The contribution of the anaesthetist to risk-adjusted mortality after cardiac surgery.

It is widely accepted that the performance of the operating surgeon affects outcomes, and this has led to the publication of surgical results in the public domain. However, the effect of other members of the multidisciplinary team is unknown. We studied the effect of the anaesthetist on mortality after cardiac surgery by analysing data collected prospectively over ten years of consecutive cardiac surgical cases from ten UK centres. Casemix-adjusted outcomes were analysed in models that included random-effects for centre, surgeon and anaesthetist. All cardiac surgical operations for which the EuroSCORE model is appropriate were included, and the primary outcome was in-hospital death up to three months postoperatively. A total of 110 769 cardiac surgical procedures conducted between April 2002 and March 2012 were studied, which included 127 consultant surgeons and 190 consultant anaesthetists. The overwhelming factor associated with outcome was patient risk, accounting for 95.75% of the variation for in-hospital mortality. The impact of the surgeon was moderate (intra-class correlation coefficient 4.00% for mortality), and the impact of the anaesthetist was negligible (0.25%). There was no significant effect of anaesthetist volume above ten cases per year. We conclude that mortality after cardiac surgery is primarily determined by the patient, with small but significant differences between surgeons. Anaesthetists did not appear to affect mortality. These findings do not support public disclosure of cardiac anaesthetists' results, but substantially validate current UK cardiac anaesthetic training and practice. Further research is required to establish the potential effects of very low anaesthetic caseloads and the effect of cardiac anaesthetists on patient morbidity.

The impact of intra-operative transoesophageal echocardiography on cardiac surgical practice.

The use of transoesophageal echocardiography during cardiac surgery has increased dramatically and it is now widely accepted as a routine monitoring and diagnostic tool. A prospective study was carried out between September 2004 and September 2007, and included all patients in whom intra-operative echocardiography was performed, 2 473 (44%) out of a total of 5 591 cases. Changes to surgery were subdivided into predictable (where echocardiographic examination was planned specifically to guide surgery) and unpredictable (new pathology not diagnosed pre-operatively). A change in the planned surgical procedure was documented in 312 (15%) cases. In 216 (69%) patients the changes were predictable and in 96 (31%) they were unpredictable. The number of predictable changes increased between 2004-5 and 2006-7 (8% vs 13%, p = 0.025). In these cases, intra-operative echocardiography was specifically requested by the surgeon to help determine the operative intervention. This has implications for consent and operative risk, which have yet to be fully determined.

Local clinical quality monitoring for detection of excess operative deaths.

A monitoring system for cardiac surgery has been in use at Papworth Hospital for 10 years. We wished to determine whether this system would have detected an increase in deaths associated with a single practitioner, whether a poorly performing doctor or a serial killer such as Dr Harold Shipman, whose activities went undetected in the absence of a monitoring system for nearly a quarter of a century. Random extra deaths were artificially introduced into the practice of a surgeon and an anaesthetist in a way that broadly reproduced Shipman's pattern. The standard monitoring system was then used to analyse the hypothetical data thus generated. Using the current standard monitoring, the excess deaths would have been detected in less than 10 months. Suspicions would have been raised even earlier. Robust local quality monitoring of risk-adjusted outcomes is possible and, in our opinion, essential.

Octogenarians undergoing cardiac surgery outlive their peers: a case for early referral.

