Recurrent inguinal hernia: preferred operative approach.

Inguinal herniorrhaphy remains one of the most common general surgical operations, with approximately 10 to 20 per cent performed for recurrence. Subsequent repairs provide considerable technical challenge, as well as substantially greater risk of developing further recurrence. Mesh repair is advocated by several specialized hernia centers, demonstrating re-recurrence rates less than 2 per cent. Detractors of this repair include cost, technical difficulty, and risk for infection. The purpose of this study was to compare results of mesh and nonmesh repairs for recurrent inguinal hernia, either using an anterior or posterior approach, at a large teaching institution. From January 1, 1985, to December 31, 1994, 146 patients underwent repair for recurrent inguinal hernia at the Veterans Administration Hospital at Memphis, Tennessee. Patients were stratified by type of repair: Lichtenstein (Mesh), open anterior (OA), Bassini, Marcy, McVay, Shouldice, and preperitoneal with or without mesh. Patient ages and weights were similar between groups. Mean operative time for Mesh repair (104 +/- 4 minutes) was longer than that for OA repairs (80 +/- 5 minutes, P < 0.05) or preperitoneal without mesh repairs (92 +/- 5 minutes, P < 0.05). Mesh-based posterior repairs had the longest operative times (116 +/- 5 minutes). Hospital stay averaged 2.8 +/- 0.3 days, similar among all groups. One wound infection (1.0%) occurred in patients undergoing Mesh repair, which required operative drainage. No patient required removal of mesh. Two patients in the Mesh group (5.9%) developed recurrence compared with four recurrences (18.0%) in patients undergoing OA repairs. Only one patient with a mesh-based posterior repair recurred (1.9%) compared to eight without mesh (21.6%, P < 0.01). Follow-up ranged from 2 to 12 years. Repair of recurrent inguinal hernia using either an anterior or posterior mesh repair technique, performed at a teaching facility, provides superior recurrence rates without increasing risk for infection or length of stay. Preperitoneal mesh based repair is the preferred technique.

Prospective, multicenter study of laparoscopic ventral hernioplasty. Preliminary results.

BACKGROUND: A standard technique for laparoscopic ventral hernioplasty (peritoneal onlay using an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene [ePTFE] patch for hernias >/=4 cm2) is being used in a prospective, multicenter, long-term study. METHODS: Demographic, operative, and postoperative data were collected and analyzed. Follow-up clinical evaluations were conducted 7-10 days, 4 weeks, 6 months, 1 year, and then annually after surgery in all patients. RESULTS: In the first 2 years of the study, 144 patients were enrolled; nine were lost to follow-up. The mean operating time was 120 min. The mean follow-up was 222 days (range 5-731). Postoperative complications were five infections, three cases of prolonged ileus, one bowel obstruction, 23 seromas (15 resolved without intervention), and six hernia recurrences. Hospital discharge occurred a mean of 2.3 days after surgery and return to normal activity a mean of 15 days postoperatively. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic prosthetic ventral hernioplasty avoids the large wound required in open repairs, with attendant complications and recurrences, and appears safe, especially if an ePTFE mesh is used. Compared with conventional open ventral hernioplasty, the laparoscopic technique may also allow shorter hospitalization and a quicker return to normal activities after surgery.

Mesh inguinal herniorrhaphy: a ten-year review.

Inguinal herniorrhaphy remains one of the most common surgical operations, with approximately 10 to 20 per cent performed for recurrence. Reviews by specialized hernia centers show mesh repair has a recurrence rate of 0.2 per cent. Detractors of this repair include increased cost, technical difficulty, and risk for infection. The purpose of this study was to compare mesh versus nonmesh inguinal herniorrhaphy at a large teaching institution. From 1985 to 1994, 892 patients underwent primary repair for inguinal hernia at the Veterans Administration Hospital at Memphis, TN. Patients were stratified by repair [Lichtenstein (Mesh), open anterior (Bassini, Marcy, McVay, and Shouldice), laparoscopic (Lap), and preperitoneal (Post)]. Operative time for Mesh repair (111 +/- 2 minutes) was longer than for Bassini or McVay (91 +/- 2 and 98 +/- 2 minutes; P < 0.05), and Lap repairs were longer than all others (192 +/- 16 minutes; P < 0.05). Hospital stay averaged 2.2 +/- 0.1 days for Mesh versus 2.6 +/- 0.1 days for all repairs combined (P = not significant). Mesh patients developed four wound infections (1.0%), none requiring mesh removal, versus nine infections (1.8%) in other groups (P = not significant). One Mesh patient (0.3%) developed recurrence, compared with 16 (3.5%) with open anterior repair (P < 0.01). Inguinal herniorrhaphy using an open mesh repair technique provides superior recurrence rates without increasing risk for infection, length of stay, or technical difficulty.

