BD SurePath Direct to Slide (DTS) cervical cytology: Migrating the benefits of liquid-based cytology to low-resource settings.

OBJECTIVES: The benefits of liquid-based cytology (LBC) in routine cervical cancer screening are often associated with the availability of instrumented platforms and economic considerations. A low-cost alternative to LBC in low-volume settings remains an unmet need. METHODS: A multisite evaluation of the BD SurePath (SurePath) LBC Direct to Slide (DTS) method was conducted. The DTS preparations were evaluated across 3 sites. Cytology features for DTS preparation included predetermined thresholds for total cellularity, cell distribution, cellular preservation, and stain quality. Rare event detection was evaluated using SiHa cells spiked into pools from negative cytology specimens. Concordance between Bethesda classification results was evaluated for SurePath LBC and DTS methods using routinely collected SurePath specimens in a split-sample study design. RESULTS: The DTS specimens met criteria for total cellularity, cell distribution, cellular preservation, and stain quality in more than 98% of all cases. Rare event detection was observed with an average detection of 5 SiHa cells per 2 mL of specimen. Concordant cervical cytology classifications were observed between SurePath LBC and DTS methods. CONCLUSIONS: The results demonstrate that the DTS process is suitable for routine cervical cytology evaluation. The procedure is reproducible and detected abnormal cervical cells in concordance with standard SurePath LBC preparation.

Diagnostic algorithm for determining primary tumor sites using peritoneal fluid.

This study was conducted to develop a novel algorithm for determining the origin of tumors by combining analysis of cluster patterns with immunocytochemistry (ICC) for markers in cells from fine-needle aspirates of ascites. We used LBC, based on SurePathTM (BD Diagnostics) technology, to screen 96 peritoneal fluid samples from patients with known malignancies and from 10 control patients with cirrhosis. Following dual ICC staining for cytokeratin 7 (CK7) and paired box gene 8 (PAX8), we developed an algorithm using immunoreactivity and three-dimensional (3D) cluster patterns to correlate staining and 3D cluster patterns with common primary origins that included stomach, ovarian, pancreatobiliary tract, colon, lung, and breast cancers. With the application of an automatic digitalized image analyzer, competence performance was analyzed using receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curve analysis. CK7 and PAX8 staining and 3D cluster patterns were used to differentiate primary origins. Samples from patients with stomach cancer were no 3D cluster /CK7+/PAX8- with area under the curve (AUC) of 0.8699 in ROC curve analysis. Samples from ovarian cancer patients were large 3D cluster/CK7+/PAX8+ with AUC of 0.9812. Samples from pancreatobiliary tract cancer patients were small 3D cluster/CK7+/PAX8- with AUC of 0.8772. The remaining cancer samples, including breast, lung and colon cancer samples, had similar patterns of large 3D clusters/CK7+/PAX8- with AUC of 0.882, especially for lung cancer. SurePathTM technology, using 3D cluster patterns and dual ICC for CK7 and PAX8 in peritoneal fluid samples, can provide important information for determining specific primary origins in cases of unknown primary carcinoma.

Characterization and clinical validation of MCM2 and TOP2A monoclonal antibodies in the BD ProEx™ C assay: An immunoassay which detects aberrant S-phase induction in cervical tissue.

BACKGROUND: The Papanicolaou (Pap) screen has been successful in reducing cervical cancer; but exhibits low sensitivity when detecting cervical dysplasia. Use of molecular biomarkers in Pap tests may improve diagnostic accuracy. DESIGN: Monoclonal antibodies to Minichromosome Maintenance Protein 2 (MCM2) and DNA Topoisomerase II α (TOP2A) were selected for use in IHC based on their ability to differentiate normal from diseased cervical tissues in tissue microarrays. Enhanced Green Fluorescent Protein Western blot analysis was used to help identify binding epitopes specific to MCM2 and TOP2A antibody clones. Antibody affinity was determined by solution phase affinity measurement and immunohistochemistry was performed using high affinity MCM2 or TOP2A antibodies on serial histological sections. RESULTS: Antibody clones to MCM2 and TOP2A clones were selected based on their ability to detect over expression in abnormal cervical epithelia. In IHC, MCM2-27C5.6 and MCM2-26H6.19 demonstrated superior staining in abnormal cervical tissue over the MCM2-CRCT2.1 antibody. A combination of MCM2 and TOP2A antibodies showed greater staining when compared to staining with any of the antibodies alone on serial histological sections. Distinct linear epitopes were elucidated for each of the MCM2 and TOP2A clones. Affinity values (Kd) for MCM2 or TOP2A antibodies had a similar range. In a research study, the MCM2 and TOP2A (BD ProEx™ C) antibody cocktail showed increased epithelia staining with increasing dysplasia. The use of BD ProEx™ C in combination with H&E staining enhanced immunohistochemical discrimination of dysplastic and non-dysplastic FFPE cervical tissue specimens. CONCLUSIONS: BD ProEx™ C containing MCM2 and TOP2A antibodies showed strong specific nuclear staining that correlated with increased dysplasia and lesion severity. Enhanced performance of the antibodies was linked to their unique topography recognition. BD ProEx™ C incorporates antibodies that enhance detection of CIN2+ cervical disease.

