Effect of radiographic contrast material exposure on spiral CT attenuation of renal calculi.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors performed this study to determine whether exposure of renal calculi to radiographic contrast material has an effect on the attenuation values at computed tomography (CT) performed with varying collimation widths. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Renal calculi (23 stones of various composition) were scanned with 1-, 3-, and 10-mm collimation. Stones were then exposed to a solution of radiographic contrast material for 5 minutes, washed with water, and rescanned 36 hours later. The reproducibility of the CT attenuation measurements on different days was evaluated by obtaining measurements in a subset of 16 renal stones on 4 different days. RESULTS: There was no statistically significant change in attenuation after contrast material exposure at narrow collimation. At wider collimation, statistically significant increases were noted in both attenuation and standard deviation. A small amount of variability between readings was noted on different days, with a minimal increase in attenuation each day. Correlation between readings remained very high. CONCLUSION: Exposure of stones to a radiographic contrast material had a statistically significant effect on CT attenuation values only at wide collimation. This may be related to technical factors including volume averaging. Absence of an effect at narrow collimation suggests that the attenuation values of renal stones do not significantly change after exposure to contrast material.

Correction of helical CT attenuation values with wide beam collimation: in vitro test with urinary calculi.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Urinary calculi are now commonly detected with helical computed tomography (CT), and it has been proposed that stone composition can be determined from CT attenuation values. However, typical scans are made with a beam collimation of 5 mm or more, resulting in volume averaging and reduction in accuracy of attenuation measurement. The authors tested a model for correction of errors in attenuation values, even at section widths larger than the width of the object. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Human urinary stones were scanned with helical CT at different beam collimation widths. A computer model was used to predict the effect of beam width and stone size on accuracy of measured attenuation. RESULTS: At 3-mm collimation, the model corrected the attenuation readings with an underestimation of 12% +/- 1 (compared with values at 1-mm collimation; 127 stones; diameters of 1.7-11.3 mm). With attenuation measured at 10-mm collimation, the model underestimated the true value by 34% +/- 3 (103 stones), with a significant negative correlation with stone diameter on magnitude of error (diameters of 3.0-11.3 mm). Correlation of data from patient scans with subsequent in vitro scanning of the same stones confirmed the validity of the model, but corrected in vivo scans consistently yielded lower values for the stones than in vitro. CONCLUSION: Volume averaging effects on attenuation in helical CT are predictable in vitro for urinary calculi--and presumably for other roughly spherical structures--as long as section width does not excessively exceed the diameter of the structure.

Calcium stone fragility is predicted by helical CT attenuation values.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Helical CT has become the preferred method for imaging urinary calculi, and so it would be useful if data from helical CT could also be used to predict the number of shockwaves (SWs) needed to break a given stone. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We measured the number of SWs required to comminute calcium stones in vitro. RESULTS: The SW requirement correlated with stone size (volume, weight, diameter) and with helical CT attenuation values when the scans were performed at 3-mm collimation. When CT scans were performed at 1-mm collimation, the number of SWs needed for comminution did not correlate with helical CT attenuation values. This result indicates that the correlation with 3-mm scans was attributable to volume-averaging effects, in which smaller stones yield smaller attenuation values. That is, attenuation values from helical CT at larger beam collimation widths contain information about stone size that can be exploited to predict the fragility of calcium stones. We observed that for calcium stones, the number of SWs to comminution was generally less than half the stone CT attenuation value in Hounsfield units. This "half-attenuation rule" predicted the number of SWs needed to complete fragmentation for 95% of calcium stones (24/24 calcium oxalate monohydrate, 13/13 hydroxyapatite, 8/10 brushite stones). CONCLUSION: This in vitro study suggests that it may be possible to predict effective SW dose using helical CT prior to lithotripsy.

Helical CT of urinary calculi: effect of stone composition, stone size, and scan collimation.

OBJECTIVE: Helical CT has become the preferred methodology for identifying urinary calculi. However, the ability to predict stone composition, which influences patient treatment, depends on the accurate measurement of the radiographic attenuation of stones. We studied the effects of stone composition, stone size, and scan collimation width on the measurement of attenuation in vitro. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred twenty-seven human urinary calculi of known composition and size were scanned at 120 kVp, 240 mA, and a 1:1 pitch at different collimations. A model, based on the physics of helical CT, was used to predict the effect of scan collimation width and stone size on measured attenuation. RESULTS: At a 1-mm collimation, stone groups could be differentiated by attenuation: the attenuation of uric acid was less than that of cystine or struvite, which overlapped; these were less than the attenuation of calcium oxalate monohydrate, which was in turn lower than that of brushite and hydroxyapatite, which overlapped and showed the highest values. At a wider collimation, attenuation was lower and the ability to differentiate stone composition was lost. Attenuation also decreased with smaller stones. At a 10-mm collimation, some uric acid stones (