A realist synthesis of prospective entrustment decision making by entrustment or clinical competency committees.

INTRODUCTION: The real-world mechanisms underlying prospective entrustment decision making (PEDM) by entrustment or clinical competency committees (E/CCCs) are poorly understood. To advance understanding in this area, the authors conducted a realist synthesis of the published literature to address the following research question: In E/CCC efforts to make defensible prospective entrustment decisions (PEDs), what works, for whom, under what circumstances and why? METHODS: Realist work seeks to understand the contexts (C), mechanisms (M) and outcomes (O) that explain how and why things work (or do not). In the authors' study, contexts included individual E/CCC members, E/CCC structures and processes, and training programmes. The outcome (i.e. desired outcome) was a PED. Mechanisms were a substantial focus of the analysis and informed the core findings. To define a final corpus of 52 included papers, the authors searched four databases, screened all results from those searches and performed a full-text review of a subset of screened papers. Data extraction focused on developing context-mechanism-outcome configurations from the papers, which were used to create a theory for how PEDM leads to PEDs. RESULTS: PEDM is often driven by default (non-deliberate) decision making rather than a deliberate process of deciding whether a trainee should be entrusted or not. When defaulting, some E/CCCs find red flags that sometimes lead to being more deliberate with decision making. E/CCCs that seek to be deliberate describe PEDM that can be effortful (when data are insufficient or incongruent) or effortless (when data are robust and tell a congruent story about a trainee). Both information about trainee trustworthiness and the sufficiency of data about trainee performance influence PEDM. Several moderators influence what is considered to be sufficient data, how trustworthiness data are viewed and how PEDM is carried out. These include perceived consequences and associated risks, E/CCC member trust propensity, E/CCC member personal knowledge of and experience with trainees and E/CCC structures and processes. DISCUSSION: PEDM is rarely deliberate but should be. Data about trainee trustworthiness are foundational to making PEDs. Bias, equity and fairness are nearly absent from the papers in this synthesis, and future efforts must seek to advance understanding and practice regarding the roles of bias, equity and fairness in PEDM.

Evaluation of Housing Affordability Among US Resident Physicians.

This cross-sectional study evaluates the extent of housing unaffordability among US residency programs.

National Survey of Combined Pediatrics-Anesthesiology Residents and Graduates: Factors Contributing to Changing Career Aspirations Over Time.

BACKGROUND: The Dual Pathway for Certification in Pediatrics and Anesthesiology was created in 2011 to develop leaders in caring for children with complex medical and surgical conditions. While existing dual-trained practitioners report continued practice in both pediatric anesthesiology (PA) and pediatric critical care medicine (PCCM), recent surveys of dual pathway trainees have shown that only one-quarter still currently plan to pursue training in PCCM, a change from their initial plans to complete training in both PA and PCCM. The aim of this study was to further characterize the motivations driving shifts in career trajectory during training as well as factors affecting the combined training experience. METHODS: We conducted an online mixed-methods survey of all individuals who had matriculated at 1 of the 7 Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-accredited combined pediatrics-anesthesiology residencies from 2011 to 2018. The survey consisted of a 30-item questionnaire addressing training experience, anticipated career trajectory, and respondent demographics. Descriptive statistics were used for closed-format questions. Responses to open-ended questions were systematically analyzed through inductive iterative review by 2 of the authors to elicit a set of overarching themes. RESULTS: We achieved a response rate of 85% (n = 53/62) with respondents from 7 of 7 combined residency programs. When asked about career goals, the majority of respondents planned to pursue both PA and PCCM (60%, n = 32) at the start of residency. However, at the time of survey completion, the percentage of respondents who were still planning to (or had already completed) train in both PA and PCCM had decreased to 23% (n = 12). Factors such as lifestyle and length of training contributed more to career choices during/after training compared to before residency. Thematic analysis of open-ended questions regarding transition between specialties, impact of dual training, and general comments revealed 3 major themes: (1) challenges of transitioning between specialties, (2) dual training is mutually beneficial, and (3) the need for an established fellowship training pathway. CONCLUSIONS: While there is continued interest in dual training in PA/PCCM for residents who enter the combined pediatrics-anesthesiology residency, factors such as duration of training and lifestyle become more important during residency and alter their career trajectories, often away from PCCM. Optimization of dual-subspecialty fellowship training will be critical to sustaining interest in dual-subspecialty training in PA/PCCM.