Totally preperitoneal laparoscopic inguinal herniorrhaphy using balloon distention.

BACKGROUND: After having performed over 200 transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP) laparoscopic hernia repairs with no recurrences and no neuropathies, we recently changed to a totally preperitoneal repair due to the development of a balloon trocar that easily 'creates' the preperitoneal space. METHODS: The totally preperitoneal operation is similar to our TAPP procedure in that it involves detailed delineation of Cooper's ligament, spermatic cord and transversus abdominis arch with fixation of mesh to Cooper's ligament and arch for an anatomic tension-free hernia repair. RESULTS: Our early experience consists of 60 hernia repairs in 50 patients (46 male, 4 female). There were 32 direct, 26 indirect and two femoral hernias. Eight hernias were recurrent. The operation takes approximately 1 h. There has been no morbidity. As with the TAPP procedure, minimal postoperative discomfort and return to regular activity within 2 to 3 days is the norm. CONCLUSIONS: We believe that the avoidance of the peritoneal incision and the attendant risks of intraabdominal adhesions associated with the TAPP procedure make the totally preperitoneal technique the preferred method of laparoscopic hernia repair.

Laparoscopic femoral hernia repair using a mesh dart.

We report 2 patients with femoral hernias (1 incarcerated) that were encountered during laparoscopic hernia repair for symptomatic direct inguinal hernias. The femoral hernias were readily repaired using the BARD dart that has been described previously for use during open femoral herniorrhaphy. We believe that this is the first report using the dart for laparoscopic femoral herniorrhaphy.

Preliminary evaluation of laparoscopic herniorrhaphy.

Since November 1990, 50 laparoscopic herniorrhaphies have been done in 47 patients (three patients with bilateral repairs), including 31 indirect and 19 direct inguinal hernias, three of which were recurrent. The 47 patients included 42 men and five women. Small indirect hernias were treated by plugging the hernia orifice with a tightly rolled polypropylene mesh plug. Large indirect, all direct, and combined hernias were treated by creating a peritoneal flap and stapling a polypropylene mesh screen preperitoneally over the defect. The mesh was stapled to Cooper's ligament, iliopubic tract, and transversus abdominous arch. Forty-five patients were discharged on the day of surgery and the other two within 24 h. The average return to full activity has been two days. The only intraoperative complication was an easily controlled trocar site bleeder. Postoperatively one minor trocar site infection occurred. One persistent and one recurrent hernia were among the group, both large indirect hernias done early in our experience (by the plug technique) before stapling instruments were available. The technique of laparoscopic herniorrhaphy is in its infancy and still evolving as our understanding of anatomy and technology improves. Even if long-term follow-up shows an acceptable recurrence rate and less patient disability, surgeons must weigh the wisdom of converting a procedure from local to general anesthesia and an inexpensive procedure into a more expensive procedure.

Laparoscopic posterior truncal vagotomy and anterior seromyotomy: a porcine model.

A training technique for posterior truncal vagotomy and an anterior seromyotomy in the anesthetized pig is described. The first of five procedures was performed open in a conventional method. All succeeding procedures were performed after the establishment of a pneumoperitoneum with CO2 insufflation and the placement of two 10 mm trocars and three 5-mm trocars. A 45 degree camera and monopolar electrocautery were used during the video laparoscopic procedure. After completion of the procedure, the pigs were opened to closely inspect the surgery performed. Though there are some minor anatomic differences between porcine and human anatomy, the pig is an excellent model for gaining technical experience in the performance of a posterior truncal vagotomy and anterior seromyotomy.

