Helper T cell-regulated B cell immunity.

In this review, we will discuss the cascade of cellular and molecular events in the immune response to protein antigens that regulate the development of high-affinity B cell memory. The behavior of antigen-experienced pMHCII+ dendritic cells DCs and the dynamics of their interaction with specific T-helper (Th) cells define the first developmental checkpoint for adaptive immunity in vivo. Recent studies provide insight into the basis of Th cell clonal selection and the requirements and consequences of antigen priming in this responsive Th cell compartment. Antigen-specific Th cells expand to become the cognate regulators of effector B cell responses and initiators of the germinal center reaction and memory B cell development. We will discuss the development and role of these diverse mixtures of antigen-specific B cells in the control of B cell memory and long-term humoral immunity that underpin effective protein vaccination.

Emergence of a type II collagen-specific helper T cell response.

Antigen-driven development of persistent self-reactive Th cells underlies the chronic, progressive nature of many autoimmune diseases. It is crucial to understand the behavior of these self-reactive Th cells; however, they have been notoriously difficult to isolate directly ex vivo. Collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) can be initiated in I-A(q)-expressing mice (DBA/1) using heterologous type II collagen (cII) immunization and is dependent on Th cells that are specific for a single immunodominant epitope. Here, we identify one compartment of cII-specific Th cell using TCR beta expression, cell surface phenotype, and direct single-cell repertoire analysis. A subpopulation of CD4(+)V beta 10(+) T cells up-regulates both CD44 and GL7 and expands significantly in response to initial priming in the majority of animals (D9: 70%). The cII-specific V beta 10(+) primary responders are further resolved through expression of a highly restricted junctional region, previously associated with autoimmune disease. This cII-specific clonotype rapidly re-expands upon antigen recall and can be isolated from the lymph nodes of arthritic animals. These single-cell analyses quantify the emergence, decline and rapid re-emergence of a self-reactive Th cell population in vivo and outline one strategy for isolating these cells directly ex vivo.

Development and maintenance of a B220- memory B cell compartment.

We have recently demonstrated that a novel somatically mutated B220(-) memory B cell subset rapidly dominates the secondary immune response to (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl) acetyl (NP). Upon adoptive transfer with Ag, B220(+)NP(+) memory B cells produce large numbers of B220(-)NP(+) B cells that can rapidly differentiate into plasma cells. Therefore, it is not clear whether the novel B220(-) memory compartment is a consequence of secondary Ag challenge or whether it develops as a stable memory subset after initial Ag challenge. In this study, we demonstrate the gradual emergence of B220(-)NP(+) B cells in the spleen to maximal numbers 3 wk after initial Ag exposure. Like their B220(+) counterparts, the B220(-) B cells initially appear unmutated at days 5-7; however, the majority rapidly accumulate affinity increasing mutations by days 9-14 of the primary immune response. More extensive cell surface phenotype (GL7(-)BLA-1(-)CD24(-)CD43(+)) argues strongly against germinal center localization and direct analysis in situ places a cohort of B220(-)CD11b(+)NP(+) B cells in the red pulp of the spleen and not in the MZs. These data provide direct evidence for the development of B220(-) memory B cells as a unique cellular consequence of primary Ag exposure. The cellular dynamics and molecular attributes of these unique memory B cells suggest they are distinct cellular products of the germinal center reaction in the primary response and are maintained long-term in the spleen and bone marrow.

Germinal center reaction.

The germinal center reaction is one critical outcome of helper T-cell-dependent antigen-specific B-cell responses. Germinal center reactions are the culmination of an orchestrated series of intercellular information exchanges discussed here as the serial synapsis model of adaptive immunity. The main purpose of the germinal center reaction is the development of B-cell memory through iterative cycles of somatic antigen receptor diversification and the selection of B cells with receptors of best fit. Recent studies provide insight into the regulation of these complex processes in vivo with new information on the cellular organization of the memory B-cell compartment.

Antigen-specific T helper cell function: differential cytokine expression in primary and memory responses.