Participation in a Resident-as-Teacher Rotation: Motivations of and Impacts on Faculty Coaches.

PURPOSE: Coaching in medical education is increasingly used for trainee development for a variety of skills, including improving trainee teaching skills through resident-as-teacher programs. Faculty who serve as coaches commit significant effort to the coaching role, often without protected time or support. Little is known about faculty motivations to participate in coaching programs or how the coaching experience affects the faculty. This study explored faculty coaches' motivations to participate as coaches in a resident-as-teacher rotation and the impacts they experienced as a result of their participation. METHOD: In this qualitative study, authors conducted 14 semistructured interviews in 2019 with faculty coaches from a single resident-as-teacher program in Boston, Massachusetts. Authors analyzed the transcripts using thematic analysis to develop a conceptual framework. RESULTS: Faculty coaches' motivations for initial participation included a sense of honor; a sense of duty; perception of competence; interest in promoting medical education; and desire for increased connectedness. These motivations all related to a larger theme of educator identity. Coaches identified 3 main impacts from participation: improvement in their own teaching, personal satisfaction from helping others and seeing improvement in their learners, and increased connectedness. These impacts affirmed the coaches' educator identity and led to ongoing motivation to participate. They also contributed to the coaches' well-being at work. CONCLUSIONS: Faculty were initially motivated to participate as coaches in a resident-as-teacher rotation based on their identity as educators. The benefits achieved-improvement in own teaching, personal satisfaction, and increased connectedness-affirmed their educator identity and led to ongoing participation and increased well-being at work. These motivations and impacts are important to consider as future programs are developed and coaches are recruited for programs across undergraduate, graduate, and continuing medical education settings.

Making prospective entrustment decisions: Knowing limits, seeking help and defaulting.

INTRODUCTION: Many studies focused on entrustment have not considered prospective entrustment decisions, where clinical competency and entrustment committees determine how much supervision trainees will require in the future for tasks occurring in not completely known contexts. The authors sought to explore factors that influence and determine prospective entrustment decisions made by members of such committees in graduate medical education (GME) and undergraduate medical education (UME). METHODS: The authors conducted a constructivist grounded theory study with 23 faculty participants from GME and UME clinical competency and entrustment committees in the United States between October 2020 and March 2021. Interviews sought to explore factors and considerations participants weigh in making prospective entrustment decisions about trainees. Data collection and analysis occurred in an iterative fashion, ensuring constant comparison. Theoretical sampling was used to confirm, disconfirm and elaborate on the evolving results. RESULTS: Trainees' ability to know limits and seek help is the foundation of participants' prospective entrustment decision making. Most participants, however, describe a presumption of trainee readiness to progress and describe commonly making default prospective entrustment decisions unless 'red flags' in performance are present. Although participants desire sufficient and trusted data about trainee performance to inform decisions, they often lack it. Finally, the perceived permanence and consequences of prospective entrustment decisions influence how participants weigh other factors contributing to prospective entrustment decisions. CONCLUSION: Trainees' ability to know limits and seek help appears to be the foundation of prospective entrustment decision making. Training programmes should strive to collect and employ robust data supporting and questioning the presence of these attributes.

Effect of a Novel Mindfulness Curriculum on Burnout During Pediatric Internship: A Cluster Randomized Clinical Trial.

