ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: Scorpion antivenom was recently approved for use in patients with clinically significant scorpion envenomation in the United States; no formal economic analysis on its impact on cost of management has been performed. METHODS: Three different strategies of management of scorpion envenomation with systemic neurotoxic symptoms in children were compared for cost minimization from a societal perspective. In strategy I, patients were managed with supportive care only without antivenom. In strategy II, an aggressive strategy of full-dose antivenom (initial dose of 3 vials with the use of additional vials administered 1 vial at a time) was considered. In strategy III, a single-vial serial antivenom dosing strategy titrated to clinical response was considered. Clinical probabilities for the different strategies were obtained from retrospective review of medical records of patients with scorpion envenomation over a 10-year period at our institution. Baseline cost values were obtained from patient reimbursement data from our institution. RESULTS: In baseline analysis, strategy I of supportive care only with no antivenom was least costly at US $3466.50/patient. Strategy III of single-vial serial dosing was intermediate but less expensive than strategy II of full-dose antivenom, with an incremental cost of US $3171.08 per patient. In a 1-way sensitivity analysis, at a threshold antivenom cost of US $1577.87, strategy III of single-vial serial dosing became the least costly strategy. CONCLUSIONS: For children with scorpion envenomation, use of a management strategy based on serial dosing of antivenom titrated to clinical response is less costly than a strategy of initial use of full-dose antivenom.
Subject(s)
Antivenins/administration & dosage , Antivenins/economics , Scorpion Stings/drug therapy , Scorpion Stings/economics , Adolescent , Child , Child, Preschool , Cost-Benefit Analysis/methods , Decision Support Techniques , Disease Management , Drug Administration Schedule , Humans , Infant , Retrospective Studies , Scorpion Venoms/antagonists & inhibitors , Treatment Outcome , United StatesABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The American Academy of Pediatrics 2004 guidelines on diagnosis and management of acute otitis media (OM) recommends use of high-dose amoxicillin for the treatment of acute uncomplicated OM. With rising childhood obesity, recommended amoxicillin dose of 80 to 90 mg/kg per day often exceed standard adult dose of 1500 mg/d. OBJECTIVE: To study prescribing patterns of primary care physicians for amoxicillin in the treatment of OM. To assess opinions of American Academy of Pediatrics subcommittee members who participated in guideline formulation. METHODS: This study had 2 parts. Part 1: Retrospective review of medical records of children visiting the hospital between April and June 2008 and with a diagnosis of OM and were prescribed amoxicillin. Part 2: Web-based survey of 14 members of the OM guidelines subcommittee. RESULTS: Part 1: Three hundred fifty-nine children were eligible, with a mean (SD) age of 3.2 (4.0) years and 185 (51.5%) of whom were males. Children weighing 20 kg or less received higher mean daily dose of amoxicillin (74.2 vs 40.4 mg/kg per day, P < 0.00). Part 2: Nine (64.3%) subcommittee members responded to the survey. Most (77.8%) affirmed that the impact of obesity on high-dose amoxicillin recommendation was not discussed during guideline formulation. If a patient's estimated amoxicillin dose exceeded the standard adult dose (1500 mg/d), 66.7% members would prescribe the standard adult dose whereas 33.3% would prescribe the recommended dose of 80 to 90 mg/kg per day. CONCLUSIONS: Primary care physicians prescribe a significantly lower-than-recommended amoxicillin dose in older children and those in the higher weight category. The opinion among subcommittee members regarding maximum dose specification of amoxicillin is varied.
