Individuality of Ag-selected and preimmune TCR repertoires.

We have combined flow cytometry and single-cell PCR to characterize the TCRBV repertoires selected by individual mice in a model CD8 response against a defined peptide/MHC complex (CW3 170-1 79/Kd). Ourresults established thatdifferent mice select individually distinct yet structurally similar CW3-specific repertoires. Repertoire selection appears to be flexible depending on the immunizing cell dose. Using a single-donor, matched-pair-recipient adoptive transfer strategy, we demonstrated that the CW3-specific TCR repertoires of normal mice are already distinct at the preimmune level. We combine our data with computer simulations to test models for the composition of an Ag-specific preimmune repertoire and its selection during an immune response.

Comparative T cell receptor repertoire selection by antigen after adoptive transfer: a glimpse at an antigen-specific preimmune repertoire.

The low frequency of precursor cells specific for any particular antigen (Ag) makes it difficult to characterize preimmune T cell receptor (TCR) repertoires and to understand repertoire selection during an immune response. We have undertaken a combined adoptive transfer single-cell PCR approach to probe the Ag-specific preimmune repertoires of individual mice. Our strategy was to inject paired irradiated recipient mice with normal spleen cells prepared from individual donors and to compare the TCR repertoires subsequently selected during a CD8 response to a defined model Ag. We found that although some TCRs were shared, the TCR repertoires selected by mice receiving splenocytes from the same donor were not identical in terms of the TCRs selected and their relative frequencies. Our results together with computer simulations imply that individual mice express distinct Ag-specific preimmune TCR repertoires composed of expanded clones and that selection by Ag is a random process.

A quantitative, single-cell PCR analysis of an antigen-specific TCR repertoire selected during an in vivo CD8 response: direct evidence for a wide range of clone sizes with uniform tissue distribution.

The development of T cell effector and memory responses against foreign antigens (Ags) involves the activation, differentiation and proliferation of naive T cells expressing distinct Ag-specific TCRs. Understanding the complexity of Ag-selected TCR repertoires in individual responders in terms of the sequences selected and their relative frequencies may provide indications about how a repertoire is established and suggest ways to influence the outcome of an immune response. Most methods of repertoire analysis are unsuitable for calculating the relative in vivo frequencies of Ag-specific clones (expressing distinct TCRs) selected during an immune response, whereas sequence data obtained by single-cell PCR analysis directly reflect cell frequencies if a sufficiently large number of cells is sampled. Using a CD8 T cell response in normal mice in which Ag-selected cells are identified by cell surface phenotype and rearranged TCRBV sequences are determined by PCR amplification of genomic DNA directly from single cells, we have analyzed a large number (>200 per animal) of structurally-related Ag-specific TCRs to calculate the frequencies of distinct TCRs selected by individual mice. We found that each responder selects a unique Ag-specific TCR repertoire in which the various TCRBV sequences are present in a wide range of frequencies. However, the overall distribution of sequences is quite similar for different responder animals. Moreover, an individual's selected TCR repertoire is uniformly represented among Ag-specific CD8 cells circulating in the blood or localized in the spleen or liver. Relatively few sequences make up the bulk of the repertoire and account for the oligoclonality observed in earlier studies. We discuss various models that could account for this skewed distribution of an Ag-selected TCR repertoire.

The diversity of antigen-specific TCR repertoires reflects the relative complexity of epitopes recognized.

Antigen-selected T cell receptor (TCR) repertoires vary in complexity from very limited to extremely diverse. We have previously characterized two different CD8 T cell responses, which are restricted by the same mouse major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecule, H-2 Kd. The TCR repertoire in the response against a determinant from Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite protein (PbCS; region 252-260) is very diverse, whereas TCRs expressed by clones specific for a determinant in region 170-179 of HLA-CW3 (human) MHC class I molecule show relatively limited structural diversity. We had already demonstrated that cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones specific for the PbCS peptide display diverse patterns of antigen recognition when tested with a series of single Ala-substituted PbCS peptides or mutant. H-2 Kd molecules. We now show that CW3-specific CTL clones display much less diverse patterns of recognition. Our earlier functional studies with synthetic peptide variants suggested that the optimal peptides recognized were 9 (or 8) residues long for PbCS and 10 residues long for CW3. We now present more direct evidence that the natural CW3 ligand is indeed a 10-mer. Our functional data together with molecular modeling suggest that the limited TCR repertoire selected during the CW3 response is not due to a paucity of available epitopes displayed at the surface of the CW3 peptide/Kd complex. We discuss other factors, such as the expression of similar self MHC peptide sequences, that might be involved in trimming this TCR repertoire.

