The scientific landscape of phytoremediation of tailings: a bibliometric and scientometric analysis.

This article seeks to evaluate the scientific landscape of the phytoremediation of mine tailings through a series of bibliometric and scientometric techniques. Phytoremediation has emerged as a sustainable approach to remediate metal-contaminated mine waste areas. A scientometric analysis of 913 publications indexed in Web of Science from 1999 to 2023 was conducted using CiteSpace. The results reveal an expanding, interdisciplinary field with environmental sciences as the core category. Keyword analysis of 561 nodes and 2,825 links shows a focus on plant-metal interactions, microbial partnerships, bioavailability, and field validation. Co-citation analysis of 1,032 nodes and 2,944 links identifies seminal works on native species, plant-microbe interactions, and amendments. Temporal mapping of 15 co-citation clusters indicates a progression from early risk assessments and native plant inquiries to integrated biological systems, economic feasibility, and sustainability considerations. Recent trends emphasize multidimensional factors influencing adoption, such as plant-soil-microbe interactions, organic amendments, and field-scale performance evaluation. The findings demonstrate an intensifying translation of phytoremediation from scientific novelty to engineering practice. This quantitative and qualitative analysis of research trends aids in understanding the development of phytoremediation for mine tailings. The results provide valuable insights for researchers and practitioners in this evolving field.

An extension of the characteristic curve model of plant species behavior in heavy metal soils.

This article proposes a mathematical model to characterize phytoremediation processes in soils contaminated with heavy metals. In particular, the proposed model constructs characteristic curves for the concentrations of several metals (As, Cd, Cu, Fe, Pb, Sb, and Zn) in soils and plants based on the experimental data retrieved from several bibliographical sources comprising 305 vegetal species. The proposed model is an extension of previous models of characteristic curves in phytoremediation processes developed by Lam et al. for root measurements using the bioconcentration factor. However, the proposed model extends this approach to consider roots, as well as aerial parts and shoots of the plant, while at the same time providing a less complex mathematical formula compared to the original. The final model shows an adjusted R2 of 0.712, and all its parameters are considered statistically significant. The model may be used to assess samples from a given plant species to identify its potential as an accumulator in the context of soil phytoremediation processes. Furthermore, a simplified version of the model was constructed using an approximation to provide an easy-to-compute alternative that is valid for concentrations below 37,000 mg/kg. This simplified model shows results similar to the original model for concentrations below this threshold and it uses an adjusted factor defined as [Formula: see text] that must be compared with a threshold depending on the metal, type of measurement, and target (e.g., accumulator or hyperaccumulator). The full model construction shows that 90 out of the 305 species assessed have a potential behavior as accumulators and 10 of them as hyperaccumulators. Finally, out of the 1405 experimental measurements, 1177 were shown to be accumulators or hyperaccumulators. In particular, 85% of the results coincide with the reported values, thus validating the proposed model.

Heavy metal pollution index calculation in geochemistry assessment: a case study on Playa Las Petroleras.

This work is aimed to assess potential risk associated with the presence of metals and metalloids in soil at "Playa Las Petroleras" sector, located in Antofagasta (Chile). The zone under study has been affected by four oil spill events. This sector is located in an urban area by the sea. So, it has a great social and environmental relevance. The concentrations of 15 elements in soil samples were assessed, four of them presenting potential ecological risk: As, Co, Cu, and Pb. Nine pollution indices were applied to data: four single pollution indices and five integrated pollution indices to assess soil pollution. The single pollution indices show that the site bears potential ecological and environmental risk due to the presence of Cu, the site being classified as highly contaminated owing to a severe enrichment of this metal. For Co, all the indices allow classifying the site as little or uncontaminated, while the level of As and Pb pollution could be considered as ranging from uncontaminated to moderately contaminated. The integrated pollution indices show that average concentrations are highly contaminated mainly owing to the presence of Cu.

Characteristic curve modeling of plant species behavior in soils with heavy metals.

Many vegetal species can accumulate great amounts of metallic elements in their tissues. For this reason, they are called metal hyperaccumulators. An indicator of great interest in environmental sciences is the bioconcentration factor because it is recognized for establishing the potential accumulation of chemicals in organisms. Particularly in soil phytoremediation processes, it measures the capacity of a certain plant to capture metals, in terms of soil concentration. According to their behavior, four types of plants can be distinguished regarding soil concentration increase: indicator, excluder, accumulator, and hyperaccumulator. This study proposes a new model to categorize plants according to their behavior related to soil concentration increase, using several characteristic curves obtained from 1288 experimental measurements collected from different bibliographic sources. The metals analyzed were Cu, Fe, Pb, and Zn. The proposed model is obtained through linear regression and nonlinear transformations to model the expected behavior of plants in high concentration conditions. In particular, the basic equation of the model has three key components to represent the expected concentration in the plant root given the final soil concentration level, the type of species, and specific metal: a linear factor that determines the growth for low concentration values, an exponential factor that determines its decrease for high concentration values, and a logarithmic factor that limits the maximum value that can be reached in practice and influences the decay for high concentration values. After fitting the experimental data using linear regression, the proposed model has a 0.084 R2 determination coefficient and all of its parameters are considered significant. Furthermore, it shows that 60 of the 257 species assessed behave as accumulators and 10 of them as hyperaccumulators. The main contribution of this model is its ability to handle soils with high concentrations, where it would be hard for plants to achieve concentrations similar to or higher than the substrate containing them. Thus, the conventional criterion of the bioconcentration factor would incorrectly categorize a plant as an excluder. In contrast, this new model allows assessing plant effectiveness in a phytoremediation process of highly concentrated affected sites, such as mine tailings.