Analytical performance of RNA isolated from BD SurePath™ cervical cytology specimens by the PreTect™ HPV-Proofer assay.

Several commercial HPV ancillary tests are available for detection of E6/E7 RNA. It is not clear how storage of a cervical Pap affects the analytical and clinical performance of the PreTect™ HPV-Proofer assay. To investigate the qualitative performance of RNA extracted from BD SurePath™ liquid-based cytology (LBC) specimens for the detection of human papillomavirus (HPV) E6/E7 mRNA using the PreTect™ HPV-Proofer assay, studies including stability, reproducibility, residual specimen analysis, and storage medium comparison assays were performed. Cervical cytology specimens were collected and stored in BD SurePath™ LBC preservative fluid and/or PreTect™ Transport Media. RNA was isolated using the RecoverAll™ Total Nucleic Acid Isolation kit and RNA integrity was evaluated in the PreTect™ HPV-Proofer assay. The performance of RNA isolated from cervical cells collected and stored in BD SurePath™ LBC preservative fluid or PreTect™ Transport Media was also evaluated through a storage medium comparison study. The RNA was found to be stable for a minimum of 21 days when stored at ambient temperature and displayed high reproducibility with the mean percentage reproducibility ranging from 90.5% to 100% for the HPV types detected by the PreTect™ HPV-Proofer assay. The prevalence rate of HPV types in this study cohort was consistent with published reports. A 93.7% first pass acceptance rate was demonstrated across all cytology grades. The positive human U1 snRNP specific A protein (U1A) and HPV rate for BD SurePath™ LBC and PreTect™ Transport Media specimens was statistically equivalent for both normal and abnormal specimens. This data support the use of RNA isolated from BD SurePath™ LBC for ancillary HPV testing and demonstrates the feasibility of using BD SurePath™ preservative fluid as a specimen type with the PreTect™ HPV-Proofer assay.

Role of protein biomarkers in the detection of high-grade disease in cervical cancer screening programs.

Since the Pap test was introduced in the 1940s, there has been an approximately 70% reduction in the incidence of squamous cell cervical cancers in many developed countries by the application of organized and opportunistic screening programs. The efficacy of the Pap test, however, is hampered by high interobserver variability and high false-negative and false-positive rates. The use of biomarkers has demonstrated the ability to overcome these issues, leading to improved positive predictive value of cervical screening results. In addition, the introduction of HPV primary screening programs will necessitate the use of a follow-up test with high specificity to triage the high number of HPV-positive tests. This paper will focus on protein biomarkers currently available for use in cervical cancer screening, which appear to improve the detection of women at greatest risk for developing cervical cancer, including Ki-67, p16(INK4a), BD ProEx C, and Cytoactiv HPV L1.

The selection and characterization of antibodies to minichromosome maintenance proteins that highlight cervical dysplasia.

