this study was to investigate whether or not education about the concept of uncertainty reduced variability in treatment decision-making. Three small groups of dentists in North York, Canada were asked to make restorative treatment decisions about simulated bitewing radiographs. They subsequently took part in a seminar about variations in perception and judgement and were given explanations of sensitivity, specificity and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. A repeat reading of the radiographs was then performed by both test and control groups. Results indicated that the intervention increased the accuracy, and decreased the variability of dentists' restorative treatment decisions. Kappa statistics were 0.33, 0.34 and 0.31 before the seminar, and 0.40, 0.43 and 0.41 after the seminar. Standard errors for kappas were 0.06, 0.05 and 0.05 before the seminar, and 0.02, 0.02 and 0.05 after the seminar. The area under the ROC curve was 0.7136 before the seminar and 0.7835 after the seminar. The data demonstrate that the dentists' decisions were less variable and more accurate following the educative intervention. This study suggests that there is potential for improving consistency and accuracy in clinical decision-making through education in probabilistic reasoning.

Oral health status and treatment needs of Canadian adults aged 85 years and over.

In an oral health survey, 1375 adults aged 85 and older were examined in North York, Canada. Only 31% of dentate nursing home residents and 47% of dentate independently living subjects had received dental care in the year previous to examination. The overall prevalence of edentulism was 66%, and about 80% of subjects wore at least one denture. Of the dentate subjects, over 60% had untreated decay, and 47% of nursing home residents had untreated root decay. Regarding clinically defined treatment needs, high levels of unmet need were identified in subjects from both types of residences. Among nursing home residents, about 45% of dentate subjects required tooth extraction, and 56% required prosthodontic treatment. Although only 27% of dentate independently living residents required tooth extraction, over 60% needed restorative treatment. Higher prevalence of both untreated decay and unmet treatment needs was associated with lower utilization of dental care for dentate subjects. For edentulous subjects, prosthetic treatment was required by 70% of nursing home residents and by 51% of independently living subjects. These results indicate that, for both nursing home and independently living residents, dental diseases and treatment needs continue through out the lifespan.

A survey of general dentists in Ontario, Part II: Knowledge and use of topical fluoride and dental prophylaxis practices.

A mail questionnaire was used to assess variations in the knowledge and practices of Ontario dentists with respect to topical fluoride and prophylaxis procedures. The questionnaire was answered by 1,276 general dentists. A high percentage (72 to 83 per cent) of respondents identified six months as the optimal time interval at which both procedures should be repeated for all patients under 19 years of age. Relatively few dentists (< 10 per cent) indicated that there should be no specific time interval for re-treatment (i.e. that it should be individually selected). The respondents' preventive knowledge was found to be deficient in two areas: few dentists (16 per cent) knew that it is not necessary to provide a prophylaxis prior to topical fluoride application to achieve maximum caries protection; and most dentists overestimated the speed of caries progress from outer enamel to the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ) in both primary (83 per cent) and permanent (82 per cent) approximal tooth surfaces. In bivariate analysis, three variables were found to be consistently and significantly related to optimal time intervals selected for both topical fluoride application and prophylaxis procedures: year of graduation from dental school; level of hygienist employment; and percentage of patients with private insurance. Multivariate analysis also identified three significant variables: year of graduation from dental school; level of dental hygienist employment; and practice business. Continuing education courses are suggested as a means of updating dentists' knowledge regarding preventive services. Studies are needed to determine the extent to which recent recommendations regarding the professional application of topical fluorides have been followed.

A survey of general dentists in Ontario, Part I: Sealant use and knowledge.

This study assessed the use of pit and fissure sealants by Ontario dentists, as well as variations in the knowledge and practices of this population with respect to certain aspects of the preventive technique. A mail questionnaire on dental practices and knowledge was answered by 1,276 general dentists in Ontario. Most dentists (90 per cent) provided sealants to their patients, and reported using sealants on an average of 45 per cent of their patients between the ages of six and 16 years. While most dentists knew that sealants have been proven effective in preventing caries (90 per cent), many incorrectly believed that sealants are cost-effective to apply to both primary molars and permanent premolars (40 per cent and 68 per cent respectively). Bivariate analyses showed that many of the reported characteristics are statistically significant. The variables that were consistently associated with sealant use include: knowledge of the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of sealants; year of graduation from dental school; level of dental hygienist employment; and continuing education participation. Although multivariate analyses identified many of these variables as statistically significant, only a moderate amount of the variation in sealant use for patients aged six to 16 was explained (R2 = 0.22). Due to misinformation about the cost-effectiveness of sealants, some dentists may overuse them in certain instances. Conversely, misinformation about the effectiveness of sealants and the risk of further decay after sealant placement has resulted in some dentists under-utilizing them. Continuing education courses are needed to update dentists' knowledge and beliefs regarding dental sealants. In addition, dentistry's professional bodies should develop clinical practice guidelines to aid dentists in their treatment planning decisions.

Developing evidence-based programme guidelines for children's dental care in a dental public health unit in Ontario, Canada.

