Comparing perceptions and measurements of snoring.

The difficulty in measuring and quantifying snoring using objective criteria is that snoring is first and foremost of a subjective perception by a listener. To test the subjective perception of snoring and to compare it with objective measurements, we studied 25 patients referred to our laboratory because of snoring. All had full nocturnal polysomnography including measurements of snoring. Snoring sounds were recorded on paper and simultaneously stored on audiotape. The technologist scoring the polysomnogram counted the number of snores during a 20-minute segment. Two other technologists, unaware of the objective snoring count, listened to the audiotape and also counted the number of events that they perceived as snores. In 11 of 25 patients there was good agreement (within 25%) between the two listeners and the objective snore count. In another 7 of 25 patients there was good agreement between the listeners, but the objective snore count differed > 25%. In the last group of seven of 25 patients the difference in subjective snore counts perceived by both listeners was > 25%. The agreement between both listeners in judging snoring severity was moderate (weighted Cohen's kappa (w) = 0.49). We conclude that perception of snoring is highly subjective. We speculate that investigations studying consequences and treatment of snoring must employ either more sophisticated properly validated methods to measure snoring or alternatively resort to measurements of the underlying physiological abnormalities responsible for snoring, such as elevations in upper airway resistance.

Postural changes in respiratory airflow pressure and resistance in nasal, hypopharyngeal, and pharyngeal airway in normal subjects.

We investigated the effect of posture on nasal and pharyngeal resistance in 12 healthy subjects studied during wakefulness. Airway pressure and airflow were measured with subjects seated and in dorsal and left lateral recumbency, during inspiration and expiration. We found that pharyngeal resistance was approximately four to six times lower than the nasal resistance. Only pharyngeal resistance was significantly increased upon assumption of a supine posture, from 0.02 +/- 0.01 Pa/mL per second when seated to 0.06 +/- 0.05 Pa/mL per second in dorsal recumbency and to 0.05 +/- 0.04 Pa/mL per second in left lateral recumbency. Mean nasal and pharyngeal resistances doubled upon assumption of a supine posture, but this difference was not statistically significant. There was no significant difference in pharyngeal resistance between inspiration and expiration. Finally, there was a strong linear relationship between pharyngeal pressure and pharyngeal resistance (r = .98, p<.0001). We concluded that in normal awake subjects 1) pharyngeal resistance increases with assumption of a supine posture, 2) the walls of the pharynx are not compliant enough to alter their resistance in response to inspiratory and expiratory pressure changes, and 3) it may be possible to infer pharyngeal resistance from measurements of pressure alone, without measurement of airflow.

Snoring and arousals: a retrospective analysis.

The purpose of this retrospective analysis was to search for possible associations between snoring and arousals. We searched our data base containing more than 2,000 records and selected only patients who 1) had objective measurements of snoring, 2) were not taking sedating medication, 3) did not have sleep apnea (apnea/ hypopnea index < 10) and 4) did not have periodic leg movements (myoclonus index < 5). This procedure left 367 patients available for analysis. We hypothesized that arousals observed in these patients were associated with snoring, and we performed univariate and multivariate regression analysis with arousals as the dependent variable, and age, body mass index, snoring, maximum nocturnal sound intensity and nocturnal oxygen saturation as the independent variables. The results showed that only snoring and mean nocturnal oxygen saturation were significant (p < 0.05) but weak determinants of arousals, accounting for only 7% of their variance. To examine whether snorers have more arousals than non-snorers, we compared a control group of non-snorers (< 50 snores/hour of sleep), with a group of heavy snorers (> 400 snores/hour of sleep). We found that the arousal index was significantly but weakly higher in snorers than non-snorers [mean +/- standard deviation (SD) = 14 +/- 8 vs. 10 +/- 6, p < 0.002]. Conversely, patients within the highest arousal quartile snored significantly more than those within the lowest quartile (snoring index 293 +/- 292 vs. 179 +/- 282, p < 0.008, respectively). We conclude that despite the limitations of this retrospective analysis, there appears to be an association between snoring and arousals, warranting further, properly designed prospective studies.

Diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea using a portable transducer catheter.

As an initial step in simplifying the diagnosis of sleep apnea with a view toward using portable equipment in the home setting, we examined the efficacy of a portable transducer catheter that measures intrathoracic pressure. This catheter, connected to a miniature data-logger, can be introduced nasally into the airway, and the data so collected can be acquired, stored, and analyzed off-line. We tested this catheter against standard nocturnal polysomnography in 10 patients suffering from obstructive sleep apnea. We found that by using a combination of the raw pressure signal and an envelope pressure signal, we accurately identified apneas and hypopneas, and classified them as obstructive, central, and mixed. For the 10 subjects studied, the polysomnographic apnea/hypopnea index was 34 + 30, versus 32 + 28 obtained by analysis of the pressure tracings. Analysis of 200 respiratory events identified one-by-one from polysomnograms and pressure tracings revealed close correspondence between the two methods. The average duration of apneas was 22.1 + 6.7 s as measured by polysomnography, versus 21.9 + 6.6 s as measured from pressure tracings. Furthermore, there was excellent agreement between the two methods (kappa = 0.89, 95% confidence limits = 0.84 to 0.94). We conclude that our technique for identifying apnea based on measurements of intrathoracic pressure using a thin, portable transducer catheter is a promising method for simplifying the diagnosis of this disorder.

Pharyngeal airflow during sleep.

This study was conducted to investigate the effects of sleep and nasal resistance on pharyngeal airflow in a group of healthy male adults without complaint of habitual snoring. Twelve subjects aged 21 to 60 years were studied in a sleep laboratory during exclusive nasal breathing. Nasal and pharyngeal airflow variables were measured concomitantly at different stages of sleep. Awake pharyngeal resistance averaged 0.02-0.03 Pa/cm3/s in recumbency. In stage 2 sleep and quiet breathing resistance increased by a factor of 3-4 and by a factor of 7-8 during snoring. Increased nasal loading did not increase pharyngeal resistance further or induce snoring. Mostly, increased pharyngeal resistances were of similar magnitude in both phases of respiration, but in a few instances inspiratory resistance exceeded that in expiration, and in a similar number the reverse was found. Overall, compliance of the pharyngeal airway was not a prominent feature in this group of subjects. The relationship between transpharyngeal pressure and resistance should be studied further in order to simplify future studies of airflow during sleep.

Subjective and objective assessment of uvulopalatopharyngoplasty for treatment of snoring and obstructive sleep apnea.

This study was designed to assess the subjective and objective effects of uvulopalatopharyngoplasty (UPPP) for treatment of snoring. We mailed a questionnaire dealing with snoring, quality of sleep, and interference with bed-partner's sleep to 100 unselected patients who were referred because of snoring. Replies were received from 69 patients. The answers were analyzed, and the subjective impressions were compared with preoperative and postoperative objective measurements of snoring and apnea. The average (+/- SD) length of follow-up was 45 +/- 20 mo. We found no significant differences in the apnea/hypopnea index, snoring index, and mean and maximal nocturnal sound intensity before and after surgery in this group. However, despite this lack of objective improvement. 78% of patients reported reduction in snoring, and 79% reported improvement in the quality of sleep; 18 of 69 bed partners no longer complained of interference with their sleep compared with only one preoperatively. We conclude that if the purpose of UPPP is to reduce the reported health hazards associated with snoring, then comparison between objective preoperative and postoperative measurements of snoring does not indicate success; if, on the other hand, the purpose of surgery is to alleviate the social hazard, then UPPP partially achieves this goal.

Snoring: is it in the ear of the beholder?

