ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: When cognitively impaired nursing home residents exhibit agitated and aggressive behaviors during bathing, nursing home caregivers are in a unique position to improve residents' experience. This report addresses whether certified nursing assistants (CNAs) who received training in a person-centered approach with showering and with the towel bath showed improved caregiving behaviors (gentleness and verbal support) and experienced greater preparedness (confidence and ease) and less distress (hassles) when assisting residents with bathing. DESIGN AND METHODS: We used a crossover design and randomized 15 nursing homes into two treatment groups and a control group of 5 facilities each. In one treatment group, CNAs received person-centered training, first with showering for 6 weeks (Time 1) and then with the towel bath for 6 weeks (Time 2). We reversed the treatment order in the other treatment group. Control group CNAs used usual showering procedures without person-centered training. We collected observational and self-report data at baseline and at the end of Time 1 and Time 2 on five caregiving outcomes. We analyzed data from 37 CNAs assisting 69 residents by using 3x2 repeated measures analyses of variance to compare the three groups on change from baseline. RESULTS: Compared with the control group, treatment groups significantly improved in the use of gentleness and verbal support and in the perception of ease. IMPLICATIONS: A person-centered approach with showering and with the towel bath improved not only how care is given to residents who become agitated and aggressive during bathing but also how CNAs perceive their experience when bathing these residents.
Subject(s)
Aggression/psychology , Baths/methods , Dementia/psychology , Homes for the Aged , Nurses/psychology , Nursing Homes , Patient-Centered Care/methods , Psychomotor Agitation/prevention & control , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Baths/nursing , Bedding and Linens , Cross-Over Studies , Dementia/nursing , Female , Geriatric Nursing , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Psychomotor Agitation/psychology , United StatesABSTRACT
Older adults who need assistance with bathing often find the activity to be both physically and emotionally demanding, as do their caregivers. Research has identified several contributing factors, including pain; fatigue and weakness; confusion; anxiety resulting from being naked in front of strangers, being afraid of falling, and being in a noisy or unfamiliar place; and discomfort from cold or drafty bathing areas or harsh water sprays. The authors of this article make the case for the elimination of forced bathing. Research supports this change in philosophy and practice, whereby bathing is not a task to be performed but rather a human interaction. Inexpensive, practical, and evidence-based alternatives are discussed.
Subject(s)
Baths/methods , Baths/nursing , Dementia/nursing , Geriatric Nursing/methods , Activities of Daily Living , Aged , Attitude to Health , Baths/adverse effects , Baths/psychology , Clinical Nursing Research , Dementia/psychology , Fear , Geriatric Assessment , Health Services Needs and Demand , Humans , North Carolina , Nurse-Patient Relations , Nursing Assessment , Nursing Homes , Oregon , Pain/etiology , Pain/prevention & control , Patient-Centered Care/methods , Philosophy, Nursing , Risk Factors , Stress, Psychological/etiology , Stress, Psychological/prevention & controlABSTRACT
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the efficacy of two nonpharmacological techniques in reducing agitation, aggression, and discomfort in nursing home residents with dementia. The techniques evaluated were person-centered showering and the towel bath (a person-centered, in-bed bag-bath with no-rinse soap). DESIGN: A randomized, controlled trial, with a usual-care control group and two experimental groups, with crossover. SETTING: Nine skilled nursing facilities in Oregon and six in North Carolina. PARTICIPANTS: Seventy-three residents with agitation during bathing (69 completed the trial) and 37 nursing assistants who bathed them. MEASUREMENTS: Agitation and aggression were measured using the Care Recipient Behavior Assessment; discomfort was measured using a modification of the Discomfort Scale for Dementia of the Alzheimer Type. Raters who were blinded to subject status coded both from videotaped baths. Secondary measures of effect included bath duration, bath completeness, skin condition, and skin microbial flora. RESULTS: All measures of agitation and aggression declined significantly in both treatment groups but not in the control group, with aggressive incidents declining 53% in the person-centered shower group (P<.001) and 60% in the towel-bath group (P<.001). Discomfort scores also declined significantly in both intervention groups (P<.001) but not in the control group. The two interventions did not differ in agitation/aggression reduction, but discomfort was less with the towel bath (P=.003). Average bath duration increased significantly (by a mean of 3.3 minutes) with person-centered showering but not with the towel bath. Neither intervention resulted in fewer body parts being bathed; both improved skin condition; and neither increased colonization with potentially pathogenic bacteria, corynebacteria, or Candida albicans. CONCLUSION: Person-centered showering and the towel bath constitute safe, effective methods of reducing agitation, aggression, and discomfort during bathing of persons with dementia.