Anatomy of the accident scene: a prospective study of injury and mortality.

This study of the accident scene focuses on the effects of vehicular deformity and restraint devices on occupant injury. In 500 patients evaluated in a Level I trauma center, seatbelts significantly reduced the likelihood of individuals' requiring the trauma center (P less than 0.0001). Seatbelts also significantly reduced the mortality rate of those who were transported to the trauma center (P less than 0.04). Dashboard intrusion correlated with pelvic (P less than 0.001) and femur (P less than 0.03) fractures, closed head injuries (P less than 0.001), and intraabdominal injuries (P less than 0.02). Steering wheel deformity correlated with pelvic fractures (P less than 0.001) and closed head injuries (P less than 0.005). Windshield violation correlated with closed head injuries (P less than 0.014) and spinal fractures (P less than 0.03). Irreparable vehicles correlated with pelvic (P less than 0.0001) and femur fractures (P less than 0.01), closed head injuries (P less than 0.0001) and intra-abdominal injuries (P less than 0.0001). The authors conclude that a careful examination of the accident scene for specific mechanisms of injury can lead to better prehospital care, more rapid and consistent diagnosis of injury, and improved patient outcome. Further prospective studies should accumulate data that will improve prehospital care, alert physicians to possible injury, increase community awareness of injury prevention, and improve vehicle construction.

Factors affecting morbidity following hepatic trauma. A prospective analysis of 482 injuries.

During a 5-year period, 482 patients with liver injuries were studied prospectively: 65% resulted from penetrating and 35% from blunt injuries. The injuries were graded by the hepatic injury scale (grades I to VI); transfusion requirements and perihepatic abscesses correlated with increasing scores. Minor surgical techniques were needed in 338 patients and 144 patients required major techniques. Omental packing was used in 60% of the major injuries and yielded 7% mortality and 8% abscess rates. Gauze packs were used for management of 10% of major injuries and yielded 29% mortality and 30% abscess rates. The patients were randomized to no drain, closed suction, or sump drainage and respective perihepatic abscess rates were 6.7%, 3.5%, and 13% (p less than 0.03; suction compared to closed suction). Multivariate analysis demonstrated increasing abdominal trauma indices and transfusion requirements as well as sump drainage to be associated independently with perihepatic infection.

AAST organ injury scale: correlation of CT-graded liver injuries and operative findings.

The Organ Injury Scaling Committee of the AAST recently published a consensus classification of splenic, hepatic, and renal injuries (J Trauma, 29:1664, 1989). The hepatic injury scale (HIS), based on parenchymal laceration and intrahepatic hematoma, includes grades 1 to 6, representing the least to most severe injury. This study classifies liver injuries by findings at celiotomy, correlates operative findings with transfusion requirements and method of management of liver injury, and relates preoperative CT to anatomic findings at laparotomy. Thirty-seven patients with blunt liver injury were evaluated by abdominal CT with and without intravenous contrast and then underwent celiotomy. Increasing operative HIS correlated well with increasing severity of injury as measured by transfusions and operative management. Thirty-one CT grades did not correlate with operative findings (84%). Four patients had intrahepatic hematomas that were not discovered at operation. Twelve lacerations were graded too high by CT and 15 too low. Of these 15, ten CT scores were at least two grades lower than operative findings. Injuries around the falciform ligament occurred in three of the low misclassifications. One patient with intrahepatic hematoma developed hepatic artery pseudoaneurysm. We conclude that the HIS readily characterizes operative findings of hepatic lacerations and that increasing operative grade correlates well with transfusion requirements and operative management. CT can define intrahepatic hematomas, but does not correlate well with hepatic lacerations. Extreme caution is required when using CT alone to define "minimal" liver injury for prospective management of blunt trauma victims.

The effect of a trauma system on the outcome of patients with pancreatic trauma.