Memory TCR repertoires analyzed long-term reflect those selected during the primary response.

Normal T cell repertoire selection and evolution in antigen-specific responses is poorly understood. We have recently described an MHC class I-restricted response characterized by an overwhelming expansion of CD8 cells expressing a Vbeta10 TCR, thus allowing the identification of antigen-selected cells directly ex vivo. Our present strategy to follow the overall TCR repertoire selection was to monitor the expression of a particular TCR alpha chain (Valpha8) on antigen-selected Vbeta10(+) cells by four-color flow cytometry. We demonstrate that while there is substantial variation among the responder mice in Valpha8 usage, the repertoires of individual animals remain relatively stable over long periods of time (>1 year), with or without repeated antigenic challenge. Thus if any evolution of this response occurs upon re-exposure to antigen, it would appear not to skew the TCR repertoire established during the primary response.

Single-cell PCR analysis of TCR repertoires selected by antigen in vivo: a high magnitude CD8 response is comprised of very few clones.

Taking advantage of a potent MHC class I-restricted response that allows the identification of antigen-selected CD8 T cells directly ex vivo, we characterized the antigen-specific T cell repertoires that develop in individual mice by single-cell PCR analysis. Each of the immune mice displayed distinct yet structurally similar TCR repertoires. The overall repertoire size was estimated to be in the range of 15-20 for most mice. No major differences were observed between primary and secondary responses. Moreover, for a hyperimmunized mouse the antigen-specific TCR repertoire expressed 8 months after the initial immunization was very similar to that found at the peak of the primary response. Our results demonstrate that a high magnitude immune response may be composed of very few clones, and that at least in the system analyzed, the memory response largely reflects the repertoire selected by the peak of the primary response.

Distinct phenotypes of antigen-selected CD8 T cells emerge at different stages of an in vivo immune response.

We have previously described a unique system for identifying Ag-selected CD8 T cells during an in vivo response in normal mice. In this system, lymphocytes isolated from DBA/2 mice injected i.p. with HLA-CW3 transfected syngeneic (H-2d) P815 cells show a remarkable expansion of CD8 cells that utilize TCR expressing the V beta 10 gene segment and additional structural features characteristic of Kd-restricted CW3-specific CTL clones. We have now taken advantage of this system to characterize the surface phenotype of CD8 cells selected by Ag in vivo. We observed several distinct phenotypes at different stages of the response. At the peak of the response, Ag-selected cells were low in CD62L and CD45RB expression but displayed high levels of CD44. In addition, there was a partial down-regulation of CD8 and TCR. Cells of this phenotype were present in lymphoid tissues for several mo after immunization. Much later in the response, Ag-selected cells expressed higher levels of CD8 and TCR. Moreover, a distinct subset of these long-term immune cells emerged that now expressed CD62L and CD45RB. Analysis of CD8 cells from different tissues also revealed certain differences, particularly in TCR and co-receptor levels from liver-derived cells compared with circulating cells at the peak of the response. Our findings suggest that the function of Ag-selected CD8 cells may be regulated over time and according to location by subtle changes in cell-surface phenotype.

Induction of a cytotoxic T cell response by co-injection of a T helper peptide and a cytotoxic T lymphocyte peptide in incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA): further enhancement by pre-injection of IFA alone.

We have previously demonstrated that it is possible to induce a consistent and strong cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response to synthetic peptides, corresponding to poorly immunogenic malaria CTL epitopes, by co-injecting them with peptides representing defined T helper (Th) epitopes in incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA). In this study we have tested different immunization protocols to improve further the elicitation of the CTL response. We show that the CTL response to a mixture of Th + CTL peptides administered in IFA was further enhanced by a previous injection of the Th epitope peptide in IFA. Moreover, we found that the response could be significantly augmented by a pre-injection of IFA alone. This enhancement was observed only if the Th epitope was also present in the second injection. The number of lymph node cells recovered was 2-3-fold higher in mice pre-injected with IFA, but the increase in specific CTL activity, expressed as lytic units per animal, by pre-injection of IFA was at least 10-20-fold. Thus, pre-injection of IFA clearly increases the magnitude of a subsequent CTL response.

MHC class I H-2Kd-restricted antigenic peptides: additional constraints for the binding motif.

