How many organs should one patient receive? The ethics of transplantation in the medical school.

BACKGROUND: Interest in the humanities in the medical school is growing; while several medical schools, mainly of Anglo-Saxon background, have developed dedicated courses, the experience in Italy is limited. METHODS: Since the academic year 2000 to 2001, a discussion of ethical problems was implemented in the nephrology course (fourth year of the Medical School of Torino, Italy; overall 6 years). In 2002 to 2003, a case entitled "Retransplantation of Multiple Organs (Prog Transplant 2002)" was discussed in 2 hours of small-group tutorial teaching: a boy received a renal graft at age 5, failed at age 7 due to recurrent glomerulonephritis, required a heart-kidney graft at age 11, and a second heart-kidney graft at 17. Student opinions were gathered by anonymous semistructured questionnaires at the beginning of the lessons as a basis for discussion. RESULTS: Following the lessons all students returned the questionnaires (n = 104). In the absence of competition for allocation, retransplantation was approved by 76.2%, unacceptable for 1% (22.9% uncertain-blank). With a waiting list of 10 patients, the opinions changed: 32.4% approved transplantation, 6.7% didn't approve it, 60.9% were uncertain. A theoretical categorization into deontological or utilitaristic approaches favored the first (41.9% vs 26.7%), with a high prevalence of blank-uncertain (31.5%); 21.9% of the students would change their opinion was that study head of the Transplant Department. CONCLUSION: Ethical aspects of the medical profession have been discussed with interest by medical school students; the high prevalence of uncertain answers and requests to develop specific tools underline the importance of this educational approach.

To give or to receive? Opinions of teenagers on kidney donation.

BACKGROUND: The attitude toward living donation varies widely in the world, for economic and cultural reasons. In Italy, as in other Mediterranean settings, the role of living kidney donation is minor. AIM: To analyze the reasons for this attitude, we gathered data in a general population sample of high school students in a large northern Italian industrial city (Torino, about 900,000 inhabitants). METHODS: Semistructured questionnaires (n = 1676), gathered in 2001 to 2002 in 14 high schools, in the context of an educational program on dialysis, renal transplantation, and organ donation, were analyzed presumably reflecting opinions gathered before the educational intervention. RESULTS: Most students, in the case of a close relative or partner needing dialysis, answer that they would donate a kidney (yes: 78.2%, no: 2.9%, uncertain-blank: 18.9%); receiving a living donor kidney is felt as disturbing: only 57.5% of the students would accept it (no: 5.9%, uncertain-blank: 36.6%), mainly because of fear of long-term problems for the donor. Donation from an older to a younger person is seen more positively than vice versa. CONCLUSION: In our settings, the attitude of the teenagers on living donation is positive; however, while "giving" is positively seen, the presence of unresolved fears is witnessed by the lower acceptance of the idea of "taking." These data suggest to focus on the risks of kidney donation in educational campaigns and in patient-physician information. The positive attitude shared by the teenagers supports the working hypothesis that lack of information is one of the determinants of the low living donor transplantation rate in our area.

Preparation of candidates for renal transplantation: cost analysis.

While the costs of renal transplantation are lower than those of dialysis, little is known about the costs of managing the waiting list. We performed a cost analysis of admission and clinical management of a waiting list for renal and pancreas-kidney transplantation. Admission to the waiting list included (1) renal graft from cadaver: minimum cost Euros () 1784.56 for men < 55 years, maximum 2127.85 for women >/= 55 years; (2) pancreas-kidney transplantation: minimum 2475.50 for men, maximum 2540.10 for women >/= 35 years. Check of suitability state on waiting list after 2 and 5 years: minimum 1400.15 for men >/= 55 years (check every 2 years), maximum 1467.07 for women >/=40, <55 years (every 5 years). The differences are related to the imaging techniques: from 43.90 (Doppler ultrasonography) to 283.28 (coronary angiography). Maintenance of the waiting list: minimum cost 1885.21 in the first year and 3187.02 in the (fifth year) for men < 55 years; maximum 2228.50 (first year) and 5116.70 (fifth year) for women >/= 55 years. These results show different costs for recipients on the basis of sex and age ranges, due to the different requirements for imaging tests such as cardiac scintiscan at age >/= 55 years) and economic charges that increase with age. Reduced waiting times allow lowered total costs. This evaluation allowed us to calculate for our region (Piemonte, Northern Italy), the management costs of the patients presently on our waiting list (369 patients at December 31, 2002) from preparation to transplantation as 959,179.18.

[Costs of dialysis in hospitalised patients with acute or chronic renal failure, according to area of treatment]. / Costi dei trattamenti dialitici condotti in aree operative differenziate in pazienti ospedalizzati, acuti e cronici.