Patients suffering pancreatic trauma before and after the creation of a regional trauma center were analyzed. Between 1975 and 1982, before the trauma system was established, 80 patients (10 per year) with pancreatic injury were treated. From 1984 to 1987 (after trauma system implementation), 58 patients (19 per year) with pancreatic injury were treated. There were no significant differences in demographics, mechanisms of injury, types of pancreatic wound, or associated injuries. Sixteen (20%) patients with pancreatic injury during the study period died before the trauma center was established. Of these, 13 (81%) died of hemorrhage. In contrast, five (9%) patients with pancreatic injury who were treated after the trauma center was operational died. Only one death was due to hemorrhage. By relative risk, a patient was 2.67 times more likely to die and 17 times more likely to die of hemorrhage before the presence of the trauma center than after (P less than .03). In this study of a patient population suffering severe intra-abdominal injuries, Organ Injury Outcome Analysis demonstrates that development of a trauma system significantly improves outcome.

Preperitoneal herniorrhaphy for the acutely incarcerated groin hernia.

Elective preperitoneal or posterior repair for recurrent groin hernias and primary femoral hernias has been shown to be a technically advantageous approach. In addition to the ease of inguinal floor and femoral canal assessment, scar tissue from prior anterior herniorrhaphy can be avoided. The emergency management of the acutely incarcerated or strangulated hernia of the groin using this approach has not been addressed. During a 30-month period, all patients with a diagnosis of acute incarceration of a groin hernia (n = 28) were surgically managed using either the anterior approach (AA) (n = 14) or the preperitoneal approach (PA) (n = 14). Two patients with strangulated intestine in the AA group required an additional midline incision for bowel evaluation and resection. Intestinal evaluation was easily accomplished through the same incision in four patients in the PA group. The preperitoneal approach also allowed proximal control of incarcerated or strangulated viscera, thus avoiding excessive manipulation of gangrenous or necrotic intestine, potential spillage of infected contents into the peritoneal cavity, and entry of bacteria, toxins, potassium, and the metabolic waste products of anaerobic metabolism into the systemic circulation during hernia reduction. There have been no recurrences in either group, and minor complications, such as wound infection and cellulitis, in the two groups are not statistically different.

Cervicothoracic arterial injuries: recommendations for diagnosis and management.

Management of arterial injuries at the thoracic outlet and neck presents a major challenge to the trauma surgeon: hemorrhagic shock, neurologic deficit, and limb loss are the serious sequelae. Over a 13-year period, 118 patients with injuries to the innominate, carotid, subclavian, and axillary arteries were evaluated. Most injuries were penetrating (78%). Half of the patients were diagnosed by physical examination and half by angiography. Patients were treated by either primary repair (35%), interposition graft (31%), ligation (8%), or anticoagulation (26%). Two patients required amputations (1 digit, 1 above elbow). Overall mortality was 14%, with 5% due to consequences of hemorrhagic shock, 7% due to cerebral ischemia, and 2% due to other causes. Claviculectomy, median sternotomy, and trap door incisions were routinely used for proximal vascular control and repair. We conclude that liberal use of angiography is indicated in stable patients for penetrating wounds near major arteries, and for blunt injuries associated with neurologic deficits unexplained by computed tomography. Patients with obvious arterial injury should have immediate exploration. Extensile exposure is mandatory for appropriate management. Blunt carotid dissections are generally best managed non-operatively with anticoagulation.

Management of complex perineal soft-tissue injuries.

Debridement, fecal diversion, and rectal washout have been proposed as the primary therapy for complex perineal lacerations, but, in most series, survivors have a pelvic sepsis rate of 40-80%. In a retrospective study, six of 18 patients sustaining severe perineal lacerations died within the first few hours of injury due to exsanguination from pelvic injuries. The remaining 12 patients underwent sigmoidoscopy, diversion of the fecal stream with irrigation of the distal rectal stump, and radical initial debridement of necrotic soft tissue. Enteral access was obtained in two patients. In the patients with mandatory daily debridement and pulsatile irrigation, no pelvic sepsis occurred. In three patients without daily debridement, pelvic sepsis complicated recovery. The ability of patients to resume oral nutrition was significantly delayed, necessitating total parenteral nutrition in three patients. We conclude that sigmoidoscopy, total diversion of the fecal stream with irrigation of the distal rectal stump, enteral access for feeding, radical initial debridement of necrotic soft tissue, and mandatory daily debridement with pulsatile irrigation optimize recovery from this devastating injury.

