Discovery of small-molecule inhibitors of Bcl-2 through structure-based computer screening.

Bcl-2 belongs to a growing family of proteins which regulates programmed cell death (apoptosis). Overexpression of Bcl-2 has been observed in 70% of breast cancer, 30-60% of prostate cancer, 80% of B-cell lymphomas, 90% of colorectal adenocarcinomas, and many other forms of cancer. Thereby, Bcl-2 is an attractive new anti-cancer target. Herein, we describe the discovery of novel classes of small-molecule inhibitors targeted at the BH3 binding pocket in Bcl-2. The three-dimensional (3D) structure of Bcl-2 has been modeled on the basis of a high-resolution NMR solution structure of Bcl-X(L), which shares a high sequence homology with Bcl-2. A structure-based computer screening approach has been employed to search the National Cancer Institute 3D database of 206 876 organic compounds to identify potential Bcl-2 small-molecule inhibitors that bind to the BH3 binding site of Bcl-2. These potential Bcl-2 small-molecule inhibitors were first tested in an in vitro binding assay for their potency in inhibition of the binding of a Bak BH3 peptide to Bcl-2. Thirty-five potential inhibitors were tested in this binding assay, and seven of them were found to have a binding affinity (IC(50) value) from 1.6 to 14.0 microM. The anti-proliferative activity of these seven active compounds has been tested using a human myeloid leukemia cell line, HL-60, which expresses the highest level of Bcl-2 protein among all the cancer cell lines examined. Compound 6 was the most potent compound and had an IC(50) value of 4 microM in inhibition of cell growth using the 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide assay. Five other compounds had moderate activity in inhibition of cell growth. Compound 6 was further evaluated for its ability to induce apoptosis in cancer cells. It was found that 6 induces apoptosis in cancer cells with high Bcl-2 expression and its potency correlates with the Bcl-2 expression level in cancer cells. Furthermore, using NMR methods, we conclusively demonstrated that 6 binds to the BH3 binding site in Bcl-X(L). Our results showed that small-molecule inhibitors of Bcl-2 such as 6 modulate the biological function of Bcl-2, and induce apoptosis in cancer cells with high Bcl-2 expression, while they have little effect on cancer cells with low or undetectable levels of Bcl-2 expression. Therefore, compound 6 can be used as a valuable pharmacological tool to elucidate the function of Bcl-2 and also serves as a novel lead compound for further design and optimization. Our results suggest that the structure-based computer screening strategy employed in the study is effective for identifying novel, structurally diverse, nonpeptide small-molecule inhibitors that target the BH3 binding site of Bcl-2.

An optimized protein kinase C activating diacylglycerol combining high binding affinity (Ki) with reduced lipophilicity (log P).

A small, focused combinatorial library encompassing all possible permutations of acyl branched alkyl chains-small and large, saturated and unsaturated-was generated from the active diacylglycerol enantiomer (S-DAG) to help identify the analogue with the highest binding affinity (lowest Ki) for protein kinase C (PK-C) combined with the minimum lipophilicity (log P). The selected ligand (3B) activated PK-C more effectively than sn-1,2-dioctanoylglycerol (diC8) despite being 1.4 log units more hydrophilic. Compound 3B indeed represents the most potent, hydrophilic DAG ligand to date. With the help of a green fluorescent protein (GFP)-tagged PK-Calpha, 3B was able to translocate the full length protein to the membrane with an optimal dose of 100 microM in CHO-K1 cells, while diC8 failed to achieve translocation even at doses 3-fold higher. Molecular modeling of 3B into an empty C1b domain of PK-Cdelta clearly showed the existence of a preferred binding orientation. In addition, molecular dynamic simulations suggest that binding discrimination could result from a favorable van der Waals (VDW) interaction between the large, branched sn-1 acyl group of 3B and the aromatic rings of Trp252 (PK-Cdelta) or Tyr252 (PK-Calpha). The DAG analogue of 3B in which the acyl groups are reversed (2C) showed a decrease in binding affinity reflecting the capacity of PK-C to effectively discriminate between alternative orientations of the acyl chains.