Distinguishing between the development of functional potential in antigen-specific T helper (Th) cells and the delivery of these specialized functions in vivo has been difficult to resolve. Here, we quantify the frequency of cytokine-producing cells within the primary and memory B10.BR Th cell response to pigeon cytochrome c (PCC). In vitro analysis of acquired functional potential indicated no Th1/Th2 cytokine polarity at the peak of the primary response with surprisingly little evidence for the selective preservation of interleukin (IL)-2, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha, IL-4, and interferon (IFN)-gamma potentials into the memory compartment. However, the expression of these functional potentials appears tightly regulated in vivo. The staggered appearance of primary response cytokines directly ex vivo contrasts markedly with their rapid coordinate expression in the memory response. Frequencies of IL-2-, TNF-alpha-, IFN-gamma-, and IL-10-expressing memory responders increased over their primary response counterparts, but were still markedly lower than revealed in vitro. IL-4-, IFN-gamma-, and IL-10-expressing Th cells remained at low but stable frequencies over the first 6 d of the memory response. Analysis of T cell receptor beta chain sequences of IL-4- and TNF-alpha-expressing PCC-specific Th cells provides evidence for early functional commitment among clonal progeny. These data indicate that the development of functional potential is a consequence of initial antigen experience, but delivery of specialized functions is differentially regulated in primary and memory immune responses.

Antigen-specific B cell memory: expression and replenishment of a novel b220(-) memory b cell compartment.

The mechanisms that regulate B cell memory and the rapid recall response to antigen remain poorly defined. This study focuses on the rapid expression of B cell memory upon antigen recall in vivo, and the replenishment of quiescent B cell memory that follows. Based on expression of CD138 and B220, we reveal a unique and major subtype of antigen-specific memory B cells (B220(-)CD138(-)) that are distinct from antibody-secreting B cells (B220(+/)-CD138(+)) and B220(+)CD138(-) memory B cells. These nonsecreting somatically mutated B220(-) memory responders rapidly dominate the splenic response and comprise >95% of antigen-specific memory B cells that migrate to the bone marrow. By day 42 after recall, the predominant quiescent memory B cell population in the spleen (75-85%) and the bone marrow (>95%) expresses the B220(-) phenotype. Upon adoptive transfer, B220(-) memory B cells proliferate to a lesser degree but produce greater amounts of antibody than their B220(+) counterparts. The pattern of cellular differentiation after transfer indicates that B220(-) memory B cells act as stable self-replenishing intermediates that arise from B220(+) memory B cells and produce antibody-secreting cells on rechallenge with antigen. Cell surface phenotype and Ig isotype expression divide the B220(-) compartment into two main subsets with distinct patterns of integrin and coreceptor expression. Thus, we identify new cellular components of B cell memory and propose a model for long-term protective immunity that is regulated by a complex balance of committed memory B cells with subspecialized immune function.

Thymocyte resistance to glucocorticoids leads to antigen-specific unresponsiveness due to "holes" in the T cell repertoire.

We have proposed that glucocorticoids antagonize TCR-mediated activation and influence which TCR avidities result in positive or negative selection. We now analyze the immune response of mice whose thymocytes express antisense transcripts to the glucocorticoid receptor (TKO mice). TKO mice responded normally to the complex antigen PPD but were proliferative nonresponders to pigeon cytochrome c 81-104 (PCC), having a large decrease in the frequency of PCC-responsive CD4+ T cells. Unlike wild-type T cells, few TKO T cells in PCC-specific cell lines expressed V alpha11+Vbeta3+. Furthermore, for naive CD4+ T cells from unimmunized TKO mice, the frequencies of many of the molecular features common to the CDR3 regions of PCC-responsive V alpha11+Vbeta3+ cells were substantially decreased. Thus, thymocyte glucocorticoid hyporesponsiveness resulted in loss of cells capable of responding to PCC, corresponding to an antigen-specific "hole" in the T cell repertoire.

Antigen-specific immunity. Th cell-dependent B cell responses.

Helper T cell-regulated B cell responses constitute a major component of the primary immune response to many pathogens. The subsequent development of antigen-specific immune memory is one critical outcome of this primary adaptive immune response. Antigen-specific immunity develops through a series of intercellular information exchanges organized around cognate T cell receptor-peptide/MHC interactions. Here, we discuss these complex molecularevents andtheircellularconsequences in a serial synapsis model of adaptive immunity. Our laboratory has developed strategies to isolate antigen-specific Th cells and B cells to analyze gene expression and cellular function in single responding lymphocytes directly ex vivo. These studies provide insight into the regulation and cellular organization of antigen-specific immune responses in vivo.

Regulating T helper cell immunity through antigen responsiveness and calcium entry.