IMPORTANCE: Mindfulness curricula can improve physician burnout, but implementation during residency presents challenges. OBJECTIVE: To examine whether a novel mindfulness curriculum implemented in the first 6 months of internship reduces burnout. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This pragmatic, multicenter, stratified cluster randomized clinical trial of a mindfulness curriculum randomized 340 pediatric interns to the intervention or control arm within program pairs generated based on program size and region. Fifteen US pediatric training programs participated from June 14, 2017, to February 28, 2019. INTERVENTIONS: The intervention included 7 hour-long sessions of a monthly mindfulness curriculum (Mindfulness Intervention for New Interns) and a monthly mindfulness refresher implemented during internship. The active control arm included monthly 1-hour social lunches. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome was emotional exhaustion (EE) as measured by the Maslach Burnout Inventory 9-question EE subscale (range, 7-63; higher scores correspond to greater perceived burnout). Secondary outcomes were depersonalization, personal accomplishment, and burnout. The study assessed mindfulness with the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire and empathy with the Interpersonal Reactivity Index subscales of perspective taking and empathetic concern. Surveys were implemented at baseline, month 6, and month 15. RESULTS: Of the 365 interns invited to participate, 340 (93.2%; 255 [75.0%] female; 51 [15.0%] 30 years or older) completed surveys at baseline; 273 (74.8%) also participated at month 6 and 195 (53.4%) at month 15. Participants included 194 (57.1%) in the Mindfulness Intervention for New Interns and 146 (42.9%) in the control arm. Analyses were adjusted for baseline outcome measures. Both arms' EE scores were higher at 6 and 15 months than at baseline, but EE did not significantly differ by arm in multivariable analyses (6 months: 35.4 vs 32.4; adjusted difference, 3.03; 95% CI, -0.14 to 6.21; 15 months: 33.8 vs 32.9; adjusted difference, 1.42; 95% CI, -2.42 to 5.27). None of the 6 secondary outcomes significantly differed by arm at month 6 or month 15. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: A novel mindfulness curriculum did not significantly affect EE, burnout, empathy, or mindfulness immediately or 9 months after curriculum implementation. These findings diverge from prior nonrandomized studies of mindfulness interventions, emphasizing the importance of rigorous study design and suggesting that additional study is needed to develop evidence-based methods to reduce trainee burnout. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT03148626.

The Use of Parenting Electives in Pediatric Residency.

BACKGROUND: Financial considerations and the desire to not prolong training often influence residents' parental leave length. Some residencies offer parenting electives. These primarily self-directed electives can extend parental time at home, support transition back to work, and allow residents to remain in training and be paid during these transitions. OBJECTIVE: Describe the prevalence and structure of parenting electives within pediatric residency programs from 3 geographic regions of the Association of Pediatric Program Directors (APPD). METHODS: All 66 pediatric residency program directors in the Western, Mid-America, and Northeastern regions of APPD were invited to participate in a phone interview regarding existence of and structure of their programs' parenting elective. RESULTS: Thirty-six programs responded (55%). Of those, 24 (67% of responding programs) offer a specific parenting elective and an additional 5 (14%) offer a generic elective that can be tailored to new parents. Curricular elements shared by almost all programs offering specific parenting electives include self-reflective exercises, exploration of a community resource, and parenting articles/book review. Most programs incorporate clinic but not call into these electives. CONCLUSION: Parenting electives are increasingly available in pediatric residency programs to support new resident parents. Sharing common curricular elements may help other programs implement and/or enhance this elective offering.

Pediatric Trainees as Parents: Perspectives on Parenthood From Pediatric Resident Parents.

OBJECTIVES: Prior work across medical and surgical specialties shows that parenthood during residency training is associated with challenges including limited parental leave, lack of accommodations for breastfeeding, and concerns about career impact. Less is known about the experience of parenthood during pediatric residency training. The objective of this study was to identify themes related to the experience of parenthood during pediatric residency. METHODS: In this qualitative study using thematic analysis, we performed semistructured interviews with participants who were currently in pediatric residency or had graduated in the previous 3 years and were parents during residency. Participants were recruited by e-mail. Data were collected and analyzed iteratively until thematic saturation was achieved. Two independent reviewers coded each transcript. Codes were grouped into categories and then into dominant themes. RESULTS: Thirty-one residents were interviewed from 13 pediatric residency programs. Four major themes regarding the experience of parenthood during pediatric residency were defined by the data: 1) the struggles of parenthood and residency exacerbate each other; 2) institutional modifiers strongly influence the experiences of resident parents; 3) resident parents develop skills and perspectives that enhance their pediatric training; and 4) although levels of support for pediatric resident parents vary, the culture of pediatrics positively influences the experience of parenthood in residency. CONCLUSIONS: There are numerous challenges navigating parenthood and residency, but institutional policies and culture can modify the experience. Importantly, the educational value of parenthood to pediatric training was immense. Our findings may be used to design interventions to support parenting during residency.

Pediatric Trainees as Parents: Perspectives From a Pandemic.

