Patient re-training in peritoneal dialysis: why and when it is needed.

The aim of this multicenter, quantitative, observational study was to analyze compliance and re-training needs of patients on peritoneal dialysis (PD) through the assessment of patient knowledge (with a Patient Questionnaire; phase 1) and patient behavior (home visit with a Score Card; phase 2). A total of 353 patients from 11 Italian centers participated in the first phase and 191 patients from nine centers in the second phase. Overall, 66% of questions on the Patient Questionnaire were answered correctly. Correct answers were more frequent in females than males, in patients under 55 years of age, and in those with higher education. The lowest rate of correct answers involved questions related to diet and physical activity (67% and 51%, respectively). Data collected during the home visit showed that 25% of patients were partially compliant with their drug therapy. Twenty-three percent of patients were non-compliant with the exchange protocol procedures, with a significant association between compliance and the incidence of peritonitis, and 11% were non-compliant with the exit-site protocol procedures without a statistically significant correlation to peritonitis. By combining the two evaluations, we found that approximately one-third (29%) of patients needed reinforcement of knowledge and ability to correctly perform PD as related to infection control and 27% for the correct use of drugs. Looking at the combined evaluation of infection control and drug use, results showed that 47% of patients needed re-training. This need for re-training was greater for younger patients (less than 55 years old), patients with lower education degree and patients in the early or late phase of PD therapy (less than 18 months or more than 36 months). Gender and degree of autonomy had no effect on the need for re-training.

Pneumoperitoneum in peritoneal dialysis patients.

The prevalence and clinical significance of pneumoperitoneum in peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients is not fully defined in current literature and some reports suggest that unlike in non-PD patients, it is rarely caused by gastrointestinal perforation. We reviewed 403 chest X-ray films of the 118 PD patients following our PD program in 1995-96, in order to define the prevalence of pneumoperitoneum. We found pneumoperitoneum in 3.7% of the X-rays (15/403) from five patients (4.2%). Its causes might have been: faulty bag exchange technique in two cases and extension tube exchange in three. One patient suffered from a simultaneous episode of peritonitis. Our data and the literature review suggest that 0-11% of pneumoperitoneum episodes in PD patients are due to gastrointestinal perforation; the main causes generally are abdominal operations and catheter manipulation. The amount of air is not useful in assessing the cause of pneumoperitoneum, which takes some weeks to disappear. Computed tomography is more sensitive than standard X-ray in diagnosis.

CAPD viability: a long-term comparison with hemodialysis.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the long-term viability of continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) to that of hemodialysis (HD). DESIGN: Retrospective study of patients of our institution starting dialysis between January 1, 1981, and December 31, 1993, and surviving for at least 2 months. PATIENTS: Five hundred and seventy-eight new patients (51.3% on CAPD and 48.6% on HD). MAIN OUTCOMES STUDIED: Cox-adjusted assessment of patient and technique survival, and of technique success. Differences in results for two successive periods of time. RESULTS: Patient survival did not differ between CAPD and HD after adjusting for age and comorbidity, and significantly improved in the second part of the follow-up (1987-1993). Technique failure was significantly higher on CAPD, in which it was inversely related to age. The probability of a patient continuing on the first method of dialysis ("technique success") was significantly lower on CAPD than on HD, but the difference decreased progressively with age and disappeared in patients > or = 75 years. CONCLUSION: CAPD is as effective as HD in preserving life in uremic patients in the long-term, and gives better results in the older elderly. In adults, the lower technique success rate may not be a problem for patients with access to a good transplantation program; for others, this drawback must be weighed against the advantages of home treatment.

Comparison of long-term survival between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis.

