Response error in reporting dental coverage by older Americans in the health and retirement study.

The aim of this research was to analyze the inconsistency in responses to survey questions within the Health and Retirement Study (HRS) regarding insurance coverage of dental services. Self-reports of dental coverage in the dental services section were compared with those in the insurance section of the 2002 HRS to identify inconsistent responses. Logistic regression identified characteristics of persons reporting discrepancies and assessed the effect of measurement error on dental coverage coefficient estimates in dental utilization models. In 18% of cases, data reported in the insurance section contradicted data reported in the dental use section of the HRS by those who said insurance at least partially covered (or would have covered) their (hypothetical) dental use. Additional findings included distinct characteristics of persons with potential reporting errors and a downward bias to the regression coefficient for coverage in a dental use model without controls for inconsistent self-reports of coverage. This study offers evidence for the need to validate self-reports of dental insurance coverage among a survey population of older Americans to obtain more accurate estimates of coverage and its impact on dental utilization.

Regression-based sampling for persons with high health expenditures: evaluating accuracy and yield with the 1997 MEPS.

BACKGROUND: Given the high concentration of health care expenditures among a relatively small percentage of the population, the 1997 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey was designed to learn more about these high expenditure individuals by oversampling them. OBJECTIVE: Oversampling high expenditure individuals enables more precise estimation of what the nation's health care dollar buys and who pays it. It also enhances the ability to discern the causes of high health care expenses and the characteristics of the individuals who incur them. METHOD: Using the 1987 National Medical Expenditure Survey, a probabilistic model was developed to select households from the 1996 National Health Interview Survey likely to contain individuals incurring high levels of medical expenditures in the 1997 MEPS. The accuracy of the selection model, and the degree to which the high expenditure population was oversampled, are assessed with the 1997 MEPS data. RESULTS: Over half of the persons selected by the regression model were expected to have high health expenditures. Of the 456 persons selected by the model for oversampling, 257 individuals or 56.4% did, in fact, have high expenditures. Regression-based sampling increased the proportion of MEPS individuals with high expenditures from 14.3% without oversampling to 17.2% of the total cohort with oversampling (or from 938-1,126 persons). CONCLUSION: This paper demonstrates that a model-based approach to oversampling a high expenditure population, or any population with dynamic characteristics, can be highly successful in terms of sampling yield and accuracy.