Uncontrolled donation after circulatory death and liver transplantation: evidence and unresolved issues.

This review aimed at summarizing the available evidence on liver transplantation from uncontrolled donation after circulatory death (uDCD) on differences in protocols, donor management, in and ex vivo perfusion techniques from center to center. Uncontrolled DCDs represent a unique, complex model of ischemia-reperfusion injury, so far not completely understood. Nevertheless, results on liver transplantation from uDCDs are promising in terms of long-term graft survival. True difficulties still remain since common/shared protocols are not achievable due to legal differences between countries (i.e. no touch period duration). To date, there is no reliable metrics to determine whether a liver is safe to be ex situ perfused or to be transplanted since existing criteria, as stated by investigators themselves, are so far arbitrary. Values and kinetics of transaminanes during normothermic regional perfusion (nRP) should not considered absolute contraindication at least for ex vivo perfusion. Intraoperative evaluation at organ recovery remains pivotal since macroscopic alterations (i.e. hepatic rupture, an abnormal appearance of gall bladder and choledocus) still represent contraindications for organ retrieval. Concerning ex vivo perfusion, the debate is still open, since the choice of type of machine perfusion (mainly hypothermic vs. normothermic) varies from center to center, mainly relying to the single center experience (especially in controlled DCD), surgeons' believes and/or criteria translated from animal models.

Factors influencing consent to organ donation after brain death certification: a survey of 29 Intensive Care Units.

BACKGROUND: Family refusal (FR) to heart beating donation (HBD) in Intensive Care Unit (ICU) is increasing in recent years with a significant impact on the number of transplantable organs. Fostering setting humanization, quality of relationships, respect for will and family reliance towards ICU could be relevant in containing FR to organ donation (OD) in ICU. Our aims were to highlight the effects of structural features of ICUs and humanization determinants on FR in HBD process, and to describe visiting policies, structure and modalities of support in ICUs. METHODS: A survey was conducted among all the ICUs of the Tuscany Region included in the National Transplant System of the Ministry of Health in Italy. Data on ICUs' general and architectural characteristics, visiting policies and support for families were collected. Baseline characteristics of brain dead certified patients (BDCPs) were retrieved from the Registry of the Regional Transplant Centre. RESULTS: Twenty-nine (93.5%) ICUs out of 31 completed the survey. 330 BDCPs were managed during 2016 in the ICUs studied, with an opposition rate of 33.3%. The following independent factors for opposition emerged: BDCPs' age (OR=1.025; 95% CI: 1.007-1.042; P=0.005), ICU length of stay (LOS) (OR=1.065; 95% CI: 1.005-1.128; P=0.034) and the availability of an ICU team trained in procurement (OR=0.472; 95% CI: 0.275-0.811; P=0.007). CONCLUSIONS: Older age of BDCPs and a prolonged ICU LOS resulted in FR. ICU team specific education emerged as the only modifiable protective factor for oppositions, thus continuous and in-depth training programs for physicians and nurses could be of importance in preventing FR.

Implementing a donation after circulatory death program in a setting of donation after brain death activity.

BACKGROUND: Donation after circulatory death (DCD) is an emerging way to implement organ procurement for transplantation. In Italy, until June 2016, the only formal DCD program was implemented in Pavia, the so-called "Alba program." METHODS: We describe our one-year experience of the DCD program implemented at the Careggi Teaching Hospital (Florence, Italy) since June 2016. We specifically describe organizational changes induced by the DCD program on our pre-existing Donation After Brain Death (DBD) program and DCD activity. RESULTS: Eighteen activations were recorded (i.e. 18 DCD donors), among whom Seven donors were discarded due to opposition in five patients and failure to meet activation criteria in two (inability to contact relatives). Our population comprises 11 donors among whom eight patients were Maastricht type II donors while three were Maastricht type III donors. 22 kidneys and six livers were retrieved, while 13 kidneys and two liver were transplanted. CONCLUSIONS: A DCD program was feasible and increased procurement of splancnic organs (kidney and liver). Starting a DCD program in a traditionally oriented to DBD poses some organizational and cultural problems. A skilled, experienced ECMO team is necessary to guarantee organ ex vivo perfusion. Another important aspect for the implementation of a DCD program is the collaboration with the emergency system which allows a therapeutic approach of patients with cardiac arrest.

Retrospective Analysis of Transcranial Doppler Patterns in Veno-Arterial Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation Patients: Feasibility of Cerebral Circulatory Arrest Diagnosis.

Transcranial Doppler (TCD) is able to detect cerebral hemodynamic changes in real-time. Impairment of cerebral blood flow during veno-arterial (VA) extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) treatment is referred to in the literature. Several cerebrovascular complications can affect VA ECMO patients, eventually leading to brain death (BD). Transcranial Doppler is a worldwide accepted technique for cerebral circulatory arrest (CCA) diagnosis for BD confirmation, and in Italy, it is mandatory in certain clinical conditions. Nowadays, no data have been published on the use of TCD as a confirmation test in VA ECMO patients evolved to BD. The aim of our study was to investigate the feasibility of TCD in CCA diagnosis during VA ECMO treatment. Thirty-two TCD examinations, performed in 25 patients on VA ECMO, were retrospectively analyzed, and factors that could be responsible for TCD waveforms abnormalities were reviewed. Differences in TCD patterns were detected depending on values of left ventricular ejection fraction and the absence or presence of intraaortic balloon pump (IABP). Four categories of different TCD patterns were then identified. In five BD patients, diagnostic CCA patterns in all cerebral arteries were identified by TCD. Our data suggest that cerebral hemodynamic changes due to both residual cardiac function and the effects of IABP can be detected by TCD in VA ECMO patients. In the case of BD, TCD seems to be a reliable instrumental test for CCA diagnosis in patients on VA ECMO when a pulsatile flow is maintained (native or IABP support).

The utility of serial echocardiograms for organ procurement in brain death.

Heart transplantation rates are limited by a shortage of donor hearts, and left ventricular dysfunction is an important cause. We hypothesized that an early echocardiographic evaluation in severe brain injury (performed within 12 hours from ICU admission) could allow the detection of potentially reversible left ventricular (LV) abnormalities and thus the initiation of tailored treatment whose effects could be assessed at a second echocardiogram performed when brain death develops. We assessed this hypothesis in 49 patients with severe brain injury who were potential heart donors. A reduction in LV ejection fraction (LVEF) (<55%) was present in five patients (10.2%): diffuse hypokinesia in three patients (6.1%), segmental wall motion abnormalities in two (4.1%). Two patients showed apical ballooning (normal LVEF). The three patients with diffuse hypokinesia showed, at the echocardiogram performed 12 hours later, a complete recovery of wall motion and LVEF. Among patients with apical ballooning, a complete resolution was observed in both patients. Two patients were considered potentially eligible for heart donation, resulting in 20% increase in donor retrieval rate. In serious encephalic lesions, potentially evolving toward brain death, echocardiography performed after ICU admission allowed the identification of LV abnormalities, which could be specifically treated with complete resolution.