Role of hydrophobic residues in the C1b domain of protein kinase C delta on ligand and phospholipid interactions.

The C1 domains of conventional and novel protein kinase C (PKC) isoforms bind diacylglycerol and phorbol esters with high affinity. Highly conserved hydrophobic residues at or near the rim of the binding cleft in the second cysteine-rich domain of PKC-delta (PKC-deltaC1b) were mutated to probe their roles in ligand recognition and lipid interaction. [(3)H]Phorbol 12,13-dibutyrate (PDBu) binding was carried out both in the presence and absence of phospholipids to determine the contribution of lipid association to the ligand affinity. Lipid dependence was determined as a function of lipid concentration and composition. The binding properties of a high affinity branched diacylglycerol with lipophilicity similar to PDBu were compared with those of PDBu to identify residues important for ligand selectivity. As expected, Leu-20 and Leu-24 strongly influenced binding. Substitution of either by aspartic acid abolished binding in either the presence or absence of phosphatidylserine. Mutation of Leu-20 to Arg or of Leu-24 to Lys caused a dramatic (340- and 250-fold, respectively) reduction in PDBu binding in the presence of lipid but only a modest reduction in the weaker binding of PDBu observed in the absence of lipid, suggesting that the main effect was on C1 domain -phospholipid interactions. Mutation of Leu-20 to Lys or of Trp-22 to Lys had modest (3-fold) effects and mutation of Phe-13 to Tyr or Lys was without effect. Binding of the branched diacylglycerol was less dependent on phospholipid and was more sensitive to mutation of Trp-22 to Tyr or Lys, especially in the presence of phospholipid, than was PDBu. In terms of specific PKC isoforms, our results suggest that the presence of Arg-20 in PKC-zeta may contribute to its lack of phorbol ester binding activity. More generally, the results emphasize the interplay between the C1 domain, ligand, and phospholipid in the ternary binding complex.

Conformationally constrained analogues of diacylglycerol (DAG). 17. Contrast between sn-1 and sn-2 DAG lactones in binding to protein kinase C.

In previous work, we have obtained potent protein kinase C (PK-C) ligands with low-namomolar binding affinities by constructing diacylglycerol (DAG) mimetics in which the sn-2 carbonyl of DAG was constrained into a lactone ring. An additional structural element that helped achieve high binding affinity was the presence of branched acyl or alpha-alkylidene chains. In the present study, the effects of similarly branched chains on a different lactone system, where the lactone carbonyl is now equivalent to the sn-1 carbonyl of DAG, are investigated. In this new lactone template, the two chiral centers must have the S-configuration for enzyme recognition. As with the sn-2 DAG lactones, the branched chains were designed to optimize van der Waals contacts with a group of conserved hydrophobic amino acids located on the rim of the C1 domain of PK-C. The acyl and alpha-alkylidene chains were also designed to be lipophilically equivalent (8 carbons each). Eight new compounds (7-14) representing all possible combinations of linear and branched acyl and alpha-alkylidene were synthesized and evaluated. The sn-1 DAG lactones were less effective as PK-C ligands than the sn-2 DAG lactones despite having a similar array of linear or branched acyl and alpha-alkylidene chains

Diacylglycerols with lipophilically equivalent branched acyl chains display high affinity for protein kinase C (PK-C). A direct measure of the effect of constraining the glycerol backbone in DAG lactones.

New synthetic diacylglycerols (DAGs) with equivalent branched acyl chains were compared with commercially available DAGs as PK-C ligands. The results support the view that there is a minimal lipophilic requirement provided by the equivalent acyl groups that results in high binding affinity. Locking the glycerol backbone of the most potent DAG into a five-member lactone resulted in a 10-fold increase in potency.

Conformationally constrained analogues of diacylglycerol (DAG). 16. How much structural complexity is necessary for recognition and high binding affinity to protein kinase C?