Evaluation of copper tailing amendments through poultry waste and ammonium nitrate.

In this study, two amendments, poultry waste and ammonium nitrate, were evaluated to condition and stabilize a mine tailing and thus help the vegetation cover settle. Individually, ammonium nitrate was tested as a nitrogen source and chicken bone ash as a phosphate source. For this, laboratory tests were made on soil columns from the area to be remediated. The mobility and availability of metals and nutrients were determined by analyzing their leachates chemically. The results showed that the use of chicken bone ash decreases soluble metal concentrations, particularly in Fe and soluble Mn. On the other hand, experimental conditions proved that the acidification produced by ammonium nitrate nitrification does not significantly increase the lechate metal content. Therefore, its use for fertilization does not involve phytotoxicity risks. Regarding the availability of macronutrients as well as trace elements, the results showed that the concentrations lie within the ranges suitable for plant nutrition. So, the treatments are effective both for fertilization and phytoremediation.

Methodology to Prioritize Chilean Tailings Selection, According to Their Potential Risks.

For centuries, Chile has been a territory with significant mining activity, resulting in associated social benefits and impacts. One of the main challenges the country faces today is the presence of a great number of mine tailings containing heavy metals, such as Cu, Cr, Ni, Zn, Pb, As, Cd, and Fe, which make up a potential risk for the population. This study is intended to develop a methodology for determining tailings requiring urgent treatment in Chile, based on risks associated with heavy metals. Geochemical data from 530 Chilean tailings were compared to the Dutch norm and the Canadian and Australian soil quality guidelines for residential use. Additionally, criteria about residents and water bodies were used, considering a 2-km area of influence around tailings. To do this, QGIS (Böschacherstrasse 10a CH-8624 Grüt (Gossau ZH),Zurich, Switzerland), a geospatial tool, was used to geolocate each deposit, considering regions, communes, rivers, lakes, and populated areas. To evaluate potential ecological contamination risks, Hakanson's methodology was used. Results revealed the presence of 12 critical tailings in Chile that require urgent treatment. From the 530 tailings evaluated, 195 are located at less than 2 km from a populated area and 154 at less than 2 km from a water body. In addition, 347 deposits require intervention: 30 on Cu, 30 on Cr, 13 on Zn, 69 on Pb, 138 on As, 1 on Cd, and 5 on Hg.

Making Paving Stones from Copper Mine Tailings as Aggregates.

Copper mining, the central axis of Chile's economic development, produces a large number of tailings, which become a potential environmental risk. This study aims to evaluate the mechanical properties resulting from the making of Portland cement mixtures with tailings as aggregates so that they can be eventually used in paving stones for building inactive tailings dams. Tailings coming from two dams at a concentration plant located in Taltal (Chile) were used. Currently, Dam 1 is inactive, while Dam 2 is active. The tailings samples obtained from both dams were granulometrically characterized by sieving. In addition, pH, humidity, Eh, and mineralogical assays (sulfides, oxides, sulfates, carbonates, phosphates, and silicates) were measured. The fines content of the tailings from Dams 1 and 2 with a sieve size of N°200 ASTM were 76.2% and 29.6%, respectively. Therefore, owing to their high percentage of fines, they cannot be as used as concrete aggregates. Aggregates must contain a maximum percentage of fines so that mortars and concrete can meet Chilean standards. In this paper, to comply with a 7% and 15% fines content lower than 0.075 mm, tailings materials were mixed with conventional aggregates containing very little fines. In addition, a reference mixture was made with only tailings aggregates with and without a superplasticizer additive. To measure the mixtures of cement, aggregates, and tailings, bending and compression strength assays were made of the specimens after a 28-day curing, according to the Chilean standard. The results of the study show that the addition of only part of the tailings to the mixture increases bending strength by 26% and compression strength by 180% compared with the reference mortar, with a fines content lower than 0.075 mm in the 7% mixture, thus allowing paving stone manufacture with tailings materials. In addition, it was possible to increase the workability of the reference mixture by using superplasticizers as additives.