The previously defined binding motif of MHC class I H-2Kd-restricted antigenic peptides consists of a Y residue in position P2 and a hydrophobic residue with a large aliphatic side chain (L, I, or V) in position P9/P10 of optimal 9- or 10-mer peptides. We show now that the presence of a charged or a F residue in position P5 reduces the Kd-restricted competitor activity of several cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) epitopes and model peptides, at a degree comparable to A substitutions for the P2 or the P9/P10 anchor residues. Various charged, polar, aromatic, and aliphatic amino acids were substituted for S256 in the CTL epitope Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite (CS) 253-260 8-mer and in its CS 252-260 9-mer form, whereas a more restricted panel of substitutions was tested in the CTL epitopes influenza nucleoprotein 147-155 9-mer and HLA-CW3 170-179 10-mer. Analysis of all the Kd-restricted epitopes so far defined also revealed an uncharged residue at this position. These additional structural constraints present in the Kd binding motif may thus improve the prediction of new epitopes recognized by T cells in the context of this MHC molecule.

Antigen-selected T-cell receptor diversity and self-nonself homology.

Recent studies indicate that the T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire selected by certain antigenic peptide-MHC combinations can be extremely diverse. This is in contrast to earlier studies reporting T-cell responses which were limited in terms of TCR diversity. In this viewpoint, we suggest these variations in TCR diversity may be explained by taking into account the homology between some antigens and self proteins to which T cells are tolerant.

Differential T cell receptor photoaffinity labeling among H-2Kd restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones specific for a photoreactive peptide derivative. Labeling of the alpha-chain correlates with J alpha segment usage.

Using a direct binding assay based on photoaffinity labeling, we studied the interaction of T cell receptor (TCR) with a Kd-bound photoreactive peptide derivative on living cells. The Kd-restricted Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite (PbCS) peptide 253-260 (YIPSAEKI) was reacted NH2-terminally with biotin and at the TCR contact residue Lys259 with photoreactive iodo, 4-azido salicylic acid (IASA) to make biotin-YIPSAEK(IASA)I. Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones derived from mice immunized with this derivative recognized this conjugate, but not a related one lacking the IASA group nor the parental PbCS peptide. The clones were Kd restricted. Recognition experiments with variant conjugates, lacking substituents from IASA, revealed a diverse fine specificity pattern and indicated that this group interacted directly with the TCR. The TCR of four clones could be photoaffinity labeled by biotin-YIPSAEK(125IASA)I. This labeling was dependent on the conjugates binding to the Kd molecule and was selective for the TCR alpha (2 clones) or beta chain (1 clone), or was common for both chains (1 clone). TCR sequence analysis showed a preferential usage of J alpha TA28 containing alpha chains that were paired with V beta 1 expressing beta chains. The TCR that were photoaffinity labeled at the alpha chain expressed these J alpha and V beta segments. The tryptophan encoded by the J alpha TA28 segment is rarely found in other J alpha segments. Moreover, we show that the IASA group interacts preferentially with tryptophan in aqueous solution. We thus propose that for these CTL clones, labeling of the alpha chain occurs via the J alpha-encoded tryptophan residue.

Oligoclonal expansion of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted cytolytic T lymphocytes during a primary immune response in vivo: direct monitoring by flow cytometry and polymerase chain reaction.

Previous T cell receptor (TCR) sequence analysis of a panel of 23 H-2Kd restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones recognizing the decapeptide HLA-CW3 170-179 revealed a striking conservation of TCR structure, in that all clones examined used V beta 10 and J alpha pHDS58 segments. We show here that the primary response in vivo after intraperitoneal injection of DBA/2 mice with HLA-CW3 expressing transfectants of syngeneic P815 (H-2d) tumor cells is characterized by a dramatic expansion of CD8+ V beta 10+ CTL in the peritoneal cavity and draining (mesenteric) lymph node, as well as in peripheral blood. Additional analysis of TCR on HLA-CW3 immune populations by flow cytometry and polymerase chain reaction further indicates that the vast majority of responding CD8+ cells express restricted V alpha domains, a dominant J alpha segment (pHDS58), and a conserved CDR3 length for both alpha and beta chains. This novel system provides a unique opportunity to directly monitor an oligoclonal primary antigen specific immune response in vivo at the single cell level independently of functional assays.

Photoaffinity labeling of the T cell receptor on living cytotoxic T lymphocytes.