BACKGROUND: In Italy, dialysis reimbursement is regulated by the "Tariffario delle prestazioni ambulatoriali" (G.U. N 216, 14/9/1996), which does not take into account separately the dialysis sessions performed in hospitalised patients. In these cases the dialysis activity is considered within the final DRG (Diagnosis Related Group). Aim of the study was an analysis of production costs of dialysis performed in hospitalised patients, according to the setting in which dialysis is performed (Intensive Care Units (ICUs), other Units, hospital dialysis ward). METHODS: The direct production costs were assessed by the "bottom-up" technique logic (cost definition from the single elements needed for producing the treatment) referring to specific Cost Centres. The main items considered were health-care staff, dialysis supplies and hardware, blood tests, dialysis data recording and transmission. RESULTS: During the year 2000, there were 4,450 treatments performed in 490 patients. They included 924 haemodialyses in ICUs; 2,531 in the nephrology hospital dialysis ward; 602 peritoneal dialysis treatments in ICUs-other wards, 393 in the nephrology ward. Direct cost per haemodialysis treatment ranged from 276.05 E (UF) to 413.46 E (HF) in ICU, from 170.47 E (Bicarbonate Haemodialysis) to 275.36 E (Slow Haemofiltration) in hospital dialysis ward; for peritoneal dialysis between 128.95 E (CAPD in dialysis ward) and 282.10 E (CAPD in ICU/other Units). During the year 2000, the global cost of production was 1,038,346.65 E. CONCLUSIONS: The cost of dialysis in hospitalised patients is high. A dedicated budget is needed to avoid deficits, particularly in highly specialised Units of large referral hospitals.

[99mTc-DTPA scintigraphy in renal transplantation. Limitations related to the immunosuppressor used]. / La scintigrafia con 99mTc-DTPA nel trapianto renale. Limiti correlati all'immunodepressore usato.

The diagnostic tools used to achieve an assessment of allograft dysfunction should be as noninvasive as possible, because kidney graft recipients are fragile patients and quite often the need is for repeated investigations. In order to evaluate the reliability and accuracy of such a method, in this case scintigraphy with 99mTc-DTPA, the authors retrospectively studied 2 groups of kidney transplanted patients, having two different basic immunosuppressive regimens: group A--86 patients--taking steroids and azathioprine; group B--93 patients--taking steroids and cyclosporine. A total of 722 scans were retrospectively compared with scintigraphic information: 196 episodes of allograft dysfunction were due to acute rejection: 118 in group A, 78 in group B; 117 episodes were due to ATN: 75 in group A, 42 in group B; 11 episodes were ascribed to CyA acute nephrotoxicity. Group A and B behave differently in respect of the perfusion index. Only in group A were perfusion indexes statistically different in rejection, ATN and nephrotoxicity. Anyway, it must be stressed that, even if in group B, scintigraphy cannot be considered an accurate diagnostic method, it is somehow a helpful tool because it gives information about a worse perfusion of the graft, independently of the underlying pathology.

[Comparison between biopsy data and the resistive index obtained by Doppler echography in the evaluation of the transplanted kidney]. / Confronto fra dato bioptico ed indice di resistenza ottenuto con eco-Doppler nella valutazione del rene trapiantato.

Doppler sonography is nowadays considered as a "first step" tool for diagnosis of vascular complications in kidney transplantation. Quite recently, it has been sometimes considered useful and effective investigation in order to obtain information about parenchymal dysfunctional pathologies, particularly about acute rejection. This has been obtained by studying the variation of resistive indexes. The goal of the following investigation was compare Doppler sonography data and histological examination in 50 kidney transplanted recipients in whom the renal biopsy was performed on a clinical basis. In the Authors' experience. Doppler sonography and study of the resistive index does not offer any reliable help in differentiating acute rejection from cyclosporine A toxicity.

[Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty after renal transplantation]. / L'angioplastica trans-luminale percutanea (PTA) dopo trapianto renale.

Renal artery stenosis is a frequent complication of kidney transplantation (10%). Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) has recently been proposed as a potential therapeutic procedure. Twelve transplant patients with arterial stenosis underwent PTA. The procedure was successful in 10 cases (83.3%). Restenosis occurred in 2 patients (16.7%); both of them underwent PTA successfully. No complications occurred. A considerable improvement in glomerular filtration rate and a reduction in high blood pressure were observed in all patients after successful PTA. The authors believe PTA to be the therapy of choice in the treatment of arterial stenoses in kidney transplant patients.

Echo-Doppler velocimetry in the diagnosis of renal artery stenosis on transplanted kidney.

Renal artery stenosis is one of the most important complications in the natural history of kidney transplantation. Particular care has to be taken in the use of angiography techniques because of the invasiveness and of the potential toxicity of radiopaque contrast material, even in the less invasive radiological tests, like endovenous sequential angiourography with image subtraction (SAU) and digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Fifty-one patients have been examined with echo-Doppler velocimetry (EDV) and also with SAU in order to verify the previous status of the artery. EDV exhibits a 100% sensitivity: all SAU detected stenosis have been formerly identified via EDV. The non-invasiveness and possibility of early repetition allows an early diagnosis capability for all transplanted patients. In this way, a surgical intervention may quite often be prevented by a precocious use of endoluminal angioplasty.

Patients with chronic renal failure are not at a risk of developing chronic peptic ulcers.

This study reports the endoscopic and histological aspects of gastrointestinal mucosa in a consecutive series of 249 patients with chronic renal failure on conservative hemodialysis, who were awaiting renal transplantation. At endoscopy the mucosa was normal in 54.2% of the cases and revealed gross inflammatory changes in 34.1%. Duodenal ulcers were found in 11.2% of patients with only one gastric ulcer. Of the 28 duodenal ulcers, 16 were active and 12 inactive lesions. Gastric biopsies sampled from 44 non-ulcer patients showed signs of chronic gastritis in 29.6%, atrophic gastritis in 18.2, and reported normal in 52.3% of the cases. The above findings were not affected by the ages of patients or by the total duration of hemodialysis treatment. It is concluded that patients with chronic renal failure share the same risk of developing chronic peptic ulcers as the general population. Moreover, the overall endoscopic and histological appearance of the mucosa in these patients appears not to differ from data reported in the general population.