Retrospective study of 70 cases of severe frostbite lesions: a proposed new classification scheme.

OBJECTIVE: Previous frostbite classifications were mainly based on retrospective diagnosis and, most of the time, could not be used to predict the final outcome of the lesions and especially the probability of an amputation and its level. The aim of this study was to suggest a new classification at day 0 based mainly on the topography of the lesions and on early bone scan results, which are more convenient and accurate in predicting the final outcome of frostbites. METHODS: The retrospective study of the clinical histories of 70 patients hospitalized at Chamonix Hospital (Mont-Blanc Massif) from 1985 to 1999 for severe frostbite injuries of the extremities has allowed us to classify the aspects of the initial lesions on day 0 and to compare them with final outcomes. RESULTS: A strong correlation was found between the extent of the lesion and the outcome of each finger or toe. When the initial lesion was on the distal phalanx, the probability of bone amputation was around 1% for the digit, 31% for the middle phalanx, 67% for the proximal phalanx, 98% for the metacarpal/metatarsal, and 100% for the carpal/tarsal. CONCLUSIONS: Based on these clinical results and on the results of bone scans (previously validated), a new classification of frostbite severity at day 0 is proposed. Four degrees of severity are defined: first degree, leading to recovery; second degree, leading to soft tissue amputation; third degree, leading to bone amputation, and fourth degree, leading to large amputation with systemic effects.

The value of technetium 99 scintigraphy in the prognosis of amputation in severe frostbite injuries of the extremities: A retrospective study of 92 severe frostbite injuries.

We report a retrospective study of the prognostic value of 2-phase technetium 99m bone scanning performed in 92 patients who presented to Chamonix Hospital with severe frostbite of the extremities in the past 12 years. The results of this study show that an initial bone scan (as early as day 3) has excellent specificity in evaluating the severity of frostbite injury. There was a direct correlation between the demarcation zone of uptake in the phalanges and the eventual level of amputation (positive predictive value, 0.84). A second scan on approximately day 7 was even more sensitive and informative. A strong correlation existed between positive uptake and eventual healing (negative predictive value, 0.99). This study showed that (99m)Tc bone scanning in the first few days after frostbite injury indicates the level of amputation in severe frostbite in more than 84% of cases. We propose an algorithm based on the results of this study that can be used to evaluate new medical and surgical management of frostbite injury.

The role of bone scanning in severe frostbite of the extremities: a retrospective study of 88 cases.

We performed a retrospective study of the results of two-phase technetium-99m hydroxymethylene diphosphonate bone scans in 88 patients with severe frostbite of the extremities. All patients were evaluated within 48 h after rewarming and all underwent a first bone scan (BS1) within 5 days after rewarming (median, day 2) (group 1). An excellent correlation was found between absence of tracer uptake in the phalanges and later amputation; this correlation was especially strong during the bone phase of the scans (specificity = 0.99, sensitivity = 0.96, positive predictive value = 0.92). Normal or high uptake in the phalanges was a reliable indicator of ultimate healing (negative predictive value = 0.99). The sensitivity of the examination was enhanced by performing a second scan (BS2) more than 5 days (median, day 8) after rewarming (group 2, n = 36). A comparative analysis of BS1 and BS2 demonstrated that some of the lesions continued to evolve between day 2 and day 8. This suggests that the lesions could still be modified during this period. On the basis of the findings it is recommended that bone scan be performed close to day 2 in all patients who present with lesions extending proximally to include the entirety of one or more phalanges. In the case of severe sepsis, the results of the first bone scan, BS1, can serve as an indication for emergency amputation. BS2 should be performed close to day 8 only if there is an area of low or absent uptake on BS1. It is concluded that scintigraphy is an excellent means of evaluating patients with severe frostbite of the extremities: as early as day 2 after the injury it can indicate whether amputation is necessary, and between days 2 and 8 it provides valuable information on the efficacy of treatment.

Medical mountain rescue in the Mont-Blanc massif.

Because of its peculiar geographic location beneath Mont-Blanc, the Chamonix Hospital plays an important role in the management of mountaineering- and skiing-related traumatic injuries. The authors, thanks to the study of 5200 mountain rescue medical reports, set out to explain the different aspects of this activity: epidemiology, specific equipment, care in the field, reception and primary survey, dispatching, common therapeutic attitudes, progress, and results. In the dangerous environment of the high mountains, emphasis is put on the physicians' experience, allowing an early evacuation in the best conditions to the hospital. Diagnosis at the scene of the accident is very basic, and the initial treatment is based on immobilization, analgesia, and sedating. In the case of resuscitation, only the vital maneuvers are performed; these actions are carried on during the short flight and improved in the crash rooms. Finally, different specific pathologies are mentioned, including cold- or heat-related injuries, exhaustion, lightning strikes, and mountain sickness.

[Hypothermia in traumatology]. / Hypothermie en traumatologie.

Basing on the experience of the Chamonix hospital team which managed in six years 89 cases of hypothermia in trauma patients, this article reviewed the literature concerning the association hypothermia-trauma. Shock is a major triggering factor. The deleterious effects of hypothermia on the outcome is due to inadequate cardiorespiratory adaptation to shock and to increased bleeding. Although a few articles reported a beneficial effect of hypothermia in head trauma, further studies are required to assess the value of deliberate hypothermia in such patients. Restoration of a satisfactory haemodynamic activity is a priority and most often requires surgery. The rewarming manoeuvres should be initiated early and always be preventive. They are active, internal and rapid in case of haemodynamic instability and when the central temperature is below 32 degrees C. It can be more progressive and less invasive in other cases. During recovery from anaesthesia the patient must be closely monitored. In spite of a possible protecting effect, hypothermia remains an aggravating factor in traumatology and must therefore be either prevented or amended.

[Frostbite: findings May 1990]. / Les gelures: mise au point mai 1990.

Frostbites are a frequent pathology in mountain sports; we treat 80 cases per years in Chamonix. Usually due to a bad equipment, they are favoured by humidity, wind, the high altitude polycythemia and dehydration. Physiopathology associates a physic phenomenon (freezing) with a vasomotor response. Diagnosis is obvious; the forecast rests on the bone scintigraphy and treatment combines fast warm up, vasodilators, hemodilution and late surgery. Only 8% of our patients have amputations. The best treatment is prevention.

[Lightning injuries in high mountain areas. Report of 29 cases]. / Les accidents de fulguration en haute-montagne. A propos de 29 cas.

Lightning, usually scarce, is a frequent phenomenon in high mountains. Due to our location at the foot of the Mont-Blanc, we have been able to examine twenty nine cases of people struck by lightning in the Chamonix Hospital. Lightning that has interested people since old times is the result of complex meteorological phenomenons, able to deliver a huge instant power. Several types of lightning have been described. They give different sorts of injuries; the most frequent affect the brain, the heart and the skin. The analysis of the results of seventeen victims admitted at the hospital does not allow to conclude to a clinical and biological specificity of the lightning stricken in high mountains. It makes it however possible to determine precisely the clinical disorders and the features of the injured and to emphasize the part due to the high mountains and consider the non specific therapeutic to set to work as soon as possible.