Spatiotemporal characterization of an experimental model of muscle pain in humans based on short-wave diathermy.

BACKGROUND: Commonly used models for eliciting muscle pain involve the injection of algesic substances or the induction of delayed onset muscle soreness. The former require invasive procedures, and the time frame for pain induction and subsidence in the latter can be inconvenient. This study presents a detailed spatiotemporal characterization of a new experimental model of muscle pain based on short-wave diathermy (SWD), developed to overcome the limitations of existing models. METHODS: The shoulder was selected as target site and the effects of the model were tested in two sessions to assess its reliability. Pain intensity profiles were recorded during the application of SWD, and changes in pressure pain threshold (PPT) in the infraspinatus muscle, together with pain intensity, duration, and quality were assessed 30 min after induction. RESULTS: SWD-induced pain intensity scores averaged 4 points on a visual analogue scale, whereas PPT showed a consistent decrease of about 25% relative to baseline values. Pain was localized in the shoulder area, and was described as continuous, dull, well-delimited, heavy, and bearable. Pain lasted for an average of 145 min without requiring reinduction and was reliably elicited in both experimental sessions. CONCLUSION: SWD can be used to elicit experimental muscle pain in a non-invasive, long-lasting, and reliable way and allows for repeated within- and between-session testing in the shoulder. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: SWD produces deep heating in muscles by converting electromagnetic energy to thermal energy. It was previously shown that it can be used to elicit experimental pain in the forearm muscles, and the present study demonstrates that this can be reliably generalized to other body sites, such as the shoulder. Furthermore, SWD application is non-invasive and presents a convenient time frame for pain induction and subsidence, thus overcoming limitations associated with traditional muscle pain models.

No Evidence of Short-term Changes in Muscle Activity Elicited by Dry Needling in Chronic Unilateral Shoulder Pain Patients.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to assess short-term changes in shoulder muscle activity elicited by dry needling in chronic unilateral shoulder pain (USP) patients. METHODS: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial was conducted, in which 30 volunteers with USP were recruited and randomly assigned to either real or sham dry needling conditions. Pain intensity scores, pressure pain threshold, glenohumeral internal rotation angles, and electromyographic activity during isotonic shoulder tasks (shoulder flexion and extension) were assessed before, immediately, and 72 hours after the intervention in the infraspinatus and deltoid muscles. RESULTS: A single application of real dry needling resulted in lower pain intensity scores and a larger range in glenohumeral internal rotation 72 hours after the intervention in comparison with sham dry needling. No differences in pressure pain threshold or muscle activity were observed due to the intervention. DISCUSSION: A single application of real dry needling resulted in clinically significant changes in the short term. No differences were detected in muscle activation in the infraspinatus or deltoid muscles. Complementary interventions and longer follow-up times may be required to observe changes in muscle activity.

Personalized pain management: The relationship between clinical relevance and reliability of measurements.

Reliability is a topic in health science in which a critical appraisal of the magnitudes of the measurements is often left aside to favour a formulaic analysis. Furthermore, the relationship between clinical relevance and reliability of measurements is often overlooked. In this context, the aim of the present article is to provide an overview of the design and analysis of reliability studies, the interpretation of the reliability of measurements and its relationship to clinical significance in the context of pain research and management. The article is divided in two sections: the first section contains a step-by-step guide with simple and straightforward recommendations for the design and analysis of a reliability study, with a relevant example involving a commonly used assessment measure in pain research. The second section provides deeper insight about the interpretation of the results of a reliability study and the association between the reliability of measurements and their experimental and clinical relevance. SIGNIFICANCE: Reliability studies quantify the measurement error in experimental or clinical setups and should be interpreted as a continuous outcome. The assessment of measurement error is useful to design and interpret future experimental studies and clinical interventions. Reliability and clinical relevance are inextricably linked, as measurement error should be considered in the interpretation of minimal detectable change and minimal clinically important differences.

An analytical method to separate modality-specific and nonspecific sensory components of event-related potentials.

