ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Law enforcement traffic stops are one of the most common entryways to the US justice system. Conventional frameworks suggest traffic stops promote public safety by reducing dangerous driving practices and non-vehicular crime with little to no collateral damage to individuals and communities. Critical frameworks interrogate these assumptions, identifying significant individual and community harms that disparately impact Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) and low-income communities. METHODS: The Public Health Critical Race Praxis (PHCRP) and multi-level frameworks from community anti-racist training were combined into a structured diagram to guide intervention and research teams in contrasting conventional and critical perspectives on traffic stops. The diagram divides law enforcement and drivers/residents as two separate agent types that interact during traffic stops. These two agent types have different conventional and critical histories, priorities, and perspectives at multiple levels, including individual, interpersonal, institutional, and cultural levels. Conventional solutions (identifying explicitly racist officers, "meet-a-cop" programs, police interaction training for drivers) are born from conventional frameworks (rewarding crime prevention regardless of cost, the war on drugs saves lives, driver behavior perfectionism). While conventional perspectives focus on individual and interpersonal levels, critical perspectives more deeply acknowledge dynamics at institutional and cultural levels. Critical solutions may be hard to discover without critical frameworks, including that law enforcement creates measurable collateral damage and disparate social control effects; neighborhood patrol priorities can be set without community self-determination or accountability and may trump individual and interpersonal dynamics; and the war on drugs is highly racialized and disproportionally enforced through traffic stop programs. CONCLUSIONS: Traffic stop enforcement and crash prevention programs that do not deeply and critically consider these dynamics at multiple levels, not just law enforcement-driver interactions at the individual and interpersonal levels, may be at increased risk of propagating histories of BIPOC discrimination. In contrast, public health and transportation researchers and practitioners engaged in crash and injury prevention strategies that employ law enforcement should critically consider disparate history and impacts of law enforcement in BIPOC communities. PHCRP, anti-racism frameworks, and the included diagram may assist them in organizing critical thinking about research studies, interventions, and impacts.
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Lower proteoglycan density (PGD) of the articular cartilage may be an early marker of osteoarthritis following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACL-R). The purpose this study was to determine associations between the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcomes Score (KOOS) and PGD of the articular cartilage in the femur and tibia 12-months following ACL-R. METHODS: We evaluated KOOS pain, symptoms, function in activities of daily living (ADL), function in sport and recreation (Sport), and quality of life (QOL), as well as PGD using T1rho magnetic resonance imaging in 18 individuals 12.50±0.70months (these are all mean±standard deviation) following unilateral ACL-R (10 females, eight males; 22.39±4.19years; Marx Score=10.93±3.33). Medial and lateral load-bearing portions of the femoral and tibial condyles were sectioned into three (anterior, central and posterior) regions of interest (ROIs). T1rho relaxation times in the ACL-R knee were normalized to the same regions of interest in the non-surgical knees. Alpha levels were set at P≤0.05. RESULTS: Worse KOOS outcomes were significantly associated with greater T1rho relaxation time ratios in the posterior-lateral femoral condyle [pain (r=-0.54), ADL (r=-0.56), Sport (r=-0.62) and QOL (r=-0.59)] central-lateral femoral condyle [Sport (r=-0.48) and QOL (r=-0.42)], and the anterior-medial femoral condyle [Sport (r=-0.46) and QOL (r=-0.40)]. There were no significant associations between the KOOS and T1rho outcomes for tibial ROI. CONCLUSIONS: Lower PGD of the femoral cartilage in the ACL-R knees was associated with worse patient-reported outcomes.