BACKGROUND: Screening efforts using the Papanicolaou test have significantly reduced the incidence of cervical cancer in countries with an active screening program. However, this test does not accurately identify all abnormal cases. Significant effort has been expended investigating molecular markers that could improve the sensitivity and specificity of detection of high-grade disease. In this study, we describe the selection and characterization of a set of antibodies to the minichromosome maintenance proteins MCM6 and MCM7 that highlight cervical disease in an immunoassay. METHODS: Antibodies to MCM6 or MCM7 proteins were identified from hybridoma clones screened against tissue microarrays containing different grades of diseased cervical tissue along with normal controls. We determined epitopes by western blotting against nested truncations of either the MCM6 or MCM7 proteins fused to GFP protein. We also determined specificity by western blotting against a panel of major MCM proteins (MCM2-MCM8). Affinity to recombinant antigen and epitope-only peptides was determined using solution-phase binding and determination of free antibody concentration by ELISA. Optimization studies resulted in the selection of antibodies specific to MCM6 and MCM7 for use in immunocytochemistry (ICC) with cervical cytology samples. RESULTS: Four antibodies were identified that demonstrated strong nuclear staining of abnormal cervical epithelial cells in immunohistochemistry (IHC) of cervical biopsies with minimal background staining of normal cervical tissues. Of these four antibody clones, 2E6.7 (MCM7) and 9D4.3 (MCM6) were chosen for further study. Linear epitopes of at most 12 amino acids were identified and verified by binding to epitope-only peptides. Affinities of at least 4×10(-9) M were determined for these two antibodies and both were found to be specific for their respective antigens by western blotting. Clones 9D4.3 and 2E6.7 were also determined to stain abnormal cells in high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion cytology samples, with minimal background staining of normal cells. CONCLUSION: In this study, we present a method for selecting antibodies that perform well in IHC and ICC applications and characterize two antibodies generated by this method that effectively stain abnormal cells in cervical cancer tissue and cervical cytology samples.

Recovery of DNA from BD SurePath cytology specimens and compatibility with the Roche AMPLICOR Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Test.

BACKGROUND: The AMPLICOR HPV Test has been validated for use with cervical cells collected in liquid-based preservative fluids, such as BD SurePath. It is currently recommended, however, that residual BD SurePath samples be stored at 4 degrees C prior to testing. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to demonstrate that DNA isolated from SurePath cervical cytology specimens and stored at ambient temperature was also compatible with the AMPLICOR HPV Test. STUDY DESIGN: DNA was extracted using the AmpliLute Media Sample Preparation Kit. Amplification and detection of HPV was performed both as directed by the manufacturer and with minor protocol modifications. RESULTS: Cervical specimens collected in SurePath preservative fluid remained stable for testing with the AMPLICOR HPV Test for at least 21 days. The performance of DNA extracted from specimens stored at room temperature was equivalent to DNA extracted from specimens stored at 4 degrees C. The beta-globin internal control was detected in all of the 146 residual SurePath cervical cytology specimens tested using the AMPLICOR HPV Test, and high-risk HPV was detected in 46.2% (18/39) of ASCUS cases, in 63.3% (19/30) of LSIL cytology specimens, and 92.3% (24/26) of HSIL cases. Concordance of AMPLICOR HPV Test results with Hybrid Capture II was 83.9%. CONCLUSIONS: The AMPLICOR HPV Test can be successfully and reproducibly performed from DNA isolated from residual SurePath cervical cytology specimens stored at ambient temperature for at least 21 days. This provides clinical laboratories flexible storage conditions for residual SurePath cytology specimens.

Screening for molecular markers of cervical papillomavirus infection: overview of methods and their clinical implications.

Molecular diagnostic adjuncts could improve the specificity of cervical cancer screening. Since persistent infection with human papillomavirus (HPV) is found in virtually 100% of cervical cancer cases, testing for markers of HPV integration may have a role in identifying underlying high-grade lesions in patients with low-grade cytologic abnormalities. Several proteins associated with the cell cycle are known to be affected by HPV integration into the host's DNA. Immunocytochemical identification of these upregulated proteins can assist in the identification of small numbers of pre-neoplastic or neoplastic cells in routine cytologic sampling.

Detection and genotyping analysis of human papillomavirus isolates from liquid-based cervical cytology specimens.

The detection of oncogenic subtypes of human papillomavirus (HPV) from exfoliated cervical cells collected in liquid-based preservative fluid at the time of the annual Pap test can be accomplished using PCR-based amplification methods. DNA sequence analysis of the L1 open reading frame (ORF) permits determination of the HPV viral subtype. DNA sequence analysis of the E6 and E7 ORFs permits further detection of various HPV genotype variants within a given HPV viral type. These techniques can be readily adopted by most laboratories employing standard molecular biology techniques.