We have reviewed the literature and our own center's results for patients on long-term continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) in comparison to results for patients on hemodialysis (HD). Contrary to recent American data showing one-year survivals to be worse on CAPD, the Canadian Registry and other studies show no significant difference in survivals on the two methods. Results are also conflicting for diabetics. Insufficient adjustments for age and case-mix variations are probably the most important causes for differences. For the general population, personal Cox-adjusted data show no difference between CAPD and HD up to ten-year follow-up, with very close curves for the adults and non-significant differences for the elderly. Old elderly (> 75 years) have better survival on CAPD in the first years of treatment. Dropout, which is higher on CAPD, decreases with age, and the patient retention on CAPD is worse than on HD for all patients, except the old elderly, for whom it is similar. These data were obtained in patients receiving a standard treatment, modified in order to give a more adequate dialysis dose only in recent years. The results of a prospective three-year study on the effect of nutritional [serum albumin and transferrin, normalized protein catabolic rate (PCRN), and subjective global assessment of malnutrition] and adequacy indices [Kt/V, creatinine clearance (Ccr), residual renal function] on patient survival on CAPD and HD are reported. Survival was not different for the two methods. Using the Cox analysis, nutritional indices did not affect survival whereas adequacy indices did. The effect of low serum albumin on survival was referable to the predialysis nutritional state. The similar survivals obtained on CAPD and HD, with Kt/V more or less than 1.0/treatment for HD and 1.7/week for CAPD, support the "peak concentration hypothesis" of Keshaviah et al. Survival in different groups of patients with different Kt/V and Ccr shows that the adequate dose on CAPD is Kt/V between 1.96 and 2.03 and Ccr > or = 70 L/week. A group of 26 patients who remained on CAPD treatment for more than eight years was also studied. Patient age and predialysis comorbidity were the most important factors affecting survival. Patients surviving longest had > 3 g/dL of serum albumin, > 0.8 g/kg/day of PCRN, a Kt/V > 1.6, and a weekly Ccr > 54L/week.

Predictive value of dialysis adequacy and nutritional indices for mortality and morbidity in CAPD and HD patients. A longitudinal study.

BACKGROUND: The effects of dialysis inadequacy on patient survival and nutritional status and that of malnutrition on survival have not been clearly assessed. Studies comparing dose/mortality and morbidity curves on continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) and on haemodialysis (HD) are also needed, to assess adequate treatment on CAPD. METHODS: We have evaluated the effects of age, 13 pretreatment risk factors, serum albumin, transferrin, normalized protein catabolic rate, Kt/V, normalized weekly creatinine clearance, residual renal function and subjective global assessment of nutritional status on survival and morbidity, in a 3-year prospective study of 68 CAPD and 34 HD patients. RESULTS: Survivals did not differ for CAPD and HD patients. In the Cox hazard regression model, age, peripheral vasculopathy, serum albumin < 3.5 g/dl and Kt/V < 1.0/treatment on HD and < 1.7/week on CAPD were independent factors negatively affecting survival. On the contrary, adjusted survivals were not affected by gender, modality, other comorbid factors, normalized protein catabolic rate, or subjective global assessment of nutritional status. Persistence of residual renal function significantly improved survival. Observed and adjusted survival did not significantly differ for CAPD and HD patients with either low (HD, < 1.0/treatment; CAPD, < 1.7/week) or high ( > or = 1.0 and > or = 1.7) Kt/V. On HD, adjusted survivals were similar for 1.0 < or = Kt/V < 1.2 or > or = 1.2. On CAPD, Kt/V > or = 1.96/week was associated with definitely better survival, with only one death/23 patients versus 19/45, with Kt/V < or = 1.96. Survival was not different for 1.96 < or = Kt/V < 2.03 and > or = 2.03. Normalized weekly creatinine clearance and wKt/V were positively related on CAPD (r 0.39, P < 0.01) and wKt/V = 1.96 corresponded to 58 litres of normalized weekly creatinine clearance. CONCLUSIONS: Indices of adequacy were predictors of mortality and morbidity, both on CAPD and HD, whereas normalized protein catabolic rate and subjective global assessment of nutritional status were not. Serum albumin did not decrease during dialysis; hence its predictive effect for survival is due to the predialysis condition and not to dialysis-induced malnutrition.

Dialysis-related amyloidosis in a large CAPD population.

