Genomic testing for suspected monogenic kidney disease in children and adults: A health economic evaluation.

PURPOSE: To assess the relative cost-effectiveness of genomic testing compared with standard non-genomic diagnostic investigations in patients with suspected monogenic kidney disease from an Australian health care system perspective. METHODS: Diagnostic and clinical information was used from a national cohort of 349 participants. Simulation modelling captured diagnostic, health, and economic outcomes during a time horizon from clinical presentation until 3 months post-test results based on the outcome of cost per additional diagnosis and lifetime horizon based on cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained. RESULTS: Genomic testing was Australian dollars (AU$) 1600 more costly per patient and led to an additional 27 diagnoses out of a 100 individuals tested, resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of AU$5991 per additional diagnosis. Using a lifetime horizon, genomic testing resulted in an additional cost of AU$438 and 0.04 QALYs gained per individual compared with standard diagnostic investigations, corresponding to an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of AU$10,823 per QALY gained. Sub-group analyses identified that the results were largely driven by the cost-effectiveness in glomerular diseases. CONCLUSION: Based on established or expected thresholds of cost-effectiveness, our evidence suggests that genomic testing is very likely to be cost saving for individuals with suspected glomerular diseases, whereas no evidence of cost-effectiveness was found for non-glomerular diseases.

Use of Whole-Genome Sequencing for Mitochondrial Disease Diagnosis.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Mitochondrial diseases (MDs) are the commonest group of heritable metabolic disorders. Phenotypic diversity can make molecular diagnosis challenging, and causative genetic variants may reside in either mitochondrial or nuclear DNA. A single comprehensive genetic diagnostic test would be highly useful and transform the field. We applied whole-genome sequencing (WGS) to evaluate the variant detection rate and diagnostic capacity of this technology with a view to simplifying and improving the MD diagnostic pathway. METHODS: Adult patients presenting to a specialist MD clinic in Sydney, Australia, were recruited to the study if they satisfied clinical MD (Nijmegen) criteria. WGS was performed on blood DNA, followed by clinical genetic analysis for known pathogenic MD-associated variants and MD mimics. RESULTS: Of the 242 consecutive patients recruited, 62 participants had "definite," 108 had "probable," and 72 had "possible" MD classification by the Nijmegen criteria. Disease-causing variants were identified for 130 participants, regardless of the location of the causative genetic variants, giving an overall diagnostic rate of 53.7% (130 of 242). Identification of causative genetic variants informed precise treatment, restored reproductive confidence, and optimized clinical management of MD. DISCUSSION: Comprehensive bigenomic sequencing accurately detects causative genetic variants in affected MD patients, simplifying diagnosis, enabling early treatment, and informing the risk of genetic transmission.

Genomic diagnostics in polycystic kidney disease: an assessment of real-world use of whole-genome sequencing.

Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease (ADPKD) is common, with a prevalence of 1/1000 and predominantly caused by disease-causing variants in PKD1 or PKD2. Clinical diagnosis is usually by age-dependent imaging criteria, which is challenging in patients with atypical clinical features, without family history, or younger age. However, there is increasing need for definitive diagnosis of ADPKD with new treatments available. Sequencing is complicated by six pseudogenes that share 97% homology to PKD1 and by recently identified phenocopy genes. Whole-genome sequencing can definitively diagnose ADPKD, but requires validation for clinical use. We initially performed a validation study, in which 42 ADPKD patients underwent sequencing of PKD1 and PKD2 by both whole-genome and Sanger sequencing, using a blinded, cross-over method. Whole-genome sequencing identified all PKD1 and PKD2 germline pathogenic variants in the validation study (sensitivity and specificity 100%). Two mosaic variants outside pipeline thresholds were not detected. We then examined the first 144 samples referred to a clinically-accredited diagnostic laboratory for clinical whole-genome sequencing, with targeted-analysis to a polycystic kidney disease gene-panel. In this unselected, diagnostic cohort (71 males :73 females), the diagnostic rate was 70%, including a diagnostic rate of 81% in patients with typical ADPKD (98% with PKD1/PKD2 variants) and 60% in those with atypical features (56% PKD1/PKD2; 44% PKHD1/HNF1B/GANAB/ DNAJB11/PRKCSH/TSC2). Most patients with atypical disease did not have clinical features that predicted likelihood of a genetic diagnosis. These results suggest clinicians should consider diagnostic genomics as part of their assessment in polycystic kidney disease, particularly in atypical disease.

