Electrical, morphological, and ultrastructural remodeling and reverse remodeling in a canine model of chronic atrial fibrillation.

BACKGROUND: In patients with recurrent persistent atrial fibrillation (AF), vulnerability to AF persists indefinitely despite presumed completion of reverse electrical remodeling within days of return to normal sinus rhythm. Atrial electrical and anatomic remodeling and reverse remodeling were studied in a canine model of chronic AF. METHODS AND RESULTS: Chronic AF was induced in 8 dogs by creating moderate mitral regurgitation and rapidly pacing the right atrium at 640 bpm for >8 weeks. Measurements performed at baseline, after establishment of chronic AF, and then at 4 hours and again at 7 to 14 days after cardioversion to sinus rhythm included atrial effective refractory periods, AF cycle lengths, left atrial dimensions, premature atrial contraction (PAC) frequency, and atrial vulnerability to atrial extrastimuli. After establishing chronic AF, atrial effective refractory period shortening, increases in spontaneous PAC frequency, increases in left atrial size with loss of contractility, and multiple ultrastructural abnormalities were demonstrated. Complete reverse electrical remodeling and decreases in PACs were observed after 7 to 14 days of sinus rhythm, but there was no resolution of anatomic and ultrastructural abnormalities. Occurrence of spontaneous AF paralleled PAC frequency, but vulnerability to AF induction persisted (75% immediately after conversion versus 63% at 4 hours and 50% at 7 to 14 days) despite reverse electrical remodeling. CONCLUSIONS: After conversion from chronic AF to sinus rhythm in this canine model, electrical remodeling occurs rapidly. However, gross and ultrastructural anatomic changes persist, as does vulnerability to induced AF. Vulnerability to AF initiation 7 to 14 days after cardioversion is more dependent on persisting structural abnormalities than on electrophysiological abnormalities.

The effect of ablation sequence and duration on lesion shape using rapidly pulsed radiofrequency energy through multiple electrodes.

Sequences of energy application to multiple electrodes and a study of ablation duration with distal tip and multi-electrode ablations were explored with a radiofrequency controller that distributes energy from a generator to up to 4 electrodes with various duty cycles. In vitro ablations were performed on bovine left ventricle in circulating blood and lesions in goats were performed to verify the in vitro results. All of the ablation sequences with simultaneous electrode activation of contiguous electrodes resulted in deeper lesions than those created in sequence. There was also no scalloping of the lesion if contiguous electrodes were activated simultaneously. During all distal tip ablations, lesion volume and depth was greater after 3 minutes of energy delivery than after 1 minute, but did not increase from 3 minutes to 5 minutes. There was a significant increase in multi-electrode ablation lesion depth with each additional minute in the ablation cycle. The in vivo ablations verified these results at 120 and 300 second ablations. Pulsed energy distal tip ablations resulted in deeper lesions than continuous only if power amplitudes over 50 W were employed. In conclusion, contiguous electrodes in simultaneous use create lesions that resemble one large lesion rather than two lesions positioned next to each other. Multi-electrode ablation lesions continue to grow at ablation durations of up to 5 minutes compared to distal tip lesions which reach steady-state between 1 and 3 minutes. Pulsed energy delivery to distal tips may result in deeper lesions than conventional if high powers are employed.

Radiofrequency multielectrode catheter ablation in the atrium.

We developed a temperature-controlled radiofrequency (RF) system which can ablate by delivering energy to up to six 12.5 mm long coil electrodes simultaneously. Temperature feedback was obtained from temperature sensors placed at each end of coil electrodes, in diametrically opposite positions. The coil electrodes were connected in parallel, via a set of electronic switches, to a 150 W 500 kHz temperature-controlled RF generator. Temperatures measured at all user-selected coil electrodes were processed by a microcontroller which sent the maximum value to the temperature input of the generator. The generator adjusted the delivered power to regulate the temperature at its input within a 5 degrees C interval about a user-defined set point. The microcontroller also activated the corresponding electronic switches so that temperatures at all selected electrodes were controlled within a 5 degrees C interval with respect to each other. Physical aspects of tissue heating were first analysed using finite element models and current density measurements. Results from these analyses also constituted design input. The performance of this system was studied in vitro and in vivo. In vitro, at set temperatures of 70 degrees C, 85% of the lesions were contiguous. All lesions created at set temperatures of 80 and 90 degrees C were contiguous. The lesion length increased almost linearly with the number of electrodes. Power requirements to reach a set temperature were larger as more electrodes were driven by the generator. The system impedance decreased as more electrodes were connected in the ablation circuit and reached a low of 45.5 ohms with five coil electrodes in the circuit. In vivo, right atrial lesions were created in eight mongrel canines. The power needed to reach 70 degrees C set temperature varied between 15 and 114 W. The system impedance was 105+/-16 ohms, with one coil electrode in the circuit, and dropped to 75+/-12 ohms when two coil electrodes were simultaneously powered. The length and the width of the lesion set varied between 17.6+/-6.1 and 59.2+/-11.7 mm and 5.9+/-0.7 and 7.1+/-1.2 mm respectively. No sudden impedance rises occurred and 75% of the lesions were contiguous. From the set of contiguous lesions, 90% were potentially therapeutic as they were transmural and extended over the entire target region. The average total procedure and fluoroscopy times were 83.4 and 5.9 min respectively. We concluded that the system can safely perform long and contiguous lesions in canine right atria.