OBJECTIVE: To examine short and long term outcomes of octogenarians having heart operations and to analyse the interaction between patient and treatment factors. METHODS: Multivariate analysis of prospectively collected data and a survival comparison with an age and sex matched national population. The outcomes were base in-hospital mortality, risk stratified by logistic EuroSCORE (European system for cardiac operative risk evaluation), and long term survival. RESULTS: 12,461 consecutive patients (706 over 80 years) operated on between 1996 and 2003 in a regional UK unit were studied. Octogenarians more often had impaired ventricular function, pulmonary hypertension, and valve operations. They also included a higher proportion of women, had a higher serum creatinine concentration, and had a trend towards more unstable angina. Younger patients had a higher prevalence of previous cardiac operation, previous myocardial infarction, and diabetes. The in-hospital mortality rate was 3.9% for all patients (EuroSCORE predicted 6.1%, p < 0.001) and 9.8% for octogenarians (predicted 14.1%, p = 0.002). Long bypass time and non-elective surgery increased the risk of death above EuroSCORE prediction in both groups. A greater proportion of octogenarians stayed in intensive care more than 24 hours (37% v 23%, p < 0.001). Long term survival was significantly better in the study patients than in a general population with the same age-sex distribution (survival rate at five years 82.1% v 55.9%, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Cardiac surgery in a UK population of octogenarians produced excellent results. Elective referrals should be encouraged in all age groups.

Computer tools to assist the monitoring of outcomes in surgery.

OBJECTIVE: In recent years, there has been increasing use of analytical and graphical methods to assist the monitoring of outcomes in adult cardiac surgery. In this paper, we present extensions to the basic VLAD methodology that add flexibility and assist in its interpretation. METHODS: Using techniques from probability theory, we have devised graphical tools whereby deviations from expected outcomes can be monitored to see how likely they are to have occurred by chance. The methods are based upon pre-operative assessments of risk and use exact analytical techniques. RESULTS: These tools allow deviations from expected outcomes to be readily assessed and compared with the distribution of chance outcomes. Appropriate colour coding allows interpretation in terms of a temperature gradient. CONCLUSIONS: Exact analysis methods based on the use of pre-operative risk assessment provide a useful means for assisting the interpretation of VLAD charts. Such analysis has the advantage that it is applicable even for relatively short series of operations. Also, it takes specific account of the heterogeneity of case mix when quantifying the variability that is expected. By displaying the overall history of outcomes in a visually intuitive manner, it complements the more formal tools for detecting isolated good and bad runs that are available.

Boxer's pericardium.

A 65-year-old retired professional boxer presented with progressively worsening shortness of breath, peripheral oedema and mild abdominal swelling over a period of 6 months. His only past medical history was hypertension. Subsequent investigations revealed chylous ascites, pericardial constriction and bilateral chylothorax. He had uneventful pericardectomy, and post-operatively the chylothorax resolved only after administration of octreotide for 10 days. The histopathological features of fibrosis, haemosiderin deposition in the pericardium and abundant haemosiderin-laden macrophages are consistent with chronic resolving haemopericardium. These findings suggested that the cause of pericardial constriction was repeated chest trauma from boxing.

Anatomic feasibility of creating an inferior epigastric arterio-venous fistula to develop the internal thoracic artery with a view to coronary grafting.

Arterio-venous fistulae increase the diameter of their feeding artery. It may be advantageous to increase the diameter of the internal thoracic artery before its use for coronary grafting. A fistula applied directly to the internal thoracic artery may compromise its subsequent use as a coronary graft and is technically difficult and invasive. However, in view of the continuity between the internal thoracic artery and the inferior epigastric artery, it is possible to achieve the same effect by constructing a fistula on the latter. The purpose of this work was to determine, in a cadaveric study, the feasibility of carrying out an arterio-venous fistula on the inferior epigastric artery so as to increase the caliber of the internal thoracic artery before coronary grafting. A morphologic study of the inferior epigastric artery and its vein and their relations as well as the feasibility of such a fistula was carried out on 10 cadavers. The epigastric artery measured 12.35+/-1.2 cm in length. Its diameter decreased from its origin towards it termination from 3.16+/-0.26 cm to 1.76+/-0.18 cm. There was a constant connection between the inferior and superior epigastric arteries. This connection was single in 30% of cases, double in 50% and through an anastomotic plexus of more than two vessels in 20%. The mean number of anastomotic connections was 1.8. The epigastric vein was constant with a diameter of 0.75+/-0.06 mm at its origin and only sufficiently large to carry out a fistula at its termination (2.6+/-0.9 mm). In conclusion, this study indicates that it should be relatively simple to create a fistula between the inferior epigastric artery and either the inferior epigastric vein or the external iliac vein.