Clinical spectrum, prognosis and estimated prevalence of DNAJB11-kidney disease.

Monoallelic mutations of DNAJB11 were recently described in seven pedigrees with atypical clinical presentations of autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease. DNAJB11 encodes one of the main cofactors of the endoplasmic reticulum chaperon BiP, a heat-shock protein required for efficient protein folding and trafficking. Here we conducted an international collaborative study to better characterize the DNAJB11-associated phenotype. Thirteen different loss-of-function variants were identified in 20 new pedigrees (54 affected individuals) by targeted next-generation sequencing, whole-exome sequencing or whole-genome sequencing. Amongst the 77 patients (27 pedigrees) now in total reported, 32 reached end stage kidney disease (range, 55-89 years, median age 75); without a significant difference between males and females. While a majority of patients presented with non-enlarged polycystic kidneys, renal cysts were inconsistently identified in patients under age 45. Vascular phenotypes, including intracranial aneurysms, dilatation of the thoracic aorta and dissection of a carotid artery were present in four pedigrees. We accessed Genomics England 100,000 genomes project data, and identified pathogenic variants of DNAJB11 in nine of 3934 probands with various kidney and urinary tract disorders. The clinical diagnosis was cystic kidney disease for eight probands and nephrocalcinosis for one proband. No additional pathogenic variants likely explaining the kidney disease were identified. Using the publicly available GnomAD database, DNAJB11 genetic prevalence was calculated at 0.85/10.000 individuals. Thus, establishing a precise diagnosis in atypical cystic or interstitial kidney disease is crucial, with important implications in terms of follow-up, genetic counseling, prognostic evaluation, therapeutic management, and for selection of living kidney donors.

Increased Diagnostic Yield of Spastic Paraplegia with or Without Cerebellar Ataxia Through Whole-Genome Sequencing.

Inherited disorders of spasticity or ataxia exist on a spectrum with overlapping causative genes and phenotypes. We investigated the use of whole-genome sequencing (WGS) to detect a genetic cause when considering this spectrum of disorders as a single group. We recruited 18 Korean individuals with spastic paraplegia with or without cerebellar ataxia in whom common causes of hereditary cerebellar ataxia and hereditary spastic paraplegia had been excluded. We performed WGS with analysis for single nucleotide variants, small insertions and deletions, copy number variants (CNVs), structural variants (SVs) and intronic variants. Disease-relevant variants were identified in ABCD1 (n = 3), CAPN1 (n = 2), NIPA1 (n = 1) and PLA2G6 (n = 1) for 7/18 patients (38.9%). A 'reverse phenotyping' approach was used to clarify the diagnosis in individuals with PLA2G6 and ABCD1 variants. One of the ABCD1 disease-relevant variants was detected on analysis for intronic variants. No CNV or SV causes were found. The two males with ABCD1 variants were initiated on monitoring for adrenal dysfunction. This is one of only a few studies to analyse spastic-ataxias as a continuous spectrum using a single approach. The outcome was improved diagnosis of unresolved cases for which common genetic causes had been excluded. This includes the detection of ABCD1 variants which had management implications. Therefore, WGS may be particularly relevant to diagnosing spastic ataxias given the large number of genes associated with this condition and the relatively high diagnostic yield.

Population data improves variant interpretation in autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease.