OBJECTIVES: Resident parents are at the intersection of converging challenges during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, and their perspective has yet to be explored. This qualitative study aimed to identify themes related to the experience of pediatric resident parents during the COVID-19 pandemic. METHODS: We performed semistructured interviews with pediatric residents who were also parents. Using thematic analysis, transcripts were analyzed iteratively until theoretical sufficiency was achieved. RESULTS: Twelve residents were interviewed from 9 pediatric residency programs. Five major themes, representing conflicts or tensions experienced by participants, were defined by the data: 1) Duty as a doctor versus duty as a parent; 2) Balance of work obligations versus childcare challenges; 3) Appreciation of added support versus worry about peers' perceptions of accommodations; 4) Gratitude for the recognition of challenges faced by resident parents versus fear of reversion to the norm; and 5) Protective impact of parenthood versus challenges to mental health. CONCLUSIONS: Both parents and healthcare workers faced innumerable challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic, and this exploration of the experiences of pediatric resident parents provides a unique lens for examining the tensions that this group faced. Our results may allow residency programs to better support their pediatric resident parents during this crisis.

MINdI: Mindfulness Instruction for New Interns.

Introduction: Trainee burnout has reached epidemic proportions and is increasing among physicians compared to non-health care professionals. Burnout is associated with depression and lower empathy, poor patient adherence to medical plans, and early physician retirement. Mindfulness is the quality of being nonjudgmental and present and has been shown to decrease physician burnout. Implementation of mindfulness curricula may decrease trainee burnout. Methods: Using Kern's six-step approach, we developed an easy-to-implement, facilitator-friendly mindfulness curriculum for pediatric interns. Curricular sessions were held monthly during preexisting 1-hour didactics over 6 months, facilitated by individuals without mindfulness experience. Learners were assessed on knowledge, attitudes, and behavior with postintervention surveys during a pilot in 2016. Qualitative data were used for curricular improvement resulting in the published curriculum. Results: Postcurriculum surveys from our pilot revealed that 69% of interns reported a more positive attitude toward mindfulness, while 62% reported having (1) greater knowledge about evidence supporting mindfulness, (2) improved knowledge on how to apply mindfulness techniques, and (3) the belief that techniques they had learned positively impacted their lives. Thirty-three percent endorsed using mindfulness techniques more frequently than they had prior to the start of the mindfulness curriculum. Discussion: Our novel curriculum provided longitudinal mindfulness training that meaningfully impacted trainee knowledge, behaviors, and attitudes. The curricular structure overcame the need for local topic experts and was feasible to implement within the confines of our complex program structure. Ongoing work will determine the impact of our curriculum on objective measures of burnout, empathy, and mindfulness.

Women's Experiences of the Effect of Financial Strain on Parenting and Mental Health.

OBJECTIVE: To develop a conceptual theory to describe how financial strain affects women with young children to inform clinical care and research. DESIGN: Qualitative, grounded theory. SETTING: Participants were recruited from the waiting area of a pediatric clinic and an office of the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children embedded within the largest safety-net academic medical center in New England. Participants were interviewed privately at the medical center or in the community. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-six English-speaking women, mostly single and African American/Black, with at least one child 5 years old or younger, were sampled until thematic saturation was met. METHODS: We used grounded theory methodology to conduct in-depth, semistructured interviews with participants who indicated that they experienced financial strain. We analyzed the interview data using constant comparative analysis, revised the interview guide based on emerging themes, and developed a theoretical model. RESULTS: Five interrelated themes emerged and were developed into a theoretical model: Financial Strain Has Specific Characteristics and Common Triggers, Financial Strain Is Exacerbated by Inadequate Assistance and Results in Tradeoffs, Financial Strain Forces Parenting Modifications, Women Experience Self-Blame, and Women Experience Mental Health Effects. CONCLUSION: For women with young children, financial strain results in forced tradeoffs, compromised parenting practices, and self-blame, which contribute to significant mental health problems. These findings can inform woman-centered clinical practice and advocacy interventions. Women's health care providers should identify families experiencing financial strain, provide referrals to financial services, and join advocacy efforts to advance social policies that address the structural causes of poverty, such as increased minimum wage and paid family leave.

TEACH and repeat: Deliberate practice for teaching.

