Testing spirometers: are the standard curves of the american thoracic society sufficient?

BACKGROUND: The performance of spirometers is often measured only under ideal conditions, with a mechanical simulator reproducing the expiratory standard American Thoracic Society (ATS) curves generated by a computer. Studies have questioned the value of these results in real-life conditions. The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy and precision of 5 office spirometers with a flow-volume simulator using the ATS curves and using flow-volume curves obtained from patients. METHODS: We measured the FVC, peak expiratory flow, and FEV1 by simulating different dynamic waveforms applied by a computer-driven syringe, the Hans Rudolph flow-volume simulator. In addition to testing standard curves recommended by the ATS, we also tested curves obtained with subjects. RESULTS: The precision of the office spirometers was good and comparable using the standard ATS curves. One device presented the best performances in terms of accuracy and precision according to the ATS recommendations, but we observed significant biases in all devices with Bland-Altman analysis, particularly with the curves obtained from subjects with severe COPD. CONCLUSIONS: The global quality of most spirometers makes them acceptable for the detection of pulmonary diseases. However, we demonstrated accuracy issues not shown by the standard testing procedure. We propose to improve the testing of spirometers by implementing more realistic flow-volume curves and to refine the analysis of the results.

Validation of a 1D patient-specific model of the arterial hemodynamics in bypassed lower-limbs: simulations against in vivo measurements.

The validation of a coupled 1D-0D model of the lower-limb arterial hemodynamics is presented. This study focuses on pathological subjects (6 patients, 72.7±11.1 years) suffering from atherosclerosis who underwent a femoro-popliteal bypass surgery. The 1D model comprises four vessels from the upper-leg, peripheral networks are modeled with three-element windkessels and in vivo velocity is prescribed at the inlet. The model is patient-specific: its parameters reflect the physiological condition of the subjects. In vivo data are acquired invasively during bypass surgery using B-mode ultrasonography and catheter. Simulations from the model compare well with measured velocity (u) and pressure (p) waveforms: average relative root-mean-square error between numerical and experimental waveforms are limited to εp=9.6%, εu=16.0%. The model is able to reproduce the intensity and shape of waveforms observed in different clinical cases. This work also details the introduction of blood leakages along the pathological arterial network, and the sensitivity of the model to its parameters. This study constitutes a first validation of a patient-specific numerical model of a pathological arterial network. It presents an efficient tool for engineers and clinicians to help them improve their understanding of the hemodynamics in diseased arteries.

Technical assessment of spirometers connected in series.

BACKGROUND: Office spirometers are now widely used to detect obstructive lung diseases. To test the technical characteristics of these devices, simulation of different forced expiratory maneuvers is performed, using computer generated waveforms. However, the tests with human subjects are also useful to detect technical flaws. The procedure used by some authors to test the accuracy of office spirometers is to compare measurements made by 2 spirometers connected in series. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of this latter procedure. METHODS: Two sets of 2 spirometers connected in series were used: the PocketSpiro with the MicroLoop, and the PocketSpiro with the SpiroScout. Different standard American Thoracic Society curves were selected for both ambient temperature and pressure (ATP) and body temperature and pressure saturated (BTPS) conditions and generated with a waveform simulator. We compared lung function indices (FVC, peak expiratory flow, and FEV(1)) recorded by the PocketSpiro when it was placed respectively upstream or downstream in the assembly. RESULTS: In ATP conditions, lung function indices were generally higher when the spirometer was placed downstream rather than upstream. The observed deviations reached up to 10%. In BTPS conditions, lung function indices were underestimated when the spirometer was placed downstream, as compared to the ATP procedure. The modification of the flow characteristics and the temperature drop are the 2 mechanisms that could explain our results. CONCLUSIONS: Connecting the spirometers in series gives variable results, depending on the position of the spirometer in the assembly. Individual tests are therefore essential, as results are not interchangeable.

Inlet boundary conditions for blood flow simulations in truncated arterial networks.