Using a direct binding assay based on photoaffinity labeling, we have studied the interaction of an antigenic peptide with MHC class I molecules and the TCR on living cells. Two photoreactive derivatives of the H-2Kd (Kd) restricted Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite (PbCS) peptide 253-260 (YIPSAEKI) were used. The first derivative contained an N-terminal photoreactive iodo, 4-azido salicyloyl (IASA) group and biotin on the TCR contact residue Lys259 [IASA-YIPSAEK(biotin)I]. As previously described, this derivative selectively bound to and labeled the Kd molecule. The second photoreactive compound, the isomeric biotin-YIPSAEK(IASA)I, also efficiently bound to the Kd molecule, but failed to label this protein. A CTL clone derived from a mouse immunized with this derivative recognized this conjugate but not the parental P. berghei circumsporozoite peptide or the [IASA-YIPSAEK-(biotin)I] derivative in an Kd-restricted manner. Incubation of the cloned CTL cells with biotin-YIPSAEK(IASA)I, but not its isomer, followed by UV irradiation resulted in photoaffinity labeling of the TCR-alpha chain that was dependent on the conjugate binding to the Kd molecule. The TCR labeling was partially inhibited by anti-LFA 1 and anti-ICAM1 mAb, but was increased by addition of beta 2m or soluble KdQ10. The exquisite labeling selectivity of the two photoprobes opens a new, direct approach to the molecular analysis of antigen presentation and recognition by living CTL.

The interaction of antigenic peptides with the H-2Kd MHC class I molecule.

An important event in the recognition of antigen by T cells is the selective interaction of peptides with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. We have defined several critical structural features that promote the efficient interaction of antigenic peptides with the MHC class I molecule, H-2Kd. For four unrelated antigens, we found that optimal synthetic peptides were short, only 9 or 10 amino acids long. These and other H-2Kd-restricted peptides were found to share a distinct 2-residue binding motif. Two regions in the H-2Kd antigen binding site that might accommodate the motif residues were identified by analysis of Ala-substituted H-2Kd molecules. A molecular model showing the possible interaction of one antigenic peptide with the H-2Kd molecule is presented.

T cell receptor selection by and recognition of two class I major histocompatibility complex-restricted antigenic peptides that differ at a single position.

Peptides derived from HLA-Cw3 and HLA-A24 within region 170-179 differ by a single substitution, at position 173, and are both presented by the class I major histocompatibility complex molecule H-2Kd for recognition by murine cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs). As a first approach to understand the way T cell receptors (TCRs) intact with the HLA peptides, we have analyzed the TCR selection by, and recognition of, the two HLA antigenic sites. First, we have compared the TCR repertoires selected by HLA-Cw3 and HLA-A24, not only by sequencing the TCRs carried by CTL clones isolated and grown in vitro, but also by analyzing the TCRs expressed in vivo by peritoneal exudate lymphocytes from immune animals. Second, we have compared the TCR crossrecognition of HLA-A24 by CTLs selected by HLA-Cw3 with that of HLA-Cw3 by CTLs selected by HLA-A24. The combined analysis of TCR selection by and recognition of these two related HLA antigenic sites provides evidence that the TCR beta junctional regions interact with the amino-terminal part of the HLA peptides.

Highly diverse T cell recognition of a single Plasmodium berghei peptide presented by a series of mutant H-2Kd molecules.

We have tested 21 independent CTL clones for recognition of a single peptide derived from the Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite protein in the context of 13 mutants of the murine MHC class I molecule H-2Kd. In this series of Kd mutants, amino acid residues located on the upper surface of the alpha-helices were individually substituted by alanine. Remarkably, most clones displayed individual recognition patterns on the Kd mutants. We had previously found that this series of CTL clones was likewise highly diverse in terms of both TCR primary structure and peptide fine specificity. Our data thus reinforce the concept that multiple T cell epitopes are available on the surface of a single peptide-MHC class I complex for recognition by specific TCR.

T helper epitopes enhance the cytotoxic response of mice immunized with MHC class I-restricted malaria peptides.

We have previously derived MHC class I (H-2Kd) restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from BALB/c mice immunized with irradiated sporozoites from Plasmodium (P.) berghei and P. yoelii. The CTL recognize synthetic peptides corresponding to a region of the circumsporozoite (CS) protein that is homologous in the two species. In the present study, we have attempted to induce CS-specific CTL by immunization with those peptides in incomplete Freund's adjuvant. Only a low level CTL response was detected in BALB/c mice immunized with synthetic peptides corresponding to the Pb or Py CTL epitopes. In contrast, CS-specific CTL responses could be readily detected in mice injected with mixtures of peptides that combined the P. berghei or P. yoelii CTL epitopes with previously defined T helper epitopes. Several different T helper epitopes were shown to enhance the response when injected as separate peptides in a mixture, or when covalently linked to a CTL epitope. These results may have general implications for the elicitation of CTL responses to defined CTL epitopes and for the design of peptide-based synthetic vaccines.