Complaint of snoring, which is usually voiced by a patient's bedpartner, frequently leads to investigations in the sleep laboratory that are designed to assess snoring objectively and determine whether it is a symptom of sleep apnea. How well this subjective complaint of the listener is confirmed by the objective measurement of snoring is not known. Consequently, we designed a study i) to test the validity of self-perception of snoring and ii) to compare subjective perception of snoring by the sleep technologist with objective measurement of its frequency and loudness. We studied 613 unselected patients referred to our sleep clinic because of snoring and suspicion of sleep apnea. They all had nocturnal polysomnography that included measurements of snoring, expressed as the number of snores per hour of sleep [snoring index (SI)] and mean (dBmean) and maximum (dBmax) nocturnal sound intensity. Following the sleep study, the technologist (and patient) independently rated a patient's snoring as none, mild, moderate or severe. Kruskall-Wallis test, Spearman rank correlations and Cohen's kappa statistics were used to compare the groups, examine the correlations between subjective and objective measurements, and check the agreement between them.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Hematocrit levels in sleep apnea.

This study addresses the hypothesis that patients with obstructive sleep apnea, who exhibit recurrent episodes of oxygen desaturation at night, have higher hematocrit levels than nonapneic control subjects. We prospectively studied 624 patients referred to the sleep disorders center at St. Michael's Hospital because of suspicion of sleep apnea. All patients had nocturnal polysomnography and measurements of hematocrit level, hemoglobin value, WBC count, and platelet count. Smoking history and awake oxygen saturation (SaO2) was recorded in all of them. Nocturnal oxygenation was assessed using three indices: lowest nocturnal SaO2 (LoSaO2), mean nocturnal SaO2 (MnSaO2) and percent of total sleep time spent at SaO2 lower than 85 percent (TST85%). Patients with TST85% in the lowest quartile (TST85% = 0) had minimally lower hematocrit levels than patients with TST85% in the highest quartile (8 < or = TST85% < or = 90): 0.41 +/- 0.03 vs 0.40 +/- 0.02 in female subjects and 0.45 +/- 0.05 vs 0.43 +/- 0.05 in male subjects, respectively (p < 0.05). Multiple linear regression analysis revealed that MnSaO2, age, and pack-years of smoking were significant predictors of hematocrit level, but they accounted for only 9 percent of the variability in hematocrit level (multiple R2 = 0.087; p < 0.05). We conclude that intermittent nocturnal hypoxemia during episodes of apnea does not lead to clinical polycythemia, but is associated with minor elevations in hematocrit value. These small elevations are unlikely to be useful as markers of hypoxic stress associated with sleep apnea.

Predicting nasal continuous positive airway pressure.

We recently proposed an equation predicting the optimal level of continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) that abolishes sleep apnea from three simple and easily available parameters: body mass index (BMI), neck circumference, and apnea/hypopnea index (AHI). The present study was designed to validate this equation in a prospective group of patients with sleep apnea returning to the sleep laboratory for CPAP titration study. We studied 26 patients and found that the optimal CPAP was equal to the predicted value in 10 of 26 patients, within +/- 1 cm H2O of the predicted value in another 10 of 26 patients, within +/- 2 cm H2O in four of 26 patients, and outside +/- 4 cm H2O in the remaining two patients. We conclude that (1) optimal CPAP can be predicted to within +/- 2 cm H2O from a few simple measurements, and (2) using predicted CPAP as a starting pressure for CPAP titration, it may be possible to optimize and/or shorten the titration study--a fact with significant implications for reducing the cost of "diagnosis-to-treatment" polysomnography.

Cardiac arrhythmias, snoring, and sleep apnea.