Morphological and physiological characteristics of discontinuous linear atrial ablations during atrial pacing and atrial fibrillation.

INTRODUCTION: Linear atrial ablations are thought to be necessary to accomplish successful catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation. In order to investigate the conduction characteristics of atrial myocardium in regions of linear lesion discontinuity (gaps), we performed activation sequence mapping in gap regions during atrial pacing and atrial fibrillation. METHODS AND RESULTS: In seven dogs, a linear epicardial ablation was created on the right atrial free wall with a discontinuous segment (gap) in the mid-portion of the lesion. A plaque electrode was used to measure conduction across the gap. Conduction was assessed during (1) atrial pacing from the edge of the plaque electrode during sinus rhythm, and (2) during atrial fibrillation. After each series of measurements, the lesion gap was decreased by creating additional radiofrequency ablations and repeat conduction maps were obtained. The process was repeated until conduction block was observed during atrial pacing. Gap lengths ranged from 0 to 25 mm. During atrial pacing, gaps as narrow as 2 mm demonstrated normal conduction and gaps as large as 5 mm demonstrated block during pacing. Although conduction block was never present across gaps greater than 5 mm, the ability to predict conduction block as a function of gap width was difficult for lesions < or = 5 mm due to a significant degree of overlap between normal conduction and conduction block in this gap range. During atrial fibrillation, 1/175 (0.6%) mapped wavelets conducted across gaps that demonstrated block during pacing; whereas, 411/600 (68.5%; P < 0.0001) wavelets conducted across gaps that did not demonstrate block during pacing (P = NS compared to preablation measurements). Histologically normal atrial myocytes were observed within gaps exhibiting conduction block. CONCLUSIONS: Visible gaps > 5 mm rarely demonstrate conduction block during atrial pacing and atrial fibrillation; whereas, gaps < or = 5 mm in length may demonstrate block. Lesion gaps that do not demonstrate conduction block during atrial pacing have no higher rate of functional conduction block during atrial fibrillation than fibrillating atria without ablation lesions.

Linear atrial ablations in a canine model of chronic atrial fibrillation: morphological and electrophysiological observations.

BACKGROUND: To test the hypothesis that susceptibility to sustained atrial fibrillation may be decreased by creation of linear atrial ablations, we established a canine model of chronic atrial fibrillation and used a novel catheter design to create atrial ablations. METHODS AND RESULTS: Chronic atrial fibrillation was induced in 16 dogs by creation of mitral regurgitation and rapid pacing of the atria. Temperature-controlled radiofrequency ablations were attempted along empirically derived, preselected atrial target sites in 11 dogs (ablation group), and a sham procedure was performed in 5 dogs (control group). Follow-up electrophysiology study and pathological examination were conducted 13+/-5 days after the initial procedure. Immediately after ablation, sustained atrial fibrillation could be initiated in 1 of 9 surviving ablation dogs and 5 of 5 controls (P=.004). Four dogs died within 24 hours of the procedure. Permanent pacing was required in 4 dogs. At follow-up, 0 of 7 ablation dogs and 5 of 5 controls had atrial fibrillation (P=.001). Furthermore, 2 of 7 ablation dogs had sustained atrial tachycardias, one of which was successfully ablated. Pathological examination demonstrated frequent incomplete lesion sets and discontinuous lesions. CONCLUSIONS: In this model, a reduction in the susceptibility to sustained atrial fibrillation can be achieved by long linear atrial ablations created with specially designed coil electrode catheters. Complete lesion continuity was not required to achieve a therapeutic effect.

Efficacy of multiple ring and coil electrode radiofrequency ablation catheters for the creation of long linear lesions in the atria.

Atrial fibrillation is an arrhythmia that may potentially be treated by creating long linear lesions in the atria to create lines of electrical conduction block. While this has been performed with success with open-heart surgery, it has been proposed that a less invasive catheter-based approach could achieve similar success. Radiofrequency energy catheter ablation was performed in vivo with two novel electrode catheters. Each was an expanding loop design: one with 3 mm ring electrodes; and one with 12.5 mm coil electrodes. Power delivery was controlled automatically with temperature (70 degrees C target) feedback from thermistors embedded in each electrode. A total of 39 lines of ablation were created in the atria of 11 normal dogs. The coil electrodes were more effective in creating lesions than the ring electrodes with a similar prevalence of transmurality (89% vs. 85%) but a higher prevalence of continuous transmurality (35% vs. 5%). Sequential electrode energy delivery was better than simultaneous multipolar delivery due to varying efficiencies of tissue heating. Inadequate heating was observed in 47% of simultaneous versus 1% of sequential multipolar deliveries, and excessive heating in 6% versus 1% of cases, respectively. It is feasible to create linear atrial lesions with an expanding loop electrode catheter. Catheters with coil electrodes are more effective than those with ring electrodes. In order to avoid coagulum formation and inefficient heating, sequential electrode energy delivery is preferable to multipolar delivery.