PURPOSE: Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is a common adult-onset monogenic disorder, with prevalence of 1/1000. Population databases including ExAC have improved pathogenic variant prioritization in many diseases. Due to pseudogene homology of PKD1, the predominant ADPKD disease gene, and the variable disease severity and age of onset, we aimed to investigate the utility of ExAC for variant assessment in ADPKD. METHODS: We assessed coverage and variant quality in the ExAC cohort and combined allele frequency and age data from the ExAC database (n = 60,706) with curated variants from 2000 ADPKD pedigrees (ADPKD Mutation Database). RESULTS: Seventy-six percent of PKD1 and PKD2 were sequenced adequately for variant discovery and variant quality was high in ExAC. In ExAC, we identified 25 truncating and 393 previously reported disease-causing variants in PKD1 and PKD2, 6.9-fold higher than expected. Fifty-four different variants, previously classified as disease-causing, were observed in ≥5 participants in ExAC. CONCLUSION: Our study demonstrates that many previously implicated disease-causing variants are too common, challenging their pathogenicity, or penetrance. The presence of protein-truncating variants in older participants in ExAC demonstrates the complexity of variant classification and highlights need for further study of prevalence and penetrance of this common monogenic disease.

Expanding the spectrum of PEX16 mutations and novel insights into disease mechanisms.

Zellweger syndrome spectrum disorders are caused by mutations in any of at least 12 different PEX genes. This includes PEX16, an important regulator of peroxisome biogenesis. Using whole genome sequencing, we detected previously unreported, biallelic variants in PEX16 [NM_004813.2:c.658G>A, p.(Ala220Thr) and NM_004813.2:c.830G>A, p.(Arg277Gln)] in an individual with leukodystrophy, spastic paraplegia, cerebellar ataxia, and craniocervical dystonia with normal plasma very long chain fatty acids. Using olfactory-neurosphere derived cells, a population of neural stem cells, we showed patient cells had reduced peroxisome density and increased peroxisome size, replicating previously reported findings in PEX16 cell lines. Along with alterations in peroxisome morphology, patient cells also had impaired peroxisome function with reduced catalase activity. Furthermore, patient cells had reduced oxidative stress levels after exposure to hydrogen-peroxide (H2O2), which may be a result of compensation by H2O2 metabolising enzymes other than catalase to preserve peroxisome-related cell functions. Our findings of impaired catalase activity and altered oxidative stress response are novel. Our study expands the phenotype of PEX16 mutations by including dystonia and provides further insights into the pathological mechanisms underlying PEX16-associated disorders. Additional studies of the full spectrum of peroxisomal dysfunction could improve our understanding of the mechanism underlying PEX16-associated disorders.

Whole-genome sequencing overcomes pseudogene homology to diagnose autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease.

Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is the most common monogenic kidney disorder and is due to disease-causing variants in PKD1 or PKD2. Strong genotype-phenotype correlation exists although diagnostic sequencing is not part of routine clinical practice. This is because PKD1 bears 97.7% sequence similarity with six pseudogenes, requiring laborious and error-prone long-range PCR and Sanger sequencing to overcome. We hypothesised that whole-genome sequencing (WGS) would be able to overcome the problem of this sequence homology, because of 150 bp, paired-end reads and avoidance of capture bias that arises from targeted sequencing. We prospectively recruited a cohort of 28 unique pedigrees with ADPKD phenotype. Standard DNA extraction, library preparation and WGS were performed using Illumina HiSeq X and variants were classified following standard guidelines. Molecular diagnosis was made in 24 patients (86%), with 100% variant confirmation by current gold standard of long-range PCR and Sanger sequencing. We demonstrated unique alignment of sequencing reads over the pseudogene-homologous region. In addition to identifying function-affecting single-nucleotide variants and indels, we identified single- and multi-exon deletions affecting PKD1 and PKD2, which would have been challenging to identify using exome sequencing. We report the first use of WGS to diagnose ADPKD. This method overcomes pseudogene homology, provides uniform coverage, detects all variant types in a single test and is less labour-intensive than current techniques. This technique is translatable to a diagnostic setting, allows clinicians to make better-informed management decisions and has implications for other disease groups that are challenged by regions of confounding sequence homology.