We investigated the frequency of cardiac arrhythmias in patients suspected of having sleep apnea, and related them to the severity of apnea, snoring, and nocturnal hypoxemia. We prospectively studied 458 patients who had nocturnal polysomnography which included objective measurement of snoring (quantified by the number of snores per hour of sleep [snoring index (SI)] and maximum nocturnal sound intensity [(dBmax)], as well as examination of the electrocardiogram (modified lead 2). We found 58 percent prevalence of arrhythmias in patients with sleep apnea (apnea/hypopnea index = AHI > 10), vs 42 percent in nonapneic controls (chi 2 = 16.7, p < 0.0001). Patients with arrhythmias had more severe apnea and nocturnal hypoxemia, but not snoring, than patients without arrhythmias. To examine separately the relationship between the prevalence of arrhythmias and snoring, nocturnal oxygenation, and apnea--we selected subgroups of patients "at the opposite ends of the spectrum" with respect to the severity of snoring, hypoxemia, and apnea. We found that 38 percent of light snorers had arrhythmias vs 39 percent of heavy snorers, 82 percent of patients with mean nocturnal oxygen saturation < 90 percent had arrhythmias vs 40 percent of patients with mean nocturnal oxygen saturation > 90 percent (chi 2 = 7.4, p = 0.006), and 70 percent of patients with AHI > or = 40 had arrhythmias vs 42 percent with AHI < or = (chi 2 = 9.2, p = 0.002). We conclude that patients with sleep apnea as a group have higher prevalence of cardiac arrhythmias than nonapneic patients and that snoring alone, without concomitant sleep apnea, is not associated with increased frequency of cardiac arrhythmias.

Sleep and posture.

Computer-assisted open catheter studies of 10 healthy, nose-breathing men in dorsal and in lateral recumbent sleep demonstrated stable intrasubject transpharyngeal differential pressures and airflow resistances. They averaged 19.6 Pa (+/- standard deviation [SD] 11.9) and 0.103 Pa/cm3 per second (+/- SD 0.065) in the dorsal posture and stage II sleep during quiet breathing and were not significantly different in the lateral posture or in stage I sleep. Five subjects were snorers, and their pharyngeal airflow pressures and resistances increased substantially during quiet breathing on assumption of recumbency and much more in sleep. In the 5 subjects who were nonsnorers, postural changes were not significant and sleep increases were moderate. During snoring, transpharyngeal pressures and resistances increased even further, averaging 188 Pa and 1.02 Pa/cm3 per second for the whole group. Transpharyngeal differential pressures and hypopharyngeal transmural pressures frequently exceeded 300 Pa in inspiration and in expiration during periods of snoring. Yet, transpharyngeal differential pressures and resistances did not reveal appreciable differences between phases that would indicate compliant change of pharyngeal cross section. Breathing frequency was unchanged, but ventilation was significantly diminished at elevated upper airway resistances (P < .01). Transpharyngeal resistances and differential pressures varied independently from widely differing nasal resistances. As with our earlier studies, pressure measurements alone clearly demonstrated breathing patterns and events.

Snoring and nasal resistance during sleep.

Although it is widely accepted that nasal obstruction leads to snoring and sleep apnea, the relationship between these variables is not clear, mainly because of the lack of studies in which nasal resistance (Rna) and snoring were measured concurrently. The authors studied eight nonapneic snoring men with healthy noses by nocturnal polysomnography that included quantitative assessment of snoring and concomitant nasal resistance. In six of these eight patients nasal resistance increased during sleep, but there was no significant change for the group as a whole between wakefulness (0.209 +/- 0.224 Pa/cm3 per second) and sleep (0.292 +/- 0.203 Pa/cm3 per second). Linear regression analysis showed no significant correlation between sleeping nasal resistance and snoring index (partial R2 = .44, P = .071). We used each subject as his own control and compared the snoring profile at a time during sleep when nasal resistance was at its highest (0.550 +/- 0.375 Pa/cm3 per second) and lowest (0.146 +/- 0.090 Pa/cm3 per second) levels. Despite the significant (P < .01) differences in nasal resistance, they were not reflected in the number of snores or their sound intensity. It is concluded that nasal obstruction during sleep is not correlated significantly to frequency or intensity of snoring during exclusively nasal breathing.

Effect of nasal dilation on snoring and apneas during different stages of sleep.