Several models have been developed to analyse cortical activity in response to salient events constituted by multiple sensory modalities. In particular, additive models compare event-related potentials (ERPs) in response to stimuli from two or more concomitant sensory modalities with the ERPs evoked by unimodal stimuli, in order to study sensory interactions. In this approach, components that are not specific to a sensory modality are commonly disregarded, although they likely carry information about stimulus expectation and evaluation, attentional orientation and other cognitive processes. In this study, we present an analytical method to assess the contribution of modality-specific and nonspecific components to the ERP. We developed an experimental setup that recorded ERPs in response to four stimulus types (visual, auditory, and two somatosensory modalities to test for stimulus specificity) in three different conditions (unimodal, bimodal and trimodal stimulation) and recorded the saliency of these stimuli relative to the sensory background. Stimuli were delivered in pairs, in order to study the effects of habituation. To this end, spatiotemporal features (peak amplitudes and latencies at different scalp locations) were analysed using linear mixed models. Results showed that saliency relative to the sensory background increased with the number of concomitant stimuli. We also observed that the spatiotemporal features of modality-specific components derived from this method likely reflect the amount and type of sensory input. Furthermore, the nonspecific component reflected habituation occurring for the second stimulus in the pair. In conclusion, this method provides an alternative to study neural mechanisms of responses to multisensory stimulation.

Pressure pain threshold mappings of the infraspinatus muscle in chronic unilateral shoulder pain patients do not reflect generalized hypersensitivity.

OBJECTIVES: Increased mechanical sensitivity has been observed on the unaffected side in chronic pain conditions, suggesting generalized or widespread hypersensitivity. However, this cannot be considered as a universal response since this hypersensitivity is inconsistent across muscle pain pathologies. The aim of this study was to assess generalized hypersensitivity in chronic unilateral shoulder pain, using pressure pain threshold (PPT) mappings of the infraspinatus muscle. The proposed evaluation is based on the assessment of PPT on a limited subset of sites, reducing potential habituation or sensitization effects. METHODS: Twenty-nine patients with unilateral shoulder pain (USP) and twenty-seven healthy volunteers were recruited. PPT was assessed using a manual pressure algometer. Six sites distributed over the infraspinatus muscle were assessed, and three repetitions were performed at each site. Mappings were derived using two-dimensional interpolation. RESULTS: Lower PPT values were found in the symptomatic side in comparison with the asymptomatic side at all assessment sites (estimated difference: 1.42 ±â€¯0.10 kgf/cm2, p < 0.001), but there were no differences among the asymptomatic side of USP patients and any of the sides in healthy volunteers (largest estimated difference: 0.17 ±â€¯0.28 kgf/cm2, p = 0.927). Furthermore, the medial region of the infraspinatus muscle showed higher mechanical sensitivity in both healthy volunteers and USP patients. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that USP does not induce generalized hypersensitivity, in contrast with previously reported findings. Physiotherapists could take these results into account for the assessment and treatment of patients with USP.

A new experimental model of muscle pain in humans based on short-wave diathermy.

BACKGROUND: Experimental models of pain in humans are crucial for understanding pain mechanisms. The most often used muscle pain models involve the injection of algesic substances, such as hypertonic saline solution or nerve growth factor or the induction of delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) by an unaccustomed exercise routine. However, these models are either invasive or take substantial time to develop, and the elicited level of pain/soreness is difficult to control. To overcome these shortcomings, we propose to elicit muscle pain by a localized application of short-wave diathermy (SWD). METHODS: In this crossover study, SWD was administered to 18 healthy volunteers to the wrist extensor muscle group, with a constant stimulation intensity and up to 4 min. Pressure pain threshold (PPT), pinprick sensitivity (PPS) and self-reported muscle soreness were assessed at baseline and at 0, 30 and 60 min after application of SWD. RESULTS: SWD evoked localized muscle pain/soreness in the wrist extensor muscle group and a decrease of PPT in the treated arm compared with the control arm that lasted for at least 60 min, reflecting ongoing hyperalgesia after SWD application. PPS was not significantly altered 30-60 min following SWD, suggesting a minimal contribution from skin tissue to sustained hyperalgesia. CONCLUSIONS: SWD was able to elicit muscle soreness and hyperalgesia up to 60 min after its application. Thus, this new model represents a promising tool for investigating muscle pain in humans. SIGNIFICANCE: This study presents an experimental model to elicit sustained muscle pain based on short-wave diathermy. The main advantages of the model are its noninvasiveness, the possibility to control stimulation parameters in a reliable way and the convenience of the time frame in which pain and hyperalgesia are developed.

