Chronic softening of cartilage without thickening of underlying bone in a joint trauma model.

We have recently developed a trauma model to study degradation of the rabbit patello-femoral joint. Our current working hypothesis is that alterations in retropatellar cartilage and underlying bone in our model are initiated independently by acute overstresses developed in each tissue during blunt insult to the joint, and that the processes of chronic degradation in each tissue are not related in a mechanical sense. The current study was conducted in an attempt to help validate our hypothesis by impacting the patello-femoral joint with a padded interface. Based upon earlier human cadaver experiments, we believe this would reduce the acute overstresses in patellar bone while the stresses developed in the overlying retropatellar cartilage would be sufficient enough to initiate a chronic softening of the tissue. Twenty-four animals received an impact to the patello-femoral joint and were sacrificed at either 0, 4.5, or 12 months post-insult. Three acute animals were impacted to develop a simplified computational model to estimate the stresses in joint tissues. The study showed there was a significant softening of the retropatellar cartilage at 4.5 and 12 months post-trauma, compared to unimpacted controls. However, no thickening of the underlying subchondral bone was documented at any timepoint. This was consistent with a reduction of stress in the bone compared to earlier studies, which document thickened subchondral bone post-insult at the same applied impact load. In conclusion, this study helped validate our hypothesis by documenting chronic softening of cartilage without remodeling of the underlying subchondral bone. Furthermore, this study, along with our earlier studies, suggest that impact load alone, which is currently used by the automobile industry to certify new automobiles, is not a good predictor of chronic injuries to a diarthrodial joint, and that simply the addition of padding to impact interfaces may not be adequate to protect occupants from chronic injuries.

A method to increase the sensitive range of pressure sensitive film.

Pressure-sensitive film is frequently used in biomechanics to document intra- and extra-articular contact pressures. This often involves the contact of two surfaces of varying curvature producing non-uniform pressure distributions. The purpose of this study was to determine the feasibility of using multiple films in such experiments to yield accurate pressure and contact area data. A composite arrangement of film was dynamically loaded using cylindrical indenters of five radii. An analytical model of each indentation was constructed to provide a standard for error analysis. The study showed that several ranges of pressure sensitive film can be used simultaneously to accurately transduce contact pressures arising from loading scenarios that produce contact pressure gradients and contact pressures that involve suprathreshold loading of a given film range.

Blunt impact causes changes in bone and cartilage in a regularly exercised animal model.

The goal of this study was to document the effect of blunt-impact trauma on the knee in a small animal model that incorporated a known level of physical exercise after impact. We hypothesized that a single blunt impact to the patellofemoral joint, of a magnitude comparable with our earlier studies, would result in degenerative changes to cartilage and to subchondral bone of the patella. Blunt impacts were delivered to rabbit patellofemoral joints without producing bone fracture, and biomechanical and histological analyses were performed on joint tissues at various times. At 12 months, the subchondral bone plate was thicker on the impacted side than on the unimpacted side and than that of the controls at comparable locations (near where surface fissures were found on the impacted side). The instantaneous modulus of cartilage was significantly less on the impacted side than that of controls at 3, 6, and 12 months after impact. The relaxed modulus of cartilage on the unimpacted side increased with time after impact and was significantly greater than that of controls at 12 months. These facts suggest that in this exercise model, the contralateral limb should not be considered a control. The retropatellar cartilage on the impacted side was significantly less thick than that of controls at 12 months, and histological analyses of the cartilage and bone indicated early-stage osteoarthrosis in the impacted joint. Thus, in this animal model a single subfracture blunt impact produced degeneration of joint tissues.

Analysis of acute mechanical insult in an animal model of post-traumatic osteoarthrosis.

Chronic degeneration of articular cartilage and bone in a rabbit model of post-traumatic osteoarthrosis has been hypothesized to occur due to acute stresses that exceed a threshold for injury. In this study, we impacted the rabbit patellofemoral joint at low and high intensities. High-intensity impacts produced degenerative changes in the joint, such as softening of retropatellar cartilage, as measured by indentation, an increase in histopathology of the cartilage, and an increase in thickness of subchondral bone underlying the cartilage. Low-intensity impacts did not cause these progressive changes. These data suggest that low-intensity impacts produced acute tissue stresses below the injury threshold, while high-intensity impacts produced stresses that exceeded the threshold for disease pathogenesis. This study begins to identify "safe" and "unsafe" ranges of acute tissue stress, using the rabbit patella, which may have future utility in the design of injury prevention devices for the human.

Subfracture insult to a knee joint causes alterations in the bone and in the functional stiffness of overlying cartilage.

The current criteria used by the automotive industry for predicting joint injury are based on fracture of bone, but clinical studies suggest that chronic diseases such as osteoarthrosis can occur from a single blunt insult without bone fracture. In the current study, blunt insults were delivered to the patellofemoral joints of rabbits without producing bone fractures. Biomechanical and histological studies were performed on joint tissues at various times after insult. The functional integrity of the retropatellar cartilage on the lateral facet was measured with mechanical indentation experiments, and the thickness of the subchondral bone was measured from histological sections. Impacts produced surface lesions on the retropatellar cartilage. The thickness of the subchondral bone in representative animals tended to increase with time after insult, and the bone exhibited significant thickening at 12 months. The overlying cartilage showed signs of degeneration. However, the mechanical stiffness of the cartilage did not change until 12 months after the insult.