This study was designed to test the hypothesis that nasal dilation reduces snoring. To achieve this we performed nocturnal polysomnography, including measurement of snoring, in 15 patients without nasal pathology before and after insertion of a nasal dilator (NOZOVENT). Snoring was quantified for each sleep stage by recording the number of snores per minute of sleep, number of snores per minute of snoring time and nocturnal sound intensities (maximum, average and minimum). We found that nasal dilation had no effect on the number of apneas, hypopneas or oxygen saturation. Snoring parameters were unaffected by NOZOVENT during stages I, II and REM sleep, but were all significantly reduced during slow wave sleep. We conclude that dilation of the anterior nares in patients without nasal pathology has a relatively weak effect on snoring, and routine use of nasal dilating appliances is not recommended for treatment of snoring.

Differences in abdominal and neck circumferences in patients with and without obstructive sleep apnoea.

We have recently shown that patients with sleep apnoea have thicker necks than non-apnoeic snoring controls. However, it was not clear whether this difference simply reflects the fact that apnoeic patients are more obese than the non-apnoeic ones, or whether it represents a preferential distribution of fat over the neck region compared to the abnormal region. We therefore measured the neck and abdominal circumferences in a large group of 670 patients suspected of having sleep apnoea, all of whom had full nocturnal polysomnography, including measurement of snoring. We divided these patients into apnoeic and non-apnoeic groups based on the apnoea/hypopnoea index (AHI) of 10. Apnoeic patients had significantly higher body mass index (BMI), neck, and abdominal circumferences than non-apnoeic controls. We then matched apnoeic and non-apnoeic patients exactly, one-for-one for BMI and age; this procedure left us with 156 patients in each group. Abdominal circumferences were similar, but the neck circumference was significantly higher in apnoeic patients (41.2 +/- 3.5 cm vs 39.1 +/- 3.7 cm, p less than 0.0001). Multiple stepwise linear regression analysis revealed that neck circumference and BMI correlated significantly with apnoea (multiple R2 = 0.27, p less than 0.001) and snoring (multiple R2 = 0.19, p less than 0.001). We conclude that obese patients with sleep apnoea have fatter necks than equally obese non-apnoeic snorers, and that the neck circumference could be a significant determinant of apnoea and snoring.

Treatment of obstructive sleep apnea with nasal continuous positive airway pressure. Patient compliance, perception of benefits, and side effects.

Obstructive sleep apnea is a chronic disease whose treatment may require long-term nightly use of relatively cumbersome and expensive breathing equipment that provides continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) via nasal mask. Compliance with this treatment may be influenced not only by the objective improvement in sleep apnea but also by the patient's subjective perception of the benefit, bed mate or family support, side effects, and cost. The last factor may not be important in Ontario, where 75% of the cost is paid by the Ministry of Health. The goal of this study was to analyze the factors that may influence patient acceptance of nasal CPAP. This was done by tabulating the responses to a detailed questionnaire mailed to 148 patients with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). There were 96 replies. We were able to contact by telephone an additional 42 patients. The results showed that 105 patients continued to use CPAP at a mean follow-up time of 17 +/- 11 months, some for as long as 6 yr. The majority of patients (81%) perceived CPAP as an effective treatment of the disorder, 5% were unsure, and 14% believed that CPAP was ineffective, despite the resolution of sleep apnea on polysomnography. Subjective improvement reported by the patients was also observed by the family members in 83% of the patients. The most common complaint, voiced by 46% of the patients, was nocturnal awakenings. Nasal problems, such as dryness, congestion, and sneezing, were the second most frequent complaint present in 44% of the responders.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The effect of snoring on mean arterial blood pressure during non-REM sleep.

The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between snoring and mean arterial blood pressure during sleep. This was accomplished by performing continuous, all-night, simultaneous measurements of snoring, oxygen saturation, sleep stages, and arterial blood pressure in a group of eight snorers and five nonsnoring control subjects. The results were analyzed to determine whether changes in mean arterial blood pressure during non-rapid-eye-movement (non-REM) sleep are different in snorers from those in nonsnorers and whether they are related to nocturnal hypoxemia. Both groups were similar with respect to their anthropometric parameters and sleep architecture. Oxygen saturations during different stages of non-REM sleep were similiar within each group. However, the analysis of variance revealed that among snorers mean arterial blood pressure increased slightly during slow-wave sleep, whereas the nonsnorers reduced their blood pressure by 17.4 +/- 3.7% compared with wakefulness values. We also performed multiple linear regression analysis for the entire group of 13 subjects using the change in mean arterial blood pressure relative to wakefulness as the dependent variable and snoring frequency and mean arterial oxygen saturation as the independent variables; the results demonstrated that only snoring frequency, and not oxygen saturation, correlated significantly with the change in mean arterial blood pressure. We conclude that snoring may influence variation of blood pressure during sleep, preventing the normally observed reduction of arterial blood pressure associated with slow-wave sleep.