Most residues on the floor of the antigen binding site of the class I MHC molecule H-2Kd influence peptide presentation.

A panel of 15 single alanine substitutions on the floor of the peptide binding groove of the murine class I histocompatibility molecule H-2Kd has been analyzed. All but two mutant molecules were expressed on the cell surface, and were tested for peptide binding and presentation to specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Eleven out of 13 mutant molecules appeared to be functionally altered. Five of the substituted residues were involved in the presentation of all peptides tested. Three participated in the presentation of certain peptides but not others. Three other residues participated in epitope formation through indirect interactions. Only two mutations had no detectable effect.

H-2-restricted cytolytic T lymphocytes specific for HLA display T cell receptors of limited diversity.

We previously showed that H-2Kd-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones specific for a single nonapeptide derived from the Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite (PbCS) protein displayed T cell receptors (TCRs) of highly diverse primary structure. We have now analyzed the TCR repertoire of CTLs that recognize a peptide derived from the human class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule HLA-Cw3 in association with the same murine class I MHC molecule H-2Kd. We first sequenced the TCR alpha and beta genes of the CTL clone Cw3/1.1 and, based on this genomic analysis, the TCR alpha and beta cDNA junctional regions of 23 independent H-2Kd-restricted CTL clones specific for HLA-Cw3. The results show that the TCR chains display very limited heterogeneity, both in terms of V alpha, J alpha, V beta, and J beta segments, and in terms of length and sequence of the CDR3 alpha and beta loops. The TCR repertoire used in vivo was then analyzed by harvesting CTL populations from the peritoneal cavity of immune mice. The peritoneal exudate lymphocytes (PELs) displayed HLA-Cw3-specific cytolytic activity in the absence of any stimulation in vitro. Remarkably, most of these freshly isolated PELs expressed TCRs that shared the same structural features as those from HLA-Cw3-reactive CTL clones. Thus, our results show that a peptide from HLA-Cw3 presented by H-2Kd selects CTLs that bear TCRs of very limited diversity in vivo. When taken together with the high diversity of the TCRs specific for the PbCS peptide, these findings suggest that natural tolerance to self peptides presented by class I MHC molecules may substantially reduce the size of the TCR repertoire of CTLs specific for antigenic peptides homologous to self.

Immunization with synthetic peptides containing a defined malaria epitope induces a highly diverse cytotoxic T lymphocyte response. Evidence that two peptide residues are buried in the MHC molecule.

In the present study, we have explored ways of inducing a CTL response to a previously defined H-2Kd MHC class I restricted epitope in the circumsporozoite (CS) protein of Plasmodium berghei, and studied in detail the fine specificity of the response. We found that the s.c. injection of a variety of synthetic peptides emulsified in Freund's adjuvant efficiently induced a specific CTL response in (BALB/c x C57BL/6)F1 (H-2d x H-2b) mice. In contrast, BALB/c mice responded only marginally, consistent with the possible requirement for a concomitant Th response that would be provided by the C57BL/6 strain. Similar to our previous observations in analyzing CTL clones from sporozoite-immunized mice, the CTL response induced by peptide immunization was in part cross-reactive with an epitope from the Plasmodium yoelii species. The minimal P. berghei CS epitope, the octapeptide PbCS 253-260, was studied in detail by the analysis of a series of variant CS peptides containing single Ala substitutions. The relative antigenic activity for each variant peptide was calculated for 28 different CTL clones. Overall, the response to this P. berghei CTL epitope appeared to be extremely diverse in terms of fine specificity. This was evident among the CTL derived from sporozoite-immunized mice, as well as among those from peptide-immunized animals. The heterogeneity found at the functional level correlates with the highly diverse TCR repertoire that we have found for the same series of CTL clones in a study that is reported separately. The relative competitor activity for each Ala-substituted peptide was also determined in a quantitative functional competition assay. For the residues (Tyr253 and Ile260) within the 8-mer CS peptide, substitution with Ala reduced competitor activity by at least 40-fold, and for two others the reduction was 5- to 10-fold. When the relative antigenic activity for each CTL/peptide combination was normalized to the relative competitor activity of the peptide, a striking pattern emerged. The two residues that most affected competitor activity showed no additional effect on recognition beyond that observed for competition. In marked contrast, Ala substitutions at the other five positions tested varied widely, depending on the CTL/peptide combination. This pattern not only supports a model whereby the Tyr253 and Ile260 residues anchor the peptide to the Kd molecule, but also implies that they are virtually inaccessible to the TCR.