We studied 212 patients from 13 Italian dialysis centers to evaluate the clinical aspects of dialysis-related amyloidosis in continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD). The mean age was 64.2 +/- 12.3 years and mean time on dialysis was 36.9 +/- 25.1 months. Residual diuresis was 615.7 +/- 554.0 mL/day and plasma beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2M) level was 27.0 +/- 12.8 mg/L. Radiological skeletal examination, neurological problems related to beta 2M, and urinary and dialytic balance of beta 2M were evaluated. Correlations between age, time on dialysis, residual diuresis, beta 2M plasma levels, beta 2M peritoneal and renal removal, carpal tunnel syndrome, and bone disease were studied. Only the number of bone lesions had a significant positive correlation with patient age and negative correlation with residual diuresis. The latter had an inverse relation with beta 2M plasma levels. Dialytic age did not correlate with any of the parameters. No other correlation was observed. Hand lesions were found in 85% of patients with bone dialysis-related amyloidosis. In conclusion, residual diuresis in our patients played a positive role in the number of bone localizations. Only age, but not time on dialysis, had a positive impact on the bone lesions. The high percentage of hand lesions suggests that the observation of this skeletal segment is a simple, safe, and effective modality of bone follow-up for dialysis-related amyloidosis.

Which treatment for which patient in the future? Possible modifications in CAPD.

On 578 unselected new patients followed from 1981 through 1993, 51% on CAPD and 49% on HD, long-term patient and method survivals, cause of death, and drop-out in the two methods were compared. Survival, adjusted for patient selection biases, was not different on CAPD and HD up to 10 years. 50% of the patients were still in their first treatment after 3.5 years on CAPD and after 7 years on HD, and 5 and 28% respectively, after 10 years. Patient survival on CAPD was not falsely improved by drop-outs. Drop-out is increasing for CAPD, mainly due to patient/partner burn-out, which should be relieved by a more liberal application of automated PD. Malnutrition is more frequent on CAPD than on HD but not for the elderly. In a 3 year prospective study on 60 CAPD and 34 HD patients serum albumin, nPCR and nutritional status, as assessed by SGA did not influence survival in each modality. Survival was similar with K(p,r)t/V > or = 1.7/week on CAPD and Kt/V > or = 1/treatment on HD, and worse below these values. On CAPD, a Kp,rt/V > or = 1.96 gave better survivals.

Low incidence of peritonitis with the T-set.

Peritonitis is still one of the most important complications of peritoneal dialysis. Over the last few years, many efforts have been made in developing new device systems. A remarkable improvement has been obtained by modifying the original connection between the catheter and the bag, especially after the introduction of the Y-set. The aim of this study was to verify whether the use of a new device system, called the T-set, could reduce the incidence of peritonitis. This connector adds the advantages of the Y-set to those of the twin bag. In a group of 53 patients enrolled in a three-year period with a follow-up of 797 patient-months, we observed an incidence of peritonitis of one episode every 50 months. Furthermore, in the subgroup of 39 new patients, we observed an incidence of peritonitis of one episode every 89 patient-months. This new device can be a further step in the evolution of connectors that reduce the incidence of peritonitis.

Simultaneous catheter replacement-removal during infectious complications in peritoneal dialysis.

The aim of this study was to verify whether the replacement of the peritoneal catheter in a single operation and during infectious complications of peritoneal dialysis is effective and safe. Sixty-eight infectious complications refractory to appropriate antibiotic therapy were treated by this technique: 26 tunnel infections, 22 peritonitis-complicating tunnel infections, 12 refractory peritonitis, and 8 recurrent peritonitis. Operations were successful in all cases of tunnel infection and recurring peritonitis, and in all cases but one of peritonitis-complicating tunnel infection. Ten failures occurred among the 12 catheters removed for refractory peritonitis. Microorganisms cultured in these 10 failures were: Fungi (3 cases), Mycobacterium (2 cases), Pseudomonas (2 cases), Acinetobacter (1 case), Acinetobacter+Pseudomonas (1 case), and Enterococcus (1 case). Complications were 3 one-way obstructions and 2 external dialysate leaks. This study supports the simultaneous catheter replacement-removal procedure during infectious complications of peritoneal dialysis (PD) with the exception of refractory peritonitis; this technique spares the patient the temporary vascular access, the shift to hemodialysis, and a second operation to insert a new catheter. There are few complications.

Morbidity and mortality of CAPD and hemodialysis.

