Chronic illness and the physician-patient relationship: a response to the Hastings Center's "ethical challenges of chronic illness".

The following article is a response to the position paper of the Hastings Center, "Ethical Challenges of Chronic Illness", a product of their three year project on Ethics and Chronic Care. The authors of this paper, three prominent bioethicists, Daniel Callahan, Arthur Caplan, and Bruce Jennings, argue that there should be a different ethic for acute and chronic care. In pressing this distinction they provide philosophical grounds for limiting medical care for the elderly and chronically ill. We give a critical survey of their position and reject it as well as any attempt to characterize the physician-patient relationship as a commercial contract. We emphasize, as central features of good medical practice, a commitment to be the patient's agent and a determination to acquire and be guided by knowledge. These commitments may sometimes conflict with efforts to have the physician serve as an instrument of social and economic policies limiting medical care.

Early combination of selegiline and low-dose levodopa as initial symptomatic therapy in Parkinson's disease. Experience in 26 patients receiving combined therapy for 26 months.

Thirty-eight patients newly diagnosed as having Parkinson's disease (mean age, 57.3 years; mean Parkinson's disease duration, 2.7 years) in the earlier phase of the disease (mean Hoehn/Yahr stage, 2; mean motor scores, 11.4) were given selegiline (Deprenyl), 10 mg daily, and maintained on this drug alone until significant clinical worsening warranted the addition of low-dose levodopa (Sinemet, 25/100 three to four doses per day). Five of these patients were not yet receiving additional levodopa despite some worsening of motor scores. Of the 33 patients now taking combined therapy, seven have been followed up for 6 months or less. Twenty-four (92%) of the 26 patients taking combined therapy for a mean of 26 months (8.5 to 99 months) who have had Parkinson's disease for 6 years showed a dramatic improvement in their parkinsonism shortly after the addition of levodopa, with significant decreases in their rated motor scores, such improvement being maintained at their latest neurologic evaluation. Eighteen (75%) of these 24 patients responded to the combined selegiline/levodopa therapy with degrees of improvement equal to or greater than 50%, compared with their motor status at the start of combined therapy just before the addition of levodopa. This degree of "reversal" of parkinsonism on addition of levodopa (mean carbidopa/levodopa dose, 98/389 mg) was not observed in any of these same patients receiving selegiline alone for an average of 13.8 months. Four patients taking combined therapy developed mild, transient, abnormal involuntary movements, and end-of-dose pattern of response after more than 2 years of combined therapy (24.75 and 33.5 months, respectively).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Selegiline use to prevent progression of Parkinson's disease. Experience in 22 de novo patients.

To test the hypothesis that selegiline (L-deprenyl), a selective inhibitor of B-type monoamine oxidase, can halt the natural progression of Parkinson's disease, its use in 22 naive patients (mean age, 58 years; mean Parkinson's disease duration, 2.3 years) in the early stages (1 to 2) of the disease was studied. Patients were started and maintained on a daily dose of 10 mg of selegiline, and they underwent neurologic examinations at 3-month intervals using our center's disease staging and total rated disability scores. The criterion set for disease progression was defined as either the appearance of a new objective sign and/or a definite, persistent worsening (greater than 25%) of existing signs after the initiation of the selegiline trial. Patients remained on a regimen of selegiline [corrected] for periods ranging from 7 to 84 months. At the time of their latest neurologic examination, 17 (77%) of the 22 patients had conditions that demonstrably worsened with selegiline alone at an average of 10.8 months from the start of the drug therapy. Six of these 17 patients with worsening conditions (or 27% of the original 22) eventually required the addition of levodopa with carbidopa (Sinemet) on average at 13 months from the start of selegiline therapy; they have continued, to date, taking this combination for an additional mean follow-up period of 20.7 months. Four of the original 22 patients had relatively unchanged, stable neurologic status at the time of their latest examination (average follow-up period, 11.6 months).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Selegiline as an adjunct to conventional levodopa therapy in Parkinson's disease. Experience with this type B monoamine oxidase inhibitor in 200 patients.

Two hundred patients at a median age of 63 years, receiving conventional levodopa therapy for 8 years, who had had Parkinson's disease for 10 years, tried a regimen of selegiline (L-deprenyl), a type B monoamine oxidase inhibitor, at a daily dose of 10 mg, for varying periods from less than 6 months to more than 24 months (28% over 24 months). Selegiline does improve parkinsonism during the initial 6 months to 12 to 24 months of combined therapy in one third to almost half of patients with an end-of-dose type of response to long-term levodopa therapy. However, even this particular class of patients is unable to maintain such an improvement by 36 months, much less by 48 months, from the start of the selegiline trial. About one quarter of poor responders to levodopa and those with random deterioration show improvement in their parkinsonian status in the first 6 months of the selegiline trial, but their conditions quickly deteriorate by 1 year. The predominant pattern of response to previous levodopa therapy and the severity of the total disability score at the initiation of the selegiline trial were the two variables that were predictive of risk of failure with the drug. No evidence suggested that selegiline decreases the excess mortality rate of Parkinson's disease above that achieved with the use of levodopa alone. Selegiline as an adjunctive agent to conventional levodopa therapy was not unduly impressive with regard to preventing progression of Parkinson's disease.

Movement disorders in the psychiatric patient.

Abnormal movements or postures often present a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge to the psychiatrist or neurologist. The authors review pertinent anatomy and physiology of disorders of the extrapyramidal system, suggest aspects of the clinical history and examination particularly important for diagnosis, and describe a range of abnormal movements. They review several syndromes in which abnormalities of behavior and movement may occur together, including Huntington's chorea, Wilson's disease, Parkinson's disease, and tardive dyskinesia.