In the context of patient-specific cardiovascular applications, hemodynamics models (going from 3D to 0D) are often limited to a part of the arterial tree. This restriction implies the set up of artificial interfaces with the remaining parts of the cardiovascular system. In particular, the inlet boundary condition is crucial: it supplies the impulsion to the system and receives the reflected backward waves created by the distal network. Some aspects of this boundary condition need to be properly defined such as the treatment of backward waves (reflected or absorbed) and the value of the imposed hemodynamic wave (total or forward component). Most authors prescribe as inlet boundary condition (BC) the total measured variable (pressure, velocity or flow rate) in a reflective way. We show that with this type of inlet boundary condition, the model does not produce physiological waveforms. We suggest instead to prescribe only the forward component of the prescribed variable in an absorbing way. In this way, the computed reflected waves superpose with the prescribed forward waves to produce the total wave at the inlet. In this work, different inlet boundary conditions are implemented and compared for a 1D blood flow model. We test our boundary conditions on a truncated arterial model presented in the literature as well as on a patient-specific lower-limb model of a femoral bypass. We show that with this new boundary condition, a much better fitting is observed on the shape and intensity of the simulated pressure and velocity waves.

Thermal and hydrodynamic modelling of active catheters for interventional radiology.

Interventional radiologists desire to improve their operating tools such as catheters. Active catheters in which the tip is moved using shape memory alloy actuators activated using the Joule effect present a promising approach for easier navigation in the small vessels. However, the increase in temperature caused by this Joule effect must be controlled in order to prevent damage to blood cells and tissues. This paper is devoted to the simulation and experimental validation of a fluid-thermal model of an active catheter prototype. Comparisons between computer-predicted and experimentally measured temperatures are presented for both experiments in air and water at 37°C. Good agreement between the computational and experimental results is found, demonstrating the validity of the developed computer model. These comparisons enable us to highlight some important issues in the modelling process and to determine the optimal current for the activation of the catheter.

Accurate modelling of unsteady flows in collapsible tubes.

The context of this paper is the development of a general and efficient numerical haemodynamic tool to help clinicians and researchers in understanding of physiological flow phenomena. We propose an accurate one-dimensional Runge-Kutta discontinuous Galerkin (RK-DG) method coupled with lumped parameter models for the boundary conditions. The suggested model has already been successfully applied to haemodynamics in arteries and is now extended for the flow in collapsible tubes such as veins. The main difference with cardiovascular simulations is that the flow may become supercritical and elastic jumps may appear with the numerical consequence that scheme may not remain monotone if no limiting procedure is introduced. We show that our second-order RK-DG method equipped with an approximate Roe's Riemann solver and a slope-limiting procedure allows us to capture elastic jumps accurately. Moreover, this paper demonstrates that the complex physics associated with such flows is more accurately modelled than with traditional methods such as finite difference methods or finite volumes. We present various benchmark problems that show the flexibility and applicability of the numerical method. Our solutions are compared with analytical solutions when they are available and with solutions obtained using other numerical methods. Finally, to illustrate the clinical interest, we study the emptying process in a calf vein squeezed by contracting skeletal muscle in a normal and pathological subject. We compare our results with experimental simulations and discuss the sensitivity to parameters of our model.

A numerical hemodynamic tool for predictive vascular surgery.

We suggest a new approach to peripheral vascular bypass surgery planning based on solving the one-dimensional (1D) governing equations of blood flow in patient-specific models. The aim of the present paper is twofold. First, we present the coupled 1D-0D model based on a discontinuous Galerkin method in a comprehensive manner, such as it becomes accessible to a wider community than the one of mathematicians and engineers. Then we show how this model can be applied to predict hemodynamic parameters and help therefore clinicians to choose for the best surgical option bettering the hemodynamics of a bypass. After presenting some benchmark problems, we apply our model to a real-life clinical application, i.e. a femoro-popliteal bypass surgery. Our model shows good agreement with preoperative and intraoperative measurements of velocity and pressure and post-surgical reports.