We evaluated changes in the signaling potentials and proliferative capacity of single antigen-specific T helper (TH) cells during a primary immune response to a protein antigen. At the peak of cellular expansion in vivo all antigen-specific TH cells exhibited a profound block in CD3- and CD4-mediated mobilization of intracellular calcium together with a more global block in T cell receptor-independent capacitative calcium entry (CCE). The proliferative response of these antigen-specific TH cells to anti-CD3, anti-CD28 and IL-2 was also severely blunted. Cross-linking CD69 on a substantial fraction of CD69+ antigen-specific TH cells relieved this block in CCE and restored proliferative capacity in vitro. The CCE rescue operated through a CD69-coupled G protein and required calcium-bound calmodulin and calcineurin. These data reveal critical changes in the responsiveness of antigen-specific TH cells and provide evidence of new mechanisms for the regulation of antigen-specific TH cell development in vivo.

Antigen-driven selection of TCR In vivo: related TCR alpha-chains pair with diverse TCR beta-chains.

Ag-driven selection mediates effective T cell help and the development of Th cell memory in vivo. To analyze the dynamics of interclonal competition during the selection process in vivo, we use the I-Ek-restricted murine response to pigeon cytochrome c (PCC). The dominant PCC-specific clonotype expresses Valpha11Vbeta3 V regions with preferred sequence features in the third hypervariable regions (CDR3). In the current study we define and quantitatively monitor four subdominant PCC-specific clonotypes that express Valpha11 paired with non-Vbeta3 TCR beta-chains (Vbeta6, Vbeta8.1/8. 2, Vbeta8.3, and Vbeta14). The subdominant clonotypes emerge with similar dynamics to the dominant clonotype and together amount to similar numbers as the dominant clonotype in vivo. These subdominant clonotypes do not efficiently enter germinal centers, although they enter the memory compartment and rapidly re-emerge upon secondary challenge. Analysis of CDR3 diversity in the TCR alpha-chains identifies many preferred sequence features expressed by the dominant clonotype. These studies quantitatively demonstrate selection for diverse Th cells in vivo and highlight TCR alpha-chain dominance in Ag-driven selection for best fit.

In vivo-activated CD4 T cells upregulate CXC chemokine receptor 5 and reprogram their response to lymphoid chemokines.

Migration of antigen-activated CD4 T cells to B cell areas of lymphoid tissues is important for mounting T cell-dependent antibody responses. Here we show that CXC chemokine receptor (CXCR)5, the receptor for B lymphocyte chemoattractant (BLC), is upregulated on antigen-specific CD4 T cells in vivo when animals are immunized under conditions that promote T cell migration to follicles. In situ hybridization of secondary follicles for BLC showed high expression in mantle zones and low expression in germinal centers. When tested directly ex vivo, CXCR5(hi) T cells exhibited a vigorous chemotactic response to BLC. At the same time, the CXCR5(hi) cells showed reduced responsiveness to the T zone chemokines, Epstein-Barr virus-induced molecule 1 (EBI-1) ligand chemokine (ELC) and secondary lymphoid tissue chemokine (SLC). After adoptive transfer, CXCR5(hi) CD4 T cells did not migrate to follicles, indicating that additional changes may occur after immunization that help direct T cells to follicles. To further explore whether T cells could acquire an intrinsic ability to migrate to follicles, CD4(-)CD8(-) double negative (DN) T cells from MRL-lpr mice were studied. These T cells normally accumulate within follicles of MRL-lpr mice. Upon transfer to wild-type recipients, DN T cells migrated to follicle proximal regions in all secondary lymphoid tissues. Taken together, our findings indicate that reprogramming of responsiveness to constitutively expressed lymphoid tissue chemokines plays an important role in T cell migration to the B cell compartment of lymphoid tissues.

Evolution of antigen-specific T cell receptors in vivo: preimmune and antigen-driven selection of preferred complementarity-determining region 3 (CDR3) motifs.

Antigen (Ag)-driven selection of helper T cells (Th) in normal animals has been difficult to study and remains poorly understood. Using the major histocompatibility complex class II- restricted murine response to pigeon cytochrome c (PCC), we provide evidence for both preimmune and Ag-driven selection in the evolution of Ag-specific immunity in vivo. Before antigenic challenge, most Valpha11(+)Vbeta3(+) Th (70%) express a critical complementarity-determining region 3 (CDR3) residue (glutamic acid at TCR-alpha93) associated with PCC peptide contact. Over the first 5 d of the primary response, PCC-responsive Valpha11(+)Vbeta3(+) Th expressing eight preferred CDR3 features are rapidly selected in vivo. Clonal dominance is further propagated through selective expansion of the PCC-specific cells with T cell receptor (TCR) of the "best fit." Ag-driven selection is complete before significant emergence of the germinal center reaction. These data argue that thymic selection shapes TCR-alpha V region bias in the preimmune repertoire; however, Ag itself and the nongerminal center microenvironment drive the selective expansion of clones with preferred TCR that dominate the response to Ag in vivo.