We have reappraised studies on morbidity and mortality in continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD), comparing it with hemodialysis (HD), the standard treatment for end-stage renal disease (ESRD). More hospitalization is required for CAPD, the difference being related to peritonitis, to the more frequent presence of some risk factors (such as diabetes and atherosclerosis) in the patients selected for CAPD, and to the lack of experience in the early years of CAPD practice. CAPD patients have less acute morbidity during treatment that not always requires hospitalization: hypotension, hypertension, arrhythmias, and myocardial ischemia. Cardiac performance is also better in CAPD patients, who develop less myocardial hypertrophy than HD patients. Hospitalization due to infectious disease not referable to technique, beta 2-microglobulin related morbidity, signs of uremic neuropathy, osteodystrophy, and malnutrition are similar in both groups. Method survival is better for HD, the difference being completely accounted for by peritonitis. Patient survival adjusted for pre-treatment differences is similar in CAPD and HD, and this is not an artifact of more drop-outs on CAPD. A high incidence of peritonitis is accompanied by an increased risk of death. Older patients have a lesser risk of death on CAPD than on HD. Diabetics have a worse survival than non-diabetics, with no difference between the two methods. Although patient survivals on CAPD and HD are the same, differences in the mode of blood purification have an interesting impact on particular aspects of morbidity.

Clinical manifestations in patients on chronic dialysis with high titres of ANCA.

Eight untreated patients with an apparent renal-limited disease continued to maintain high titres of ANCA long after the onset of the disease and the start of dialysis. In spite of the high ANCA titres, three of them remained for a long time free of symptoms related to the disease. Three pts developed, at various times from the beginning of the disease, fatal pulmonary hemorrhages.

Hospitalization: CAPD versus hemodialysis and transplant.

We studied morbidity in 648 patients treated in our center in a ten-year period as indicated by duration of hospitalization: 232 patients were on CAPD, 188 on hemodialysis (HD) and 228 had cadaveric kidney transplants (Tx). Duration of hospitalization was divided into four groups according to its causes. The age of the patients on CAPD was 61 +/- 14 years, 53 +/- 17 on HD and 36 +/- 10 in the Tx group. The total follow-up was 629 patient-year (p-y) on CAPD, 458 p-y on HD and 928 p-y on Tx. The first admission was longer on CAPD (30 +/- 18 days) and on Tx (36 +/- 18 days) than on HD (18 +/- 12). After the first admission, the total days of hospitalization (days/patient-year, d/p-y) were more for CAPD than HD and Tx. Analysis of these data showed that the difference was due to peritonitis and to the different percentage of elderly patients in the CAPD group. With a reduction in the incidence of infectious complications (peritonitis, tunnel or exit-site), hospitalization in CAPD could be reduced to a length of time similar to that currently needed by HD and Tx patients. This can result in important cost-saving.

Nutritional status in long-term CAPD patients.

We studied normalized urea nitrogen appearance (NUNA), normalized protein catabolic rate (NPCR), and normalized daily creatinine excretion (NDCE) in twenty-one patients (15 men, 6 women; mean age 63 +/- 9 years) on CAPD for more than 4 years (80 +/- 27 months). In the same patients we evaluated the changes in serum albumin and transferrin with time. After 74 +/- 26 months on CAPD, NUNA was 0.12 +/- 0.03 g/Kg IBW/day, NPCR = 1.09 +/- 0.19 g/Kg IBW/day; NDCE = 15.1 +/- 3.1 mg/Kg IBW/day; serum albumin = 3.8 +/- 0.2 g/dl. NUNA was correlated with NPCR (p < 0.001) and both were correlated with NDCE (p = 0.007 and p = 0.008). NPCR significantly decreased as patient age increased (p = 0.007) but was not correlated with time on CAPD, sex or serum albumin. Serum albumin did not change as age increased. Serum albumin and serum transferrin had not significantly changed after 4 years (after 8 years in a subgroup of eight patients). Finally, we compared these data to the initial data recorded for the same patients (mean interval: 64 +/- 21 months). NUNA, NPCR and NDCE did not change significantly. Changes in NPCR were directly related to changes in NDCE (p = 0.019). This study supports that long-term CAPD does not necessarily impair nutritional status and suggests that the oldest patients can maintain stable serum albumin concentrations on lower protein intake than younger ones.