Nonuniform heating during radiofrequency catheter ablation with long electrodes: monitoring the edge effect.

BACKGROUND: Long, narrow electrodes are being considered for radiofrequency ablation of atrial fibrillation; however, preliminary work revealed coagulum formation on the electrodes and lack of lesion continuity. This may be due to the "edge effect," which concentrates radiated energy at sharp geometric gradients. It is proposed that temperature sensors at electrode edges are preferable to a single centered sensor for temperature feedback and monitoring of long electrode geometries. METHODS AND RESULTS: A finite element model was used to predict the heating properties of new long electrode geometries. Sixteen dogs with atrial fibrillation underwent left and right atrial ablation using catheters with multiple 12.5-mm coil electrodes. Electrodes with a single thermistor were compared with electrodes with dual thermocouples placed at opposite ends and on opposing sides of the electrode. Power, temperature, and impedance were recorded for all lesions, and coagulum adhesion and magnitude were noted in a subset of lesions. Finite element analysis shows uneven heating, with the main heating concentrated at the electrode edges and a propensity toward temperatures >100 degrees C with single-thermistor feedback control. Ablations with dual thermocouple electrodes achieved higher measured temperatures at lower power levels than those that used single-thermistor electrodes. Impedance rises and coagulum adherence occurred less frequently with dual thermocouple electrodes than with single, centered thermistor electrodes (176 of 395 versus 9 of 425 lesions; P<.0001; 46 of 98 versus 7 of 150 lesions; P<.0001, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Maximum heating from radiofrequency energy occurs at the electrode edges, particularly with long electrodes. The safety of temperature-feedback atrial ablation with these electrodes is significantly improved by monitoring temperatures at the edges.

Effects of dispersive electrode position and surface area on electrical parameters and temperature during radiofrequency catheter ablation.

Positioning of the dispersive electrode has no significant effect during radiofrequency ablation. Doubling the surface are of the dispersive electrode results in a lower impedance, higher current delivery, and increased tip temperatures, particularly if the baseline impedance is >100 ohms. These findings may have important implications for optimizing radiofrequency energy delivery using currently available radiofrequency generators.

Temperature measurement as a determinant of tissue heating during radiofrequency catheter ablation: an examination of electrode thermistor positioning for measurement accuracy.

INTRODUCTION: Temperature monitoring has been proposed as a control for lesion occurrence and dimension during radiofrequency transcatheter ablation. Effective temperature measurement depends on thermistor positioning relative to the heated cardiac tissue and the convective cooling effects of the circulation. But the accuracy of a single tip thermistor as a measure of peak electrode-tissue interface temperature is unknown. METHODS AND RESULTS: A standard 8-French, 4-mm electrode catheter with 5 thermistors (1 tip thermistor, 4 radial thermistors) was used to deliver radiofrequency energy in vitro to 3 porcine right ventricles and in vivo to 7 mongrel dogs. In vitro, the catheter orientation was varied. In vivo the catheter was positioned under fluoroscopy at a variety of atrial, tricuspid annular, and ventricular sites, with no attempt to adjust catheter orientation. In both cases varied discrete power levels were used so that a wide temperature range was attained. Lesions created in vivo with a standard, single thermistor tipped electrode were compared to those of a catheter with a thermistor extending 1 mm from the tip. Power was varied and tip thermistor temperatures recorded. All lesions were examined pathologically. Comparisons of radial thermistor temperature to tip thermistor temperature for 3 catheter orientations in vitro resulted in tip thermistor underestimation of peak electrode-tissue interface temperature by a median of 0.5 degrees C in 35% of the perpendicular orientations, 1.9 degrees C in 82% of the 45 orientations, and 5 degrees C in 83% of the parallel orientations. During in vivo trials, the tip thermistor underestimated the peak electrode-tissue interface temperature during 2 of 51 lesions by 1.2 degrees C and 7.6 degrees C. There was a sudden rise in electrical impedance in 17 of 51 radiofrequency energy deliveries. Only one case was observed where the peak electrode-tissue interface temperature was below 95 degrees C. The normal to extended tip thermistor configurations analysis showed similar relationships between lesion size and temperature. CONCLUSIONS: Accuracy of a single tip thermistor was found to be dependent upon catheter-tissue orientation. With routine catheter positioning in vivo, the tip thermistor was a good indicator of peak electrode-tissue interface temperature. Thus with power regulation to avoid temperatures greater than 90 degrees C, a single flush-mounted tip thermistor is probably adequate for temperature monitoring of lesion formation and avoidance of impedance rises.