Isolation of RNA from cell lines and cervical cytology specimens stored in BD SurePath preservative fluid and downstream detection of housekeeping gene and HPV E6 expression using real time RT-PCR.

This study was performed to demonstrate that RNA isolated from cell lines and cervical cytology specimens stored in SurePath preservative fluid would be functional in real-time RT-PCR assays. RNA was isolated from cervical cell lines or cytology samples stored in SurePath preservative at room temperature for 2-5 weeks using five commercially available RNA purification kits, three of which contain proteinases. The quality of the RNA was assessed by real time RT-PCR amplification of GAPDH, GUSB, U1A, HPV 16 and 18 E6 mRNAs. RNA was isolated successfully from cells that were stored in SurePath preservative fluid with only the three protocols that contained proteinases. GAPDH was amplified in 98-100% of the samples, GUSB in 90-98%, and the least abundant transcript, U1A, was amplified in 81-96% of the samples. HPV 16 and 18 E6 transcripts were detected in 56% of high grade, 39% of low grade and 2% of normal samples, with a concordance between DNA genotype and E6 mRNA expression of 97%. We demonstrated that RNA can be extracted from cervical cell lines and cytology specimens stored in BD SurePath preservative fluid with three different procedures that all contain proteinases. This RNA is suitable for real-time RT-PCR applications.

Isolation of RNA from residual BD SurePath liquid-based cytology specimens and detection of HPV E6/E7 mRNA using the PreTectt HPV-Proofer assay.

Infection with high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV) is known to be associated directly with the development of cervical cancer. Recent data suggests that the detection of E6/E7 mRNA from high-risk HPV types may serve as a better diagnostic method for detecting the presence of cervical pre-cancer than HPV DNA testing. This report details a commercially available nucleic acid isolation protocol which can be used to isolate reproducibly RNA from residual BD SurePath liquid-based cytology specimens stored for up to 28 days, and have demonstrated the quality and quantity of mRNA is sufficient for detection with the NorChip PreTect HPV-Proofer assay. Of the 242 specimens tested in this study, 236 (97.5%) tested positive for U1A internal control gene expression. HPV type 16, 18, 31, 33 or 45 mRNA was detected in 16/20 (80%) of the analyzed high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) specimens, with a low frequency of HPV mRNA detected in the normal lesions (3%). The presence of HPV E6 expression in a subset of HPV positive specimens was also detected by real-time RT-PCR. These findings confirm that RNA of sufficient quality can be isolated from residual BD SurePath cervical cytology specimens for use in downstream NASBA and RT-PCR-based assays.

Evaluation of biomarker panels for early stage ovarian cancer detection and monitoring for disease recurrence.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the utility of novel combinations of biomarkers, using both a one-step and two-step assay format, to distinguish serum of early ovarian cancer patients from that of healthy controls and to discern the utility of these biomarkers in a monitoring capacity. METHODS: For ovarian cancer detection, HE4, Glycodelin, MMP7, SLPI, Plau-R, MUC1, Inhibin A, PAI-1, and CA125 were evaluated in a cohort of 200 women with ovarian cancer and 396 healthy age-matched controls. Each biomarker was assessed by serum-based immunoassays utilizing novel monoclonal antibody pairs or commercial kits. For detection of disease recurrence, HE4, Glycodelin, MMP7 and CA125 were evaluated in 260 samples from 30 patients with OC monitored longitudinally after diagnosis. RESULTS: Based upon ROC curve analysis, the sensitivity/specificity of specific biomarker combination algorithms ranged from 59.0%/99.7% to 80.5%/96.5% for detection of early stage ovarian cancer and 76.9%/99.7% to 89.2%/97.2% for detection of late stage cancer. In monitoring evaluation of 27 patients who experienced recurrence of OC, sensitivity for predicting recurrence was 100% for the biomarker panel and 96% for CA125. At least one of the panel biomarkers was elevated earlier (range 6-69 weeks) than CA125 and prior to clinical evidence of recurrence in 14/27 (52%) patients. CONCLUSIONS: We have developed and demonstrated the utility of several one- and two-step multi-marker combinations with acceptable test characteristics for possible use in an ovarian cancer screening population. A subset of this panel may also provide adjunctive information to rising CA125 levels in disease monitoring.