The design of potent protein kinase C (PK-C) ligands with low nanomolar binding affinities was accomplished by the combined use of pharmacophore- and receptor-guided approaches based on the structure of the physiological enzyme activator, diacylglycerol (DAG). Earlier use of the former approach, which was based on the structural equivalence of DAG and phorbol ester pharmacophores, identified a fixed template for the construction of a semirigid "recognition domain" that contained the three principal pharmacophores of DAG constrained into a lactone ring (DAG-lactones). In the present work, the pharmacophore-guided approach was refined to a higher level based on the X-ray structure of the C1b domain of PK-Cdelta complexed with phorbol-13-O-acetate. A systematic search that involved modifying the DAG-lactone template with a combination of linear or branched acyl and alpha-alkylidene chains, which functioned as variable hydrophobic "affinity domains", helped identify compounds that optimized hydrophobic contacts with a group of conserved hydrophobic amino acids located on the top half of the C1 domain where the phorbol binds. The hydrophilic/hydrophobic balance of the molecules was estimated by the octanol/water partition coefficients (log P) calculated according to a fragment-based approach. The presence of branched alpha-alkylidene or acyl chains was of critical importance to reach low nanomolar binding affinities for PK-C. These branched chains appear to facilitate important van der Waals contacts with hydrophobic segments of the protein and help promote the activation of PK-C through critical membrane interactions. Molecular modeling of these DAG-lactones into an empty C1b domain using the program AutoDock 2.4 suggests the existence of competing binding modes (sn-1 and sn-2) depending on which carbonyl is directly involved in binding to the protein. Inhibition of epidermal growth factor (EGF) binding, an indirect PK-C mediated response, was realized with some DAG-lactones at a dose 10-fold higher than with the standard phorbol-12, 13-dibutyrate (PDBU). Through the National Cancer Institute (NCI) 60-cell line in vitro screen, DAG-lactone 31 was identified as a very selective and potent antitumor agent. The NCI's computerized, pattern-recognition program COMPARE, which analyzes the degree of similarity of mean-graph profiles produced by the screen, corroborated our principles of drug design by matching the profile of compound 31 with that of the non-tumor-promoting antitumor phorbol ester, prostratin. The structural simplicity and the degree of potency achieved with some of the DAG-lactones described here should dispel the myth that chemical complexity and pharmacological activity go hand in hand. Even as a racemate, DAG-lactone 31 showed low namomolar binding affinity for PK-C and displayed selective antitumor activity at equivalent nanomolar levels. Our present approach should facilitate the generation of multiple libraries of structurally similar DAG-lactones to help exploit molecular diversity for PK-C and other high-affinity receptors for DAG and the phorbol esters. The success of this work suggests that substantially simpler, high-affinity structures could be identified to function as surrogates of other complex natural products.

Differential localization of protein kinase C delta by phorbol esters and related compounds using a fusion protein with green fluorescent protein.

Enzyme localization often plays a controlling role in determining its activity and specificity. Protein kinase C (PKC) has long been known to translocate in response to physiological stimuli as well as to exogenous ligands such as the phorbol esters. We report here that different phorbol derivatives and related ligands, selected for differences in chemical structure and profile of biological activity, induce distinct patterns of redistribution of PKC delta. Localization of a PKC delta-green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusion construct was monitored in living Chinese hamster ovary cells as a function of ligand, concentration, and time using confocal laser scanning microscopy. delta-PKC-GFP was expressed predominantly in the cytoplasm, with some in the nucleus and perinuclear region. Phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) induced plasma membrane translocation followed by slower nuclear membrane translocation. As the concentration of PMA increased, the proportion of nuclear to plasma membrane localization increased markedly. In contrast to PMA, bryostatin 1, a unique activator of PKC that induces a subset of PMA-mediated responses while antagonizing others, at all doses induced almost exclusively nuclear membrane translocation. Like PMA, the complete tumor promoter 12-deoxyphorbol 13-tetradecanoate induced plasma membrane and slower nuclear membrane translocation, whereas the inhibitor of tumor promotion 12-deoxyphorbol 13-phenylacetate, which differs only in its side chain, induced a distinctive distribution of PKC delta-GFP. Finally, the novel constrained diacylglycerol derivative B8-DL-B8 induced a slow Golgi localization. We speculate that differential control of PKC delta localization may provide an interesting strategy for producing ligands with differential biological consequences.

beta2-chimaerin is a novel target for diacylglycerol: binding properties and changes in subcellular localization mediated by ligand binding to its C1 domain.