Carotid artery trauma: management based on mechanism of injury.

Fifty-six patients with carotid injuries were reviewed (35 penetrating and 21 blunt). Shock correlated with a profound neurologic deficit on admission (p less than 0.03) in those with penetrating wounds. Thirty-one percent had primary repair, 25% had interposition grafting, 17% were ligated, and 17% were anticoagulated. Two graft failures resulted in death. Three blunt common carotid injuries followed direct cervical soft-tissue trauma; 18 internal carotid (ICA) dissections followed apparent extreme neck extension or flexion. Seven had bilateral ICA dissections (39%); none of these died. All dissections were diagnosed by angiography prompted by a change in the neurologic examination or an initial neurologic deficit unexplained by CT scan. Seventy-one percent had major associated injuries; 43% intra-abdominal solid viscus, 24% pelvis/long bone fractures, and 24% cervical spine/facial fractures. Dissections were treated with anticoagulation; 60% improved, 23% were unchanged, and 17% deteriorated. It is concluded that interposition grafting should be avoided if possible following penetrating wounds; liberal angiography is warranted with incompatible CT findings following blunt trauma; and anticoagulation is safe and effective therapy for blunt carotid dissections.

Pelvic fractures: an analysis of factors affecting prehospital triage and patient outcome.

Using an established prehospital regional triage protocol, 175 patients sustaining fractures of the pelvis were managed in a level one trauma center during a 38-month interval. The majority of injuries (51.7%) were caused by motor vehicle accidents and involved an average trauma score (TS) of 13 and an average injury severity score (ISS) of 24. The overall mortality was 16%; 43.5% had open fractures, 13.2% had closed fractures, and 30.6% had been in pedestrian accidents. Significant risk factors for mortality were age, blood pressure on admission, associated injuries, and the presence of an open pelvic fracture. It appears that TS alone is not reliable in prehospital triage of patients with pelvic fractures. Age and mechanism of injury may better identify the patient at risk for morbidity and mortality.

Superiority of closed suction drainage for pancreatic trauma. A randomized, prospective study.

During a 42-month period, 65 patients sustaining pancreatic injuries were treated. They were randomized on alternate days (two separate trauma teams) to receive sump (S) or closed suction (CS) drainage. Twenty-eight patients were randomized to S and 37 to CS; there were six early deaths, which precluded drainage analysis, leaving 24 evaluable S patients and 35 CS patients. Penetrating wounds occurred in 71% and blunt in 29%. No significant differences appeared between the groups with respect to age, Penetrating Abdominal Trauma Index (PATI), Injury Severity Score (ISS), or grade of pancreatic injury. Twelve patients in each group required resection and drainage for grade III injuries, with the remaining patients receiving external drainage alone. Five of twenty-four S patients versus one of thirty-five CS patients developed intra-abdominal abscesses (p less than 0.04). We conclude that septic complications after pancreatic injury are significantly reduced by CS drainage. Bacterial contamination via sump catheters is a major source for intra-abdominal infections after pancreatic trauma.

Epidural analgesia in thoracic trauma: effects of lumbar morphine and thoracic bupivacaine on pulmonary function.

Changes in pulmonary function tests were compared in 14 thoracic trauma patients, of whom seven received thoracic epidural bupivacaine for analgesia and seven received lumbar epidural morphine. In both groups epidural analgesia decreased subjective pain levels when compared to parenteral narcotics which the patients received before epidural catheter placement. Patients in the bupivacaine group had statistically significant improvements in vital capacity and forced expiratory volume, and a decreased respiratory rate. Patients in the morphine group had no significant change in pulmonary function. The use of thoracic epidural bupivacaine for analgesia in post-traumatic chest injuries produced superior improvement in pulmonary function when compared to lumbar epidural morphine.