Moclobemide and clomipramine in reactive depression. A placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial.

The purpose of this study was to compare moclobemide and clomipramine in reactive depression according to the Newcastle II classification. Sixty patients were allocated to either 300 mg moclobemide, 150 mg clomipramine or placebo, all divided in 3 daily doses. Improvements occurred over time, but differences between treatments and compared with placebo were never statistically significant. Dizziness, tremor and anticholinergic symptoms were significantly more frequent with clomipramine than with moclobemide and placebo.

Dexamethasone suppression test, TRH test and Newcastle II depression rating in the diagnosis of depressive disorders.

The dexamethasone suppression test (DST), the thyrotropin releasing hormone (TRH) test and the Newcastle II depression rating (NII) were compared with the clinical diagnosis and evaluated in 61 patients fulfilling the criteria of an affective disorder according to the DSM-III classification. A statistically significant correlation between clinical diagnosis and DST as well as NII, but not between clinical diagnosis and TRH test, was found. There was no correlation between DST and the severity of depression according to the Hamilton depression rating. The nosographic and the diagnostic specificities and sensitivities for the DST, TRH test and NII and DST and NII, a nosographic sensitivity of 50% and a nosographic specificity of 84% were found. Correspondingly, the diagnostic sensitivity was 43% and the diagnostic specificity was 88%. The DST and the TRH test were found of no value in the prediction of the response to antidepressive treatment. Mainly because of a low diagnostic sensitivity the NII, the DST and the TRH test are of limited value in the diagnosis of depressive disorders.

Paroxetine in the treatment of depression--a randomized comparison with amitriptyline.

Paroxetine is a new antidepressant drug with potent serotonin (5HT) uptake inhibitory properties. In this double-blind comparative study, the antidepressant effect of paroxetine and amitriptyline has been compared in 44 patients with depressive illnesses of an endogenous nature. Each drug was given for 6 weeks. The 17-item Hamilton Depression Scale was used to measure the antidepressant effect. Reported events were assessed applying a 22-item check list. Non-parametric statistical analyses were applied in the evaluation of treatment outcome for the 30 patients who completed the study. The results showed no significant differences in overall antidepressant efficacy between paroxetine and amitriptyline and that paroxetine displayed significantly fewer instances of dry mouth and orthostatic dizziness than amitriptyline. No obvious relationship was demonstrated between the plasma levels of the drugs and their clinical effects.

Moclobemide and clomipramine in the treatment of depression. A randomized clinical trial.

Moclobemide (Ro 11-1163), a benzamide derivative, is a MAO-inhibitor which selectively and reversibly inhibits monoamine oxidase type A. Thirty-eight patients with episodic, chronic and atypical depressive disorder (DSM-III) were equally randomized to 6 weeks' treatment with either three daily doses of 100 mg moclobemide or 50 mg clomipramine. Both treatment groups improved with time as assessed weekly by the Hamilton Depression Scale and the Clinician's Overall Assessment of Depression State, and there was no interaction between treatment and time. Anticholinergic complaints, tremor and dizziness occurred more frequently on clomipramine, and they were longer lasting and more severe. Because of its low toxicity, good tolerance, its selectivity and reversibility moclobemide may be a better alternative than the older monoamine oxidase inhibitors.

Assessment of the anticholinergic effects of antidepressants in a single-dose cross-over study of salivation and plasma levels.

In order to evaluate the anticholinergic effect of antidepressant drugs, 11 healthy volunteers were given single oral doses of reference drug, test drugs or placebo on a double-blind basis at weekly intervals. The doses corresponded to average daily patient medications. Spontaneous whole mouth and parotid salivation, and plasma levels of drug and possible metabolites were measured 2, 6 and 10 h after drug administration. Moderate, statistically significant inhibition of salivation was found when nortriptyline, imipramine-N-oxide and mianserin were given. Less pronounced, but still statistically significant inhibition occurred after ingestion of nomifensine and zimelidine. The zimelidine effect was exclusively due to the metabolite norzimelidine, and the inhibition after imipramine-N-oxide was mainly due to the metabolite imipramine, but imipramine-N-oxide itself also had slight activity. Isocarboxazide and lithium had no effect on salivation. From these results and reported values of pharmacokinetic variables, the average level of anticholinergic activity during long-term treatment may be predicted: for mianserin and (nor-)zimelidine moderate inhibition of salivation, although less pronounced than with nortriptyline; for nomifensine no clinically significant effect; and for imipramine-N-oxide a negligible contribution from the unmetabolized drug.

Dexamethasone suppression test and TRH test in endogenous depression.

Dexamethasone suppression test (DST) and thyrotropin releasing hormone (TRH) stimulation test were performed in 34 patients with endogenous depression. Compared with 33 psychiatric controls (limit of discrimination for serum cortisol of 275 nmol/l = 10 micrograms/100 ml) the specificity of the DST was 91% and the sensitivity was 65%. Compared with 24 healthy subjects the sensitivity of the TRH test was 24%, and the combined sensitivity for the DST and the TRH test was 76%. In contrast to the TRH test the DST showed a significant relationship (r = 0.54, P less than 0.01) to the Hamilton Rating Score. Repeating the tests after clinical recovery parallel changes of the two tests were found in 14 of 19 patients with abnormal DST in the depressed phase. In the remaining five patients the DST normalized, while the TRH test remained unchanged. It is suggested that both the apparent higher diagnostic sensitivity and the higher rate of normalization after clinical recovery of the DST is due to the dependency of the severity of depression.

Comparison of peripheral anticholinergic effects of antidepressants: dry mouth.

Twenty-one healthy volunteers were given single doses of placebo or antidepressants corresponding to average daily doses of patient medications. Spontaneous whole mouth and parotid salivation was measured two, six, and ten hours after drug administration in session 1; in session 2 after ten hours. The results indicate that a subdivision of antidepressants into four groups can be made according to inhibitory effect on salivation: (a) isocarboxazide and lithium citrate with no effect, (b) zimelidine and nomifensine with slight effect, (c) imipramine oxide and mianserin with moderate effect and (d) maprotiline, nortriptyline, clomipramine, imipramine, and amitriptyline with pronounced effect. Research implications and predictive value for new antidepressants are discussed.