Realized genetic selection differentials in Canadian Ayrshire, Jersey, and Brown Swiss dairy cattle populations.

Estimated breeding values of a selection index, production, durability, health, and fertility traits from Canadian Ayrshire, Jersey, and Brown Swiss bulls and cows were used to study genetic selection differentials (GSD). The bulls and cows were born from 1950 and 1960, respectively. The GSD for the 3 Canadian dairy populations were studied along the 4-path selection model: sire-to-bull (SB), dam-to-bull (DB), sire-to-cow (SC), and dam-to-cow (DC) pathways. We also determined the variations in realized GSD due to herd and herd × year of conception in addition to the effects of some environmental factors on realized GSD of the SC and DC paths. The mean realized GSD of the DB were higher than those of other paths and were increasing for lifetime performance index, 305-d milk yield, 305-d fat yield, and 305-d protein yield in all 3 dairy cattle populations. We observed no clear trends in realized GSD for type traits in all 3 dairy cattle breeds except for the apparent increasing trends in realized GSD of mammary system, dairy strength, and feet and legs in the DB and SC paths of the Ayrshire breed. No clear patterns were observed in the realized GSD of daughter fertility in the SB, DB, and SC paths of all dairy cattle breeds. Realized GSD for somatic cell score showed increasing and favorable trends in the 3 most influential selection paths (SB, DB, and SC). Year of conception influenced realized GSD of artificial insemination bulls in Ayrshire, Jersey, and Brown Swiss dairy populations. Selection emphases for the SC path generally increased with time. There was considerable variation among herds in selection pressures applied in the SC and DC pathways but no clear association with housing system or region. This study demonstrates that variations exist among herds of minor dairy cattle breeds in their selection for economically important traits. These variations offer opportunities for further improvements in these populations.

Realized genetic selection differentials in Canadian Holstein dairy herds.

Estimated breeding values for a selection index, production, durability, health, and fertility traits for Canadian Holstein bulls and cows born from 1950 and 1960, respectively, were used to define and determine realized genetic selection differentials (GSD) and generation intervals along the 4-path model of genetic improvement and the variability among herds in realized GSD. The effects of some non-genetic factors on realized GSD were also determined. The mean generation intervals of the sire-to-bull (SB), dam-to-bull (DB), sire-to-cow (SC), and dam-to-cow (DC) pathways reduced, respectively, from 9.7, 7.5, 7.7, and 4.7 years in 1980 to 2.3, 2.5, 4.8, and 3.6 years in 2016. The realized GSD of lifetime performance index and 305-d milk, fat, and protein yields for the SB and DB paths were greater than those of the SC and DC, and realized GSD for DB were increasing for all production traits and the index after 2009. With the exception of daughter fertility (DF), we found zero to negative selection in the DC path for all the traits studied, due to the minimal opportunity for selection in that path. No clear trends were observed in realized GSD of SB, DB, or SC paths for mammary system, dairy strength, feet and legs, or herd life. The realized GSD for DF in the SB, DB, and SC remained largely negative, except after the early 2000s when positive realized GSD were observed in the SB and DB paths. The realized GSD for DF in the DC path remained positive throughout the period of the study, though mostly non-significantly different from zero, except for 2014 and 2015. Realized GSD for somatic cell score in the SB, DB, and SC paths showed increasing and favorable trends. Year of conception, housing system, agricultural region, and their interactions had significant effects on realized GSD of some traits in the SC and DC paths. We also observed considerable variations in realized GSD among herds. The population mean realized GSD and those of the top and bottom 10% of herds could serve as benchmarks that individual herds could use to monitor their past selection and make changes if they are not moving in the intended direction.