Reorganized Force Control in Elbow Pain Patients During Isometric Wrist Extension.

INTRODUCTION: Reorganized force control may be an important adaptation following painful traumas. In this study, force control adaptations were assessed in elbow pain patients. Increasing the contraction demand may overcome pain interference on the motor control and as such act as an internal control. It was hypothesized that elbow pain patients compared with controls would present greater change in the direction of force when increasing the demand of the motor task. METHODS: Elbow pain patients (n=19) and asymptomatic participants (n=21) performed isometric wrist extensions at 5% to 70% of maximum voluntary contraction. Pressure pain thresholds were recorded at the lateral epicondyle and tibialis anterior muscle. Contraction force was recorded using a 3-directional force transducer. Participants performed contractions according to visual feedback of the task-related force intensity (main direction of wrist extension) and another set of contractions with feedback of the 3 force directions. Going from the simple to the detailed force feedback will increase the demand of the motor task. Force steadiness in all 3 dimensions and force directions were extracted. RESULTS: Compared with controls, elbow pain patients presented lower pressure pain thresholds at both sites (P<0.05). Force steadiness was not significantly different between groups or feedback methods. The change in force direction when providing simple visual feedback in contrast with feedback of all force components at all contraction levels was greater for patients compared with controls (P<0.05). CONCLUSION: The larger change in force direction in pain patients implies redistribution of loads across the arm as an associated effect of pain.

Effects of Prolonged and Acute Muscle Pain on the Force Control Strategy During Isometric Contractions.

UNLABELLED: Musculoskeletal pain is associated with multiple adaptions in movement control. This study aimed to determine whether changes in movement control acquired during acute pain are maintained over days of pain exposure. On day 0, the extensor carpi radialis brevis muscle of healthy participants was injected with nerve growth factor (NGF) to induce persistent movement-evoked pain (n = 13) or isotonic saline as a control (n = 13). On day 2, short-lasting pain was induced by injection of hypertonic saline into extensor carpi radialis brevis muscles of all participants. Three-dimensional force components were recorded during submaximal isometric wrist extensions on day 0, day 4, and before, during, and after saline-induced pain on day 2. Standard deviation (variation of task-related force) and total excursion of center of pressure (variation of force direction) were assessed. Maximal movement-evoked pain was 3.3 ± .4 (0-10 numeric scale) in the NGF-group on day 2 whereas maximum saline-induced pain was 6.8 ± .3 cm (10-cm visual analog scale). The difference in centroid position of force direction relative to day 0 was greater in the NGF group than in the control group (P < .05) on day 2 (before saline-induced pain) and day 4, reflecting changes in tangential force direction used to achieve the task. During saline-induced pain in both groups, tangential and task-related force variation was greater than before and after saline-induced pain (P < .05). PERSPECTIVE: Persistent movement-evoked pain changes force direction from the pain-free direction. Acute pain leads to increased variation in force direction irrespective of persistent movement-evoked pain preceding the acutely painful event. These differences provide novel insight into the search for and consolidation of new motor strategies in the presence of pain.

Movement Evoked Pain and Mechanical Hyperalgesia after Intramuscular Injection of Nerve Growth Factor: A Model of Sustained Elbow Pain.

