Patients' attitudes toward informed consent for intravenous contrast media.

OBJECTIVES: To assess patient attitudes concerning informed consent and the risks of ionic and nonionic contrast material, 1,197 completed questionnaires were obtained from individuals either awaiting contrast injection or waiting for other services. METHODS: Six different questionnaire formats were administered, including two detailing the specific risks of ionic and nonionic contrast, respectively. Different questionnaire formats were used to assess whether the severity or the probability of adverse consequences had more influence on a patient's desire for information. Two questionnaires evaluated the effect of comparing medical risks to equivalent risks from everyday nonmedical activities. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Regardless of questionnaire format and the severity of potential risk, the large majority of individuals want some information before contrast injection, and approximately half view such information as essential. Individuals reacted more to the probability of a potential reaction than its severity, and to items ordered toward the end of a particular questionnaire than at the beginning.

Mediastinal bulk in Hodgkin disease. Method of measurement versus prognosis.

The presence of a large mediastinal mass (bulk disease) in patients with newly diagnosed Hodgkin disease is believed by many to predict a poorer prognosis and to warrant more aggressive treatment. These masses are formed by an aggregate of mediastinal lymph nodes. The determination of bulk disease is confusing, with at least 27 definitions having been proposed. This study seeks to determine the best definition, and determine the role of thoracic computed tomography (CT) versus chest radiographs in the evaluation of mediastinal bulk disease. One hundred seven consecutive newly diagnosed adult patients with Hodgkin disease were evaluated using 13 commonly used definitions of mediastinal bulk. Of the 76 patients with mediastinal disease, 73 had bulk disease as defined by at least one definition. Of the 16 patients who had recurrence of mediastinal disease, only the presence of bulk disease according to one definition (hilar adenopathy, greater than or equal to 2 cm) was statistically significant in its prediction (P = .05). No definition based on the size of the mediastinal nodal mass reliably predicted those patients with recurrence. No differences in our data were found for differing stages or disease cell types, the presence of extension, or with differing treatment regimens. This study highlights the confusion and controversy surrounding the use of bulk disease of the mediastinum as an adverse prognostic indicator. The numerous methods of measuring mediastinal bulk in patients with newly diagnosed Hodgkin disease are confusing, overlap, and are not statistically reliable in predicting recurrence. Efforts to create a standard or ideal definition were unsuccessful. Thoracic CT was useful in those patients whose bulk disease distorted only one side of the mediastinal silhouette on chest radiographs.

The prevalence of asymptomatic gallstones in the general population.

The gallbladder and biliary system were scanned by real-time ultrasound in 2274 patients undergoing diagnostic ultrasound for other than gallbladder disease. Patients (212) with previous gallbladder symptoms or with nonvisualization of their gallbladder were excluded from the study. Obesity is the most important risk factor for the development of asymptomatic gallstones in women (P less than .01), although it is not a significant factor in men. Increasing age is an important risk factor for both sexes, and the only significant risk factor in men (P less than .01). While few men have asymptomatic gallstones before the age of 40, 5% of women aged 20-29 and 9% aged 30-39 do. In the 40 and over age group, men (14%) and women (11%) had insignificantly different prevalences. In women, the number of previous pregnancies is a significant risk factor (chi-square = 5.4, P = .02). For instance, there is a 3%, 8%, and 17% overall frequency of gallstones in women with 0, 3, and 6 or more previous pregnancies, respectively. A stepwise logistic regression analysis, after adjusting for age, body mass index, and for women, number of pregnancies, found no significant increased risk related to race (P = .40), high blood pressure (P = .43), heart disease (P = .47), or diabetes (P = .46). After age adjustment, there is no significant gender effect (P = .25). Asymptomatic gallstones are a relatively common occurrence in men over 40 and women over 30. While age is the only significant risk factor in men, obesity, parity, and to a lesser extent age were significant risk factors in women.

Diagnostic radiology peer review: a method inclusive of all interpreters of radiographic examinations regardless of specialty.

A proposed method of assessing the quality of diagnostic radiographic examinations includes peer review designed to evaluate physicians, including nonradiologists, involved in the performance and interpretation of such examinations. A pilot project evaluated this system with randomly selected Pennsylvania Blue Shield data files of 10 providers billing for chest radiography interpretations during the second quarter of 1989. Of the 98 chest radiographs reviewed blindly, all inadequately marked radiographs and incomplete written reports were produced by nonradiologists. Technical quality of images obtained by radiologists did not significantly differ from that of images obtained by nonradiologists (P = .189). All five interpretive errors that could have seriously affected the patient's health care were produced by nonradiologists (P = .019). Four of these serious errors were made by providers billing for fewer than 25 radiographs. While administrative and time cost limitations are obvious, this method of peer review encompasses all physicians billing for a particular radiographic service, irrespective of specialty.

Efficacy of automated biopsy guns versus conventional biopsy needles in the pygmy pig.

Debate over which biopsy needle is the best has intensified recently with the introduction of automated biopsy guns including the 18-gauge long-throw and short-throw Biopty, the 18-gauge Cook, and the 14- and 18-gauge Klear Kut. To evaluate the efficacy of these mechanized biopsy guns versus that of conventional manual biopsy needles in the acquisition of adequate tissue for histopathologic evaluation, open hepatic and renal biopsies were performed in 15 pygmy pigs. The specimens were evaluated separately in a double-blind fashion by two histopathologists using graded criteria. Overall, the best results were obtained with the manual 14-gauge Tru-Cut needle, the long-throw 18-gauge Biopty gun, and the 18-gauge Cook biopsy gun. By comparison, the aspiration-type needles did not perform as well when considered as a group. Several other needles scored well in the biopsy of either the liver or kidney, but not in both. Disappointing results were obtained with the Klear Kut guns (both 14- and 18-gauge) and the Vacu Cut and PercuCut needles.

The significance of necrotic mediastinal lymph nodes on CT in patients with newly diagnosed Hodgkin disease.

Necrosis in lymph nodes shown on CT in many patients with nodal metastases may indicate that the primary tumor is aggressive and has a high degree of malignancy. However, the significance of nodal necrosis in patients with mediastinal Hodgkin disease remains uncertain. We studied the thoracic CT scans of 76 patients who had newly diagnosed Hodgkin disease with mediastinal involvement with respect to the presence of necrosis (low attenuation, complex, fluidlike areas), the size and volume of the mass, the sites involved, extension ("E" disease), and the patients' clinical response to treatment. CT scans showed necrotic nodes in 16 patients (21%). The difference between these patients and those without necrotic nodes was not statistically significant with respect to sex, age, stage, distribution of disease, presence of E disease, cell type, mass diameter, or the presence of bulk disease (mass diameter/maximal thoracic diameter greater than or equal to 0.33). The mass volume as measured by CT was not significantly (p = .08) larger (1274 cm3) than the group without necrotic nodes (876 cm3). An analysis of the various mediastinal sites involved showed no difference between patients with and without necrotic nodes. Lastly, the presence of necrotic nodes had no significant impact on patients' clinical response to treatment or survival. The presence of mediastinal necrotic nodes appears to have little radiologic or prognostic significance in patients with newly diagnosed Hodgkin disease.