B cell memory and the long-lived plasma cell.

The germinal center reaction is pivotal to the induction of B cell memory. The signals that regulate this complex microenvironment, with their cellular and molecular consequences, underpin long-term protective immunity. Recent studies have identified many key regulators of the germinal center cycle and have revealed an array of cellular outcomes that further define the memory B cell compartment.

Immune response decisions at the single cell level.

Helper T cells regulate the progressive differentiation of antigen-specific B cells in complex and dynamic microenvironments in vivo. In this review, antigen-driven B-cell differentiation will be discussed in three phases: pre-germinal center, germinal center and post-germinal center. Each phase of the response appears to have unique cellular starting points, specialized regional microenvironments and its own set of controls and cellular outcomes. Decisions made by individual lymphocytes at each of these phases determines the shape of protective immunity in vivo.

Phenotypic analysis of antigen-specific T lymphocytes.

Identification and characterization of antigen-specific T lymphocytes during the course of an immune response is tedious and indirect. To address this problem, the peptide-major histocompatability complex (MHC) ligand for a given population of T cells was multimerized to make soluble peptide-MHC tetramers. Tetramers of human lymphocyte antigen A2 that were complexed with two different human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-derived peptides or with a peptide derived from influenza A matrix protein bound to peptide-specific cytotoxic T cells in vitro and to T cells from the blood of HIV-infected individuals. In general, tetramer binding correlated well with cytotoxicity assays. This approach should be useful in the analysis of T cells specific for infectious agents, tumors, and autoantigens.

Visualizing immune responses in vivo.

Helper T cell dependent B-cell responses develop in the complex microenvironments of secondary lymphoid organs. New strategies for visualizing antigen-responsive lymphocytes offer direct insight into how differentiation proceeds in vivo.

Enumeration and characterization of memory cells in the TH compartment.

There is a great deal of interest in understanding how helper T cells differentiate in vivo and exert their regulatory role on a developing, immune response. Essential to development of protective immunity is the development of memory T cells. To study memory T cells in vivo we first need the means to identify and characterize these cells as they develop in their complex microenvironments. We have developed a method which allows us to directly purify both primary and memory helper T cells from the draining lymph nodes of mice as they respond to pigeon cytochrome c in vivo. Junctional sequences from these populations and from individual T cells show a strong selection for CDR3 length and residues characteristic of antigen binding. Overall these studies support a model of progressive clonal maturation with the memory T cell repertoire being more homogeneous than that of the primary response. There is some suggestion that affinity maturation may take place after repeated immunization, but on a more modest scale than that seen for antibodies. Finally we present the use of two new technologies that promise to greatly expand the analysis of immune responses in vivo. The use of flow cytometry with simultaneous detection of five and six fluorescence parameters helps to reliably resolve rare subsets of antigen-specific cells in order to understand the progression of their differentiation in vivo. Lastly, we have developed peptide/MHC tetramers as a new class of staining reagent that has wide applicability in the study of T cell responses in vivo.

Tracking antigen-specific helper T cell responses.

T-cell receptor transgenic animals provide an excellent source of T cells for the analysis of antigen-specific helper T-cell development. Alternatively, studies in normal animals continue to focus on specific immune responses dominated by T cells using restricted sets of antigen receptors. These complementary strategies provide direct access to the dynamics of helper T-cell differentiation in vivo.

Antigen-specific development of primary and memory T cells in vivo.

The expansion and contraction of specific helper T cells in the draining lymph nodes of normal mice after injection with antigen was followed. T cell receptors from purified primary and memory responder cells had highly restricted junctional regions, indicating antigen-driven selection. Selection for homogeneity in the length of the third complementarity-determining region (CDR3) occurs before selection for some of the characteristic amino acids, indicating the importance of this parameter in T cell receptor recognition. Ultimately, particular T cell receptor sequences come to predominate in the secondary response and others disappear, showing the selective preservation or expansion of specific T cell clones.