The members of the chimaerin family of Rac-GTPase-activating proteins possess a single C1 domain with high homology to those present in protein kinase C (PKC) isozymes. This domain in PKCs is involved in phorbol ester and diacylglycerol (DAG) binding. We previously have demonstrated that one of the chimaerin isoforms, beta2-chimaerin, binds phorbol esters with high affinity. In this study we analyzed the properties of beta2-chimaerin as a DAG receptor by using a series of conformationally constrained cyclic DAG analogues (DAG lactones) as probes. We identified analogs that bind to beta2-chimaerin with more than 100-fold higher affinity than 1-oleoyl-2-acetylglycerol. The potencies of these analogs approach those of the potent phorbol ester tumor promoters. The different DAG lactones show some selectivity for this novel receptor compared with PKCalpha. Cellular studies revealed that these DAG analogs induce translocation of beta2-chimaerin from cytosolic (soluble) to particulate fractions. Using green fluorescent protein-fusion proteins for beta2-chimaerin we determined that this novel receptor translocates to the perinuclear region after treatment with DAG lactones. Binding and translocation were prevented by mutation of the conserved Cys-246 in the C1 domain. The structural homology between the C1 domain of beta2-chimaerin and the C1b domain of PKCdelta also was confirmed by modeling analysis. Our results demonstrate that beta2-chimaerin is a high affinity receptor for DAG through binding to its C1 domain and supports the emerging concept that multiple pathways transduce signaling through DAG and the phorbol esters.

The transition from a pharmacophore-guided approach to a receptor-guided approach in the design of potent protein kinase C ligands.

The pharmacophore-guided approach used in the first phase of the design of novel protein kinase C (PKC) ligands was based on the study of the geometry of bioequivalent pharmacophores present in diacylglycerol (DAG) and in the more potent phorbol ester tumor promoters. A number of potent DAG lactones were generated by this approach, in which the glycerol backbone was constrained into various heterocyclic rings to reduce the entropic penalty associated with DAG binding. Based on the information provided by X-ray and NMR structures of the cysteine-rich, C1 phorbol ester/DAG binding domain, the DAG lactones were further modified to optimize their interaction with a group of highly conserved hydrophobic amino acids along the rim of the C1 domain. This receptor-guided approach culminated with the synthesis of a series of "super DAG" molecules that can bind to PKC with low nanomolar affinities. These compounds provide insight into the basis for PKC ligand specificity. Moreover, some of the compounds reviewed herein show potential utility as antitumor agents.

Conformationally constrained analogues of diacylglycerol (DAG). 15. The indispensable role of the sn-1 and sn-2 carbonyls in the binding of DAG-lactones to protein kinase C (PK-C).

The binding mode of DAG-lactones to PK-C was investigated using the C1b domain from the X-ray structure of the phorbol ester/C1b complex of PK-C delta as a template. Modeling experiments revealed two binding alternatives in which one of the carbonyls of the DAG lactones remained uninvolved with the protein. Experimentally, however, the removal of either sn-1 or sn-2 carbonyls caused a dramatic drop in binding affinity towards PK-C. Although it was not possible to discriminate between the two binding alternatives of the DAG-lactones, the study demonstrates an important role for the additional carbonyl group. The function of this group could be equivalent to that of the C-9(OH)/C-13 (C = O) motif in phorbol esters, which also appears free of interactions in the phorbol ester/C1b complex. This role presumably reflects interaction with the phosholipid head groups required for high affinity binding under the conditions of the biological assays.