Children's Diet during the Early Stages of the Nutritional Transition. The Foundlings in the Hospital of Valencia (Spain), 1852-1931.

The nutritional transition brought about profound changes in the nutrition of the European population in the 19th and 20th centuries. The predominant consumption of cereals gave way to kilocalorie-, protein-, vitamin- and mineral-rich diets that involved a greater intake of animal products. However, not all population groups underwent this transition at the same pace; socio-economic conditions, sex and age led to important inequalities. This article uses institutional sources to analyse the nutrition of children during the early stages of the nutritional transition and to compare it with that of other age groups (adult psychiatric patients). The study examines the average diets and nutritional balance of foundlings in the Hospital General de Valencia from 1852 to 1931. The main conclusion of the study is that, throughout the period under study, foundlings were exposed to a poor, traditional diet, characterized by structural deficits and imbalances. This may have affected their physical growth, health and biological wellbeing in adulthood, and demonstrates that the nutritional transition was anything but a homogeneous process.

Dietas y desigualdad social en la transición nutricional española: el Hospital Provincial de Valencia y el Hospital Sant Jaume de Olot; 1900-1936 / Diets and social inequality in the Spanish nutritional transition: the Hospital Provincial of Valencia and the hospital Sant Jaume of Olot, 1900-1936

Introducción: los estudios sobre la transición nutricional española (TNE) hasta mediados del siglo xx se basaban en estimaciones indirectas y muy agregadas del consumo que no permiten conocer aspectos importantes de aquel proceso. Objetivo: mostrar las nuevas posibilidades de estudio que proporcionan las dietas hospitalarias y proponer nuevos indicadores de la TNE a partir de las estimadas en el Hospital Provincial de Valencia (HPV) y en el Hospital Sant Jaume de Olot (HSJO) entre 1900 y 1936. Método: calculamos el consumo de alimentos y nutrientes de pacientes y empleados en aquellos hospitales y en diferentes subgrupos de población del primero. Contrastamos nuestros resultados con los obtenidos para España en el artículo anterior de este suplemento. Resultados: las dietas hospitalarias contribuyeron a difundir alimentos estratégicos de la TNE: primero, leche, huevos y carne fresca, y después, pescado fresco, verduras y frutas. La difusión de estos alimentos, sin embargo, fue desigual entre la población y no redujo con la misma intensidad los déficits en la ingesta de macronutrientes y micronutrientes. Conclusiones: las dietas hospitalarias confirman la mejora del estado nutricional de la población española en las décadas anteriores a la Guerra Civil y el papel pionero que tuvieron las instituciones sanitarias en este proceso. No obstante, también muestran diferentes cronologías en la reducción de los déficits de importantes nutrientes entre grupos de edad y estatus socioeconómico

Introduction: studies about the Nutritional Transition in Spain (NTS) until the mid-20th century are based on direct, and heavily aggregated, consumption estimates, a methodology that obscures important aspects of this process. Objective: to show the new possibilities of study opened by the analysis of hospital diets and to suggest new NTS indicators based on the menus provided by the Hospital Provincial in Valencia (HPV) and the Hospital Sant Jaume in Olot (HSJO), between 1900 and 1936. Method: we have calculated food and nutrient consumption among patients and hospital staff as well as among different groups of the population, and compared the results thus obtained with those calculated for the whole of Spain in the previous article in this supplement. Results: hospital menus contributed to disseminate certain strategic foodstuffs for the NTS: milk, eggs and fresh meat first, and fish, vegetables and fruit later. The public dissemination of these foodstuffs was, however, uneven, and deficits in the intake of micro- and macro-nutrients intake decreased at different paces, according to social group. Conclusions: hospital diets confirm that nutrition in Spain improved in the decades that preceded the Civil War, as well as the pioneering role that sanitary institutions played in this process. The data also suggests that the process operated at different paces in the reduction of deficits in the intake of certain nutrients according to age groups and socio-economic status

[Diets and social inequality in the Spanish nutritional transition: the Hospital Provincial of Valencia and the hospital Sant Jaume of Olot, 1900-1936]. / Dietas y desigualdad social en la transición nutricional española: el Hospital Provincial de Valencia y el Hospital Sant Jaume de Olot; 1900-1936.

INTRODUCTION: studies about the Nutritional Transition in Spain (NTS) until the mid-20th century are based on direct, and heavily aggregated, consumption estimates, a methodology that obscures important aspects of this process. OBJECTIVE: to show the new possibilities of study opened by the analysis of hospital diets and to suggest new NTS indicators based on the menus provided by the Hospital Provincial in Valencia (HPV) and the Hospital Sant Jaume in Olot (HSJO), between 1900 and 1936. METHOD: we have calculated food and nutrient consumption among patients and hospital staff as well as among different groups of the population, and compared the results thus obtained with those calculated for the whole of Spain in the previous article in this supplement. RESULTS: hospital menus contributed to disseminate certain strategic foodstuffs for the NTS: milk, eggs and fresh meat first, and fish, vegetables and fruit later. The public dissemination of these foodstuffs was, however, uneven, and deficits in the intake of micro- and macro-nutrients intake decreased at different paces, according to social group. CONCLUSIONS: hospital diets confirm that nutrition in Spain improved in the decades that preceded the Civil War, as well as the pioneering role that sanitary institutions played in this process. The data also suggests that the process operated at different paces in the reduction of deficits in the intake of certain nutrients according to age groups and socio-economic status.

Introducción: los estudios sobre la transición nutricional española (TNE) hasta mediados del siglo XX se basaban en estimaciones indirectas y muy agregadas del consumo que no permiten conocer aspectos importantes de aquel proceso.Objetivo: mostrar las nuevas posibilidades de estudio que proporcionan las dietas hospitalarias y proponer nuevos indicadores de la TNE a partir de las estimadas en el Hospital Provincial de Valencia (HPV) y en el Hospital Sant Jaume de Olot (HSJO) entre 1900 y 1936.Método: calculamos el consumo de alimentos y nutrientes de pacientes y empleados en aquellos hospitales y en diferentes subgrupos de población del primero. Contrastamos nuestros resultados con los obtenidos para España en el artículo anterior de este suplemento.Resultados: las dietas hospitalarias contribuyeron a difundir alimentos estratégicos de la TNE: primero, leche, huevos y carne fresca, y después, pescado fresco, verduras y frutas. La difusión de estos alimentos, sin embargo, fue desigual entre la población y no redujo con la misma intensidad los déficits en la ingesta de macronutrientes y micronutrientes.Conclusiones: las dietas hospitalarias confirman la mejora del estado nutricional de la población española en las décadas anteriores a la Guerra Civil y el papel pionero que tuvieron las instituciones sanitarias en este proceso. No obstante, también muestran diferentes cronologías en la reducción de los déficits de importantes nutrientes entre grupos de edad y estatus socioeconómico.