Is CAPD competitive with haemodialysis for long-term treatment of uraemic patients?

Although there are only 10 years of clinical experience with CAPD, compared to about 30 years of clinical practice with haemodialysis, it is time to compare the results obtained from the two methods. In this review, after briefly summarising the state of the art for some worrisome aspects of CAPD (peritonitis, loss of ultrafiltration and peritoneal clearance, malnutritional status), the ability of CAPD and haemodialysis to control the uraemic abnormalities are compared. Anaemia, blood pressure, cardiac function, renal bone disease, beta 2-microglobulin, and uraemic neuropathy are examined in the light of our personal experience and the literature; data so far published seem to indicate that the two methods are roughly similar for controlling these conditions. A survey of the studies comparing patient and method survival is also included. Patient survival on CAPD or on haemodialysis does not differ by more than 6 years. Method survival is better for haemodialysis; this is primarily due to the high drop-out rate from CAPD because of peritonitis, and the difference is very much reduced in CAPD centres with a low incidence of peritonitis. On the whole, CAPD seems to be able to compete, sometimes favourably, with haemodialysis. However, in our opinion the two methods are not in competition; each has its preferential indications, limits and complications, and both should be offered to uraemic patients in accordance with their medical or social needs. One should be ready to shift the patient from one method to the other when necessary, either for short periods of time or indefinitely.

A six-year comparison of patient and technique survivals in CAPD and HD.

Comparisons of patient and technique survival were made for 120 CAPD and 139 HD patients undergoing dialysis between January 1981 and December 1986. Cox's proportional hazard regression model was used to compare patient and technique survival, with an adjustment for pre-treatment prognostic differences. Only the patients' first treatments were considered. The CAPD patients were 10 years older, on the average, than the HD patients and had more complicated conditions (58% with 3 or more co-existing risk factors vs. 35%). Overall patient survival between CAPD and HD did not differ (P = 0.2694). However, when adjusted for patient age, sex and other comorbid complicating conditions, CAPD patients over the age of 66 had a significantly lower risk of death than their HD counterparts (P less than 0.05). There were no differences in the adjusted patient survival for patients aged 30 to 66. Four pre-treatment prognostic factors had statistically significant adverse effects on patient survival: age, diabetes, malignancy and peripheral vascular disease. Survival of the HD technique, when unadjusted, was better than survival of CAPD (P = 0.0457). Even after adjustment for sex and age, this difference was still very nearly significant (P = 0.0656). No risk factors were found to be significantly associated with technique survival. Based on patient and technique survival, CAPD would appear to be an excellent alternative to HD and may be the preferred treatment for high risk patients over the age of 66.

CAPD is a first class treatment: results of an eight-year experience with a comparison of patient and method survival in CAPD and hemodialysis.

An 8-year experience on CAPD, in a single center with all treatments of ESRF (end-stage renal failure) available, is presented. Method choice was left to the patient, after extensive counselling. However, CAPD selection was very negative, and CAPD patients were older, with a much larger percentage of diabetics and loaded by more risk factors, suggesting an influence of the staff preferences on patient choice. After a first period with unsatisfactory results, we obtained an important improvement of patient and method survival coinciding with the introduction of a new connector with disinfectant (Y-system) which allowed a reduction of peritonitis rate to 1 episode for 36 patient/months. For the period 1.1.81 to 31.12.86 a comparison was made (life table analysis) between new ESRF patients placed initially on CAPD or on HD. The 5-year survival was not statistically different in spite of the very negative CAPD selection of patients, who were 10 years older, on the average. Excluding diabetics, survival curves were identical in the two methods. Age at death and causes of death were not different. Method survival was better on HD (98% vs. 71% on CAPD, at 5 years, p less than 0.01): significance and limits of this evaluation are discussed. Drop-out figures were definitely lower than in the literature and this was attributed to the sharp reduction in peritonitis rate. Only 1.7% of CAPD patients discontinued the method due to inadequate ultrafiltration. In 29 CAPD and 28 HD patients with more than 4 years treatment some biochemical and clinical data were compared. Serum cholesterol was significantly higher and serum proteins lower in CAPD.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)