The North York Public Health Department operates a school-based dental care programme. Dental care providers are expected to follow guidelines in order that the programme shall achieve the best outcomes for the clients served. A model is described by which published evidence informs the guideline development process. The process is considered to require knowledge of the epidemiology of dental disease in the target population; skills in collecting, critically appraising and summarising the scientific literature; working with internal and external advisory panels to write the guidelines; disseminating results and assessing both compliance and health outcomes. This work is one example of a larger trend to evidence-based health care.

The normative need for tooth extractions in older adults in Ontario, Canada.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the reasons for clinically defined need for tooth extractions were examined. DESIGN: Descriptive survey; interview and clinical data. SETTING: The City of North York, Canada. SUBJECTS: 1,531 dentate adults aged 65 and over, 69% being nursing home residents. MEASUREMENTS: Age, sex, type of residence and dental attendance pattern. OUTCOME MEASURE: Normative need for tooth extraction. RESULTS: One or more extractions were required by 38% of nursing home residents and 21% of independently-living subjects. The mean number of teeth indicated for extraction were 1.4 and 0.6, respectively. Among nursing home residents, caries was more often the reason for extraction for almost all tooth types, but for independently-living subjects periodontal reasons were more common. Overall, a significantly higher proportion of nursing home residents needed extractions due to both caries and periodontal reasons (25% and 16%) compared to subjects who lived independently (10% and 11%). For nursing home residents in all age groups, more subjects required caries-related extractions, but for independently-living subjects about equal proportions required extractions due to caries and periodontal diseases. Although the percentage of subjects requiring extraction due to caries varied significantly by age and residence type, the percentage needing extractions due to periodontal diseases showed slight variation and remained under 20%. CONCLUSION: This study indicates that among high risk groups of older adults caries continues to be the major reason for tooth extraction. However, problems with sampling limit the external validity of these results.

Oral health and family characteristics of children attending private or public dental clinics.

The City of North York Public Health Department (NYPHD) operates a school-based dental programme that provides preventive and treatment services to children according to evidence-based practice guidelines. This programme and private dental practices (PDP) represent the only sources of dental care for children in North York. The purpose of our study was to compare the oral health and family characteristics of clients from the NYPHD and PDP using a dental examination and a parent interview. Results showed that NYPHD and PDP clients had similar levels of fluorosis, calculus, and periodontal health, but NYPHD clients had experienced greater levels of decay. Clients of the NYPHD and PDP also had significantly different family characteristics, many of which were significantly associated with the presence of one or more decayed primary or permanent teeth. Multivariate logistic regression identified mother's immigration history, past caries experience, and parents' rationale for scheduling their child's dental appointments as the principle risk makers for dental decay. When compared with PDP clients, the NYPHD serves higher-needs children who otherwise might not receive care.

Report on the RCDS-CDHSRU workshop on developing clinical guidelines/standards of practice.

Investigators from the Community Dental Health Services Research Unit (CDHSRU) held a workshop to test a model for developing clinical guidelines/standards of practice, which are required under the Regulated Health Professions Legislation. Forty-two individuals from Ontario and Canada, including dentists, representatives of the public, and professionals, participated in the three-day workshop, held under the auspices of the quality assurance committee of the Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario (RCDS). Through direct experience, workshop participants sought to learn each of the steps, as defined by the literature, involved in clinical guideline development. Ultimately, they hoped to recommend steps for RCDS to follow in developing standards of practice. To ensure that a realistic and valid model emerged from the workshop, a real topic, namely the management of smooth surface enamel lesions in permanent teeth, was used to develop and test clinical guidelines. Prior to the workshop, participants were sent literature on one of five aspects of the topic, as well as papers describing the methodology of critically appraising the literature, and partially-completed templates outlining the basic steps to be followed. During the first evening and first morning of the workshop, participants listened to presentations on the development of clinical guidelines, the prevalence of smooth surface lesions, the role of economics in guideline development, and the necessary considerations in writing clinical guidelines. Under the leadership of trained facilitators, they then worked in small groups to write evidence-based recommendations and report them to the other workshop participants for feedback. Using this feedback, they returned to their groups to revise their recommendations and work on the workshop's overall recommendations to the RCDS. The day concluded in the evening, when the workshop facilitators and coordinators met to edit the groups' recommendations into a consistent format for presentation to all participants. On the second morning, the participants attended a plenary session to review the evidence-based recommendations developed by the groups, as well as their overall recommendations on the steps to be followed by the RCDS. Ultimately, workshop participants partially completed the templates and developed preliminary evidence-based recommendations on the management of enamel smooth-surface caries. Based on their experiences, they recommended a seven-step process for the future development of clinical practice guidelines/standards of practice in Ontario. These steps are recommendations only, and are not RCDS policy.

Dentists' variability in restorative decisions, microscopic and radiographic caries depth.