BACKGROUND: Deliberate practice facilitates skill mastery. We aimed to create a novel resident-as-teacher rotation, leveraging a deliberate practice framework with repeated practice in real-life teaching settings, with feedback from dedicated faculty member coaches. METHODS: A resident-as-teacher rotation was designed for 35 Postgraduate Year-2 (PGY2) paediatric residents. To facilitate deliberate practice, teaching experiences were observed by faculty member coaches and were repeated with different audiences. Participating residents received pre-rotation, post-rotation and follow-up surveys on their confidence and comfort with teaching, supervision and feedback skills. All residents were also surveyed the year before and the year after implementation on their perceptions of their teaching, supervision and feedback skills, and whether the residency provided adequate training on these topics. RESULTS: Survey response rates varied from 40 to 71%. The rotation was highly valued, and deliberate practice was a most valued aspect. Mean scores in comfort and confidence significantly increased from pre- to post-rotation, with these increases sustained months later. Prior to implementation, residents' perceptions of their teaching skills and the adequacy of their training increased incrementally with each postgraduate year. After the inaugural year of the rotation, the PGY2 class rated their teaching skills and training as higher than more experienced residents. DISCUSSION: A novel resident-as-teacher rotation successfully incorporated deliberate practice in real-life settings by repeating teaching activities with feedback from dedicated coaches. The rotation led to sustained increases in residents' confidence in their teaching, supervising and feedback skills, and improved perceptions of their teaching training during residency.

Defining the Essential Components of a Teaching Service.

OBJECTIVES: A large portion of residency education occurs in inpatient teaching services without widely accepted consensus regarding the essential components that constitute a teaching service. We sought to generate consensus around this topic, with the goal of developing criteria programs that can be used when creating, redesigning, or evaluating teaching services. METHODS: A list of potential components of teaching services was developed from a literature search, interviews, and focus groups. Eighteen pediatric medical education experts participated in a modified Delphi method, responding to a series of surveys rating the importance of the proposed components. Each iterative survey was amended on the basis of the results of the previous survey. A final survey evaluating the (1) effort and (2) impact of implementing components that had reached consensus as recommended was distributed. RESULTS: Each survey had 100% panelist response. Five survey rounds were conducted. Fourteen attending physician characteristics and 7 system characteristics reached consensus as essential components of a teaching service. An additional 25 items reached consensus as recommended. When evaluating the effort and impact of these items, the implementation of attending characteristics was perceived as requiring less effort than system characteristics but as having similar impact. CONCLUSIONS: Consensus on the essential and recommended components of a resident teaching service was achieved by using the modified Delphi method. Although the items that reached consensus as essential are similar to those proposed by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, those that reached consensus as recommended are less commonly discussed and should be strongly considered by institutions.

Application Factors Associated With Clinical Performance During Pediatric Internship.

OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to identify aspects of residency applications predictive of subsequent performance during pediatric internship. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective cohort study of graduates of US medical schools who began pediatric internship in a large pediatric residency program in the summers of 2013 to 2017. The primary outcome was the weighted average of subjects' Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education pediatric Milestone scores at the end of pediatric internship. To determine factors independently associated with performance, we conducted multivariate linear mixed-effects models controlling for match year and Milestone grading committee as random effects and the following application factors as fixed effects: letter of recommendation strength, clerkship grades, medical school reputation, master's or PhD degrees, gender, US Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 score, Alpha Omega Alpha membership, private medical school, and interview score. RESULTS: Our study population included 195 interns. In multivariate analyses, the aspects of applications significantly associated with composite Milestone scores at the end of internship were letter of recommendation strength (estimate 0.09, 95% confidence intervals [CI]: 0.04, 0.15), numbers of clerkship honors (est. 0.05, 95% CI: 0.01-0.09), medical school ranking (est. 0.04, 95% CI: 0.08-0.01), having a master's degree (est. 0.19, 95% CI: 0.03-0.36), and not having a PhD (est. 0.14, 95% CI: 0.02-0.26). Overall, the final model explained 18% of the variance in milestone scoring. CONCLUSIONS: Letter of recommendation strength, clerkship grades, medical school ranking, and having obtained a Master's degree were significantly associated with higher clinical performance during pediatric internship.