Site of airway obstruction in patients with obstructive sleep apnea before and after uvulopalatopharyngoplasty.

This study describes a simple method, based on a movable catheter technique, for use during routine polysomnography to identify the site of obstruction, and this has been applied to 51 patients with suspected sleep apnea. The obstruction was found to be retropalatal in 30, retrolingual in 7, and could not be determined in 14 patients (12 had no sleep apnea, 1 did not sleep, and 1 had central sleep apnea). Twelve of these patients had uvulopalatopharyngoplasty with preoperative and postoperative polysomnograms to determine the site of obstruction. The preoperative obstruction was retropalatal in nine and retrolingual in three. Postoperatively, four patients (one with retrolingual obstruction and three with retropalatal obstruction) no longer had sleep apnea. In the remaining eight patients, the site of obstruction was unchanged from the preoperative one. Several conclusions result: 1. the movable catheter technique offers a simple way to determine the site of obstruction in patients with significant obstructive sleep apnea, 2. most such patients obstruct in the retropalatal region, and 3. preoperative localization of the site of obstruction to the retropalatal region does not seem to improve the surgical outcome of uvulopalatopharyngoplasty.

Snoring and sleep architecture.

The purpose of this study was to examine whether snoring adversely affects sleep architecture and sleep efficiency, and thus may account for the frequent complaints of daytime tiredness and fatigue expressed by heavy snorers. We recruited eight self-confessed heavy snorers and six self-confessed nonsnorers. All subjects had full nocturnal polysomnography, including continuous monitoring of snoring, which was quantified by counting the number of snores per hour of sleep (snoring index), the number of snores per minute of snoring time (snoring frequency), maximal and mean nocturnal sound intensity (dBmax and dBmean, respectively). We found that even the self-confessed nonsnorers snored lightly, with significantly smaller frequency and index than the heavy snorers. Sleep architecture was similar in both groups. Distribution of snoring among the sleep stages differed for light and heavy snorers: light snorers snored uniformly throughout all sleep stages, whereas heavy snorers tended to snore more during slow-wave and REM sleep. Snoring frequency and snoring index were similar during all sleep stages in light snorers, but they were higher during slow-wave sleep in heavy snorers. Wakefulness time after sleep onset and sleep efficiency correlated significantly with the snoring index. We conclude that although snoring does not affect sleep architecture in general, it influences sleep efficiency and wakefulness time after sleep onset; this may have an adverse effect on daytime function of heavy snorers.

Determinants of blood pressure in snorers.

To examine the hypothesis that the tendency to raised blood pressure in snorers is associated with nocturnal hypoxaemia and snoring, blood pressure was measured and snoring, oxyhaemoglobin saturation (SaO2), and thoraco-abdominal movements were monitored overnight in 372 snorers. Snoring was quantified as number of snores per hour of sleep (snoring index). The data were analysed by multiple linear regression of diastolic blood pressure against age, body mass index (BMI), apnoea-hypopnoea index (AHI, number of episodes per hour), snoring index, and SaO2. Diastolic blood pressure correlated significantly with BMI, AHI, and mean nocturnal oxygen saturation, but not with the snoring index. However, snoring index correlated with BMI, AHI, and mean nocturnal oxygen saturation. Snoring is thus not a direct risk factor for hypertension, but may influence blood pressure via its association with obesity, obstructive sleep apnoea, and nocturnal hypoxaemia.