Restorative and dental caries depth decisions were recorded for 5168 un restored approximal tooth surfaces by 17 dentists who worked in the school dental clinics of the North York (Ontario) Public Health Department. Each dentist examined 15 pairs of experimental bitewing radiographs for which true caries depth had previously been determined by microscopy of the sectioned teeth following production of the radiographs. The dentists independently recorded their restorative decisions and radiographic caries depth perceptions. The relationship between the variation in the dentists' restorative decisions and their perceptions of caries depth based on a re-reading of the bitewings on the one hand, and true caries depth on the other was also examined. The percentages of total variability in each dentist's restorative decisions attributable to radiographic and to microscopic caries depth were estimated using regression analyses. Large variations were found among the 17 dentists' distributions of overall restorative and depth decisions. The relationship between microscopic caries depth and the dentists' restorative decisions was, understandably, less strong than that of the dentists radiographic perceptions of caries depth and restorative decisions. Relative to true caries depth, high numbers of false positive and false negative restorative decisions were made. Overall, 50% of the variability in the dentists' restorative decisions was explained by the perceptions of radiographic caries depth; however, among individual dentists, the range was from 29% for one dentist to 69% for another. A much lower percentage of the overall restorative variation was explained by microscopic depth, 18%. Like the finding of the only two previous European studies that quantified the role of radiographs on clinical decisions, this study demonstrated that dentists' perceptions of dental caries depth using bitewing radiographs play a major but variable role in their restorative decisions for approximal tooth surfaces.

Ontario dentists' knowledge and beliefs about selected aspects of diagnosis, prevention and restorative dentistry.

Based on the responses of 1,276 general dental practitioners in Ontario to a mail questionnaire, variations in certain aspects of the dentists' diagnostic, preventive and restorative knowledge and beliefs are examined. Despite recent practice recommendations and guidelines indicating that patient need and service selectivity, rather than traditional, routine prescriptions, should be the guiding principle of practice, many dentists seem to follow tradition in defining optimal intervals for dental examinations and prophylaxes, bitewing radiographs and topical fluoride applications. Although the respondents' knowledge and beliefs were correct and consistent with current evidence in many areas, some large deficiencies were identified. These include: a lack of awareness that professional prophylaxis prior to topical fluoride application is usually unnecessary and that sealant applications to certain teeth are not cost-effective; an over-estimation of the speed at which dental caries progress through the enamel; and, despite good knowledge about the opportunities for the remineralization of enamel lesions with fluorides, a tendency to restore enamel caries. In some instances, practitioner beliefs were shown to influence practice. For example, dentists who knew about the slow progression of approximal surface caries also reported more often that bitewing intervals should be longer, and that the placement of a restoration should be delayed until the caries penetrates the dentin. Similarly, correct knowledge about sealant effectiveness was positively associated with high sealant use. If dentists are to be expected to understand and follow emerging diagnostic, preventive and restorative practice recommendations and guidelines, continuing education is required to correct and update some of their knowledge and beliefs, as displayed in the responses to this questionnaire.

Dentists' stated restorative treatment thresholds and their restorative and caries depth decisions.

OBJECTIVE: This study examines the relationships between stated restorative treatment thresholds of 16 dentists and both their restorative decisions and caries depth determinations for approximal tooth surfaces based on bitewing radiographs. METHODS: Sixteen dentists independently examined 15 pairs of experimental bitewing radiographs. They separately recorded restorative and dental caries depth decisions for 4,864 unrestored approximal tooth surfaces, 304 identical surfaces per dentist. In addition to caries depth and restorative decision data, these dentists provided their restorative thresholds using a five-point scale. RESULTS: Three dentists stated it would be appropriate to restore enamel lesions, nine would wait until caries had reached the dentinoenamel junction, and four would wait until caries extended into the dentine. Although dentists stating an enamel restorative threshold intended definitely or probably to restore relatively more surfaces and recorded relatively more surfaces with dentinal caries, ANOVA analyses revealed that the differences among the restorative and the depth means according to the restorative thresholds were not significant. Considerable variation existed in both the restorative and depth decisions among the dentists in each threshold group. CONCLUSION: Although interesting trends occurred in the restorative and depth decisions relative to the stated thresholds, this study suggests, like others in Europe, that these thresholds cannot be taken at face value to explain restorative decisions.

Estimation of procedure times in a publicly funded dental programme.

For the purposes of planning and evaluation, knowing the time-costs associated with each dental procedure carried out in a publicly funded dental programme is very helpful. This knowledge, along with the expected or known benefits, also allows researchers to assess the efficacy of a dental procedure. However, only a few estimates of dental procedure times exist in the literature, and most of these focus on restorative treatments. The North York Public Health Department operates a school-based public dental programme, where each dental procedure carried out by a dentist or hygienist is entered into a dental management information system database, along with the date of the procedure and the hours worked by the provider on that date. Using these data and multiple regression analyses it was possible to estimate the average time required to carry out the most common procedures in North York's dental programme. These estimates were found to be similar to estimates published in the dental literature and very similar to estimates of the Ontario Dental Association. Thus, this method of calculating procedure times appears valid and may be very useful to managers of public dental programmes and public dental health researchers.