OBJECTIVE: Lateral epicondylalgia presents as lateral elbow pain provoked by upper limb tasks. An experimental model of elbow pain provoked by movement/muscle contraction and maintained over several days is required to better understand the mechanisms underlying sustained elbow pain. This study investigated the time course and pain location induced by nerve growth factor (NGF) injection into a wrist extensor muscle, and whether movement and muscle contraction/stretch provoked pain. METHODS: On Day 0 twenty-six painfree volunteers were injected with NGF (N = 13) or isotonic saline (randomized) into the extensor carpi radialis brevis (ECRB) muscle of the dominant arm. On Day 2 pain was induced in all participants by hypertonic saline injection into ECRB. A Likert scale and patient-rated tennis elbow evaluation (PRTEE) was used to assess pain and functional limitation (Days 0-10). Pain intensity during contraction/stretch of ECRB, and pressure pain thresholds (PPTs) were recorded before and after injections on Days 0 and 2, and Days 4 and 10. RESULTS: Compared with isotonic saline, NGF evoked: i) greater Likert pain ratings from 12 hours post-injection until Day 6, ii) greater PRTEE scores on Days 2 and 4, iii) greater pain during ECRB contraction/stretch on Day 2, and iv) lower PPTs on Day 4. CONCLUSIONS: This article presents a novel experimental human pain model suitable to study the sustained effects of lateral elbow pain on sensorimotor function and to probe the mechanisms underlying persistent musculoskeletal pain.

Modulation of motor variability related to experimental muscle pain during elbow-flexion contractions.

Experimental muscle pain typically reorganizes the motor control. The pain effects may decrease when the three-dimensional force components are voluntarily adjusted, but it is not known if this could have negative consequences on other structures of the motor system. The present study assessed the effects of acute pain on the force variability during sustained elbow flexion when controlling task-related (one-dimensional) and all (three-dimensional) contraction force components via visual feedback. Experimental muscle pain was induced by bolus injection of hypertonic saline into m. biceps brachii, and isotonic saline was used as control. Twelve subjects performed sustained elbow flexion at different levels of the maximal voluntary contraction (5-30% MVC) before, during, and after the injections. Three-dimensional force components were measured simultaneously with surface electromyography (EMG) from elbow flexors and auxiliary muscles. Results showed that force variability was increased during pain compared to baseline for contractions using one-dimensional feedback (P<.05), but no significant differences were found for three-dimensional feedback. During painful contractions (1) EMG activity from m. trapezius was increased during contractions using both one-dimensional and three-dimensional feedback (P<.05), and (2) the complexity of EMG from m. triceps brachii and m. deltoid was higher for the three-dimensional feedback (P<.05). In conclusion, the three-dimensional feedback reduced the pain-related functional distortion at the cost of a more complex control of synergistic muscles.

Spatial reorganisation of muscle activity correlates with change in tangential force variability during isometric contractions.

The aim of this study was to quantify the effects of spatial reorganisation of muscle activity on task-related and tangential components of force variability during sustained contractions. Three-dimensional forces were measured from isometric elbow flexion during submaximal contractions (50s, 5-50% of maximal voluntary contraction (MVC)) and total excursion of the centre of pressure was extracted. Spatial electromyographic (EMG) activity was recorded from the biceps brachii muscle. The centroids of the root mean square (RMS) EMG and normalised mutual information (NMI) maps were computed to assess spatial muscle activity and spatial relationship between EMG and task-related force variability, respectively. Result showed that difference between the position of the centroids at the beginning and at the end of the contraction of the RMS EMG and the NMI maps were different in the medial-lateral direction (P<0.05), reflecting that muscle regions modulate their activity without necessarily modulating the contribution to the task-related force variability over time. Moreover, this difference between shifts of the centroids was positively correlated with the total excursion of the centre of pressure at the higher levels of contractions (>30% MVC, R(2)>0.30, P<0.05), suggesting that changes in spatial muscle activity could impact on the modulation of tangential forces. Therefore, within-muscle adaptations do not necessarily increase force variability, and this interaction can be quantified by analysing the RMS EMG and the NMI map centroids.