Multiple biomarkers in molecular oncology. II. Molecular diagnostics applications in breast cancer management.

In recent years, the application of genomic and proteomic technologies to the problem of breast cancer prognosis and the prediction of therapy response have begun to yield encouraging results. Independent studies employing transcriptional profiling of primary breast cancer specimens using DNA microarrays have identified gene expression profiles that correlate with clinical outcome in primary breast biopsy specimens. Recent advances in microarray technology have demonstrated reproducibility, making clinical applications more achievable. In this regard, one such DNA microarray device based upon a 70-gene expression signature was recently cleared by the US FDA for application to breast cancer prognosis. These DNA microarrays often employ at least 70 gene targets for transcriptional profiling and prognostic assessment in breast cancer. The use of PCR-based methods utilizing a small subset of genes has recently demonstrated the ability to predict the clinical outcome in early-stage breast cancer. Furthermore, protein-based immunohistochemistry methods have progressed from using gene clusters and gene expression profiling to smaller subsets of expressed proteins to predict prognosis in early-stage breast cancer. Beyond prognostic applications, DNA microarray-based transcriptional profiling has demonstrated the ability to predict response to chemotherapy in early-stage breast cancer patients. In this review, recent advances in the use of multiple markers for prognosis of disease recurrence in early-stage breast cancer and the prediction of therapy response will be discussed.

Multiple biomarkers in molecular oncology. I. Molecular diagnostics applications in cervical cancer detection.

The screening for cervical carcinoma and its malignant precursors (cervical neoplasia) currently employs morphology-based detection methods (Papanicolaou [Pap] smear) in addition to the detection of high-risk human papillomavirus. The combination of the Pap smear with human papillomavirus testing has achieved significant improvements in sensitivity for the detection of cervical disease. Diagnosis of cervical neoplasia is dependent upon histology assessment of cervical biopsy specimens. Attempts to improve the specificity of cervical disease screening have focused on the investigation of molecular biomarkers for adjunctive use in combination with the Pap smear. Active research into the genomic and proteomic alterations that occur during human papillomavirus-induced neoplastic transformation have begun to characterize some of the basic mechanisms inherent to the disease process of cervical cancer development. This research continues to demonstrate the complexity of multiple genomic and proteomic alterations that accumulate during the tumorigenesis process. Despite this diversity, basic patterns of uncontrolled signal transduction, cell cycle deregulation, activation of DNA replication and altered extracellular matrix interactions are beginning to emerge as common features inherent to cervical cancer development. Some of these gene or protein expression alterations have been investigated as potential biomarkers for screening and diagnostics applications. The contribution of multiple gene alterations in the development of cervical cancer suggests that the application of multiple biomarker panels has the potential to develop clinically useful molecular diagnostics. In this review, the application of biomarkers for the improvement of sensitivity and specificity of the detection of cervical neoplasia within cytology specimens will be discussed.

Molecular diagnostic assays for cervical neoplasia: emerging markers for the detection of high-grade cervical disease.

The accurate detection and diagnosis of cervical carcinoma and its malignant precursors (collectively referred to as high-grade cervical disease) represents one of the current challenges in clinical medicine and cytopathology. The advent of molecular diagnostics and the use of whole-genome profiling using DNA microarrays promises to yield improved understanding of the disease process with the subsequent development of more accurate diagnostic procedures based upon these discoveries. Recent reports describing a variety of experimental approaches have identified a series of candidate genes that are overexpressed in cervical carcinoma. In this article, representative examples of these markers and the resulting translational research will be reviewed within the context of improved cervical disease detection. An emerging class of markers, the minichromosome maintenance protein family of DNA licensing factors (MCM-2, MCM-6, MCM-7), shows promise for the specific detection of high-grade cervical disease using simple antibody-based immunochemistry formats. These proteins are overexpressed in cervical disease as a result of infection by oncogenic strains of human papillomavirus (HPV) and subsequent uncontrolled activation of gene transcription and aberrant S-phase induction, mediated through the E2F transcription factor pathway. This behavior appears to be a hallmark of high-grade cervical disease and provides the link between oncogenic HPV infections and the molecular behavior of cervical neoplasia (CN). The use of these molecular descriptors of CN in simple immunochemistry formats compatible with conventional cytology preparations is anticipated to improve the screening and detection of cervical disease within the healthcare system.